Re: Hmmm
I think the only truly negative thing you can say about them is that they took too long to react when the problem first appeared and we're too quick to say they had identified the cause of the fault.
Too long to react? How so? The device had been out less than a week and (at least in the UK) wasn't yet generally available and only people who had pre-ordered had a device.
I do agree that they were too quick to claim to have identified the problem and shipping new devices out. Given the issue seems to be more likely to be related to charging hardware rather than battery (Li-Ion is rather sensitive to ovevercharging/incorrect charging voltage) the end result would most likely have been the same, full recall.