* Posts by JohnFen

5648 publicly visible posts • joined 20 Feb 2015

Another sign of the End Times: Free software guru Richard Stallman speaks at Microsoft HQ

JohnFen

Re: Shrug

Yes. The quote is a comment on the political scene in the US at the time -- no politician could be seen as being friendly to China, because "commies". It would have been political suicide.

Nixon, however, was famous for being a hard-line anticommunist, so he was the exception to that rule. He could talk with China without endangering his political career.

JohnFen

Re: Stallman went there to preach the Gospel of Free Software

"maybe one day Microsoft enters a new season in its corporate life, a season where Microsoft becomes a force for good"

Man, that would be great. But I think the chances of that happening approach zero.

OK, let's try that again: Vulture rakes a talon on Samsung's fresh attempt at the Galaxy Fold 5G

JohnFen

Re: Why?

"Wouldn't you like a big screen that still fits in your pocket?"

I don't, to be honest. But I can see that others might.

JohnFen

Re: How bloody much?

Emphasis on "at least".

I expect any phone to last well beyond 5 years, and particularly a phone at that price point.

Loss-making $15bn hipster chat biz Slack suddenly less appetising to investors as it predicts deeper losses

JohnFen

Re: Slack

If I had a choice, I'd use neither as well. But if I had to choose between the two, I'd take Slack over Teams in a heartbeat. Sadly, my employer is making us use Teams.

How do you do, fellow kids? Facebook now Boomerbook as British oldies outnumber teens

JohnFen

So, not leaving Facebook then?

Using Instagram (or any other Facebook product) is no better than using Facebook proper.

Mozilla says Firefox won't defang ad blockers – unlike a certain ad-giant browser

JohnFen

Re: Ad Blocker?

Adblock Plus is available for the new Firefox, although I don't recommend using it. There are much better options.

JohnFen

Re: Ads

I'm not actually bothered by ads as such. I'm bothered by the spying that comes with them -- so I block that to the best of my ability. That doing so also blocks the ads themselves is a problem the ad companies brought on themselves. I have exactly zero sympathy for them.

Let's recap reCAPTCHA gotcha: Our cunning AI can defeat Google's anti-bot tech, say uni boffins

JohnFen

Hopeful

Since reCAPTCHA v3 is very likely to be impossible for me to pass, I'm hopeful that someone will create a system that will defeat that as well.

SpaceX didn't move sat out of impending smash doom because it 'didn't see ESA's messages'

JohnFen

Re: "Turn right" and fuel

"the predicted orbit takes into account possible collisions over a long period, say 100 years of predicted trajectories."

No satellite will last anywhere close to 100 years. The design lifetime of a satellite depends on the satellite, but 10-15 years is considered "standard".

JohnFen

It's true that "all nontrivial software contains bugs". However, high quality software has undergone sufficient testing and development to ensure that the bugs that it contains are not of the sort that will cause it to fail in critical operations.

Microsoft's cloudy Windows Virtual Desktop: It fills a gap, but there are plenty of annoyances

JohnFen

Re: Is this where X-Server steps in (for Linux) ?

"if you want to compare X11... why not VNC, Teamviewer"

Of course, comparing X11 to VNC, etc., is still apples and oranges since X11 can serve up multiple independent desktops rather than sharing an existing one.

This is, for me, the "killer app" of X11.

Apple says sorry for Siri slurping voice commands of unsuspecting users

JohnFen

Re: Why have these "things" at all?

"supermarkets"

Supermarkets aren't "needed"?

They certainly are if you both enjoy eating and live in an urban setting where you can't grow your own food.

JohnFen

"Human grading is an absolutely essential part of improving voice response systems like Siri, Alexa and Google Assistant"

All the more reason to avoid using any of these things, period.

"And any data used for training is anonymised hence ‘private’"

The only way to actually "anonymize" data is to collect it in the aggregate and delete the individual data collection completely. I don't think Apple is doing this, therefore it's not really "anonymized".

"and having this data processed by a third party"

I don't think this was a major mistake. There's no reason to think that the privacy problem is any better if the recordings are listened to by actual Apple employees rather than contractors.

JohnFen

Re: Random identifier

"In that case, it wouldn't be attached to any other data, not by hash or anything else"

If that's actually what they're doing, then there's no point in having an identifier at all. The entire purpose of an identifier is to allow you to correlate different bits of data as belonging to the same set.

JohnFen

Re: Random identifier

This is a common bit of trickery from companies that want to continue spying on you -- to claim that you're OK because they don't use an already existing personal identifier and instead assign you a new personal identifier. It's utterly nonsensical.

Hey, it's 2019. Quit making battery-draining webpages – say makers of webpage-displaying battery-powered kit

JohnFen

Re: At Charlie Clark, re: bells & whistles.

I still think that sites that use them are broken.

JohnFen

Re: An easy way to save power...

" So we got <nav>, <section>, <article>, <video> and a heap of useful form elements."

Yes, and it is many of those elements that present a security problem, mostly (but not entirely) by making it impossible to disable the stuff contained in those elements. Not impossible in terms of the HTML5 spec, as browsers could decide to allow users to choose whether or not they want those elements rendered -- but I don't know of any browser that actually allows this.

JohnFen

Re: An easy way to save power...

"HTML 5 comes with the necessary semantics to make websites that both look good and are comprehensible in other modes."

It also comes with a whole slug of security problems that are more difficult to protect against.

JohnFen

Re: An easy way to save power...

You joke, but I would seriously love to see this happen.

JohnFen

Re: There's little incentive to do this

"I was fighting against unnecessary scripts to keep the page load time down and the general responsiveness good rather than the power useage low"

And whether you meant to be or not, you were also fighting to protect the users of the website from security risks.

"Their view is that it should be done right first time and that testing is time wasted."

Oh, sheesh, that's just massive incompetence right there. If you haven't tested a thing well, you have no idea if it was done right and have to assume that it wasn't.

JohnFen

Words of wisdom

"Use of JavaScript, to the extent possible, should be minimized."

So much this! Not just on mobile devices for power reasons, but across the board. The less JS, the better.

Apple cracks, straps on free repair service for defective Watches

JohnFen

"the best performing, longest surviving smart wearable (so-far) that I ever bought is the Pebble Time Steel Smartwatch for about £99"

I agree entirely with this -- in fact, I'm still using one on a daily basis. I couldn't be happier. It's the best smartwatch (for me) that I've ever tried.

I have been keeping an eye on the market, trying to plan what I'll do when the day comes that my Steel will have to be replaced, but I haven't found anything that seems suitable yet. I fear that I'm going to have to build my own.

Apple blinks on iPhone repairs, touts parts program for independent tech mechanics... sort of

JohnFen

We'll see

Apple's obnoxious stance on this issue has been well-entrenched for so many years that it's hard to believe that it's changing in any meaningful way. This is more likely a PR move, or a move to make it easier for them to continue to oppose right-to-repair legislation.

But we'll see. I hope that they surprise me!

Are US border cops secretly secreting GPS trackers on vehicles without a warrant? EFF lawyers want to know

JohnFen

The SIMs typically used in these devices are connected to data-only plans and cannot place phone calls at all, unfortunately.

JohnFen

They're very likely using one or more of the commercial GPS car trackers that are available on the open market (even to you and I). These things are pretty simple -- they include a battery, a GPS receiver, and a data-only cell link. They typically work by having software call the device and download the GPS history.

This also makes repurposing them reasonably easy -- just remove the SIM card and replace it with your own.

JohnFen

How can I look "suspicious"?

I want to get some free GPS trackers!

Can't bear to part with that well-worn copy of Windows 7? Microsoft might let you keep it updated an extra year

JohnFen

Re: A bit more time ... for migrating to Windows 10 from Windows 7

"You are however deliberately missing my point"

I didn't miss your point -- it was what I was replying to. I just don't agree with you.

JohnFen

Re: Windows 10

My hatred for UEFI runs deep. Having it absent (best), or being able to disable it entirely is a bare-minimum requirement for any machine I buy.

JohnFen

Re: The cost of Win10 is far too high.

"The start menu search from Vista onwards has been very handy."

I find it the opposite of handy. The problem is that if I use the application frequently, then I don't want to have to type a bunch of keys to find it. If I don't use the application frequently, then I have to remember what it's called -- which often requires looking through the menu anyway, to remind me.

JohnFen

Re: At Eric, re: staying with Windows.

"You realize Windows 10 is free, yes?"

I don't realize that. Win 10 seems very expensive to me. The cost just isn't money.

"As long as you have an activated installation of Windows 7 Microsoft will give you a free digital licence to Windows 10"

If you have Win 7 and haven't already downgraded to 10, it's probably because you've already determined that 10 costs more than you're willing to pay.

JohnFen

Re: A bit more time ... for migrating to Windows 10 from Windows 7

"You simply can't run a business without Windows"

This is simply untrue, as demonstrated by numerous businesses that don't use Windows. It may be true for many businesses, but the blanket statement that it's always impossible is false.

JohnFen

Re: "start migrating to web-based tools"

"Web-based tools are OK for the simplest task."

And only barely. Every web-based tool I've ever used has sucked -- but some suck worse than others.

JohnFen

Re: The cost of Win10 is far too high.

"that's exactly what the 10 Start Menu does."

But it does it badly. Much worse than the real Start Menu that Microsoft ditched.

JohnFen

I don't use Windows

I don't use Windows (outside of work, which doesn't count), but if I did it would be WIndows 7 -- regardless of whether or not Microsoft supports it.

Want an ethical smartphone? Fairphone 3 is on the way – but tiny market share suggests few care

JohnFen

Maybe so. But speaking just for me -- this is the only smartphone that I've seen in the past few years that even comes close to being one that I'd be willing to buy.

JohnFen

Re: Nice!

I'm swooning!

JohnFen

Nice!

An SD card slot and a headphone jack? Tell me it has a user-replaceable battery and I can install my own ROM, and this becomes a serious contender.

Biz forked out $115k to tout 'Time AI' crypto at Black Hat. Now it sues organizers because hackers heckled it

JohnFen

Re: If only...

"a website can't censor what you say, because censorship is the sole prerogative of the government."

What? Of course a website can censor you. It's done all the time -- any time a website removes a comment (for being spam, abusive, whatever), that is censoring by definition.

JohnFen

Re: Why would you take that talk to BlackHat?

"that show is way over priced"

Let's be honest here -- all such conventions are way over-priced.

Yes, TfL asked people to write down their Oyster passwords – but don't worry, they didn't inhale

JohnFen

I use long, randomly generated passwords. If I had to do something like this (and it would have to be a great discount for me to even consider it!), I'd change the password prior to the transaction to something like "P@ssw0rd", do the transaction, then change it back afterwards.

Google bans politics, aka embarrassing stuff that gets leaked, from internal message boards

JohnFen

Re: Interesting precedent

"This seems like a pretty reasonable stance for ANY company to take."

I agree.

In fact, every company I've worked for (that I remember, anyway) in the last 20 years has had an overt policy of forbidding discussions of politics and religion in the office outright, so from where I sit, that's the normal and expected practice.

JohnFen

Re: Wouldn't be so bad if it wasn't for their corporate cult mentality

I agree with much of what you say here, and it's why I've been avoiding working for any SV-style companies for many years now. Silicon Valley is straight-up toxic.

Pokemon Go becomes Pokemon No as games biz Niantic agrees to curb trespassing addicts

JohnFen

It's Niantic's fault for not seeing this obvious issue well in advance and putting in real safeguards to mitigate it.

JohnFen

Re: What's the problem?

"I thought their solution to trespassers was to shoot first and not bother with questions?"

As with all stereotypes, this is more wrong than right. It isn't the case in the majority of the US, but is certainly true in certain parts.

JohnFen

Re: not a lot of time to do digging

"They are checked, by the players - it is a crowd-sourced and verified data set now."

Clearly, that system is not working well enough.

JohnFen

Re: They had to go and ruin it

"Try applying that rationale to other areas"

That rationale is already applied to lots of other areas, in the form of the concept of the "attractive nuisance".

Wait a minute, we're supposed to haggle! ISPs want folk to bargain over broadband

JohnFen

Re: Price

"So you are willing to break your contract with someone else, to put that other person to the inconvenience of having to go through the processes again of finding someone to replace you even though you had already agreed to do the work?"

Sadly, this is a common enough practice that it's even a joke: "Where does your contractor go when the job is half done?"

I have a one-strike policy for this dishonest nonsense. When someone I've hired does this, they don't see my money ever again.

JohnFen

Re: PlusNet Billing

I wouldn't care if a call center was overseas if it weren't for the fact that it's extremely painful to actually get help from them.

JohnFen

That's the main (but not only) reason why I will never buy a car from a dealership again. I buy them used, directly from the owners, and have never regretted it.