* Posts by Ken Hagan

8168 publicly visible posts • joined 14 Jun 2007

'There was no one driving that vehicle': Texas cops suspect Autopilot involved after two men killed in Tesla crash

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: This is weird

"a) the cops are wrong"

"b) Tesla are lying "

I think we should allow Elon to be just "wrong" rather than "lying". He's no less human than the cops.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Tesla boss Elon Musk has not explicitly responded to the incident

It's a very interesting update. Whether it is "job done" when the local police are "100% convinced" that no-one was driving the car is another matter. If both statements are true, then we have to come up with a scenario where both passengers know the car doesn't drive itself and yet neither is at the wheel when it smacks at high speed into a tree.

Maybe such a scenario exists. My gut feeling, though, is that either the police or Elon are wrong.

What next for Visual Studio? Microsoft's monster IDE can't please everyone and 64-bit will not solve legacy problems

Ken Hagan Gold badge

"huge news"

"huge news for devs who have been requesting this for over a decade"

Genuinely surprised by this. If your *IDE* needs more than 2GB, you're doing it wrong. This is basically an editor/debugger with the ability to launch other programs like compilers. MS themselves long ago created a component framework to let multiple processes contribute to a single UI, so there is precisely zero technical reason to extend to 64-bits. I can see that there is equally no reason to stay at 32-bits, so I am not *surprised* if MS have had a rolling program of quietly porting components over and they have now finished that, so the fully 64-bit product can be released. But it is not huge news.

The huge news in development environments (and I'm pleased to note that it is mentioned in the Fine Article) is that VScode, which at least started life as a "stripped down, but runs almost anywhere" version of the VS editor, is arguably now as important as its ancestor. There's a lesson there for people who think that the next version of a product always has to have more gold-plated kitchen sinks than a previous version.

Watchdog thinks Google tricked Australians into giving up data, sues. Judge semi-agrees

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: on and off is a view feature.

Something like this: https://www.theregister.com/2020/02/03/google_maps_hack_cartful_phones/

(I don't think that story provides evidence that Google continue to track, for traffic jam purposes, even after you've switched off location, but El Reg's article has links to the sort of things you were talking about. Also, I thought the story was very funny and deserves a re-posting every now and then.)

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Did I miss it?

I have a sub to at least one website that is not required to view their content but which makes up for the fact that I adblock everything so they aren't getting revenue that way.

They aren't actually asking me to trust them, though I probably would. Instead, they have trusted me and it works.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: what amount of trouble was reasonable for users to undergo to protect their data

Funnily enough, Google do (definitely) know where I am but these adverts don't. They think I live near my ISP's HQ. I sometimes wonder if the advertisers have paid for location profiling and are getting diddled. Then I remember who they are and what they are advertising and suddenly I cease to give a shit.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Opt In

Not really. They would present a single "privacy " page with 100 settings each with a long-winded explanation, plus one handy opt-in-all button.

The trick is to include one or two items that nearly all users want, somewhere in the list. If the only way to make the pussy appear is to opt-in on one obscure thing, most users will opt-in-all.

Some websites already do this with cookie choices.

University of Hertfordshire pulls the plug on, well, everything after cyber attack

Ken Hagan Gold badge

The distribution is not flat. The Russell Group is much richer that many "old polys" and one or two RG universities are much richer than most of the rest and within one of the RG, one of its college's cash piles has to be plotted on logarithmic axes if you want it on the same graph as all the others.

But actually, all that cash (wherever it lies) is probably not the issue. I suspect that the real issue is that universities have these things called students who are much harder to control (IT security-wise) than employees.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: "that no one will be disadvantaged as a consequence of this."

I assume they mean that you will get your degree even though you weren't able to learn any of the course material.

Whether future employers see that as "no disadvantage" probably depends on how many other universities are similarly affected, and whether this state of affairs lasts for more than a couple of years.

Right now I'd say that anyone still in full-time education is at something of a disadvantage compared to someone just a year or two older.

(I'd also like to point out that, despite the UK's recent announcement that unis are re-opening, a lot of them are still telling anyone without a practical element to their course to carry on with the online lectures, either at home or in the digs you've been trapped in since whenever.)

Elon Musk's SpaceX bags $3bn NASA contract to, fingers crossed, land first woman on the Moon

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Sub-heading: "And the 13th guy"

Any particular reason why it can't be two women? Has that decision already been taken?

Microsoft calls time on Timeline: Don't worry, more features that nobody asked for coming your way

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: "more features that nobody asked for"

Absolutely, but the last time that happened in the world of computers was when the guy added a macro language to the spreadsheet program because he'd finished it early.

UK government opens vaccine floodgates to over-45s, NHS website predictably falls over

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: You have to separately book the second one?

That was my experience, too ... and my state is the UK so I am a little puzzled by all this talk of having to book a second date.

Oracle vs Google: No, the Supreme Court did not say APIs aren't copyright – and that's a good thing

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: What About Rust?

Is that mandatory, or simply the common practice? I'd have said that a language that *cannot* represent an interface without also providing the implementation is a language that is brain-dead because it can't consume any useful libraries that are written outside the language.

How do we stamp out the ransomware business model? Ban insurance payouts for one, says ex-GCHQ director

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: An excellent idea

I would hope that the /subsequent/ premiums for maintaining the insurance would have the same effect. It seems amazing to me that insurers are not the ones making a killing here. Immediately /after/ a payout, both the insurer and the perpetrator know that the victim is ripe for a repeat attack so why would the insurer not adjust the premium accordingly, to be lowered to a less eye-watering level only once the customer has demonstrated (and continues to demonstrate under regular audit) safe working practices?

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Stop using MS Windows is also an option

Nope, I think you've missed the point:

"The important files are my personal files, which I have full R/W access to."

That's the point. It is really hard to protect files that (in some sense) must not be protected!

I think you can probably do it with a SELinux setup that has religiously mapped out all of the required access for all of the packages that a user needs to do for their job, and then locked the whole system down. I bet that fewer than one in ten thousand Linux systems are configured that way and I bet there are fewer than ten thousand people on the entire planet with the expertise to do it.

Ken Hagan Gold badge
WTF?

Re: Dumb and Dumberer

"Domain Guest user, enabled and in the domain admin group."

Now *there's* a collection of words that I never expected to see in that order.

SpaceX's Starlink: Overhyped and underpowered to meet broadband needs of Rural America, say analysts

Ken Hagan Gold badge
Happy

Well, you know how to troll. You've picked up two victims in your first hour!

Ken Hagan Gold badge

It doesn't add up

If the article is correct then Musk has to launch 30,000 satellites every 5 years to maintain his constellation and that only provides low-bandwidth service. Notably, this is an on-going cost, not a capital one, so the cost of the service is unlikely to come down. It seems unlikely (to me) that rival technologies will not be able to reach nearly all of Musk's potential customers, with a significantly faster and cheaper service, with a combination of more down-to-earth tech like fibre backbones and 4G/5G radio links. Don't bother telling me that those aren't happening, because if *they* aren't commercially viable then Starlink certainly isn't.

Satellite broadband probably has a role in delivering emergency-level coverage to "just about anywhere". If Musk can deliver *that* for $100 a month then there are probably enough people (globally) to make that work. But as a daily driver internet service for residential customers? No way. No matter where you live.

SAP: It takes exploit devs about 72 hours to turn one of our security patches into a weapon against customers

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Best place to hide a leaf....

There does seem to be a tendency for vendors to release patches on Microsoft's Patch Tuesday. That presumably has a similar effect, overloading the bad guys and buying the smaller vendors a little time.

And given the size of some MS offerings, who's to say that they aren't using your technique too?

Greenland's elections just bolstered China's tech world domination plan

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Meh

Does China really have most of the world's supply? Or is it just that they have no environmental laws so they can undercut everyone else? I seem to recall that when they tried to put a squeeze on everyone else, all that happened was that mines everywhere else re-opened because they were now profitable.

I am reminded of Tim Worstall's observation a few years back: the known reserves of any mineable commodity are always some scarily small number of years because once you have a decade or two under your belt you stop looking, for a few years.

Atheists appeal to higher power for intercession over alleged sins against privacy

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: My clan of (non)believers is better than yours...

Perhaps they haven't seen Life of Brian. (Anecdote: I introduced my sons to these films and the reaction was mainly "Oh, so that's where all thememes came from.", so perhaps the IAAI haven't used the internet either.)

Or perhaps they just didn't understand the joke.

Turns out humans are leading AI systems astray because we can't agree on labeling

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: AI in everything is the problem

"Notice how no-one talks about the Turing test any more? That's because it was passed, ..."

It was? When? How? Who? I've never seen any computer system get anywhere close. Come to that, I've seen *people* fail it (usually working in institutions as customer-facing staff and following rule sets, to be fair). Or did they re-define Turing test, so that I'm not allowed to ask questions that any 5-year-old could answer but that fall outside the computer's domain of expertise? (For example, does this picture show baseballs or a bucket? Obviously a 5-year-old could answer that, but apparently an AI researcher can't.)

Mullet over: Aussie boys' school tells kids 'business in the front, party in the back' hairstyle is 'not acceptable'

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Very open-minded

I wouldn't put it past some head-teachers to exclude you until it had grown back. (Particularly in the case of fee-paying schools, where the attitude seems to be that your parents have volunteered you into the system so the school can make up whatever shit they like.)

Here in the UK, a 12yo girl was excluded for several weeks before Christmas because her dress didn't show enough leg. Eventually the school began legal action against her parents for not sending her to school. (Then the story reached the national press and the school has now dropped the case.)

Also here in the UK, a website that collects stories from teenagers has collected numerous examples of girls wearing trousers under their (mandatory) school skirts to reduce the amount of sexual harassment.

It's almost like the kids want to have control over their own bodies. Shocking! They are at school to learn and they should learn to do as they are bloody well told by the Responsible Adults. Except that *some* of the responsible adults seem to be living on another planet.

NASA's Perseverance rover in brick form: China set vs unofficial Lego fan design

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: No, sorry.

Given the distressingly non-zero number of spontaneously aborted embryos, one would to conclude that, for Nature too, pregnancy is a probability and not boolean.

Diary of a report writer and his big break into bad business

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: I hate Adobe, but...

I find proof-reading quite hard on a screen. I'm not surprised to find that she prints it out to do that job.

UK prime minister Boris Johnson reluctant to reveal his involvement in the OneWeb deal

Ken Hagan Gold badge
Facepalm

Re: Clueless

Shhhhhh!!

Open Source Initiative board election results scrapped after security hole found, exploited to rig outcome

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Seems obvious...

Easy, you say? I wonder if the Nominet ballot made that mistake?

John Cleese ‘has a bridge to sell you’, suggests $69,346,250.50 price to top Beeple's virtual art record

Ken Hagan Gold badge

I think so. We used to joke about selling London Bridge, but then someone actually did (!) so we've had to switch.

Ministry of Defence tells contractors not to answer certain UK census questions over security fears

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Census 2021 -cash for stats is ridiculous. Gov have EVERYTHING already. The list incomplete

But this is government we're talking about. Collecting up all those records for just one person is probably beyond them. Doing it for the entire population is just ridiculous. (In other words, they aren't paying for the information. They are paying for you to collect it up for them.)

Ken Hagan Gold badge

"some of the 'exciting' things he'd done in the past while waiting for meetings to get going"

You know, there are two ways of parsing that.

Starlink's latent China crisis could spark a whole new world of warcraft

Ken Hagan Gold badge

So what? There is no chance that they'd be allowed to build a satellite jammer on land they own in the US and very little chance they'd be allowed to build something in one African country that blacked out all that country's neighbours. Even blacking out China would probably hobble India, Japan, etc to an extent that was seen as an act of agression.

'No' does not mean 'yes'... unless you are a scriptwriter for software user interfaces

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Listening to '1984' on audiobook

If you manage to have sex in public whilst in your own home ... well done, but I think you will find it is still illegal.

Conversely, for the wild flowers case I think you will be able to argue that they aren't wild (by definition) if they arein your garden.

Better examples mighthave been things like theft and violence, which are definitely illegal in the home, even if it is your wife or children.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Listening to '1984' on audiobook

If it is worth making illegal, I don't see why a home should grant sanctuary like some church in the middle ages.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Yes/No/Cancel

"Better still would be to ban modal dialogs outright, and force designers to come up with a UI that doesn’t need them to interrupt you to ask stupid questions in the first place…"

I've used interfaces like that. They are horrible. Modality is useful if an action requires several things to be specified at once. Some parts of reality are like that, so you can't just live/design in denial about it. By entering a modal dialog you ensure that only one such complicated action is in-flight in the user's head at any given time. That's usually good to encourage. UIs that have loads of modeless toolbars or docked thingummies about the place are the alternative. Sometimes that works. Usually you end up with an interface like Gimp or Blender, where the novice user runs screaming from the room.

Don't be a fool, cover your tool: How IBM's mighty XT keyboard was felled by toxic atmosphere of the '80s

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: keyboard condoms

Therapy, or more driving lessons. Most of us can go a bit longer than 30 minutes without mowing down a pedestrian.

But yeah, they can be a bugger to wipe off.

Third time's a harm? Microsoft tries to get twice-rejected encoding patent past skeptical examiners

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Jpg xl?

I thought jpeg2000 was never used because the patent position was unclear, so I'm not sure what your point is. It sounds like there is prior art here, in the form of the actual inventor who wants it to be public, so if MS are allowed to kill it with legal FUD then we are all the losers.

We can't avoid it any longer. Here's a story about the NFT mania... aka someone bought a JPEG for $69m in Ether

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: "the original is so much more valuable than even the most faithful copy"

More to the point, each JPEG became a copy as soon as it moved off the original device used to create it. That device probably no longer exists. Even the $69m version is just a copy.

OVH data centre destroyed by fire in Strasbourg – all services unavailable

Ken Hagan Gold badge

It's not too late, yet!

Good news about everybody being safe, but...

Update 5:20pm. Everybody is safe.

Fire destroyed SBG2. A part of SBG1 is destroyed. Firefighters are protecting SBG3. no impact SBG4.

— Octave Klaba (@olesovhcom) March 10, 2021

We appear to be reading this tweet before it has been posted. If people move quickly enough, they may be able to migrate away from SBG2 before the fire starts.

Intel CPU interconnects can be exploited by malware to leak encryption keys and other info, academic study finds

Ken Hagan Gold badge

"I'm wondering if the real fix for this is no SMP whatsoever..."

Nah. The real fix for this is to run your own code on your own hardware. Despite decades of marketing hype, and some pretty serious efforts at encrypted computation, it remains true that if you lose physical security, you lose security.

Given the collapsing costs of actual hardware and the availability of free-as-in-beer operating systems and hypervisors, the movement to renting space in someone else's machine, alongside god-knows-who and at the far end of a long wire, is surely one of the more unexpected trends of recent years.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Intel's ring is not a documented part of the ISA and indeed did not exist in earlier implementations thereof so we can state with 100% confidence that it is not an x86 issue.

Google engineer urges web devs to step up and secure their code in this data-spilling Spectre-haunted world

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Irony

This is the same google that desperately wants to adds "APIs" to let browsers (that is, scripts from a fourth party added by a third-party ad-broker to a second-party web-page that you happen to visit) access the whole PC rather than just a sandbox.

You only need pen and paper to fool this OpenAI computer vision code. Just write down what you want it to see

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: A rather large piece of paper for a fair test

The wider problem is that no-one seems to be training AIs on wider problems. A 1yo child has experience of the world through vision, sound, taste, smell, interaction, and (one hopes) the beginnings of a system of externally imposed behavioural constraints. When such a child sees a picture, they know it is a picture rather than the real thing but they can also understand that it can stand in for the real thing in some contexts, such as a conversation.

I haven't seen any reports of AIs being trained on such a broad range of inputs, so I'm not surprised that they still so easily led astray. I do wonder though whether the hardware is now beefy enough to start planning such experiments.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: still deciding on whether to release the code

As long as it is only used as "player 2" in an online version of Pictionary, I really don't see the problem.

Flagship Chinese chipmaker collapses before it makes a single chip or opens a factory

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: More to this than meets the eye

Which explains why all the world's biggest software companies are Russian now.

Pressure builds on Nominet as members demand to know leadership's contingency plans for when they’re fired

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: the title is (now) too long

I don't think Grayling has the necessary genius-level IT background, but Big Dom is free.

Splunk junks 'hanging' processes, suggests you don't 'hit' a key: More peaceful words now preferred in docs

Ken Hagan Gold badge

FAT64 ??!?

Sorry, I haven't really been paying attention to the market in ever-smaller-but-more-capacious devices but if someone has felt the need to extend a floppy disc layout to 64 bits then *that* is the most offensive thing in this thread.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: No more middots

I think "its" is a better literal translation of a neuter possessive.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: No more middots

Fix the problem, not the symptom, you say?

It'll never catch on.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Just a warm up for what they did in Dacia. There's a reason it is called Romania now.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Haven't quite a few people in the UK recently been grandfathered into a new passport? Presumably they weren't offended. The concept of not losing a right that your grandparents had is pretty old and certainly predates the US. Obsessing over one particular abuse would seem to me to grant that abuse rather more weight than it deserves.