nav search
Data Centre Software Security DevOps Business Personal Tech Science Emergent Tech Bootnotes
BOFH
Lectures

* Posts by DougS

11717 posts • joined 12 Feb 2011

Oracle takes its gripes about Pentagon's JEDI contract to federal court

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Conflicted

They are right though that the argument that single sourcing will improve things is specious at best. At worst it will lead to lazy programmers unintentionally designing lock-in to Amazon's cloud, so when the 10 years are up the DoD will have no choice but to pay whatever they demand because it will cost too much and take too long to make things portable.

Having multiple suppliers guarantee that it is done right, especially if everything has to be regularly tested on a different cloud from that used for production.

0
0

In 2018, Facebook is the villain and Microsoft the shining light, according to techies

DougS
Silver badge

If Facebook is the new Microsoft

Is Microsoft the new IBM? They are the largest tech company now, as IBM once was. While they sell to consumers, they are more prominent in the enterprise market, just as was true for IBM in their heyday. While "nobody gets fired for buying IBM" used to be the mantra, now that's true about Microsoft.

1
0

China on its way to becoming the first nation to land on the far side of the Moon

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Hooray. Not the "dark side"

Flat earthers believe that the Moon and other planets are spheres, only the Earth is flat. Because its special.

0
0

Nice phone account you have there – shame if something were to happen to it: Samsung fixes ID-theft flaws

DougS
Silver badge

$13,300?

For discovering a bug so bad it basically gave access to everyone's Samsung account??? At even a dime per user exposed the guy could probably retire on a beach somewhere.

I wonder how much he could have made if he'd sold this on the dark web? Or how much Samsung would have paid in fines if the flaw had been used to grab the info of all their EU users?

0
0

Boffins build blazing battery bonfire

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Lots of choices

We use the type of nuclear we do because we wanted more than just electrical output, we also wanted nuclear weapons. THAT'S why all the money was spent developing that system, if it wasn't for that we wouldn't have any nuclear plants generating electricity in the entire world.

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Lots of choices- DoS works for physical stuff!

Why would terrorists try to take out the containment for molten silicon, which would be underground and set in concrete so not exactly a "soft" target? They'd just need to reroute power around and they'd be fine, unless you took out a bunch of them (I assume rather than a giant one at a generating station you'd have a number of them distributed around the grid close'ish to renewable sources like turbine farms and utility scale solar.

The same amount of explosive could take out an entire large city-scale substation, and be FAR more disruptive and expensive to repair.

Terrorists generally want to kill people, not inconvenience them with a short term blackout. Those who want blackout type harassments (Russian hackers etc.) would probably find it easier to come in via the network and insecure SCADA links from the safety of their own extradition-proof country.

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Balls

You can't store enough heat in water for useful amounts of power without huge pressures, which makes them bombs no one wants to have in their home. There's a reason water heaters are required to have a pressure relief valve spec'ed at 150 psi.

2
1
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Lots of choices

Pumped storage can also be a terrorist target, if it is practical to breach containment and cause flooding. There isn't really anything for terrorists to target with molten silicon, breaching its containment isn't going to harm anyone unless the storage facility is 20 feet from your house. They can't "steal" the molten silicon and do anything with it since it'll cool down. It isn't worth enough to be worth stealing, either.

Ditto for earthquakes, that could breach containment for either but one may flood entire cities and the other will let a bit of silicon escape into the surrounding soil where it will quickly cool and solidify, and can be either left in place (I don't think it is harmful to the environment?) or easily dug up and removed.

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

What's unsafe about molten silicon?

It can't explode, if the containment is breached due to an earthquake or similar there is little or no environmental impact, it can't be stolen and have its energy repurposed into a destructive weapon. I don't know enough about this to say whether or not it is practical, but I can't imagine there are any legitimate safety concerns. Batteries and pumped hydro are far less safe, that's for sure!

3
1

Did you know that iOS ad clicks cost more than Android? These scammers did

DougS
Silver badge

Re: "it can restart itself after three minutes"

I'd blame Google for making it possible for the app to do so, not for abusive app writers to be abusive.

Reminds me of the tale of scorpion and the frog...

1
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: How much Google earned from the clicked ads?

Which is why Google has little incentive to try to stop click fraud completely, only to limit it JUST enough that it doesn't destroy the market for online advertising.

1
0
DougS
Silver badge

With a spin on the statistics and some marketing it's easy to let people think that iPhone users are more willing to spend.

Its blatantly obvious. The average price of all iPhones sold is FAR higher than the average price of all Androids sold, so of course iPhone owners are more willing and able to spend ON AVERAGE. Sure, there are Android phones that cost as much as the most expensive iPhone, and there are Android owners with incomes of tens of millions of dollars who could buy 10 iPhones for every Reg reader and not even miss the money, but that doesn't change the averages.

For most of the world's population, an iPhone is far beyond their means. There are Android phones that cost under $50, which is still beyond the means of some of the world's poorest.

1
0

Have a gander at this: Amazon agrees not to act as Silicon Valley's foie gras dealer

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Chacun à son goût

So basically any city geese and ducks where I live could produce foie gras, since they have effectively unlimited food thanks to people feeding them all the time and food dropped everywhere? I find that difficult to believe.

4
5

Official: Voyager 2 is now an interstellar spacecraft

DougS
Silver badge

ssh -T voyager /bin/sh --login -i

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

I was around 50 years ago, just barely

I remember learning about the Voyager 1 & 2 in grade school, and the school had a vinyl replica of the gold record that we passed around. I wonder how many of those were made, and what they'd go for on eBay these days? Might still be sitting on a shelf in a dark corner of a storage room in my old grade school, which is closing next year. If they have a "garage sale" maybe I should go there to see if I can find it :)

Pretty cool they are both still going, too bad they are going to run out of power within my lifetime (or at least so I hope!) I have a feeling some billionaire will cause a ruckus a century from now by recovering one of them, bringing it back to Earth, and putting it on display in his house.

Can NASA arrest property rights over them once they are dead, or would it be considered similar to salvaging a shipwreck in international waters?

5
0

Qualcomm axes staff, winds down data center processor efforts ... while China takes the blueprints and runs

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Still, they got one over on Apple

Since Apple sells zero iPhones running iOS 11 (everything that supported it supports 12) this won't affect them. Though if iOS 12 infringes on the same patents they can probably get it added to the injunction eventually.

Given the timing of this ruling, one wonders if this is China's first salvo in retaliation for the arrest of Huawei's CFO? Because China has in the past shown little interest in banning import of ANY products due to patents held by US companies, only doing so when a patent is held by a Chinese company.

Banning sales of the only US based smartphone vendor operating in China is even better than a tariff, because it is not really possible for the US to retaliate for via tariffs, which seems to be the only tool Trump thinks there is in a trade war. The stakes are getting more serious now. If there are any similar lawsuits pending against Ford or IBM or other major US companies operating in China, I would guess they are going to start moving through the courts very quickly.

3
0

Ecuador says 'yes' to Assange 'freedom' deal, but Julian says 'nyet'

DougS
Silver badge

@ian michael gumy - "Schiff will bury this"

Sorry, wishful thinking on your part. The house republicans made an absolute joke of their constitutionally required oversight rule, by not asking any tough questions, making anyone who would provide uncomfortable answers testify behind closed doors, not issuing any subpeonas, and accepting a laughable standard of "executive privilege" that - had Clinton tried it during the Benghazi hearings - would have caused Sean Hannity's head to explode!

There will be REAL oversight in less than a month, and between that and Mueller's probe connecting him with his first (of no doubt many) felonies, he knows it is just a matter of time before he does the following:

1) his own version of the 'Saturday night massacre' firing Mueller, Rosenstein, and the entire SDNY office, and ordering all evidence collected by Mueller and the SDNY destroyed

2) pardons himself and his family for all crimes ever committed in their entire lives, because it is the things that he did before he ran that the SDNY is now investigating are starting to worry him more than the things he did during his campaign

3) resigns, claiming "I've done everything I set out to do as president so its time to get back to the business world"

4) a few years from now is convicted of tax evasion and other crimes by the state of NY, but no doubt he'll skate by like most white collar criminals and be given probation instead of the jail time he deserves due to his age and the desire to avoid a political firestorm

2
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Assange is a political prisoner, in the United Kingdom, end of

Bullshit. They offered him a deal where he won't face the music in the US and he STILL won't leave. I think he is staying for the attention at this point. Let him rot there, until Ecuador decides to put him out on the street.

70
25

Expired cert... Really? #O2down meltdown shows we should fear bungles and bugs more than hackers

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Was this

True, payment processing can be a problem, but no more of a problem than it is for manual payment. Ideally it would be done with a yearly subscription for all your certificates in a lump sum, or paid in monthly installments, rather than dribbling out a small payment each time a certificate is renewed. The accounting department would HATE YOU if you managed 3000 certificates and each was a separate charge for yearly renewal!

Automated renewal also makes it practical to have certificates that last only a month, making the cumbersome process of revoking them if compromised less of a factor.

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Was this

And that still requires a manual process to insure EVERY certificate finds its way into that electronic monitoring system. This is better than a manual process around every renewal since you only need to do it once for a certificate and then you are good for as long as that particular certificate-requiring function remains exactly the same.

Better, but not good enough.

4
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: V2X

Vehicles will need (or at least want) to communicate with one another, yes. But there's absolutely no reason they need to communicate via a cell tower. They will be in close proximity to one another and can communicate directly, there's no need to go to/from a cell tower which will often be further away than the cars that need to talk to each other.

As long as autonomous cars have to share the road with human driven vehicles they will need to be able to operate without any V2V communication though. They can't trust humans to always signal a turn etc. so they will still need to drive defensively and not fully trust the info they get from other vehicles.

The exception to that trust would be for things like drafting bumper to bumper in the left lane, obviously you'd need to trust that the cars ahead will act appropriately and the lead car will alert the rest of a hazard that will require braking or steering. So sorry, no user modifiable software allowed!

5
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Was this

In what electronic diary? Notifying whom?

Do you know how many certificates large enterprises have to manage now? It would be a full time job for someone - but if you made it that, you'd be screwed when they went on vacation or quit and the reminder from their electronic diary went to /dev/null.

The whole system around certificates is irretrievably broken if you require humans to be in the middle of it. It has to be automated - a subscription service that automatically updates. We will never see the end of such issues so long as humans have to be "reminded", because we are fallible. If the certificate for some weird page hardly anyone visits expires, it might be weeks before the company is notified. If the certificate required for mobile data to work at a large provider expires, it could do a lot of damage in the hours required for the problem to be diagnosed and corrected.

12
0

The curious tale of ICANN, Verisign, claims of subterfuge, and the $135m .Web dot-word

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Alternate system

Yes, it absolutely does. But so does the current system.

What problems does the current system create that average users of the internet give a damn about? They don't care if new TLDs cost a lot, or there is corruption in ICANN. It doesn't affect the typical internet user! Hell I'm glad new TLDs are mostly a failure, it was a stupid idea from day one and if they were in wide use the internet would be in a bigger mess.

The average person is exposed to a lot of corruption in their day to day lives, from government, from corporations, etc. On the list of corrupt organizations measured by how much it personally affects them, ICANN would be somewhere in the thousands.

1
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Alternate system

What could ICANN do that would piss off large ISPs? They are pretty much independent of ICANN.

0
2
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Where are ICANN based?

Well that's kind of the sad reason for this. The ROW rightly decided the US had too much control and ICANN should have greater independence from the USA. Unfortunately, while they gained some independence from US oversight, this happened without getting any new international oversight!

8
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Alternate system

I think this is vanishingly unlikely. Who is going to convince multiple big ISPs to switch off the real DNS root to an alternate one at the same time? Along with other big players in DNS resolution where end users might set it directly, such as Google's 8.8.8.8 along with newcomers 1.1.1.1 and 9.9.9.9.

Because you sure aren't going to get a grass root campaign that causes a majority of individual internet users in the world to switch their resolution. Because you'd 1) have to explain why they should and 2) more importantly you'd have to teach them HOW.

You have to get a strong majority of worldwide users, otherwise no company would risk not being on the real DNS system and only available on the new alternate.

Sadly, the best you can hope for is one of these lawsuits succeeds and brings some light into the shady dealings, or some sort of palace coup takes out the current leadership (and doesn't end up replacing them with something that's ultimately worse)

0
3

Tech support discovers users who buy the 'sh*ttest PCs known to Man' struggle with basics

DougS
Silver badge

"UI differences" in cars have always existed

There are cars with auto transmission gear selection on the steering wheel, some on the console, some on the steering wheel. Some have wiper controls on the left, some on the right, and when I was a kid I remember my dad's car had them on the dash. Some cars have a stalk for cruise control, others have buttons on the steering wheel. I won't even get into the multitude of ways climate control, radio, setting the clock etc. works.

I don't see this problem as being any different than it was 50 years ago, other than than cars can do more stuff so they have more stuff to control. This will all be resolved in a decade or so by autonomous cars, where you'll have a touch screen to do anything you need to do which won't distract you from driving because you won't be.

6
1
DougS
Silver badge

That story obviously wasn't from 2018

And your superior attitude doesn't belong in the workplace, either.

9
0

Do not adjust your set: Hats off to Apple, you struggle to shift iPhones 'cos you're oddly ethical

DougS
Silver badge

Of course Apple could use narrowly focused data like your iTunes example, but that's a far cry from collecting anything and everything. There's also nothing stopping them from having that data collected and processed locally so it never leaves the device. There's no reason it needs to be uploaded off your phone, other than to combine it with other devices like an iPod, Mac etc. which would be of limited utility unless you listened rarely on your phone compared to other devices.

Please spare me "just because Apple says they aren't doing it doesn't mean they aren't doing it". Just because Google's stated policies don't allow them to make every scrap of info they collect on you available to all governments of the world, as well as selling it on eBay for your neighbors to buy doesn't mean they aren't doing it, right?

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: 2nd hand....

Look at trade in values, not second hand pricing. Find me a site that shows the same value for an iPhone X or iPhone 8 as a Galaxy S8. I'll wait. For a long time, because there isn't one.

1
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Are you sure?

If you sell 200+ million units of ANYTHING in a year, you are going to have some issues with a certain percentage of them. I haven't had the issues you list and I've owned an iPhone X since launch and before that had an iPhone 6S plus since launch. Google has had a long list of problems with each Pixel and they sell 1% or 2% as many as Apple. As far as I'm aware, no one I know has had any of these problems with their iPhone (not that all my friends tell me about every problem they have with their phones, but I do hear some of them and except for broken screens those issues are universally Android related)

If you don't believe iPhones last longer than Android phones, you are being willfully ignorant. Go look at the resale value (either in absolute terms or as a percentage of original sales price) and compare to ANY Android phone. If they were as poorly built as you seem to believe, no iPhones would last long enough to be resold!

2
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Time to change the business model.

They already are, they set a goal a couple years ago to double their services revenue by 2020, and they are ahead of schedule on it, seeing growth of 20-30% a year.

Having older phones last longer and get sold second hand is increasing their user base by 10% a year in the US (probably similar everywhere) which means more people to sell services to, even if their yearly sales of new phones begins to decline due to people waiting longer before replacing them.

2
0
DougS
Silver badge

I can't imagine that if Microsoft and Google are doing it that Apple aren't at least dipping their tongues in to the data pool and having a taste if not a full slurp.

With what goal? Google (and Facebook) has to do it because they make all their money from advertising, so their business model demands slurping data. Microsoft has decided to emulate that and try to make money from advertising in addition to their existing sources, whether they will be successful or give up remains to be seen. Apple doesn't really do advertising (except for its own products) so there's no reason for them to slurp data.

So you think they do, and store petabytes of personal info on all of us just "because", even though it has no current business value for them? Even though doing so without a purpose would risk major brand damage if it it became known, since they've been positioning themselves as the company that values your privacy and doesn't collect every scrap of data they can? It would be an insane risk to take when the reason is "just because".

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

More importantly

Apple's user base is increasing at over 10% a year in the US - I'm guessing it is similar in the rest of the world. So even if Apple's sales are flat or even decline because phones are "good enough", they will still add more and more iOS users every year because when people upgrade after 2-3 years years, their old phone will get itself a second owner, instead of ending up in a drawer like most old Androids.

That hurts them in the short run because they make such a large percentage of their revenue from selling iPhones, but in the long run the bigger user base gives them more people to sell services to. More people means more customers for services, which have been growing at 20-30% a year - and they still have yet to enter some markets like video streaming or cloud services that they might in the future.

2
0

Wow, what a lovely early Christmas present for Australians: A crypto-busting super-snoop law passes just in time

DougS
Silver badge

@Mark 85

The problem isn't the lack of critical thinking processes on the part of (most) candidates. It is the lack of critical thinking processes in voters. When republicans have an ever growing checklist of requirements to be considered a "real" republican (and now need a blessing by king Trump) they need to put any critical thinking skills they have on hold. Which is why the only congressmen willing to stand up to Trump are the ones on their way out the door.

Democrats look to be following the same playbook, as recently there have been suggestions from some democratic donors that potential 2020 democratic candidate Beto O'Rourke isn't "progressive enough" and actually said electing him would be like electing Obama again. Bernie or bust I guess, nevermind his age. Just like Bush and Reagan couldn't win nomination in today's republican party, perhaps before long Clinton (Bill) and Obama couldn't win nomination in today's democratic party.

3
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Half a World away

Hey, we have a president who may be guilty of treason, I think we are still in the lead for worst western democratic leadership! But you've made great strides with this new law, you may pass us yet!

6
1
DougS
Silver badge

Re: WhatsApp snooping

They will leave that up to Facebook to figure out, but it seems you could modify the software to ALWAYS produce a BCC key, so you wouldn't be able to tell when they are listening and when they aren't.

That will come in handy for when they demand a copy of all communications be sent to them to storage and later search, as that is the obvious next step for Australia's new totalitarian government.

4
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: I promised I'd keep doing this...

They can make use of GNU PGP illegal, and put you in jail, I suppose. The UK will jail people for refusing to tell them their password, so anything is possible.

5
0
DougS
Silver badge

Let's say stupidity prevails and Apple, Google and Microsoft build Australian spy support into their operating system software. What stops me from refusing to update from a pre-spying software version?

The "bad guys" will stick with today's versions of iOS, Android and Windows. Maybe in five years that could get to be a problem, but they might outlast the current government until someone else comes along who maybe has more sense. Or will they try to make non-conforming stuff illegal after a time, so any Android phone not capable of being updated becomes illegal?

I hope Apple, Google and Microsoft tell the Aussie government to stuff it. See how long the current leadership lasts after telling the public that they can no longer buy an iPhone, Android or Windows PC.

3
0
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Australia is doing a favor to the world

The US has shown the same thing, or have you not noticed our orange faced buffoon who thinks he's king?

7
1

You're legit and you know you are... Thanks to chanting racist footie fans, linking to dodgy stuff isn't necessarily illegal (well, in Europe)

DougS
Silver badge

Re: The US has a lot of overly authoritarian tendencies, but limiting speech is [..] not one of them

That's why we are fortunate freedom of speech is enshrined in the Constitution, so is resistant to any attempts to modify it via executive order. His followers would have a cow if a president was able to override the first amendment without changing the Constitution, because that would mean a future president could override the second.

All Trump can do is call speech he doesn't like "fake news", but his followers' credulity will only extend so far as the evidence piles up against him and the mainstream media reports are proven true. He risks undoing decades of republican effort to cultivate the idea of "liberal media bias" meaning that only Fox News and similar sources can be trusted by republicans. When they learn Fox has been lying to them all along, many will not be happy.

1
1
DougS
Silver badge

Re: Please select your response to this article:

Cave to US pressure? The US has free speech rights far beyond what the EU allows. The US has a lot of overly authoritarian tendencies, but limiting speech is fortunately not one of them.

7
1

Google: I don't know why you say Allo, I say goodbye

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Google abdicated its responsibility to Android users

True, but you aren't required to have your messages backed up to your Google account.

There's no reason Google couldn't support a user supplied encryption key so that you'd have security in your backups. That's really my only dig on Apple's security policies - while iCloud data is encrypted in transit and at rest, it isn't encrypted with a key you control. Apple is able to supply your iMessages that are backed up on iCloud in response to subpoena, because its "at rest" encryption is done with a key that Apple controls.

Which is why I don't use iCloud for backups, and instead am forced to use iTunes for backups which does use an encryption key I supply. I assume that similar would be possible with Android, albeit less convenient.

0
0
DougS
Silver badge

Google abdicated its responsibility to Android users

It was obvious people with smartphones wanted to talk to each other. Apple created iMessage, which is proprietary but checks the most important box - security. It is peer to peer encrypted so it is secure from snooping by either the carrier or the governments of the world.

Google spread themselves too thin with a bunch of alternatives, and let WhatsApp take over as the default Android chat app. It was also secure from snooping but its one shortcoming was that it wasn't built into the text messaging app, so Android users still had two apps to use to message.

Google's solution was to push a "better" SMS, which is fine except that it isn't end to end encrypted so it is still snoopable by carriers and governments. Since it will be built into their text messaging app, a lot of users will drop the superior WhatsApp to use this, and lose security as a result.

Nice job, Google! - spy agencies of the world

0
0

It's official. Microsoft pushes Google over the Edge, shifts browser to Chromium engine

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Worst possible outcome

Yes, but using the same engine still makes Chrome more dominant, because Google will remain by far the leading contributor to Chromium. They will obviously prioritize implementing stuff that helps steal users data over stuff that helps users preserve their privacy. Will other browsers built in Chromium go out of their way to delete such stuff?

Would you be this blasé if Apple's WebKit engine was by far dominant among browsers, and they had an inordinate say about what features are added? Instead of being more anti-privacy than I'd like as Google is, Apple might be more pro-DRM than you'd like in the choices they make about what to add to the code base.

1
3
DougS
Silver badge

Worst possible outcome

Like we need to see Chrome become more dominant, and be able to set advertiser friendly web standards that make it harder to protect your personal information while surfing!

24
1

Amazon robot fingered for bear spray leak that hospitalised 24 staffers

DougS
Silver badge

The best part is the workplace accident was the accidental release of pepper spray - which is basically what bear spray is. They are getting as good as The Simpsons in the "life imitates art" category, and with a lot faster turnaround!

In the episode, the release was caused by a robot screwing up.

4
0

Waymo's revolutionary driverless robo-taxi service launches in America... with drivers

DougS
Silver badge

Re: The whole driverless car thing

Driverless cars aren't a solution to fatalities. Well, they will need to be for people to accept them (my 90% decline in accident rate compared to humans in the same conditions standard) but for me the reason I'd want one isn't due to safety. These are the solutions as far as I'm considered:

1) I can take 1000 mile car trips instead of dealing with the nightmare flying has become if I can sleep in the car, surf the web, watch TV etc. instead of sitting behind the wheel having to pay attention

2) I can go out, get drunk, and have my car take me home instead of dealing with the hassle of taxis/lyft

3) In a few decades when I might be too old to drive safely, I won't have to depend on others for my mobility

0
1

Tesla autopilot saves driver after he fell asleep at wheel on the freeway

DougS
Silver badge

There is no "at fault" for AI

Insurance would either be handled by the automaker itself, or you'd pay based on the record of the model car you have (i.e. Google car might be more than Ford and less than Uber) and how many miles you travel rather than your own driving record.

0
0

Apple co-founder and former CEO has the most expensive John Hancock on the planet

DougS
Silver badge

Re: Weird Correlation

I wasn't sure if she signed or just stamped it with the royal seal. I'm a yank, I don't know about this stuff since we don't have kings and queens - only a shitty president who thinks he was elected king.

0
0

The Register - Independent news and views for the tech community. Part of Situation Publishing