* Posts by Nick Kew

2841 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jan 2007

Looming EU copyright rules – tackling Google news article scraping, installing upload filters – under fire from all sides

Nick Kew

Fair Use

Genuine question regarding Google's use of short excerpts from newspaper stories.

Whatever happened to "Fair Use"? Quoting a short excerpt from a copyrighted work has always been fair game. And when I search news, what I see at Google seems to me entirely fair use: a sentence or two quoted help me judge which particular links on a results page I'll click through to read the full story.

The real issue seems to me the obstacles many of the newspapers then put in my way when I click through. I wonder if the real grievance isn't that so many people just decline to jump through their hoops and go elsewhere?

Nick Kew

Re: But does YouTube really hate it?

Any regulation runs the risk of unintended consequences. You may have just identified one.

Or perhaps one reason the commission itself watered down its original draft was that someone convinced them of this very point?

Nick Kew
Stop

Not true. Copyleftists right back to the Prophet RMS are very clear that getting paid and charging for ones work are OK.

There may be an element in the Peanut Gallery who demand everything free, but I'm surprised at you conflating those with Copyleftists.

US midterms barely over when Russians came knocking on our servers (again), Democrats claim

Nick Kew

Are you sure your disc drive has stopped rotating, or are you just ignoring the messages?

Nick Kew

Re: I can believe it!

Security is one possible concern. And simply discouraging printing, so people only do it when there's a real good reason.

Back in the days when printers (and 'puters) cost real money, it was also part of office management. Restrict access to trained staff. Admin/secretarial staff to pick up printouts and shove them in $user's intray.

Not entirely illogical. Open it to everyone, and someone is sure to mess it up. If not changing the toner, then trying inexpertly to clear a paper jam. Or something.

Nick Kew

Re: I can believe it!

Hmm. None of you worked in the kind of corporate environment where the printer is/was in a forbidden area? Or simply a completely unknown location that's never the same two jobs running? Out of paper was indeed a problem one couldn't deal with oneself.

Diplomat warns that tech industry has become a pawn as politicos fight dirty

Nick Kew

Re: National Champions

Are you putting your own money where your mouth (or keyboard) is?

If so, respect for your conviction. I find betting on weakness too scary.

Nick Kew

Re: Wrong way round?

@Mage - that's 20th century (and, to an extent, older) trends you're describing. The rise of megacorps.

What a cheep shot: Bird sorry after legal eagles fire DMCA takedown at scooter unlock blog

Nick Kew
Facepalm

Pics?

This story carries a headline pic of a keyboard with some litter on it. Adding nothing to the story - in normal Reg tradition.

But surely this is a case where we really should have a relevant pic! For those of us who have never heard of "bird scooters" - but have seen a few variants on the "Boris Bike" without always knowing whether they were municipal or private sector - it could give some clue what you're actually talking about!

(Googling finds pics, and they appear to make Boris Bikes look advanced and luxurious by comparison).

*taps on glass* Hellooo, IRS? Anyone in? Anyone guarding taxpayers' data from crooks? Hellooo?

Nick Kew

Re: We're 14 days into 2019 so far...

'Scuse an ignorant Brit failing to understand US government, but ...

That shutdown 24 days ago was because Congress wouldn't give Trump his toy?

That must be a Republican Congress. The incoming Democrats merely inherited the tantrum.

Yesno?

Nick Kew

Re: Governing America

After April too. Michael Gove (whose ministerial responsibility includes food) gave a categorical assurance in an interview broadcast on the morning of Jan 5th. No lowering of food standards, including on imports.

Meaning of course a No to the US red lines on a trade deal. No US food standards, no US trade deal, and most of the brexit controversies are moot. In particular, Gove's assurance is precisely what the EU need to hear for the Irish Border Problem to go away.

... or would be, if only a government minister's assurances carried weight against brexit ideology.

Facebooker swatted, Kaspersky snares an NSA thief, NASA server exposed, and more

Nick Kew

Re: Xterm re-implemented in Javascript.

It's not new. It rings a bell associated with stuff I was playing with around '97-ish, from which I infer it's been around in some form since last century.

CES flicks the off switch on massager award… and causes a buzz

Nick Kew

Note how his metadata morphs - from sensible comment to a proxy for recursion - as the article progresses. The pronunciation nonsense, along with the recursion, is space filler for an article whose contents and wordcount were mismatched.

If I could turn back time, I'd tell you to keep that old Radarange at home

Nick Kew
FAIL

Re: NTP

Story set in Early '90s.

So NTP was just getting under way (RFC 1305 in 1992), but far from widely established. A bleeding-edge try-me-and-debug protocol might seem a less-than-obvious choice for such an, erm, immediate problem. Even if Our Hero was himself a Networking Man and had heard of it.

The D in SystemD stands for Dammmit... Security holes found in much-adored Linux toolkit

Nick Kew
Coat

That penguin in the pic

Do I spot the merest hint of orange on top?

Fake news? More like ache news. Grandma, grampa 'more likely' to share made-up articles during US election

Nick Kew

Daily Mail & co

Must be sitting back smugly.

Oh look, an academic study seems to have stumbled on how we pull our readership's strings.

Attention all British .eu owners: Buy dotcom domains and prepare to sue, says UK govt

Nick Kew

Re: How long until the new referendum will be called?

To be fair, there have been UKIP-ancestors longer than that. The National Front in the 1970s and the BNP since the 1980s campaigned for out, and their exclusion from all debate has probably fuelled some of the vitriol that now drives brexit.

What changed for UKIP (apart from deep-pocketed Establishment backing) was an era of white immigration, that helped a slick publicity machine separate an anti-immigration agenda from cries of racism that could've silenced them. Ironically they're basically right: anti-immigration and anti-immigrant are not the same, though there was ample overlap to see off the UKIP predecessors.

Nick Kew

Re: Don't worry, it's only money

Not just Cornwall.

See a really nice Dartmoor house? An affordable £250k, probably because it needs work, like installing modern electrics and connecting to water mains, not to mention general refurbishment for (if nothing bad turns up) a large six-digit builders bill.

Look at the smallprint. That £250k isn't the house, it's a lease that expires in 2026, after which you pony up all over again for up to a 20 year maximum. Could that be why noone has put in the investment to modernise? Oh, and you're also paying £7k/year rent, which will also have to be renegotiated when the term is up.

That's what it's like having Charles's mafia on your patch.

Nick Kew

Re: Wow, it's almost...

Foreign intervention has been openly taking place for well over 30 years.

Most famous (but not I think the worst) instance: Rupert Murdoch.

Nick Kew

Re: Wow, it's almost...

You do realise that she is an elected MP?

For those of us who don't live in Maidenhead (and who the **** can afford that?), she's not elected. I've never had the opportunity to vote for or against her, not even in theory.

Of course she's in a Damned-if-you-Do/Don't position, with an undefined decision to implement, and thugs who make Tommy Robinson sound like the voice of reason claiming "52%" for their fantasy.

Hmm, looks like a manifestation of what I posted two and a half years ago:

That’s an agenda claiming – and believing they have – a 52% electoral mandate, yet not really representing even the whole of the BNP/UKIP. Give them their isolationism and we can rapidly slip back to poverty, and with less food or energy security than even in the 1970s. Deny it to them and it seems most unlikely they’ll shut up.

Drone goal! Quadcopter menace alert freezes flights from London Heathrow Airport

Nick Kew
Holmes

Re: pictures?

I'll stick to my theory. Gatwick was a christmas tree; all that follows is inspired by that.

Nick Kew

Re: At least people can take comfort from the fact that ...

Thanks for invoking that great cultural memory.

Carry On Flying. Sid James pulls stunts to distract attention from [subplot involving Windsor's assets and evil genius Williams]. Clouseau-eqsue cop Bresslaw devotes lots of effort to Innocent Hawtrey seen in possession of kiddies model aircraft that doesn't fly. Any screenwriters want to flesh something out?

Sorry, Samsung. Seems nobody is immune to peak smartphone

Nick Kew

Nobody is immune?

OK, what kind of a "nobody" is that? Does it apply also to those vendors who price a phone as working technology rather than a fashion statement?

Would be kind-of delicious if Huawei turned out to be eating their lunch. Though I'd settle for others like Moto, whose G has served me nicely for the last few years.

This is the final straw, evil Microsoft. Making private GitHub repos free? You've gone too far

Nick Kew

Re: Free! For up to three collaborators!

So that'll do nicely for experimenting with a prospective project. Zero entry cost, and if it shows signs of growth you cross that bridge when you come to it with all options available.

Huawei's 5G security scrutiny pain could be Cisco's gain – analysts

Nick Kew
Devil

Re: News at 11?

Well, the fact that it says Cisco but NOT other western players might say something?

Maybe it's because Cisco had been badly wrongfooted in the market? What it's now benefiting from is time to catch up. That is not to Nokia's or Ericsson's benefit if they were competing on fairly-equal terms with Huawei and each other all the time.

US tech industry falling behind $rest-of-world cannot be more than a temporary aberration! A share price up 24% looks like a bottom line, and in a broader market that's a sea of red ink, it says the campaign has been successful.

Happy new year, readers. Yes, we have threaded comments, an image-lite mode, and more...

Nick Kew
Holmes

Re: A question about buttons...

OK, someone had to view source. Might as well be me.

Shadow Systems is right, and his screenreader is also right. The arrows are nowhere in the markup, they're merely part of the stylesheet.

Here's a relevant cut&paste .. damn, neither unescaped nor fully-escaped works here, I'm going to switch <> to [] instead:

[div class=actions] [a class="vote up" title="Like this post? Vote for it!" data-user-vote="true" href="https://forums.theregister.co.uk/post/vote/up/3687493"] 9 [/a] [a class="vote down" title="Dislike this post? Vote it down!" href="https://forums.theregister.co.uk/post/vote/down/3687493"] 0 [/a]

What Shadow Systems describes is exactly what's there. Putting on my accessibility hat, I'd say that's a real issue, and should be remedied.

The simplest remedy would be to add the up and down arrows as icon images within the links: this is what it already looks like to a visual browser. Then alt=upvote / alt=downvote will render just fine in a screenreader. The drawback there is the extra markup, but the icons themselves are purely passive: being within the links is what matters, and you can get rid of that abusive use of the title attribute on the links.

There is probably an alternative solution using an audio stylesheet to inform screenreaders, but my knowledge of the subject is way too outdated to suggest implementation details.

Nick Kew

Pagination

There seems to be a gremlin.

After a week or two of threaded comments mostly all-on-one-page over the season of humbug, today I'm getting oldfashioned pagination (three pages to this article). From memory, today's Friday regulars On-Call and Dabbs also paginated on me.

Yes, I did check my personal settings before posting this. Everything was set to the defaults, which apparently should mean no pagination!

Nick Kew

Re: Width

Too much text at El Reg? Tosh!

I trust El Reg is not so dumb as to give even a moment's thought to following the stupid trend of many websites to emulate a vacuous powerpoint.

My 2019 resolution? Not to buy any of THIS rubbish

Nick Kew

Re: You miserable sod ...

He's an entertainer. The curmudgeon is good entertainment.

Give him 50 columns over the year, I expect most of his no-nos will put in an appearance. Maybe not all of them describing his own experiences with them.

New Horizons probe reveals Ultima Thule is huge, spinning... chicken drumstick?

Nick Kew

Re: Beyond the Known World

It's not that. It's a semi-mythical land at the end of the world. The name goes back to the Greeks, but of course it's a lot more remote and exotic than anything in the Odyssey.

By going to the end of the world, NASA seems to be saying they can have no possible ambition to go any further.

What happens when a Royal Navy warship sees a NATO task force headed straight for it? A crash course in Morse

Nick Kew

I have fond memories of that Bergen-Newcastle ferry. Sleeping out on deck, and realising in the morning it was probably the best place, as other passengers bemoaned their enclosure.

Has that line been restored? Last I heard, it was being discontinued.

Millennium Buggery: When things that shouldn't be shut down, shut down

Nick Kew

Re: Engineers who become managers

Nobody who wasn't a competent techie should ever manage competent techies.

Bah. My experience of UK industry (not so much elsewhere) are that managers are incompetent techies who got promoted to move them on from a role in which they were useless.

Nick Kew

A metric for management failure

Our Parliament looks like an interesting case of extreme management failure. Both for itself (failure to manage necessary building maintenance) and for the country (b*****).

While few can aspire to rival that, we can nevertheless use it as a yardstick. This never-never update could no doubt clock up a few MicroParliaments.

Heard the one where the boss calls in an Oracle consultant who couldn't fix the database?

Nick Kew

Re: Take care what you argue over...

@Old Used Programmer - your missus may be more authentic than us. Swift's usage (which I had forgotten until you mentioned it) pre-dates, and may be the inspiration for, ours.

Nick Kew

Re: Naming conventions

Not entirely original. Homer got there first, where Odysseus outwits the Cyclops. But still a jolly wheeze.

Nick Kew

In school?

Computers existed, and were indeed beginning to appear in schools by the time I left. But not in the kind of school I went to, that relied on the state for its budget.

I had the impression you were of a comparable vintage yourself?

Nick Kew

@jake - Round about 2000?

Those of us whose education pre-dates computer science as a supposedly-serious degree subject[1] started with all sorts of gaps in our knowledge. Noone explained to me heap vs stack, I just figured it out on the job sometime back in the 1980s.

[1] Including some who later taught the subject, and whose graduates emerged qualified for things their professors never will be on the recruiters' tickboxes.

Nick Kew

Re: RE: Getting one over on the boss

Once upon a less-than-happy time, I was tasked with setting up a company mailserver to keep copies of everything (company afraid of lawyers).

On paper.

With all attachments. OK, I made that one up: they didn't think of attachments, but I did, and pointed out some issues with them.

Bored IT manager automates Millennium Eve checks to ditch snoozing for boozing

Nick Kew
Unhappy

Re: Handy stuff this automation.

Damn, I set myself right up for that.

Can I say "damn you" at the same time as upvoting?

Nick Kew

Re: Handy stuff this automation.

One day indeed. In my case, starting in the 1980s.

Trouble is, when you're in a busy office, automating jobs away just leaves you without a job. Going home would be noticed.

Nick Kew

Re: The Sorcerer's Apprentice

I can cite working examples! How about the moon's orbit, for one?

For values of perpetual in not just human but geological time ...

Nick Kew

Re: Needs the human touch

I have cron jobs that run at hour+delta, where delta is a small number of minutes. It's a habit I started when working on busy shared systems, and I thought it made sense to offset my jobs from the likeliest peaks of scheduled activity.

In a one-off script, I might do something like

$ run-job-1

$ sleep 30

$ run-job-2

... etc

Racing at the speed of light, Sage superhero bursts through the door...

Nick Kew

Re: Not me...

There's repetition and repetition. I certainly remembered your recent anecdote, perhaps 'cos it was eye-catching first time round (and I expect you got my upvote - though that's not the level of detail I commit to memory). Had it been years rather than months ago, the reminder might have been entertaining in its own right.

Did I mention ... erm ... OK, yes I did.

Nick Kew
Nick Kew
Angel

Re: Not me...

Looks at us and says, "Thanks, guys. I will be in touch. Carry on." Took care of us, too. And we got a written apology.

Oooh. If ever there was a true dream situation @work, you just described it.

Staff sacked after security sees 'suspect surfer' script of shame

Nick Kew

Re: Trying to avoid the Wrath of Swambo?

Now that you mention it, I recollect something akin to the reverse.

Was introduced to the Karma Sutra at age 19. Girlfriend shared it with me, not vice versa.

Nick Kew

Re: Access Denied

@Goldmember - I'd veto them on grounds of the prolific spam they inflicted.

Nick Kew

Re: @AC "wouldn't be common freakin' sense to not surf dodgy websites at work?"

As early as the early 1980s, Internet bandwidth getting maxed out always meant porn.

1980s porn being ASCII porn. As in (.) (.) . If you mean anything more ambitious, I'll refer you to this from my blog.

I guess you never worked in a data-heavy environment.

First web server I set up for $work was about access to satellite image data. The expectation was that clients would order the actual data on tape[1], but I convinced management to allow limited online actual download. The limit was eventually set to 10Mb, for those whose line would hold up for the very long time that would take.

[1] The fact they could use a nice WWW GUI including an applet to select a dataset from an interactive and zoomable map display was radical for the time. A few years later ('96 or '97) Java applets arrived and some of that capability migrated to clientside.

Nick Kew

Re: @AC "wouldn't be common freakin' sense to not surf dodgy websites at work?"

Then there was this thing called USENET so you really didn't have to go to dodgy web sites to surf.

Damn, I've led a sheltered life. Never encountered usenet binaries: they were one of those mythical things.

Nick Kew

Re: "wouldn't be common freakin' sense to not surf dodgy websites at work?"

2) (In the 1990s) It is faster than my 56K connection

You've led a sheltered life there.

56K? Pah. I was lucky to get 56 bytes. Per minute, at work, and home was little better.