* Posts by Cynic_999

2855 publicly visible posts • joined 15 Aug 2013

Laws on police facial recognition aren't tough enough, UK data watchdog barrister tells Court of Appeal

Cynic_999

Re: @mark l 2

Yes. It is extremely easy to police a population when you believe that all the criminals are colour-coded.

Cynic_999

No, China's facial recognition system is not significantly more accurate than anyone else's. They just have better propaganda promoting its use. It's a bit like the lie detector, which "works" only because the subect being tested believes that it works. The same is true of voodoo.

Cynic_999

Re: Not surprised

If the judge still did not understand the relative advantages (and disadvantages) of using Skype as compared with using a phone, then it was because you failed to explain it to him/her. That was your *job* as an expert witness. There was no need to go into any technicalities - the relative pros and cons are easily explainable without any reference to the technical reasons behind them.

Ex-barrister reckons he has a privacy-preserving solution to Britain's smut ban plans

Cynic_999

Re: This could actually make $$$

Kids swap porn at school via bluetooth etc. It will take time for all phones and PCs to be upgraded to ones that only have media players that are compliant - and even if parents can ensure that the phones have adult-content PIN codes, I suspect that non-compliant media players will exist that can be trivially downloaded, as well as apps that remove the flag from the header. Kids old enough to want to watch porn will do so - that genie cannot be put back in the bottle. Kids just need educating to see porn as fictitious entertainment used for sexual gratification and has nothing to do with how people behave (or should behave) in real life. Getting randy and masturbating is highly unlikely to harm any child, although like many other (non-sexual) activities, there is a small risk of it becoming obsessive.

PC printer problems and enraged execs: When the answer to 'Hand over that floppy disk' is 'No'

Cynic_999

What used to be a joke has become fact

I see that POTUS has recently accused the author of a book that exposes how stupid Trump is of revealing state secrets.

Google isn't even trying to not be creepy: 'Continuous Match Mode' in Assistant will listen to everything until it's disabled

Cynic_999

Re: Catching up, maybe???

There is a huge difference between a program that keeps the microphone live so that it can continuously "listen" for voice cues in real time, to a system that instead or in addition stores the audio for post-processing (or another purpose). People are unlikely to expect you to cover your ears if you happen to be within earshot, but would probably not be happy if you are recording them, in the same way that people will not object to you seeing their kids on the beach, but may well get very upset if you point a camera in their direction ...

A memo from the distant future... June 2022: The boss decides working from home isn't the new normal after all

Cynic_999

Real life

There are good reasons why most people far prefer to socialise with friends in person rather than simply opening a beer at home and chatting with their mates via video call. Even when there is no overt interaction, most also prefer to go to (e.g.) a cinema with a friend or friends rather than alone. People often find that they are happier carrying out DIY or housework etc. if there is someone present to talk to, even if that person is not assisting with the work. There are similar reasons why working at the office in the physical presence of collegues makes for a better & more productive work environment than working alone at home.

Health Sec Hancock says UK will use Apple-Google API for virus contact-tracing app after all (even though Apple were right rotters)

Cynic_999

Security theatre

I really cannot see how any contact tracing based on bluetooth can be anywhere close to effective enough to make any difference whatsoever to the spread of the virus. Being within range of another bluetooth device does not mean that you at at all likely to have caught the virus, and not having come within range does not mean you are significantly more likely to be safe. Consequently there will be far too many of both false positives and false negatives to be of any help at all. In fact, making people stop work and isolate for 14 days because (for example) they had an infected person stop next to them when both were in their cars at traffic lights will cause unnecessary hardship for many people.

Cynic_999

Re: NHSX devs apparently superior to Google devs

That makes no sense. A phone is not going to know it is lost unless someone sends a message to it telling it. And if you can notify the phone that it is lost, then the phone can reply immediately with its last known position. No need at all for bluetooth distress calls.

We cross now live to Oracle. Mr Ellison, any thoughts? 'Autonomous self-driving computers eliminate human labor, eliminate human error'

Cynic_999

Re: Fill the void

Computer error is *extremely* rare. Programming error and input error OTOH ...

Tens of millions of Internet-of-Things, network-connected gizmos at risk of remote hijacking? Computer, engage shocked mode

Cynic_999

Details needed

Pity there are no details of the bugs in question. I'd like to know whether or not such bugs would be exploitable over a NAT router, which is how most IoT devices would connect to the Internet. (NAT routers have to modify the IP and TCP or UDP headers of all packets, and so may well not pass whatever malformation is required to exploit the bug).

Only true boffins will be able to grasp Blighty's new legal definitions of the humble metre and kilogram

Cynic_999

"

Does anyone know if this works better if you put it in a bowl of rice?

"

It would then go snap, cracle and pop.

Cynic_999

Awkward definition for mass

I see the kg is defined with reference to caesium atoms and Planck's constant. Why? Having defined the metre, surely it would be easier to then define the kg as being the mass of a certain volume of pure water in a vacuum at it's temperature of maximum density. Using the conditions of a vacuum and temperature of max density means that it can then be derived without needing to define either units of pressure or units of temperature.

ZFS co-creator boots 'slave' out of OpenZFS codebase, says 'casual use' of term is 'unnecessary reference to a painful experience'

Cynic_999

It's not about the words

All words are simply hooks we use to hang concepts and objects. Words should never of themselves cause offence - it is the meaning and intent behind the words that are all that are relevant. That is true *even if* the contemporary meaning was derived from something distasteful. It is the meaning that the speaker/writer was conveying at the time that is the crux of the matter. The term "slave device" has nothing whatsoever to do with any form of human exploitation. Many English words have 2 or more meanings, and context is key.

Conversely, just because a person has carefully chosen neutral or positive words to convey an offensive concept does not make it any less offensive. Many very offensive ideas have been sold using positive-sounding words. Such as "patriot," "freedom" and "democracy."

What's next? Should I object to the term "execute a program" on the grounds that it might remind people of the death penalty? How about "whipped cream"?

ISTM that there are people who are determined to take offence even when they know full well that no offence was intended, and nothing involving harm was being even obliquely referenced.

I foresee that the home of the president in the US will soon be needing a coat of paint and a new name. Perhaps "The Orange House"?

Cynic_999

So you obviously object to the term, "child process"

Overload: A one-way ticket to a madman's situation

Cynic_999

Low power PCs

If programmers were permitted to use only low powered PCs with limited resources, ISTM that the quality of programs written would increase by quite a bit ...

From unmovable boot screens to dead certs, neither are what you want to see in a hospital

Cynic_999

Re: Signed Certificates are only as good as...

What would be wrong with a system where the certificate never automatically expires, but can be revoked if & when necessary?

Someone got so fed up with GE fridge DRM – yes, fridge DRM – they made a whole website on how to bypass it

Cynic_999

Re: Entirely legal

Sounds like you do not believe that the "internet of things" needs to be secure. One thing a malicious hacker *might* do is to program your WiFi enabled aircon to be part of a DDOS attack, or to send millions of spam emails. You wouldn't even know it was doing so.

Cynic_999

Re: Entirely legal

Or because parts have been unnecessarily glued or welded together so that it is impossible to make any reasonable repairs.

Russia drags NASA: Enjoy your expensive SpaceX capsule, our Soyuz is the cheap Kalashnikov of rockets

Cynic_999

> Having all humans on one planet is like putting all your eggs in one basket: if something goes wrong you can lose them all.

Yes maybe. But we are so far away from the possibility of setting up a long-term self-sustaining colony on a different planet that it is a sci-fi pipe-dream. Better ways of getting to another planet is the very least of the problems that will need to be solved. Talk of "terra-forming" a whole planet is laughable - we cannot alter the climate of Earth by even a tiny amount in the direction we want, so what chance of making changes that are many, many magnitudes greater anywhere else?

Not to say that we should not be working toward that goal - but to think that it is achievable within the next several centuries (at the very best) is delusional.

Still waiting for flying cars to become commonplace - as has been predicted regularly over the past 70 years - and surely represent a fraction of the design challenges that need to be overcome by any off-world settlement. It would be a lot easier to build an undersea city.

Cynic_999

Re: Roomy

And there was a certain naval ship accident that was attributed to having touchscreen throttles rather than physical levers. Touchscreen require you to look at the screen when operating the control. Physical levers can be located and operated by touch alone.

Cynic_999

Re: The Crew Dragon has a payload capacity of 6000Kg

> The Soyuz system is either more expensive to launch than Crew Dragon, or they are ripping the US off shamelessly.

No, those are not the only alternatives. Crew Dragon may be selling its services at less than cost in order to gain a market. And whether the profit made by a company on its product is enough to be described as a "rip-off" is completely subjective. I consider that Apple's mark-up is a shameless rip-off, but many would disagree. Same with Dyson's products. At the end of the day, capatilist doctrine says that the market dictates what is a fair price and nothing else.

Cynic_999

Re: Market price

We really cannot compare costs yet. A company that has a monopoly in a proven product will put a huge mark-up on its selling price, whilst a brand-new competior may well initially sell cheap (even below cost) in order to gain a foothold in the market. Only after both products have become established will the selling prices track the manufactuing costs more closely.

Cynic_999

I'm not so sure that the consequences for making an *effective* protest would be a lot different between the two countries.

Cynic_999

> How is the Crew Dragon more expensive at $55 million versus the $80+ mil the Russians were charging?

It was explained. It is effectively akin to comparing the manufactuing cost of your product to the retail cost of a similar rival product. The quoted cost of SpaceX is like the raw manufacturing cost without any profit being made, while the quoted cost of the Russian flight is what the Russians have chosen to charge their customers and is far higher than what it actually costs the Russians because they are making a profit.

As Uncle Sam flies spy drones over protest-packed cities, Homeland Security asks the public if that's a good idea

Cynic_999

Re: I am reminded...

Well - drones that are big enough to carry a kg or so of explosives are available to the general public at very affordable prices, so if the government started using drones to attack the public, the public could do the same in return. I doubt that many government buildings or military sites are adequately protected against a few bomb-carrying quadcopters - which can be either remotely controlled or pre-programmed to fly to the target.

Cynic_999

Re: I don't even see an option to make a comment.

> Police use helicopters for this all the time, and that is not qualitatively different than using a drone

In addition, helicopters are considerably more expensive to operate than drones. Which means that there are fewer helicopters available, and they will be used far more selectively - only for events where it is deemed such surveillance is highly likely to yield significant information.

How many Internet searches do you make each month? How many do you think you would make if you had to pay £10 per search? The easier & cheaper something is, the more likely that it will be used unnecessarily or inappropriately.

Oh crap: UK's digital overlords moot new rules to help telcos lay fibre in sewer pipes

Cynic_999
Joke

This was available ages ago:

https://archive.google.com/tisp/install.html

Cynic_999

Underground fibre is usually (always?) run by first burying a relatively large diameter pipe, and then blowing the fibre through it. This allows for far easier additional or upgraded fibre to be run later. So the detectability would depend more on the material that the pipe is made of rather than the fibre.

If the design is sensible, such pipes would have some sort of easily detectable marker built into the pipe, such as a metallic strip.

EU aviation wonks give all-electric training aeroplane the green light – but noob pilots only have 50 mins before they have to land it

Cynic_999

Re: The silence of the lands

Very true - and even rich students will almost all start training in a basic aircraft and then do a type conversion to a more complex aircraft only after gaining a PPL. For the same reason that people usually learn to drive in a car rather than an articulated lorry.

Cynic_999

Re: The silence of the lands

Ummm -

1) The vast majority of GA training flights are in an aircraft with a fixed pitch propellor

2) In VP aircraft attempting to take-off in full coarse pitch would be a huge mistake and probably culminate in a failed take off or accident. So is a very, very rare occurance.

2) Take-off and initial climb in small training aircraft aircraft will *always* be done at full power.

3) The angle of climb will not affect the amount of noise - and in any case will be at the recommended speed (and climb angle) for the aircraft configuration. Attempting to climb-out much steeper than that will lead to a stall and probably a fatal crash - though a steeper climb angle can be deliberately achieved by the use of a different flap setting and climb speed, which is practised in the PPL syllabus as a "short-field takeoff"

Cynic_999

Hybrid arragement

Aircraft engines need to be big enough to supply the maximum power demand - which is only needed during takeoff and initial climb. For the majority of any flight, the engine is producing significantly less than its maximum power.

So - you could fit a smaller petrol engine but have batteries supplying the extra power needed for takeoff and climb. As soon as the aircraft levels out in the cruise, the petrol engine can supply all the power the aircraft needs plus a bit extra to charge the batteries so they are ready for the next takeoff.

Such a hybrid power chain adds weight - whether that will be more or less than the weight saved by the smaller engine is a matter for the design engineers to calculate.

A hybrid arragement would also add to safety by giving an alternate power source in the event of an engine failure that would improve the chance of making it to a suitable place to land.

Cynic_999

Re: Here we go again...

Provided you can supply enough current to meet the maximum charge rate of the battery, charge time has *nothing* to do with battery capacity. If it did, then using your Tesla example, you should be able to charge your phone in a few seconds! Or you could halve the charge time by using two 12.5kW batteries that you charge at the same time instead of using one 25kW battery!

In fact minimum charge time is pretty much the same for any particular battery technology regardless of the battery capacity.

Cynic_999

Many (not all) training flights are booked as 1 hour slots - of which at least 10 minutes will be taken up by taxying and at the hold. So 50 minutes airborne is not ridiculously short - assuming that that includes a reasonable reserve so that the pilot can actually fly for 50 minutes rather than having to subtract a safety margin.

However if the aircraft is out of action for an hour after every flight to recharge, a flight school will need to have twice as many aircraft. Unless it can be fitted with a quick-change battery arrangement so that one set of batteries can be charging on the ground while the other set is flying.

US Air Force wants to pit AI-powered drone against its dogfighting hotshots in battle of the skies next year

Cynic_999

Conventional war in which dog-fights occur is only likely between enemies of more or less equal strength. When there is a huge disparity in military capabilities, warfare is conducted by means of guerilla warfare (aka "5th column", "terrorist"). This type of warfare is thus developed and used by weaker nations (and factions), while the powerful nations try to develop defences against it rather than employing such tactics themselves to any great extent. Increasing your firepower gives you no advantage whatsoever against someone leaving a bomb at a power station or dam wall, or pouring poison into your water supplies etc.

Cynic_999

And no CPU failure at high G

Contact-tracer spoofing is already happening – and it's dangerously simple to do

Cynic_999

Re: re: 1) my phone blocks numbers not in my contact list

If the caller can leave a message with their extension, they can also include the main phone number - so no need for caller ID

Cynic_999

Re: re: 1) my phone blocks numbers not in my contact list

Many companies use number withheld for good reason. If someone from that company calls you and gets no answer, you would probably see the missed call and call back. You'd then get through to the company's switchboard, and the receptionist would have no idea which of the company's employees had tried to call you.

Cynic_999

Good that you never need to take calls from numbers that are not in your contact list. I wonder whether your contact list includes all the numbers that may be used by your doctor, bank or the police?

As anti-brutality protests fill streets of American cities, netizens cram police app with K-Pop, airwaves with NWA

Cynic_999

Re: Antifa ; Anonymous

"

You can buy 'The Anarchist Handbook' on Amazon. Don't.

"

You forgot to mention that owning a copy of that book is illegal in the UK, and could get you serious jail time.

Cynic_999

Re: "Yes, Anon activists are back."

"

If you willingly failed to act on a situation or engineer a situation that results in death, isn't that murder too?

"

Failing to prevent a death is not generally a crime under UK law, no. There may be specific circumstances that give you a legal duty of care, but should you fail in that duty and someone dies, it would be manslaughter rather than murder.

As for "engineering a situation that results in death" - it would depend on whether you did or should have known that the situation you engineered was significantly likely to result in death or injury. Even then it would be manslaughter rather than murder unless it could be proven that you had the deliberate intention of killing or seriously injuring someone (not necessarily the actual victim).

I believe (but could be wrong) that France has a general law that requires its citizens to render reasonable assistance when a life is at risk.

Cynic_999

Re: I'm not afraid of the police. At all.

"

How do you feel about the FACT that more cops have been killed by criminals than cops have killed innocents?

"

You are welcome to your own opinions. You are not however welcome to your own facts.

As another poster has pointed out, a quick search reveals that your "fact" is a complete lie.

Cynic_999

Re: "Yes, Anon activists are back."

People who quote the "few bad apples" mantra usually never complete the quote. It is the few "bad apples" *that spoils the entire barrel*.

Cynic_999

Re: "Yes, Anon activists are back."

You completely miss the point. Sure, criminals do bad things. But they do not do so with the backing and support of the government, and they will be punished if caught. When government forces do bad things without facing any punishment it is a completely separate and different matter.

The fact that scores of people were killed by street gangs does not worry me nearly so much as the fact that a police officer can get away with murdering an innocent Brazillian electrician and not even be rebuked - and his commanding officer is even promoted. Or that an innocent man carrying a table leg can be gunned down by police with impunity. Or a naked and unarmed man can be shot and killed in his own bedroom by police who raided his home.

Guess who came thiiis close to signing off a €102k annual budget? Austria. Someone omitted 'figures in millions'

Cynic_999

It becomes even more confusing when a unit of measurement has two different meanings. Such as an Imperial gallon and a US gallon.

Or, for that matter, a megabyte being either 1000000 bytes or 1048576 bytes depending on what sounds better to marketing.

Software bug in Bombardier airliner made planes turn the wrong way

Cynic_999

Brilliant programming

I suspect that it would have taken many lines of code to have included such a function as a deliberate feature. Instead of all that effort, all the manufacturer now needs to do is document it and ask the relevant authorities to update their missed approach procedures so that turns are made in the opposite direction under certain conditions.

Cynic_999

" ... is an Andover over Dover on handover from Hanover, over"

Surprise! That £339 world's first 'anti-5G' protection device is just a £5 USB drive with a nice sticker on it

Cynic_999

I have a better device

For a cheaper price (£250), you can buy my device, which has a *red* sticker. It is superior because it uses quantum blockchain entanglement that maintains full biodiversity at the terahertz level, thus protecting against pathogens such as covid-19 and the common cold. If you are a female under the age of 30, I will require a photograph of your full body (without clothing) in order to properly calibrate the device.

China to test digital version of its currency at 2022 Winter Olympics

Cynic_999

We had it in the 1990's

We developed Mondex in the 1990's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondex

But it was inadequately publicised and so the public did not accept it. Mondex really is as anonymous as cash, because the money is stored as data in the Mondex wallet (smart card), and can be transferred directly to any other Mondex wallet with no external record of the transaction being kept, and no connection or data transfer to anywhere else. It is effectively exactly the same as having paper money & coins in a physical wallet. Transactions are fast because there is no need to check for approval from a third party. The downside is that just like cash notes, if your Mondex card is lost or destroyed, you lose your money. Therefore, like a physical wallet, it is not a good idea to have too much money in the card at any one time.

The card can however be secured with a PIN so that it is not attractive to a thief. Another advantage is that money can be transferred from one Modex card to another via a data connection (e.g. modem or Internet), so you can pay people anywhere in the World remotely (as well as anonymously).

Not going Huawei just yet: UK ministers reportedly rethinking pledge to kick Chinese firm out of telco networks by 2023

Cynic_999

Backdoors

As the article says, no backdoors have been found in Huawei kit despite a lot of people looking.

But just in case, maybe we should buy Cisco from the USA instead.

Oh ... wait ... https://www.tomshardware.com/uk/news/cisco-backdoor-hardcoded-accounts-software,37480.html