* Posts by Charles Manning

3509 publicly visible posts • joined 26 Jun 2007

Read-only nation: can Open Source change the British way?

Charles Manning

Building false expectations

This change to ICT gives people a very warped idea of what computer technology is about. Computer science is one of very few fields where the universities expect that the students have absolutely no experience and indeed have very strange expectations of what the subject is about.

My son is in first year computer science and I had a discussion with one of his lecturers, which provided some alarming stats:

Of the intake, around 6% had done a lot of programming, about half had never programmed and the rest had done a little programming.

Computer science has the highest failure rate of any first year subject in the science/engineering area.

First year doesn't really get into proper computer science. It is really there to weed out those with the aptitude and desire from those who thought: "Hey I like playing with Facebook, maybe I should study computer science."

Given that so few kids actually go into university with any understanding of what CS is about, it is no wonder.

Google was 'warned repeatedly' about rogue drug ads

Charles Manning

I want a CC limited to only certain countries

The further problem with CC handling is that there is no limit on where a CC gets processed. Hand over a CC number and it can get charged anywhere.

To counter this, many customers would likely prefer to have a CC that can only be charged in certain countries, as specified by the customer. That way we get to limit how our CCs are used.

I'd limit mine to the country where I live and a few where I do internet charging. I would not want my CC processed anywhere else.

Make it the banks' problem. They'll soon make something work.

Intel rewrites 'inadequate' roadmap, 'reinvents' PC

Charles Manning

Quintillions of milliwatts

See there is a use for that number.

While Intel might actually be able to make SOCs, the real challenge is going to be to handle diversity and customer demand.

ARM do that by making cores and allowing others to take those cores and design their own chips and getting those fabbed wherever. Doing this requires an infrastructure that supports such customization.

Unless Intel have the ability to allow their customers to specify custom chips they will never play this game.

Intel are also formed around the idea of making really high margin chips. If margins come down to a dollar or so per chip will they still be able to keep their heads above water?

Bing to offer Facebook-slurping 'friend search'

Charles Manning

But....

You need FB and Bing to tell you that they are your friends..

Renault readies sub-£7000 e-car for Blighty

Charles Manning

It's not even an e-car

It's an e-quad-bike. Only one small step up from an e-scooter. Will it get any grant at all?

Glass aeroplanes and iPads on the way, say boffins

Charles Manning

Look down at the baggage in the hold

What a view!

Apple seeks patent for keyboard that sucks

Charles Manning

And unfortunately the step can be quite small

Prior art on a full-size keyboard is suddenly novel if applied to a cell phone.

Official: phones sting bees

Charles Manning

How about the real factors....

OK, EM radiation from phones etc might be a small cause, but putting too much emphasis on this masks the more significant reasons.

The most serious reasons are surely:

1) Gross over-management of bee hives. Bees are no longer allowed to breed naturally - which allows them to adapt to local conditions and changing conditions. Instead bees are bred for honey production and to make them placid. Instead of allowing these selected bees to then breed naturally, it is very common for hives to be "re-queened" on an annual basis. The old queen gets killed and a new queen is brought in. How are the bees supposed to adjust to conditions with that sort of management. No wonder they're stressed and can't cope with mild environmental changes.

Then there are even worse practices (in USA/Canada at least) of renting out bees and trucking them to follow the crops starting in Souther USA and ending up in Canada. When they get to the end of the road the bees are killed. As they move, they also compete with local bees, preventing them from surviving properly. How the hell are these bees supposed to thrive in an environment like that.

2) Loss of habitat and forage.

3) Pesticides etc. (possibly)

If cell phones are a real problem they are so low on the list that they have practically no impact.

How bin Laden thwarted US electronic surveillance

Charles Manning

Not much different to UUCP then...

... just using a mechanical link.

Still faster than regular post.

Israeli hover-jeep returns to flight testing

Charles Manning

Would you trust a robot to fly out your injured buddy?

Well what are the alternatives? If I have to choose between putting my buddy in one of these or him not getting any medical support then it's a nobrainer!

Sod-all for tech in Australian federal budget

Charles Manning

IT is a generalised expense

IT expenditure is in all sorts of budgets. Why expect there to be a specific IT budget any more than a specific paper clips budget?

Official: Microsoft buys Skype for $8.5bn

Charles Manning

Enjoying?

Until a few weeks back, the Skype client on ubuntu crashed as soon as a call was established.

HP's beloved 12c calculator turns 30

Charles Manning

Excellent!

A big problem with HPs is that all the scientifics are programmable and thus cannot be used for some exams. That really sucks for anyone who is used to RPN and needs to use a Casio etc.

Sinclair Scientific sounds like an option.

New top-secret stealth choppers used on bin Laden raid

Charles Manning

Yeah sure, but

Don't they train their pilots to handle this sort of flying? Of course they do.Perhaps the pilot has trained on a regular Blackhawk and this new extra-blade version handles very differently.

Or of course it could have just crashed for numerous reasons or have been shot down.

Charles Manning

But it was not shot down

"Being in the middle of a firefight seems to lessen the lifespan of most copters" only if it gets shot down. The USAian were very quick to say it was not shot down so either it was duff hardware or bad driving.

Woz snubs Paul Allen, praises pea soup

Charles Manning

Design patent, not utility patent

Apple is annoyed because they have a design patent for a particular look and style which Samsung is copying.

This is not at all the same as a utility patent.

Pakistani IT admin leaks bin Laden raid on Twitter

Charles Manning

Exactly correct

Here is Christchurch NZ we had the twitterati reporting on the recent earthquakes. Much of what was said and was harvested by media was complete crap. Reports of certain buildings falling down that were unscathed and later had to be withdrawn.

At least reporters have some training and know to distinguish between rumour and verifiable reports but the unwashed masses don't care about that when trying to get their tweet out and be the centre of attention.

Of course at the end of the day it really does not seem to matter. News is no longer concerned with conveying fact. It is far more interested in drama and competing with other entertainment on TV etc. Poor young journalists who sign up to a career modeled on Woodward and Bernstein and end up just generating punchy headlines to attract clicks and eyeballs.

Yahoo! Hadoop! brain! spin-off! doomed! to! fail!

Charles Manning

Talent went to Cloudera? So what!

These are not unionized auto workers who expect a job for life. This is the software industry where people change jobs like underwear.

Many of those who went over to Cloudera did so out of frustration of how yahoo was operating. Fix what's broken and give the right incentives and many will stream back.

Natty Narwahl: Ubuntu marine mammal not fully evolved

Charles Manning

Fanboi lost his logic?

"But then bashing something has greater dramatic effect if the tone of the editorial is such that it appears you have no alternative."

He was bashing Unity because it is crap and not ready.

Saying Unity is fine because you can replace it with classic gnome would seem as daft as saying Windows Vista is fine because you can replace it with XP.

ARM's Intel challenger set for 2012 release

Charles Manning

ARM != Advances Risc Machine

Even if it did stand fro that in the past, ARM is now just ARM and means nothing.

Charles Manning

Nobody wants storage

What they want is access to their "stuff".

As wireless mobile networking gets faster and cheaper, cloding makes more and more sense.

The tin-foil hat wearers will be worried about third party service provides but worried folk and organisations can manage their own data and can make their own clouds.

Ubuntu 'Natty Narwhal' breaks the surface

Charles Manning

11.04's "killer app"

is definitely Ubuntu Classic

What the hell is it with these UI people? KDE3 was easy to use. KDE4 introduced a whole lot of abstractions that might make sense to UI theoreticians but make no sense to Joe and Jane Punter.

Unity seems like the Ubuntu attempt to to KDE4.

TomTom sorry for giving customer driving data to cops

Charles Manning
Thumb Up

Turning a blind eye to speeding harms everyone

If you get nicked for speeding then I'm glad. You're a wanker who disregards the safety of others and deserve to be caught and fined.

If TomTom is helping dickheads like you get caught then that's good.

I don't have a GPS navigator, but if I do buy one it will be a TomTom!

Apple breaks location-storing silence

Charles Manning

Commentard sheep

And after the pissing and moaning they'll all still use their smartphones, Facebook, ....

Microsoft lobby will turn Google into Microsoft

Charles Manning
FAIL

I might have the details wrong, but...

AFAIK, Google did not actually intrude into any networks and snoop around trying to extract pictures of your daughter, bank records or the like.

AFAIK, all they did was record SSIDs broadcast by the wireless routers and geotag them. The SSIDs are broadcast according to a well known protocol for publishing/advertising SSIDs to invite attachment.

A more fitting analogy would be that your daughter was standing on the front lawn - in full view of all - yelling out "Hi I'm Mandy and I want some I/O" as Google drove past...

Charles Manning

All patents

Why just take on software patents? All patents suffer the same flaws as software patents. All stifle innovation as much as each other.

I've heard the argument that all software is equivalent to a mathematical formula and you can't patent those. Bollocks. Uncle Turing told us all computers and programs are equivalent to machines and you can patent those.

Either all patents are a bad idea or all ideas should be patentable. Software does not deserve any special treatment.

Patents have been a big headache for software/computer developers for a long time - the whole history of computing in fact - and it is probably close to impossible to develop any reasonable body of software that does not violate at least one patent. Even if patents can be invalidated with prior art they are valid until overturned. That means for some software that the legal battles will take more man hours than the development.

Lasers set to replace spark plugs in car engines

Charles Manning

For illuminting cockpits

Many governments are trying to crack down on those green lasers sued to dazzle pilots.

These spark plug lasers must be pretty intense and will be stocked by every car parts outlet. Won't they make night flying a bit more fun?

Google pours millions into wind power

Charles Manning

Not very difficult.

A car using 10l/100km (28mpg UK) will emit approx 230g CO2/km. 5 tons is around 20,000 km.

World pays tribute to Yuri Gagarin

Charles Manning

Manned space flight: politics, not science

Hats off to Gagarin and and his orbital brethren, but manned flights to the moon and beyond have always been political moves - not scientific ones.

Orbital platforms (ISS etc) give us an interesting platform for some science, but going to the moon was motivated purely by the political goal of beating the Russians at something during in the cold war - to give the USians something to crow about.

It is ridiculous to send a man to do a robot's job. The Russians knew this from day one. The Russians missions to the moon gathered as much science (photos, rocks, sensor measurements) as the yanks. Robots allow you to do things far more efficiently and experimentally - no bodies to worry about.

What the yanks wanted though was a picture of guys in white saluting the Stars and Stripes.

It is not at all surprising that once Apollo 11 had fulfilled the political goal of putting a man on the moon and bringing him back, the Apollo mission lost all its lustre. Apollo 13 would have had no more interest than ST116 if it had not had all the drama of men stuck in space.

H2O water-powered shower radio

Charles Manning

It is harvesting waste

If you just open the tap and let the water gush out then the energy is just turned into heat and sound. The pump still works the same because it still pressurizes x amount of water to the same delivery pressure.

Exactly the same happens with one of those pressure reduction valves.

The only (slight) difference is that the heat generated by the high velocity water has been reduced and thus you will set the water temp slightly higher and your water heater will have to work harder.

MYSTERY of huge Canadian chicken-shed EXPLOSION

Charles Manning

Hadn't been used for years...

except for a clandestine meth lab.

Charles Manning

How to make saltpetre

http://www.ssrsi.org/Onsite/PrimNG/chem1.htm

All you need is some dirt from a farm shed. A chicken raising barn should have accumulated quite a lot of nitrates over the years. Spill some diesel and you have ANFO...

Microsoft reveals WinPhone 7 'Mango' details

Charles Manning

Huh?

These are basic features one would have expected in the first release. Does WP7 really suck that bad?

UK is 15th best place in the world to do IT

Charles Manning

Still...

I prefer to live in rural NZ on the wrong end of a 2Mbps link. Sitting here appreciating my home office door open and the sound of tree frogs with a backdrop of a paddock of sheep.

Gigabits aren't everything. Defunutly.

Nissan Leaf electric car

Charles Manning

Not if the power is signed with a Nissan authentication key

If it is Nissan brand power then it just charges.

Nokia to help WinPho outsell iOS in four years

Charles Manning
Thumb Down

Also forgets...

Most of the Nokia phones sold worldwide are candy-bar phones with very little margin and sell for approx the cost of a WinPho license and make very little profit for Nokia.

If you look at anything comparable to an iphone then Nokia sells less than 20M devices/year (ie. one seventh of Apple).

The vast bulk of phones will continue to be candy-bar phones selling at lower and lower prices. ie. Today's candy-bar phones sold cheaper and to a wider audience.

If they want to, Apple could play this game too without killing their premium products. Think of the ipod nano vs ipod touch.

MS will continue to specify high end specs to keep a comoditised high end platform for interoperability. MS will not want WP to be sold in smaller handsets because that kills the brand.

Charles Manning

re: This prediction is not credible.

Agree on all points

Facebook Data Center: If it won't run ARM, what will it run?

Charles Manning
Coat

Cooling

All they need are fanbois.

TI acquires National Semiconductor for $6.5bn

Charles Manning

Digital Engineering 101

All digital electronics is analogue - just driven to clipping.

TI already has a good portfolio of analogue devices and interface chips. Perhaps they're really after IP.

Single-patent lawsuit hits Apple, Google, Amazon, Priceline...

Charles Manning

Sue the USPTO, not the companies

The USPTO will continue to crank out crap patents until they get to be held responsible. Uncle Sam loves them because they actually generate federal income. The only measure being applied to the USPTO is number processed and how much cash they generate.

If the USPTO had to bear the costs of defending crap patents then the quality might improve.

Fukushima fearmongers are stealing our Jetsons future

Charles Manning

And turns into...

Plant food.

Stop sexing up IT and give Civil Servants Macs, says gov tech boss

Charles Manning

It's a common myth

The logic: Anyone can get to and modify the source code - including malicious people. Therefore it is easy to inject back doors etc into open source code. Therefore open source cannot be trusted.

Google unleashes (another) Facebook knock-off

Charles Manning
WTF?

Perhaps

you were thinking of Microsoft.

Nokia deal to 'rocket Windows Phone 7 past iPhone'

Charles Manning

Get knowledge before speaking

"And won't my hard work be pirated due to the wild west "open" nature of the Android app space?"

No. You don't have to release the source to your apps or give them away for free. No real difference between Andoid apps and others.

"Which version??" Most of the core functionality is the same. I still download apps for my G1 that work the same on my Nexus1.

Do you really believe that WinMo7 will give you a future proof platform? Every WinPhone version has changed the APIs. Of course MS are quite slow at getting their act together so WinMo7 will likely still be their latest offering in 2015.

Handy radiation checker comes to iPhone

Charles Manning
WTF?

Why do you wear your laundry in the bath?

I guess if you splash about a lot it will result in good agitation.

How to slay a cellphone with a single text

Charles Manning
Megaphone

Er...

How do you tell them apart?

The message was clearly sufficiently formed to be transmitted and transfered through the network.

It is only "malformed" in the eyes of the receiver.

TV sitcom opens up the world of penetration testing

Charles Manning

Same as 555 phone numbers

They use fictional numbers to prevent being hassled by the owners of the real IP address.

This is **ENTERTAINMENT**. Don't expect fact.

Don't expect boring sifting through logs etc. Expect some wizzy 3D graphics that show a connection going red.

The bad news is that this distort expectations like CSI has. Every crime can be solved in 30 minutes - minus ad breaks. Pointy-haired-boss will expect any intrusion can be sorted in the same amount of time.

Assange ambushes Australian Prime Minister on live TV

Charles Manning
Paris Hilton

Poor little narcissist

Haven't been in the headlines recently, have we?

<- Perhaps she can squeeze out a tear for you.

Chicken Little report: Sat-nav dependency spells DISASTER!

Charles Manning

No low-tech alternative for timing

GPS is near ubiquitous use in high precision timing is far more worrysome than anything loss of navigation.

GPS provides accurate timing down to tens of nanoseconds. Nothing else comes close (except for Galeleo and GLONAS).

Radio time signals, NTP etc are orders of magnitude away and are not good enough for high precision timing.

No more cell phones. No more broadband. That's where the real dark ages will come from.

Japanese nuke meltdown may be underway

Charles Manning
FAIL

Moronic argument

Incremental amounts over years have a completely different impact than massive releases.

Compare these two events:(A) Shoot Joe with an AK47. (B) Give Joe a cup of tea and let him drink it at his leisure.

You'd expect the cup of tea to cause far more damage since it is releasing approx 5-10 times as much energy into Joe as shooting him with the AK47.

But, curiously, the AK47 causes more damage. Can't figure out why.