* Posts by Doctor Syntax

33144 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

Doom developer John Carmack thinks artificial general intelligence is doable by 2030

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "prototype AI to show signs of life."

"he definitely considered that his robots were intelligent"

They were also fictional.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

First define intelligence. Not artificial intelligence, real intelligence because unless we agree on that we can't tell whether you've achieved your goal in producing an artificial version. Not in some airy-fairy philosophical terms but in terms which has be independently confirmed and agreed upon. 2030? Good luck in achieving that first step by then. Otherwise you're simply putting whatever you've got in a box, calling it AI and claiming success.

I've just finished re-reading Feynman's appendix to the Challenger report. His last sentence is something that should be borne in mind by anyone making such claims:

"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled."

Car industry pleads for delay to post-Brexit tariffs on EVs

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: All that is happening

I should have added "and some of them really don't like being reminded about it".

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: All that is happening

"The real story should be why such a course of action is so unpalatable to the UK."

It's unpalatable to half of the UK because we told the other half and they didn't want to listen or didn't believe it so we're lumbered with it. It's unpalatable to the other half because they were told and didn't want to listen, didn't believe it and probably in many cases still don't so they've lumbered themselves and us with it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'm confused....

If it wasn't minimising the effect of Brexit the tariff would be a whole lot more.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Nationalism or a Green Transition.

"because there won't be enough EVs in the continent of Europe for decades"

And if there were there wouldn't be the public charging infrastructure to support them.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'll be sticking with petrol (or diesel) for my next car.

No but it evens out the load.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'll be sticking with petrol (or diesel) for my next car.

That could be supply and demand but hydrogen is certainly tricky stuff to handle. But I've no doubt supply and demand is operating between EV sales and public charging infrastructure is holding back EVs. It's not just range concerns, it's the huge percentage of properties with no private car parking where home chargers an be located and to a lesser extent charging times. I can always find a choice of petrol pumps with minimal queuing and only occupy one of them for a few minutes at a time. I can point to rows of houses near home with no chance of installing private charging facilities with numbers of vehicles parked outside far in excess of the capacity of the few local chargers. If government is serious about getting a move to EVs they need to take action to ensure that is remedied. The only effect of banning sales of ICE vehicles will be to grossly extend the working lives of the existing fleet and/or create an underclass who have no means of transport, bus services being a fraction of what they were 60 years ago. It's no use passing legislation that is little more than a pius hope greenwashing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Not too much point building EVs if they can't put an adequate public charging infrastructure in place. But don't worry. HMG has assured us building EVs is one of the many things for which the UK is the best place in the world.

Mixin suspends deposits and withdrawals after $200m cryptocurrency heist

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Oh dear. This has never happened to any other crypto exchange. We're really unlucky.

Try the other one. It's got bells on.

No customer left behind, SAP's Klein tells users angered by cloud-only decision

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: at least they are honest now?

It's anonymised but there's this bunch of data about the Acme Mk 10...

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Have I got this right?:

1. We're not going to leave you behind

2. We're going to leave you behind

3. If we leave you behind at least we're not going to slurp your data to feed the AI

4. If we don't leave you behind we're going to slurp your data to feed the AI

US Trademark Office still wants to keep faxes, but is willing to try this cloud thing

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: not quite simultaneous

Should still be ordered by time of receipt and hence transmission. If it's buffered by the sender they've only themselves to blame. But it wouldn't be stored & forwarded during actual transmission unlike email.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"The USPTO doesn't want any responses faxed - just emailed, which begs the question why that wouldn't work as a fax alternative."

Let me guess. With patents precedence matters. If the situation arises that two inventors submit similar claims at more or less the same time they need to decide who has precedence. With fax they know - transmission and reception are simultaneous. Enail is store and forwards so time of receipt is no indication of time of transmission and if that same situation arises they won't know and the loser will always claim theirs was first but delayed and/or dirty tricks were played with clock setting.

OTOH a prolonged outage of all forms of communication to USPTO wouldn't lose anything of value to humanity as a whole.

California governor vetoes bill requiring human drivers in robo trucks

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

At least it's an experiment that's running a very safe distance from me. The downside is that i won't see one of these attempting our local trap for HGV drivers using satnavs configured for cars but I can live with that. Literally.

Google killing Basic HTML version of Gmail In January 2024

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

There are a couple of alternatives which can be used singly or together: a local email client and a better mail service provider.

OSIRIS-REx successfully delivers NASA's first asteroid sample

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"it could potentially have these organic building blocks that started life here on Earth"

I suppose everyone's forgotten the Miller Urey experiment that told us there's no need to throw the problem over the panspermia wall.

T-Mobile US exposes some customer data – but don't call it a breach

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

So it's not a breach of security if you leak it yourself?

UK procurement is too glacial to bring AI into defense, MPs told

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"The UK's procurement processes are not fit to bring AI into the nation's military capabilities, lawmakers heard at a parliamentary hearing."

Thank goodness for that.

No, no, no! Disco joke hit bum note in the rehab center

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: So the system didn't cut the ringtone when the phone was picked up

I'd like to find one to integrate a USB document camera into X-Sane.

Oh, you meant that sort of "sane".

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: So the system didn't cut the ringtone when the phone was picked up

"because, obviously, who would configure a 90-second ringtone ?"

They made an assumption. Any assumption quickly becomes a limitation if not a bug. Assume as little as possible, Even so it should be a requirement of ringing a phone that the ring tone ill be cut off as soon as it's answered.

Microsoft hiring a nuclear power program manager, because AI needs lots of 'leccy

Doctor Syntax Silver badge
Mushroom

WFR

Windows For Reactors

The home Wi-Fi upgrade we never asked for is coming. The one we need is not

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

I think Zen will be my next ISP.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Interest, expertise and time

"sadly still on FTTC"

Not sadly at all as far as I'm concerned. C is only a few hundred metres away so fast enough. Why pay more?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Just go back to using a router of my own. Had to buy another because the older ones had died or probably full of unaddressed CVEs. One of the advantages of that is thet a more modern one combines the FTTC modem whereas the old setup had a separate emodem.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Whoops !!!

"Cloning the MAC Address of the original ISP router can be useful to avoid 'simple' detection if you replace the router"

Didn't bother, just stuck a TP-Link in as was. Only issue with that, several generations of router have been quite happy to live with the name I chose to give the router in my hosts file. This one doesn't like it so I just use the IP address to connect to it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Another reason not to use the ISP's router - they can't log in remotely as PlusNet did with mine, lock it down and prevent me reconfiguring the DHCP reserved IP addresses I'd previously set up when it was still open to configuration from the LAN side.

Fujitsu to quit Tokyo HQ

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

There's also a "dogfooding" aspect to the move. Fujitsu currently emphasizes its "Uvance" digital experience practice and methodologies.

Unlike some companies we could think of.

Of course it's possible they might need to sell off property to pay compensation to ex-sub-postmasters - if so, not before time. Justice delayed is justice denied.

How is this problem mine, techie asked, while cleaning underground computer

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirty environments for Computers

The old percussive maintenance.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

It depends on whether you're in Glasgow.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A 1980s minicomputer at the bottom of a mine ?

Primitive? A VT220 was luxurious when all you have was a VT100.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

"No-one suspects that something with four wheels contains something deadly until it goes KABOOM."

No-one?

Suspecting exactly that was SOP in Northern Ireland. It became law that an unoccupied car should be locked because of the increased risk of it being stolen and used as a bomb (which puzzled me why it seems to have been so easy to lift documents from a PSNI Super's car). There were substantial areas where it was illegal to park an unoccupied car (they may not have been aware of it but my children were sometimes car-sitters on weekends when I needed to run a quick errand into one of the zones).

Even so, my lab was bombed. Someone the IRA wrongly though worked there was targetted. They loaded his car, told him to drive there and held his family hostage. As he didn't work there the car never got beyond the double gate trap. Everyone was evacuated to the back of the site until it went off

I was down town in court at the time and got told about it by a couple of Peelers (even writing about it brings back the terminology of the time and place) while the defence had asked for a recess whilst they considered what I'd just said. Windows were blown in but not much real damage. I was greeted by a strong smell of clove oil as I entered the door. I used it as a dehydrating agent for preparing wood sections and had a 100 ml bottle near one of the windows that blown in. The spilled oil must have got trodden right down to the door.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Installing Code Red / NIMDA patches on windows 2000 machines"

Not Code Tangerine?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A cave, rather than a mine, and a laboratory, rather than a computer

They may well have their own source of radon without the radium. https://www.ukradon.org/information/ukmaps

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Experience is a dear teacher but some will learn by no other."

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dickensian

And probably causes byssinosis as well.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

But what about the rest of the desk?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

Or they hated it so much they didn't want another. In fact i have a cheap keyboard like that which is years old - I got it to set up stuff which would mostly run headless so it's had hardly any use.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

An over-seas allowance? I'd have appreciated that. Instead I was up against the Civil Service/HMG mentality which says "We rate people who are qualified for their jobs by their education well below those who aren't, promotion comes with responsibility measured by direct reports, not by what the actual job is, and if we want a national pay policy the easiest place to start is with the public sector."

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

Jake may well have been free-lance.

If you're cautious about using ML and bots at work, that's not a bad idea

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: LLM/ML processes

"Pastiche Generator" would be my description. They create pastiches of real statements, images or whatever. Whether the response to any prompt will be all true, all false, all irrelevant or somewhere in-between is, if not pure chance, at least not ready determinable ahead of time.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: tendency to generate false information – a phenomenon known as "hallucination."

Right now AI is the term being used to push these things onto the world in general. Yes' it's an oxymoron but that's the way marketing works.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: tendency to generate false information – a phenomenon known as "hallucination."

A statement based on reports that somebody reported a crime or was a witness at a trial and mangles them to say that that person was convicted of the crime is simply not true. Which epithet you choose to apply to the untruth is your personal choice and frankly doesn't matter very much. What matters is that people are trusting the system that creates such a statement.

"How much of a world model or theory of the world does a newly conceived human have?"

The newly conceived born human acquires a world model by being a physical entity and encountering the other physical entities around it. It starts to do so before starting to acquire language. Our non-human relatives do the same without ever acquiring language. Language - words - is/are the means by which we apply symbolic labels to the real world in order to build and manipulate ideas about them. They are not intrinsic to an internal model of the external world. But words are al LLMs have. They do not have the physicality to react with the physical world.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "Who's responsible for the hallucinations?"

Hence Pascal's point. If you use AI to generate a file and use it in some way which causes problems it's your fault and those problems are down to you.

Apple squashes security bugs after iPhone flaws exploited by Predator spyware

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: These clowns

“take full control of our device” sounds more like Microsoft's approach. I think Apple is more along the lines of "it's your device but you're not going anywhere outside our walled garden". I suppose vulnerabilities like these could have also opened up the possibility of 3rd party stores such as F-Droid run for Android phones.

Europe wants easy default browser selection screens. Mozilla is already sounding the alarm on dirty tricks

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Yes, it's the frameworks that are the problem. All they give to the developer is apparent plausible deniability. Given that they chose to adopt the framework it's not even that plausible.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Choice screens are the least of the problems. Much worse is the growing habit of web sites checking the browser and refusing to play if it isn't one of their favoured ones - which is increasingly likely to be Chromium based.

Colleges snub Turnitin's AI-writing detector over fears it'll wrongly accuse students

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

People have been using textual analysis for years to (try to) identify writers. Computers have been used in the Who Really Wrote Shakespeare game since they became available. But I don't see it working well by trying to score individual sentences. I'd have thought it would work better picking on a whole lot of factors, consistency of choice of grammatical constructions, consistency of shortening (e.g can't vs cannot vs can not) & so forth that would require gathering statistics from the entire text or at least substantial portions of it. It might be quite reasonable for all replies form any particular LLM to occupy quite a small portion of a multidimensional space defined in that way.

Amazon 'protects' against junk AI e-books by limiting author-bots to three a day

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'm happy

It would take a controlled experiment to find out but it may well be hurting their profits already. They may be making money now but it's quite possible they could make more by letting customers find wht they're looking for.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "that limit protects its customers"

One book every three days would be too much.

Page: