* Posts by Pompous Git

3087 publicly visible posts • joined 24 Sep 2014

10 minutes of silence storms iTunes charts thanks to awful Apple UI

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Copyright violation ?

"I'd ask Simon and Garfunkel about the sound of silence."

"For the words of the profits were written on the studio wall, concert hall, and echoes with the sounds of salesmen..."

Pompous Git Silver badge

"Read about the Cage/Zappa case here:"
BTDT. Batt was a fool to credit his work to Cage and then claim he meant somebody other than John Cage. A bit like when the Merkins were claiming that The Bard of Stratford Upon Avon hadn't written Shakespeare's works. They were written by someone else. Presumably also called William Shakespeare.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: So why is the 32 bit version twice the size

"It is like the surface of the tape in a tape recorder."
That comes off on the tape heads when the tape gets old enough; even professional tapes used for creating copies from the master.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: So why is the 32 bit version twice the size

"If you made it a file with maximum compression then the length would be a single bit = 0. The playback time could be slowed to whatever you want."
Which means that there is no resemblance between 4'33" and recordings of silence. 4'33" is four minutes and 33 seconds of musicians not playing their instruments (tacet in the score). They are nevertheless performing and recordings of 4'33" have differing content.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Test

"Speaking of hacking, does this look like a graph to anyone else?"
Recognised it instantly! It's the beginning of this song:

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: 10 minutes of silence

"It is occupied by nothing. Same as zero on the number line."
So why is the 32 bit version twice the size of the 24 bit version? Shirley 0*2=0

Pompous Git Silver badge

Royalties

In 1993, Frank Zappa recorded 4'33" for "A Chance Operation" — a tribute CD which included works written by, influenced by, or dedicated to John Cage and he paid royalties.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: 10 minutes of silence

"One cannot copyright titles, only content. It has no content."
Er... I just created two wav files of 10 minutes silence. The 24 bit version is 105,840,044 bytes in size; the 32 bit version is 211,681,280 bytes in size. My questions are:

1. If there's no content, then what is it that's occupying disk space?

2. Will the cognoscenti be able to perceive a difference between the 24 bit and 32 bit versions?

3. Will converting the wav files to 320 kb/s MP3 distort the silence to the extent that it becomes annoying?

nbn™ cracks the $1bn revenue barrier, cracks whip on tardy retailers

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Morrow, what a clown.

"You're doing better than I..."
At the time I took the test.

Ookla

"This is nothing like the next-gen broadband service we were promised by a long shot. Heads need to roll."
If you think of a way we can implement that without suffering dire consequences, let me know. I'd like to help!

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Morrow, what a clown.

"Don't blame people for not subscribing to something that is not attainable due to their and the liberals incompetence."
I find 12 Mb/s on FW unattainable and it has nothing whatsoever to do with the Liberals.

Ookla

It's actually slightly faster than usual today.

Taken a while but finally here's the first proper smart-home gizmo

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Want/need?

"I always know where my corkscrew is."
But then you're not married to Mrs Git. You may recall (or not) that Mrs Git lost her mobile phone and we deduced it had to be in the house somewhere, but being turned off to conserve electricity, could not be located. Some five months and one new mobile phone later, it turned up in a bag containing various shoe polishes, rags and brushes under the kitchen sink. I have found not only a bottle of red wine in the fridge "chambré-ing", but the clothes iron... and I'd better stop there.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: a quick think gives me 3 reasonable usecases.

"The workl awaits..."
Apparently so, but what is it waiting for? Google translate is no help...

Workl workl

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Want/need?

"I suspect there are a lot of much simpler, low tech solutions to switching a light (or other switch) on and off without leaving a chair."
Sound activated switches have been around for a very long time. They were being advertised in men's magazines in the 1970s as a way to impress the girl you were seducing. I thought that a particularly stupid idea at the time. I preferred leaving the light on all the better to appreciate the pulchritude of my partner. When you are as myopic as me you need all the light you can muster.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: HomePlug?

"in general, routers are not connected directly to the mains electricity"
You can though. It does let all the smoke out of the wires so they don't work anymore unfortunately...

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Want/need?

"Anyone for an internet connected corkscrew?"
That actually almost makes sense. Here in Australia stelvin seals are ubiquitous and I seldom see a cork. In the meantime, the corkscrew has decided to hide itself so when I need one I can't find it! Being able to log onto the interwebs and locate it would be quite useful. In the meantime, more useful still would be an Internet connected wine merchant. Oh wait; I've already got one! Get Wines Direct

"Does it let you switch on your bedroom light at home in Edinburgh while in a hotel in Sydney?"
Or does it allow you to instruct Tommy the Talking Lightbulb to say to your wife and her lover: "That's a very interesting technique! I haven't seen her do that since she took on three German shepherds at once!"

Chap behind Godwin's law suspends his own rule for Charlottesville fascists: 'By all means, compare them to Nazis'

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Everything I don't like is a Nazi

"A septuagenarian is somebody between 70 and 79 inclusive."
Not according to the OED. Septuagenarian:

"A person seventy years old."

But that is, as you say, a miner mistake in the minefield of etymology.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"And using this particular marker, your father is not a relative. I'd say that makes this a pretty poor measure of "race"."
And so far you have yet to come up with a reference that Homo sapiens sapiens is "a race" as you claim. Homo sapiens are the only surviving species in the Genus Homo I gave the scientific definition of race down to the actual page number of the dictionary: that is a race is a subdivision below the species level. To be a subdivision, there have to be at least two, else it's not a subdivision. You are not going to overturn the whole of biological nomenclature by arguing that 2 = 1 on El Reg.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Devil's Advocate @Updraft102

"So if you are right about what "right-wing" means, then pretty much everyone else is wrong about it"
I find it amusing that Hilary Clinton is well to the right of Adolf Hitler, yet considered to be left wing by the average Merkin.

Political Compass

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"White people are becoming an underclass? Really? Where?"
I don't think Bob Dylan was singing about Zimbabwe:

Only A Pawn In Their Game

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: How many downthumbs will this get?

"That brings back a political joke from the Soviet era."
At a May Day parade, a very old Jew carries a slogan, "Thank you, comrade Stalin, for my happy childhood!"

The Party representative approaches the old man. "What's that? Are you deriding our Party? Everybody can see, when you were a child, comrade Stalin was not yet born!"

"That's precisely what I'm grateful to him for!" the Jew said.

Pompous Git Silver badge
Coat

Re: Rocks

"Don't knock the stone age, it lasted a lot longer than the post stone age will."
You're that bloke who walks down the street holding a sign saying: "The End is Nigh!"

Mine's the coat with a copy of Last and First Men in the pocket

--------------->

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Fuck me...

"I am half Danish."
I'm half English, half Austrian and half Jewish. Probably explains why I'm overweight...

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"mtDNA contains 37 genes. That's three-seven, thirty-seven, of around 19,000 coding genes in the human genome.

Unless those genes differ significantly in function from one haplogroup to another, there's very little in them that you could claim distinguishes one human from another."

But the main haplogroups contain subgroups that are grouped geographically and/or culturally, and are associated with varying ratios of important genes. I referred earlier to the recessive genes possessed by many Ashkenazim that can cause great distress when conveyed from both parents. The genes causing the problem aren't mtDNA, but they are strongly associated with a particular haplotype subgroup.

"Pharmacogenomics is the study of how genes affect a person’s response to drugs. This relatively new field combines pharmacology (the science of drugs) and genomics (the study of genes and their functions) to develop effective, safe medications and doses that will be tailored to a person’s genetic makeup.

Many drugs that are currently available are “one size fits all,” but they don't work the same way for everyone. It can be difficult to predict who will benefit from a medication, who will not respond at all, and who will experience negative side effects (called adverse drug reactions). Adverse drug reactions are a significant cause of hospitalizations and deaths in the United States. With the knowledge gained from the Human Genome Project, researchers are learning how inherited differences in genes affect the body’s response to medications. These genetic differences will be used to predict whether a medication will be effective for a particular person and to help prevent adverse drug reactions.

The field of pharmacogenomics is still in its infancy. Its use is currently quite limited, but new approaches are under study in clinical trials. In the future, pharmacogenomics will allow the development of tailored drugs to treat a wide range of health problems, including cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer disease, cancer, HIV/AIDS, and asthma."

Should we really ignore our biological differences, or accept that they exist and make good use of that knowledge?

Pompous Git Silver badge

mtDNA: as meaningless as hair colour or stamp collecting

Migration of Anatomically Modern Humans out of Africa

Thanks to mtDNA mapping we now know for example that Polynesia was not colonised from South America, that Britain was colonised by farmers from the region we now call Syria and that Australia's Aborigines were the first anatomically modern humans to leave Africa.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"No - because haplogroups can interbreed with each other. It's as meaningless a distinction as hair colour.."
I didn't say they couldn't; I actually said they could. I also said they were chromosomally distinct from other members of the species. This is so because the mtDNA is not carried on the germ cells, it's carried in the maternal mitochondria. Your mother is your mother. mtDNA from one haplogroup cannot pass to another. They remain distinct. An individual's hair colour doesn't even stay distinct in that individual's lifetime.

"And your point about being able to change haplogroup - the same logic applies to any other genetic marker."
Not so. I can select for or against any individual gene that occurs in a germ cell. I can only select for or against the full mtDNA package by selecting a particular mother. Absent genetic engineering.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Nazi is a slur anyway

"Should we feel happy they did not adopt the circle or say the cross."
The swastika is a cross/gammadion/fylfot [delete whichever is inapplicable]. As I quoted from the OED earlier: "A primitive symbol or ornament of the form of a cross..."

Medieval swastika at Coventry Cathedral still as I saw it when ~8 or 9 years old.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Everything I don't like is a Nazi

"If we're being pedantic, it's "Grandmother"."
No, that's being formal...

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Everything I don't like is a Nazi

"Upset that I skipped giving a definition for Grampa Nazi?"
No, you misspelt grandma...

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Everything I don't like is a Nazi

"Grammar Nazi: A woman over 60 years old who advocates ethnic cleansing."
Sexist barsted...

Pompous Git Silver badge

"True capitalism depends on increasing the business output to satisfy the demand of increasing customers. Unfortunately without infinite resources or customers it will always fail at some point."
Back when I first connected to the Internet with a 300 baud modem (~300 bps), I was told that was the upper limit to what the telephone lines could sustain. Also, we were just about to run out of copper, so there wasn't going to be enough to meet demand for telephones, never mind digital comms. You may have noticed that copper pairs now carry far more data than 300 bps and that there's no shortage of telephones to meet demand.

There's an old saying that we didn't leave the stone age because of a shortage of rocks.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"A haplogroup is not a race."

So a haplogroup is not "an interbreeding subgroup of a species whose individuals are chromosomally distinct from other members of the species". Reference please. I do stand to be corrected if wrong. It's my understanding that you can't change from one haplogroup to another without changing who your mother was. A bit more difficult than "stamp collecting".

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: " ..call a spade a spade..."

"The thing I never got, is that shovels are more spade shaped than spades."

Depends on the shovel...

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"There is only one race here, the human race."
Presumably haplogroup L3. Leaving haplogroups L1 and L2 as ubermensch? Fuck me...

"I attended a lecture by Fuller one time. He was a very interesting man."
I have no problems agreeing with that...

"Nature is trying very hard to make us succeed, but nature does not depend on us. We are not the only experiment." -- R. Buckminster Fuller

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Nazi is a slur anyway

"After WWII, we should have renamed toilets "Nazis" and used the symbol of the swastika as the international symbol to indicate a toilet."

swastika: "A primitive symbol or ornament of the form of a cross with equal arms with a limb of the same length projecting at right angles from the end of each arm, all in the same direction and (usually) clockwise; also called gammadion and fylfot.

1882 E. C. Robertson in Proc. Berw. Nat. Club IX. No. 3. 516 In Japan‥the cross-like symbol of the sun, the Swastica, is put on coffins.    1895 Reliquary Oct. 252 The use of the Swastica cross in mediaeval times.    1904 Times 27 Aug. 10/3 [In Tibet] a few white, straitened hovels in tiers.‥ On the door of each is a kicking swastika in white, and over it a rude daub of ball and crescent." [From the OED]

In Sanskrit swastika means "well-being". The symbol has been used by Hindus, Buddhists and Jains for millennia and is widely believed to have originated in India. Early European travellers to Asia such as Marco Polo were inspired by its positive and ancient associations and started using it back home.

There are more cultures on this planet than the one dominated by the USA. Shitting on them would hardly be likely to improve international relations.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Something people are missing.

"You sound accusatory. Have I come across as condoning this kind of behavio(u)r?"
Then please accept my apologies; I did not intend to. You most definitely have not come across as condoning this behaviour. You did however state: "Try not to equate the views of a single nut-job with the opinion of the rest of us, it just makes you look silly." I was pointing out that it was a lot more than the views of a single nutjob. And as you say it wasn't until 2014 that "forced sterilization in correctional facilities" was banned. That makes me glad; I was unaware of it and believed that law was still in effect.

"how's the ol' History War coming along? Visited Risdon Cove and/or Oyster Cove recently?"
Don't believe everything that the black armbanders tell you of Tasmanian history. As one of my aboriginal acquaintances has said: We must be the only race [Tasmanian Aborigines] on the planet who have to prove our existence every day.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: @The Tick Godwin not applicable here

"The government voices its opinion on issues all the time without sacrificing anyone's free speech rights."
[Clears throat]

Censorship dressed up is denial of free speech

"If the warning bells are not ringing by now, they should be. Clearly, the Racial Discrimination Act is open to rubbery interpretation on just what an offensive or insulting tone is. If I go into my classroom and in the course of my lesson I use a tone that is apparently offensive or insulting to any racially identifiable group, then I am breaking the law. This background is worth keeping in mind in the light of the intention of Attorney-General Nicola Roxon to make changes that are in the exposure draft of the Human Rights and Anti-Discrimination Bill 2012. Under the mooted changes, there is a broadening of the definition of what constitutes offence or insult.

The draft goes further, stating that offending and insulting will come under the umbrella of "unfavourable treatment".

To quote King Lear: "That way madness lies."

The unspecified "unfavourable treatment" is a worrying catch-all phrase. The Roxon proposal intends to expand the reach of current anti-discrimination law to all those in "any area of public life", which is defined as work, education, membership of clubs and sport participation.

This means that if I go into my classroom and dismiss a particular indigenous, Chinese, American, Australian or any nationality text as bad writing, should anyone take offence or be insulted by my remarks, then I am in effect, under the Roxon view, breaking the law. Then there is the question of tone.

After the Bolt case, Marcia Langton, professor of Australian indigenous studies at the University of Melbourne, in a piece of untrammelled invective published in The Sunday Age, directed to "Bolt and his kind", said: "What Bolt refuses to acknowledge, or is deliberately misleading about is the fact that identifying as Aboriginal is almost certainly likely to lead to being run out of school by racists." This is wrong.

Her remarks were, and still are, to me as a whitefella, "offensive" and "insulting" and were made in a "tone" that is sneering and sarcastic. They imply that my school, which nurtures Aboriginal children and has staff give up their time to teach in remote communities, is one where Aboriginal children are likely to be excluded by racists on staff. This is not a "fact" and it discredits Langton as a serious academic.

Still, if an aggrieved student made a complaint against me because of what I said or the tone in which it was said, my employer would have to undertake, as would be the case for any educational institution, an exhaustive and time-consuming inquiry on the supposition that an insult was intended or offensive remarks made.

The Roxon laws would therefore make the flow of free speech untenable."

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Yeah, no.

"The Ashkenazim, also known as Ashkenazi Jews, derive their name from Ashkenaz not from Nazism."
As I understand it, Nazi is a common contraction of the name Ignatz (Ignatius) and in the region of Austria where my father was born also means a stupid and clumsy person.

I think you can guess how I know that. My name's Jonathan, not Ignatius.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"There is no scientific definition of a race."

Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, p. 1777. ISBN 0-12-200400-0.

Race: an interbreeding subgroup of a species whose individuals are geographically, physiologically, or chromosomally distinct from other members of the species".

"Look up the whole Linnnaean (or other) taxonomic system. There are zero mentions of "race"."
Irrelevant. "Linnaean taxonomy" as such does not really exist; it's a collective term for several separate fields that use similar approaches. In biological taxonomy, race is an informal rank in the taxonomic hierarchy, below the level of species. Races are defined according to any identifiable characteristic, including gene frequencies. Chromosomal races are populations distinguished by having unique karyotypes and what I was referring to.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Something people are missing.

"For example, eugenics is included in various curricula today. As in "those who forget history ..."."
For those who forget history:

"But the concept of a white, blond-haired, blue-eyed master Nordic race didn't originate with Hitler. The idea was created in the United States, and cultivated in California, decades before Hitler came to power. California eugenicists played an important, although little-known, role in the American eugenics movement's campaign for ethnic cleansing.

Eugenics was the pseudoscience aimed at "improving" the human race. In its extreme, racist form, this meant wiping away all human beings deemed "unfit," preserving only those who conformed to a Nordic stereotype. Elements of the philosophy were enshrined as national policy by forced sterilization and segregation laws, as well as marriage restrictions, enacted in 27 states. In 1909, California became the third state to adopt such laws. Ultimately, eugenics practitioners coercively sterilized some 60,000 Americans, barred the marriage of thousands, forcibly segregated thousands in "colonies," and persecuted untold numbers in ways we are just learning. Before World War II, nearly half of coercive sterilizations were done in California, and even after the war, the state accounted for a third of all such surgeries."

Eugenics and the Nazis -- the California connection

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Something people are missing.

"Excuse me? THE FUCKING NAZIS NEVER HAD THIS COUNTRY! How can the blithering idiots "take back" something they never had?"
I think most of us loathe Nazism because of its eugenics element. It's worth noting that applied eugenics occurred in the USA long before it was taken up in Nazi Germany.

"In 1906 J.H. Kellogg provided funding to help found the Race Betterment Foundation in Battle Creek, Michigan. The Eugenics Record Office (ERO) was founded in Cold Spring Harbor, New York in 1911 by the renowned biologist Charles B. Davenport, using money from both the Harriman railroad fortune and the Carnegie Institution. As late as the 1920s, the ERO was one of the leading organizations in the American eugenics movement.

....

By 1928, there were 376 separate university courses in some of the United States' leading schools, enrolling more than 20,000 students, which included eugenics in the curriculum."

Hitler didn't gain power in Germany until 1933.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The thin line between right and wrong

"Just to clarify that a bit more, I subscribe to Buckminster Fuller's view that a "racist" is "someone who believes in race." There is only one race, here, and we're all part of it. For that reason, I also reject the idea of forming organisations to advocate for one's race. It's a misguided concept."
The only problem with that is it's biologically incorrect. We are all one species, but species are subdivided divided into races. As I pointed out elsewhere, within Africa there exist three haplogroups*/races; outside Africa there is only one haplogroup.

Incorrect word usage inevitably leads to talking at cross purposes. Species != race.

* Offspring inherit their mtDNA from their mother. Membership of a haplogroup is determined by which of the available mtDNA types you have. It's possible that Africa has more than three haplogroups; more may remain to be discovered.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: The future...

"I appreciate that you are reiching for that pun"
I think you just Hitlered the nail on the head...

Vaping ads flout EU rules, even if to promote healthier lifestyles

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Nicotine is not Tobacco

"but what about the additives they put in for smell/taste?"
They are optional. I don't have anything of that nature in mine.

The cheek of it! Beach bar owner shoots nude bather in the booty

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Carry on camping

"There's only one scene to be remembered."
Oh I dunno. I quite like the beginning...

Carry On Camping 1969 full movie

Kremlin's hackers 'wield stolen NSA exploit to spy on hotel guests in Europe, Mid East'

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: WordPad

"You seem to be confusing a number of topics. CMYK splitting isn't a feature of PDFs - they can hold any number of image and colour formats formats."
Then please explain why when MS were asked about the lack of CMYK support in the PDFs created in Publisher their response was that the bureaus needed to get up-to-date and leave their prejudices behind, or some such. I'm paraphrasing.

"Almost everything will 'automagically' eventually convert to CMYK. Whether you leave it up to your printer, your print driver or do it in pre-process is up to you."
When I was still learning the digital side of this stuff, I accidentally forgot to convert an RGB image to CMYK. I received 4 pieces of film, but only two of them were really usable as three were identical.

"The fact that you state that InDesign creates 'fully compliant' PDFs shows that you don't need to use Acrobat or Adobe Reader as you stated."
InDesign is an Adobe product. Consequently its Adobe PDF creator is compliant. It would be a surprise if it wasn't.

" if you do have a trusted print shop who have the original files they can often fix composition errors, bleeds trims and print marks"
I have been called on in the past to do such stuff on native files. I'm a political animal and when the document under consideration was that of a political organisation I did not approve of, I was sorely tempted. Happily I resisted. You must be singularly trusting to believe that everyone is to be similarly trusted.

GoDaddy gives white supremacist site its marching orders after Charlottesville slur

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: 'scum in the shadows'

"The MSM doesn't inform any more, if it ever did"
Thomas Jefferson:

"Nothing can now be believed which is seen in a newspaper. Truth itself becomes suspicious by being put into that polluted vehicle. The real extent of this state of misinformation is known only to those who are in situations to confront facts within their knowledge with the lies of the day...

I will add, that the man who never looks into a newspaper is better informed than he who reads them; inasmuch as he who knows nothing is nearer to truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods & errors. He who reads nothing will still learn the great facts, and the details are all false."

Pompous Git Silver badge

"Why do white supremacists always seem to be obese, scruffy, poorly educated and plastered in tatts?"
Because they're trying to blend in with the hoi poloi? I see lotsa tatts, new jeans in shop windows with the knees already worn out and mucho obesity?

I've actually contemplated getting one discrete tattoo on my forearm. A heart with an arrow through it and the words: "Born to raise tomatoes" underneath.

Google and its terrible, horrible, no good, very bad week in full

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Equality

"The stereotype of women always being more sensitive to colours than men is not a stereotype. It is science."
It also no doubt gets you called a sexist. I know this because when I point out that "As a group, the Aborigines have significantly better visual acuity than the Europeans" I'm called a racist.

[sigh]

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Optional

"it seems a bit odd to me that you'd demand Google 'clarify' its code of conduct to people who *aren't bound by it*"
Not really. Codes of Conduct are generally available to the public and for good reason. Let's say the CoC allows employees to swear at customers. Customers then have no grounds for complaint when called a stupid cunt. OTOH is the CoC specifically forbids abusing customers in any way, then customers have grounds to complain to the employer.

NB I deliberately chose an extreme example, not a real-world one.

Pompous Git Silver badge

Re: Suggestion

"The handy thing about the symphony orchestra case is that you really only need someone in a symphony orchestra to be good at one thing: playing the music."
Not really. They also need:

* To be able to follow the direction of the current conductor

* To turn up to work. I am minded of when the brass section of the LSO decided to spend the afternoon in the pub when Frank Zappa hired the orchestra

* To get along with their fellow musicians. A tympanist who tells the first violinist she's a cunt who couldn't play Twinkle Twinkle Little Star if she tried might not be a welcome addition...