* Posts by Steve Knox

1972 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jul 2011

Idaho patriots tool up to battle Jihad with pork bullets

Steve Knox
Facepalm

Re: So much for respecting the religious beliefs of other people.

I'd agree with you, Geoff ... If any given religion respected the beliefs of any of the others. Problem is, they don't. It's their way or the highway ...

Buddhism

Taoism

Shinto

Bahai

Faith is a non-starter for anyone capable of thinking for themselves.

The worst thing is, you're committing the same logical fallacy as those you criticize -- the only difference is that you're generalizing to an even more absurd degree. They say "religion x is all dangerous crazy nutters" and you say "all religious are dangerous crazy nutters."

Well I say those who over-generalize are the dangerous crazy nutters.

Obama says US won't scramble jets or twist arms for Snowden

Steve Knox

Re: Blimey...

Bear in mind that for this particular jet, 300 hours flying time can add up to roughly 400,000 miles.

US cops make 'first ever' Bitcoin seizure following house raid

Steve Knox
Joke

Re: This article lacks precision

I don't know -- that looks like five-digit precision to me...

Steve Knox
Headmaster

Well, 'drug dealer' is a generic term anyway; it's only modern usage which gives it its specific connotation (much like 'UFO'). Having said that, I think you'll find what qualifies him as an illicit drug dealer is the selling of prescription drugs either without a pharmaceutical license or to individuals without valid prescriptions (or most likely both).

Throwing arms let humans rise above poo-flinging apes to play cricket

Steve Knox
Trollface

Re: The Elbow Angle..

Oh cricket vs baseball, the cricket ball, being made of cork wrapped in leather really really hurts if it hits you, one floored me for a good ten minutes one when it hit me in the ...

Well, that's the cricket half of the comparison .. We need to get you on a field with a baseball and professional pitcher to test the baseball half...

Steve Knox
Happy

Re: Cricket vs Baseball

Netball came from basketball, not the other way round, and was specifically modified for women.

Baseball and rounders have a common origin, rather than having an ancestor-descendant relationship.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_netball

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baseball#Origins_of_baseball

HGST: Enough of those mutant hybrids. We'll do an Apple, thanks

Steve Knox

Re: upgrades

This looks to me more like HGST isn't bothering with hybrids because WD is already doing it, just as WD isn't bothering with helium because HGST is already working on it.

China may have ordered them to operate separately, but that applied primarily to their existing product lines. It didn't order them to act as if the other party didn't exist and an eventual merger wouldn't happen. Given that, it makes strategic sense not to duplicate efforts, especially in those cases where the other party already has a leg up.

Michael Dell: 'Cash in your shares, we are in a mess'

Steve Knox
Holmes

Re: Shakiness of Dell

Do you really think that after the action (whatever it is) Dell will be the company it once was?

Well since the stated goals of both individuals involved are to make Dell into something other than the company it is, I'd think the answer to that is rather obvious.

US DoJ: Happy b-day, Ed Snowden! You're (not?) charged with capital crimes

Steve Knox
Trollface

The Enemy

To be guilty of espionage, don't you have to have provided information to "the enemy"?

He provided it to The Guardian. What more do you want!?

Not all data encryption is created equal

Steve Knox
Boffin

Re: Show me the backdoor

The weakness in your argument is "publicize". The counter example is Stuxnet and its children.

Do you really believe that Chinese military hackers, or the Russians, or the NSA would publicize the holes/backdoors they find, i.e., show YOU or anyone else their backdoors?

The weakness in your argument is in selecting only the weakest examples I have given.

The NSA probably would not but that's why the OP painted them as the baddies and why I didn't cite them as a party who would publicize.

The Russians and Chinese are a different story. The Chinese might if it were politically expedient, but they're equally likely to lie and say they have found an exploit when they haven't, in order to keep their populace scared of speaking out. The Russians may keep it secret for a time, or they may sell it to some of their hackers.

But the other examples I cited (and you conveniently left out), the independent privacy advocates, some of whom had a part in creating these algorithms, certainly would publicize any holes and backdoors they found.

Steve Knox
Boffin

Show me the backdoor

These security and encryption protocols have also been investigated and tested by the best academics and independent experts.

Many of these experts have been outspoken critics of the NSA and advocates for privacy.

None of them have found a backdoor.

The Russian government, the Chinese government, the executives of every major multinational corporation, the Pirate Bay, and the creators of TOR (to name but a few) have the resources and the reasons to find and publicize any NSA backdoors in these standards.

None of them have.

It's fucking hard to connect your dots with these encrypted firewalls between them.

Apple: If you find us guilty in ebook price-fix trial, EVERYONE suffers

Steve Knox
Childcatcher

Apple's Right

A ruling against them would have a very chilling effect on how companies enter new markets.

If they lose this case, companies will have to spend hours of executive time coming up with new ways to better hide their tracks when they want to disrupt a new market by illegally price-fixing to cause the incumbents to have to increase their prices.

This extra time will cause executives to demand better conditions than their already paltry salary and benefits packages, which will eat into shareholders' returns. Sure they can probably offset a bit of the costs by firing some of the plebes, but do that too often and you risk shrinking the market for your increasingly expensive products a little too much.

When Apple needs speed and security in Mac OS X, it turns to Microsoft

Steve Knox
Happy

Re: Wow...

Really? Have you been on this site long? Check the archives -- they write some good ones!

Wannabe Dell owner Icahn's buyout blueprint blasted by board bods

Steve Knox
Black Helicopters

RE: The meeting is July 18th.

That's what they want you to believe...

Offensive, iconoclastic internet trolls will not be prosecuted, says DPP

Steve Knox

Re: where's the line?

<i.May i suggest we measure it [offensiveness] in Politicians?</i>

Shurely we should use a scale in which 1 is a meaningful amount, rather than the highest possible end of the scale? Most posts would have to be rated at fractions of a femto-Politician.

Let's not go down the whole gram/kilogram road again.

COLD BALLS OF FLAME light up International Space Station

Steve Knox
Holmes

Re: x(r)

I really don't get how a reaction that not only extracts half of the potential energy of a reaction, but produces poisons to boot can lead to "more efficient combustion engines" through this mechanism

Because it shows us what not to do? Process of elimination? Better understanding of why x doesn't work can give us insight on how to make x1 work better.

PC makers REALLY need Windows 8.1 to walk on water - but guess what?

Steve Knox

Re: It's not that hard to see the problem

... the replacement PC sales arising from organisations finally beginning to move from WinXP...

Don't know about your organization, but the PC sales from my organization moving from XP were exactly 0 -- we upgraded OS, not hardware. Apart from a few poor planners, I'd expect similar from most businesses -- if they've been following a 5 year refresh, all of their hardware would be fine for running Win7, so why waste money on new boxes?

New material enables 1,000-meter super-skyscrapers

Steve Knox

Re: Any rope is the problem

Not really, I think it is in the Petronas Towers where they have two lifts per shaft, one of top of the other, one for the even numbered floors and one for the odd numbered ones.

Technically, that would be one lift with either two cars or one car with two cargo bays, depending on exactly how it's constructed.

Multiple lifts implies independent movement, which is not possible with that arrangement.

Steve Knox

Re: Any rope is the problem

@Steven Roper: Of course the downside of any rail-driven lift system is power consumption, because you now have to have an engine on the lift car itself driving the car against gravity.

Not if the engine is in the rails.

@Charles 9: ...more modern systems rely on a governor to engage brake shoes on the rope or motor...

Not according to http://science.howstuffworks.com/science-vs-myth/everyday-myths/question730.htm -- modern failsafe brakes engage the rails in the shaft. An untethered car could use the same system with little modification.

Australian unis to test quantum-comms-over-fibre

Steve Knox

Re: Idle Question

Yes, but all you'll get from that is every possible result -- you'll still have to sift through them and test each one contextually to determine if its the correct result.

Steve Knox

Hmmm....

Should a third party intercept or observe the key, the loss of entanglement should be measurable to the recipient since the entanglement is destroyed.

What if the third party uses a system similar to that described in http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/06/03/quantum_boffins_get_spooky_with_time/ ?

If that could work, they would be able to measure the transmitted photon but still end up with a photon entangled with the original photon which they could resend...

NSA: We COULD track you by your phone ... if we WANTED to

Steve Knox
Thumb Up

@Don Jefe

"... since Murdoch bought them they've become nothing more than a supermarket tabloid with a distinctive sketch style..."

That's a nice turn of phrase,and the best thing is you can apply it to pretty much any Murdoch property.

Samsung wins Apple MacBook contract, starts spitting out PCIe SSDs

Steve Knox
Joke

El Reg storage desk is fairly confident this means 1TB capacity products are coming...

The product is called the XP941 and comes in three capacity points: 128GB, 256GB and 512GB.

...

[The XP941] occupies a seventh of the space of a 2.5-inch SSD.

1TB? Why not 3.5TB for those of us with 2.5-inch drive bays (and ~5 grand to spend on an SSD)?

Julian Assange: Google's just an arm of US government

Steve Knox
WTF?

Re: No, but seriously ...

1. "Freedom of speech" does not include freedom from the consequences of your speech, or more appropriately in this case (see #2), freedom from the consequences of other actions just because you happen to be involved in some public speech.

2. To date, there has been no government action against Assange because of what he's published. His extradition is related to a legal issue with some women in Sweden (see my earlier post.)

3.The government does set the rules, and it is bound by them as much as Google is. If the HMRC did send Google a bill for taxes related to sales, Google's response would be what it has been all along: "we didn't make those sales here"-- at which point HMRC would have to prove that those sales were made here -- because those are the rules. If you don't like the rules, fine: get your government to fix them. Don't blame Google for following them.

Steve Knox
Trollface

Missed Opportunity

[Assange] described interactions with both Google and the State Department which he claimed was "evidence" of intimate relations between the organisations.

Shurely the title should have been:

"Assange has problem with intimate relations."

Supercomputer vid proves NASA black-hole ring sniffers were RIGHT

Steve Knox

Re: The study was based on a non-rotating black hole

Why on earth(or in space for that matter) would you assume that the black hole was not rotating?

To ensure that the model works before applying it to the more complex but admittedly more common problem of a rotating black hole. As my mom used to say, "better to waste a little supercomputer time on an untested model now, than to waste a lot on a still-untested model later" -- or something to that effect.

FTA: ... the models are now being extended to spinning ones.

NSA PRISM snoop-gate: Won't someone think of the children, wails Apple

Steve Knox

Re: Local Vs Foreign

I thought PRISM was only used against us foreigners, and not good, law-abiding (or not) US citizens.

Well, they have to be 51% sure that their target is foreign.

Therefore, none of what is being discussed about robberies, local sheriffs finding local kids and whatever else does not fall into the reported remit of PRISM.

Yes. Read the last paragraph in Microsoft's quote, buried at the end of the article. It explains that and why these reports being released include non-PRISM data.

Does that mean the remit is being over-reported, or perhaps the news from Apple, Microsoft et al isn't the full picture, but only shows attempts from them to just show it has nothing to do with them?

No, it means that Apple, Microsoft, et al. have released summary data about all government requests, including non-PRISM ones because they're not allowed to release even summary information about PRISM requests alone, and the news agencies, including El Reg, are (in some cases possibly un-) intentionally bigging up the scandal by being vague on that distinction (for example, by not making the distinction until the end of the article, and then only in a quote from Microsoft. Really? Who pays attention to Microsoft anymore?)

Big browser builders scramble to fix cross-platform zero-day flaw

Steve Knox
Meh

Re: Really??

Really?

The first antivirus software I ever saw was Symantec Antivirus in the summer of 1989...running on a lab of Macs at a local college.

So, Windows 8.1 to give PC sales a shot in arm? BZZZZT, wrong answer

Steve Knox

What do you think the word means?

Microsoft clearly wanted this redesign to be successful (definition 1 from dictionary.com), and it certainly took a lot of effort effort on their part to try to make it successful (definition 4 from dictionary.com). Definition 2 is in many ways a restating of definitions 1 and 4, and definition 3 isn't relevant contextually.

I'm trying to think of a definition for ambitious which is relevant in context, but not applicable...

Pandora to hit airwaves with terrestrial radio station buy

Steve Knox
Coat

"hot adult contemporary"

I'd like one of those, please.. nudge, nudge, wink, wink.

NSA accused of new crimes ... against slideware

Steve Knox
Coat

GRRRRRRRR

Are you trying to force us to choose between agreeing with the NSA or with a powerpoint consultant!?

Well here's my way out of that trap:

I for one am glad that the NSA slides show no understanding of graphic design, for two important reasons:

1. It means that they probably didn't waste money on some self-important "slideware professional," and

2. At least we can take solace in the fact that those who've been spying on us have had their eyes raped by that hideous slide, and hopefully a few hundred more like it. It's not much, but it's a start.

Steve Knox
Unhappy

Re: Yech

Not if Apple's iOS7 is any indicator...

CIA-funded upstart: The truth about Prism and NSA's web snooping

Steve Knox
Meh

Re: spin

You'd be surprised at the banality of much of the US government's "TOP SECRET" stuff.

NSA Prism: Why I'm boycotting US cloud tech - and you should too

Steve Knox

Re: Hello pot, this is kettle.

I could go on and on and on. Look; corporations don't have the power of governments to completely ruin your life. They can only do so by involving a government in the first place.

I don't think so. Corporations don't need government intervention to illegally pollute, to destroy someone's credit rating, to create dangerous workplaces -- in fact the only reason they don't do more of that crap is because of government intervention.

The US government employs over 2 million people.

Actually, the Executive branch employs approximately 2.75 million people. (source: http://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/data-analysis-documentation/federal-employment-reports/historical-tables/total-government-employment-since-1962/) -- by the way, this has remained steady (within ~200,000 or so) since 1962. But that's everybody they employ, the vast majority of which aren't involved in this particular scandal and don't have the power over individuals you're trying to ascribe to all of them. The size of the relevant groups (the NSA/CSS, maybe the CIA, and if you're feeling particularly paranoid, the entire FBI as well) is classified, and I've seen estimates from 100,000 to 200,000 people.

The overwhelming majority of [US government employees] are accountable to no one.

Says who? How many US government employees have you observed being "accountable to no one"? Give me some real data on this. Most US government agencies are answerable to at least two of the major branches (often Executive and Legislative, but also Executive and Judicial (think law enforcement), and even Legislative and Judicial) and there are more regulations targeting government employee behavior than targeting corporate employee behavior.

Most of them are good people, but good people can to terrible things when bored, scared or apathetic. And this can't apply to corporate employees as well?

It's easy to paint any large organization with broad strokes, but the fact of the matter is that more than 90% of the 2 million US government employees you mention have (a) no access to the data discussed in the original article, (b) little to no direct control over the fate of individuals, (c) a hell of a lot more people looking over their shoulder than you or I have and hence way more accountability than you think, and (d) would really rather you just left them to do their job, rather than lumping them in with all of those shady types.

Steve Knox
Stop

Re: Hello pot, this is kettle.

There are no dragnet style snooping operations in Canada.

That you know of.

I'm willing to say that given the culture in Canada, such things are less likely, but to make a blanket assertion like that is either incredibly arrogant, fucking naive, or most likely, both.

Steve Knox
Paris Hilton

Re: Hello pot, this is kettle.

I'm still at a loss about all of this. We KNOWINGLY gave this data to Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Facebook, et al. Their respective sites' terms of use have been regularly shown to give them carte blanche with this data.

Is the implication here that governments or government officials are somehow more susceptible to corruption and snooping than multinational corporations?

Haven't these companies spent the last decade trying to outdo each other on data mining technologies, and hasn't the big buzzword in their boardrooms been "monetizing" that data?

I'm not saying we shouldn't be leery about government snooping in our cloud data; I'm saying we should have been leery about snooping in our cloud data all along, because it's being held by companies who've made a practice of optimizing snooping technologies.

The point about the Constitution is a great one in this regard, because at the heart of it, it's a contract --just like those contracts the cloud providers offer. What real opportunity do those contracts offer for you to determine if, say, Amazon's (or even just one clever and corrupt techie) dipped into your data for their own purposes? How could you prove it, and how long would you have to fight them through the courts before you received any compensation?

America's mobile phone unlock block coming unstuck

Steve Knox
Boffin

Re: Confused...

Simples:

1. "Locking" a phone to a given provider is a software feature.

2. Software is often copyrighted.

3. The large US telecomms companies have quite a bit of money to throw at lawyers, lobbyists, etc.

Ergo, phone unlocking is a DMCA violation.

Steve Knox
Facepalm

Yes, because...

...makes our streets just a little bit safer by making it harder for large scale phone trafficking syndicates to operate in the open ...

When I go out after dark, my greatest fear is of being mugged by phone traffickers...

I'm not sure which would be worse:

a) if this were just another fevered dream of a misinformed politician, or

b) if such organizations really do exist and succeed...

Of course, if these syndicates are selling the unlocked phones in foreign jurisdictions where the prohibition against unlocking doesn't exist, how does this law affect them anyway? Also, if they're breaking the law to obtain the phones in the first place, is this provision really going to stop them in their tracks?

Amazon yoinks Dora and SpongeBob from Netflix for MEELLLIONS

Steve Knox

Re: Oh, Amazon

"HD" streaming is a con. The so-called "HD" picture looks worse than an SD DVD upscaled by a decent DVD player...

Then you're using a shit streaming service or you have a shit internet connection. Netflix HD streaming on my home internet connection is better than cable HD and I have to get right up to the screen and look really hard to find any compression artifacts at all.

I suggest you go back and look for a better ISP or streaming video provider, and contemplate the idea that not all of us have made the same bad decisions you apparently have.

Steve Knox
FAIL

Re: Oh, Amazon

The quality isn't crap...

Depends on how you can view it. Amazon currently only offers HD streaming for a few specific client types -- you can't stream in HD using their web viewer, and they don't have a streaming client for Windows, either.

If Amazon fixed either of these massive gaping wounds, I'd subscribe.

Leaks point to new mystery Macs 'with Jony Ive's fingerprints on'

Steve Knox
Coat

'with Jony Ive's fingerprints on'

I doubt it. Apple generally cleans their hardware nice and shiny* before shipping.

* Okay, technically they pay Foxconn to do it...

Internet pioneer Vint Cerf predicts the future, fears Word-DOCALYPSE

Steve Knox
Meh

"Use ODF", "Use XML"? You're missing the entire point folks. However open the format is, just because the data structures exist with software to decode them today doesn't mean it will exist in 50 ... or even 5 years time.

No, you missed the point. The open formats have public documents describing the data structures, and XML is designed to be semantically self-consistent. In order for XML and ODF to be completely unreadable in 50 years time, we'd have to destroy everything that uses our current binary model of computing and burn down a few hundred warehouses full of books and paper documents as well.

Your only significant point is the 360kb disk your Wordstar doc is stored on -- but in a competent modern IT department, that document would have been transferred to current media when the old media were retired.

Perhaps there should be a relatively small, open library of data formats established somewhere - disk structures, storage formats, software encoding techniques et al?

IEEE, ECMA, ANSI, W3C, et al. They don't exactly meet your "small" requirement, though.

Steve Knox
Holmes

It may be that a Ferrari will help my trips to the shops a lot.

"It may be that the cloud computing environment will help a lot. It may be able to emulate older hardware on which we can run operating systems and applications,"

We don't need the cloud for that. I've got an 8 -year-old-desktop that can emulate 20-year-old hardware perfectly fine. Heck, I remember running a Z80 emulator on a Z80.

Steve Knox
Paris Hilton

Perhaps...

...how his up-to-date version of Microsoft Word can't read Powerpoint files created in 1997.

he might want to try using Powerpoint for that?

New Tosh 'droid slabs include Newton-like scrawl-pad: We try it out

Steve Knox
Meh

"... the quite brilliant handwriting recognition on Windows 8 ..."

Sorry, but no. After having tested Windows 8 handwriting recognition on several occasions, I can tell you that brilliant doesn't apply. In fact, recognition is a bit of a stretch.

'Extremely sophisticated' Apple settles watery iDevice lawsuit

Steve Knox
Holmes

Anyone want to bet that this settlement only covers US customers??

Tell you what. On behalf of the US government, I'm prepared to offer you this Apple settlement for free! You even get a revised extradition treaty, new copyright laws, a great drug war --

What's that? You just want the settlement? I don't know -- it's a package deal.... Let me talk to my supervisor...

Nah, sorry, he says if that's all you want you'll have to sue Apple in your own court.

Sure I can't interest you in an extreme rendition partnership policy? Have it your way, then.

Steve Knox
Boffin

Re: Missing number

Basic estimation. The payouts for the different device types average out to about $200 per device. There are an estimated 153,105 devices, making approximately $30 million in estimated payout to customers. That leaves approximately $23 mil for the lawyers.

Now this is just an estimate, but you can be sure they're getting something in that order of magnitude.

EFF files objections with W3C decrying addition of DRM to HTML5

Steve Knox
WTF?

Re: In an ideal world...

It's true that DRM will not prevent pirate copies from appearing 10 seconds after the content goes live, but the people who are paying still get a gimped service.

Gimped in what manner?

Modern systems and networks can easily handle encryption, streaming, and decryption of full 1080p content.

Are you complaining that a rental service doesn't allow you to make your own copies?

Kaspersky plans source code reveal to avoid Huawei's fate

Steve Knox
WTF?

“some doors, they are not back doors, but somewhere in-between”

Those would be side doors, then. Or interior doors if you take a direct-line approach.

Bill Gates: Corporate tax is not a moral issue

Steve Knox
Holmes

Re: I don't buy it

Is this really what the founder of the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation is suggesting?

No. Now if you're finished playing with your straw man, put him away and go get ready for dinner.

What he's suggesting is that companies are amoral entities, and as such, any social requirement for ethical behavior on their part has to be implemented via external regulation, because there is no internal drive for such behavior.

What is sad is that he even has to mention this. It's capitalism 101 -- every adult in a capitalist society should already know this.