* Posts by Ken Hagan

8168 publicly visible posts • joined 14 Jun 2007

What's that, Lassie? Boston Dynamics is suing its robot dog tech rival?

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Fair, but probably irrelevant

If you want your patent on walking to stand up in court, you'll first have to demonstrate that Nature didn't beat you to it by millions of years.

At least, that would be how any sane country dealt with this. Sigh...

Twitter engineer calls out Elon Musk for technical BS in unusual career move

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: The Hospital versions..

"Correcting a factual error is not insubordination."

Indeed. Why did Musk think this person was on the payroll if it wasn't because they had expertise that the company owner didn't? Correcting factual errors is literally his frigging job.

Update: ...until it isn't. Truly Musk is a grade A plonker, Twitter is doomed and I'd start to worry about his other companies too becaue he seems to be getting unhinged. (Probably the 168-hour weeks he's putting in.)

Still, at least when Musk goes bankrupt I'll have the ultimate rejoinder to "If you're so smart, why aren't you rich?".

Twitter is suffering from mad bro disease. Open thinking can build it back better

Ken Hagan Gold badge

"I wonder if having auto-moderation through posting rate limits might be an interesting experiment to try."

You'll have to think carefully about the algorithm that determines the rate limit. Otherwise when several dozen people gang up to troll, their victim will have to choose which one(s) they can afford to rebut without going over their quota.

Hey, GitHub, can you create an array compare function without breaking the GPL?

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Some functions are very simple

"After all, it's just a database and walking through the relational links is just another SQL query. "

I don't think that's true for the machine learning methods used by Copilot.

GitHub's Copilot flies into its first open source copyright lawsuit

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Time to go back to the drawing board ?

"How hard would it be to generate different training datasets based on license, and then fully track attribution during the training process."

Very, I would have thought. Determining what licences apply to particular bits of code in a mixed project might require natural intelligence. You might end up having to limit the system to code that has been opted-in by its owner (as someone suggested a few million comments ago) and that opens up the possibility of "hostile" training data.

There may simply be no way for Copilot to be both legal and worth using. Too bad, Microsoft. The world does not owe you a business model.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Getting off github

Since the purpose of git is to keep all versions of the code, it would be fairly easy to ignore recent code.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Is it "fair use" or is it intellectual property theft?

" set some horrible precedents if it's not considered properly "

Well if MS manage to drive a coach and horses through the copyright protection of code, they might be amongst the biggest losers.

Musk tells of risk of Twitter bankruptcy as tweeters trash brands

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Ending WFH

Probably not saving you the cost of a constructive dismissal suit, though. (OK, that might depend on what country they were hired in, but it's certainly true for any staff Twitter might have in the EU.)

Sizewell C nuclear plant up for review as UK faces financial black hole

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Daft

There's no way they can give a green light to HS2, to knock a few minutes off the journey time to Brum (and then stop), at the same time as giving a red light to our chances of having enough power to heat and light our homes. That would be certifiable idiocy.

Except, of course, none of these decisions are being made rationally. They are all being made politically.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Daft

"New labour, otherwise known as Tory-lite."

If you can't see the gap between Brown and Truss, you must be looking from very far away. (That guy in the middle distance is probably Trotsky.)

9front releases new version of Plan 9 OS fork: The Golden Age of Ballooning

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: The Front Fell Off

Thanks!

Gelsinger takes ax to Intel after chip sales slump, profit nosedives

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Accprding to the OED, it is a legitimate spelling of "axe", common in North America and etymologically and phonologically superior to the alternative.

Your next PC should be a desktop – maybe even this Chinese mini machine

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Home office

What you really need to move between home and office is a few hundred GB of data. A portable SSD might suffice, particularly if it is an SSD with USB3 connectivity and a VM image on it.

Twitter's most valuable users are ghosting the platform

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: > I use it to follow people/services to keep up to date with topics, but I never post anything

Interesting and it appears that there are several Firefox extensions that will do this for you.

Anyone here willing to share experience with one or more of them?

Voyager mission's project scientist retires after 50 years of service

Ken Hagan Gold badge
Thumb Up

Re: 160bps is the downlink...

"0.79 attoWatt"

Detecting an aW is impressive. Pulling one out of that noise level, more so. Then doing something useful with it is just ridiculous.

AI programming assistants mean rethinking computer science education

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Learning while earning

Ah, but tools like CoPilot literally don't know where they got the code from and no-one really knows how they work. In that sense, I suppose they are like an experienced programmer.

Firefox points the way to eradicating one of the rudest words online: PDF

Ken Hagan Gold badge

But e-readers are basically just HTML. That's why they can reflow when you change the font size. The difference between them and web pages is all the ad-related, script-infested bollocks that they don't include.

The web could be as pleasant as your e-reader, but the UX experts keep right-royally-fucking-it-up.

20 years on, physicists are still figuring out anomaly in proton experiment

Ken Hagan Gold badge

New physics?

Wouldn't it be funny if sticking a proton in an electric field delivered more new physics than the LHC?

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: A smashing time

Since the proton doesn't actually break, I think it's more like trying to determine the internal structure of the ball bearing by throwing eggs at it.

How I made a Chrome extension for converting Reg articles to UK spelling

Ken Hagan Gold badge
Pint

Re: None of my business

You wanted "kuhler". Ah, no, that doesn't work either.

You wanted the IPA, but then even though it would be unambiguously correct, no-one would be able to read it.

Icon: not IPA

Ken Hagan Gold badge

That's a pretty long final word.

What I take away from that is that I am mid-Atlantic and I strongly suspect we all will be eventually. Oh, and neither side can claim any kind of rationality, either historical or phonetic, for their choices.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: *article paid for by Google

It's an IT site so I would hope that all dates were ISO 8601 format.

To make this computer work, users had to press a button. Why didn't it work? Guess

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Bad design

"If you're paying attention, it's pretty obvious that it only fits properly one way around on the horse, but I'd give the average person only a 50% chance of putting it the right way around first time."

Sounds like a USB cable. :(

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Bad design

Permanent admin is for amateurs. The pros use temporary admin for their mischief and then point to their non-admin credentials as an alibi.

Windows Subsystem for Android declared ready for prime time

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: WSA or ASW?

Why would I want to do that when I can just run my "legacy stuff" directly on the machine hosting the Windows 11 VM? :)

Millennials, Gen Z actually suck at workplace security

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Cookies are not a security risk

You write potential.

I read possible future.

Not trying to be blasé, but I think it is worth distinguishing between things that are a risk already and things that might lead to a risk in future.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Meh

Possibly also a difference between those for whom the P in PC actually did mean "personal", as opposed to the generation who have never used a device that wasn't basically controlled by someone else. (Microsoft, Google, Apple, Meta, ...)

CEO told to die in a car crash after firing engineers who had two full-time jobs

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Judge on results, not appearances

And half way through that project you find that you haven't started yet but have only 6 months to deliver.

What's your next move, Einstein?

How GitHub Copilot could steer Microsoft into a copyright storm

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Liability has already been defined

While true, I don't think that is relevant. El Reg is posted publically and available to share and analyse, but it remains copyright.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

" I'm inclined to believe that the designers of Co-pilot could have easily designed the system to also emit attributions for strongly related source code. "

From my understanding of how ML works, that actually sounds like a very hard problem. These algorithms typically offer very few clues for why they chose a particular solution.

Even if possible, I suspect the result would be a warning that this code may fall under any of half a dozen popular FOSS licences and dozens of other personal copyrights.

Both issues would be much more simply dealt with by always warning that "this code probably breaches someone's copyright and you are on the hook if you choose to use it". Funnily enough, that's what MS seem to have done, except they've buried it in their T&Cs rather than reminding users on each occasion.

Moon has been drifting away from Earth for 2.4 billion years, rocks reveal

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Ha! Read about that in the early 1970s

The article said as much. Perhaps the title should have said "confirms" rather than "reveals".

China dumps dud chips on Russia, Moscow media moans

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: It's just words

Putin might fall, but I can't see anyone partitioning a country with thousands of nukes.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Russian SMO

The Geneva Conventions stand a very good chance of recovrring from this since it is obvious to anyone with a brain that it is advantageous for your opponent to abide by it. It is equally obvious that the civilized portion of the human race cannot allow a violator to benefit. In short, most of the human race have a vested interest in seeing Putin (personally, this isn't an anti-Russian thing) lose catastrophically.

Musk says Starlink will keep providing free service to Ukraine

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Oh look, it's a Narcissist acting like a Narcissist

"the worlds second biggest narcissist"

I guess it would be needlessly inflammatory for you to clarify, but with so many contenders to choose from I'm a little curious to know who you place below him.

Broker-dealers can stop burning records to CD, but they don’t have to, says SEC

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: is this safer or less safe?

It reads the same to me: a proposition that may or may not be true followed by a request for evidence.

...which you didn't provide.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

is this safer or less safe?

Cloud storage isn't exactly new. We probably have enough experimental data to estimate how reliable it is compared to traditional backup strategies.

That's end-to-end reliability, so I'm including the likelihood of the provider going bankrupt, the provider suffering finger trouble and the provider deciding to cease service (for any reason) and telling the customer "You have until next month to pull everything you want back down the wire to your new solution. After that, bye-bye data.".

So, umm, have there been any studies?

China doesn’t need to take Taiwan’s fabs to escape US trade bans

Ken Hagan Gold badge

$1 trillion is a lot of anyone's money

I think the article fails to consider the likely consequences of threatening to cost the US a trillion dollars worth of damage. Saddam Hussein probably had similar ideas in mind when he invaded Kuwait. "Hah, I'll have the Americans over a barrel now, and I can go on to threaten Saudi oil-fields, too!". The American reaction, however, was to treat this as something of an existential threat (to their economy, if not their territory) and found that quite a large number of other nations were in the same threatened position and willing to offer diplomatic support for military action.

Hopefully President Xi has given the matter rather more consideration.

This maglev turntable costs more than an average luxury electric car

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Meh

Not only that. The picture would suggest that the stylus is not part of the magnetically levitated frame and so presumably the evil vibrations can come through there instead.

More than 4 in 10 PCs still can't upgrade to Windows 11

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: I wonder...

But if they drive people to other OSes, they'll never get any subscription revenue. They will have turned customers of Windows (and, let's not forget, Windows applications, of which MS sell quite a few) into users of other OSes.

And for what? The OS is supposed to abstract away hardware details. Why can't Win11 cope with older hardware by not offering certain features?

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: I wonder...

"Windows 11 is not disabled for VMs - it installed easily through Parallels on my 10 year old iMac."

Yes, it isn't gratuitously disabled for VMs, but the VM needs to meet all the hardware requirements and I think a clean VirtualBox VM struggles with that. There are some instructions on the interwebs about how to hack the Win11 installation so that it works. It may not even be necessary anymore, I don't know. My own Win11 VirtualBox VM was created a few months ago. However, without the excuse that I need to check that my stuff still works, I can't think of a good reason to upgrade.

The interesting question is what happens in 2025 when all this "legacy" hardware is still going strong and MS want to turn off support for Win10. The original decision to require certain hardware for Win11 must have been made pre-pandemic and pre-chip-shortage, when it must have seemed fairly reasonable (to an MS exec) to suppose that pretty much everyone would be running on newer hardware by 2025.

Oracle VirtualBox 7.0 is here – just watch out for the proprietary Extension Pack

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Too high risk

There's no risk of getting caught if you don't break the rules.

Admittedly, living without USB2 support in your VM can be annoying, but it isn't risky.

Lufthansa bans Apple AirTags on checked bags

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: GPS

...except for the ones being used by baggage handlers to find all the AirTags, obviously. :)

Loads of PostgreSQL systems are sitting on the internet without SSL encryption

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: many forums

True, and a fair point. Of course, an answer might even have been a least-awful work-around when it was posted but have been superseded by later changes.

I suppose it's another way that many Q&A sites seem to be designed to favour low quality answers.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Perhaps the postgres people should write a canonical reply to that question, post it on their site (where its semi-authoritative nature will be apparent), and then do the googling you did so that they can reply to such questions by saying "A secure solution is now documented <u>here</u> and an insecure one will lead to your database being read and possibly damaged by malicious parties.".

Of course, many forums have a rule that says answers cannot simply hyperlink to another site but must be self-contained. This is probably a big reason why those sites typically contain so many answers that are dangerously over-simplified. Perhaps the official answer should also include a "minimal acceptable summary" that people can cut-n-paste into the forum to meet that requirement.

I can see why they want to be self-contained, since links go stale, etc., but in most cases the best answer to a question is to refer to an existing, well-written explanation from someone who is a recognised authority on the subject.

Microsoft warns: Windows 11 update breaks provisioning

Ken Hagan Gold badge

UK speaker here: I'm aware of the usage and certainly use it myself, but it's a weaselly euphemism for "problem". We like euphemisms over here but we shouldn't forget that they are euphemisms and are therefore just a socially acceptable form of dishonesty.

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: And just one of many reasons

I assume your very senior person and your least competent PFY aren't Register readers, then.

Block this: Using satellites to plaster ads over our skies could work, say boffins

Ken Hagan Gold badge

The resolution isn't good enough.

But someone *will* hack these. They'll probably just use the manoevering rockets to create a short firework/meteor display.

IceWM reaches version 3 after a mere 25 years

Ken Hagan Gold badge

Re: Impressive

"You can have have a minimal desktop and terminal in < 40 MB RAM"

I should hope so! Windows managed that back in the 90s and a minimal OS shouldn't be doing any more than NT did back then. (Come to think of it, a maximal OS shouldn't either.)