* Posts by Roland6

10737 publicly visible posts • joined 23 Apr 2010

Selling hardware on a pay-per-use or subscription model is a 'lie' created by marketing bods

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Spot on!

Lets further debunk these claims...

"avoidance of capex (and potential debt/difficulty to get loans)"

If you don't take out and repay any loans, you won't build up a credit rating and so will find it hard to get loans...

The only reason (other than tax) to avoid capex, is to avoid having to pay out a lump sum and maintain it as an asset.

It should also be noted what happened in the late 1980's as companies rushed to convert assets such as property into opex, whilst they did liberate monies that could be invested or (more usually) returned to investors, they also significantly increased their opex, with a massive downward pressure on prices these companies found that they could not compete on price with (mostly) foreign companies... the companies that retained their property assets (ie. continued to own their factories) could leverage this asset to keep their opex low and thus continue to be price competitive...

Third-sector organisations that rely on grants tend to find it is more renumerative to purchase stuff outright as grant giving organisations tend to prefer to fund capex.

"avoidance of maintenance cost"

The only thing avoided is explicit maintenance costs - your subscription to say Microsoft 365 includes maintenance.

"avoidance of obsolescence"

I laughed at this one, a client has their 15+ year old fork lift's via a service contract, the service company has no interest in replacing the fork lifts with more modern ones...

Which really gets to the bottom of the xyx-as-a-service lie. Once customers are hitched to the service there is little real need and incentive to innovate at the pace we have seen in the IT industry these past 40 years. So in fact there is the potential to miss/avoid the 3~5 year refresh and 10~15 years down the road, discover the world has moved on but your xyz-as-a-service provider hasn't. Additionally, we have the converse, a business has to suffer the service providers upgrades delivered at the service providers convenience not the user organisation.

"elasticity/flexibility up and down and in terms of contract terms"

The benefits only really accrue if you have very dynamic or loads with uncertain scaling requirement - something that was common 10+ years back when businesses first opened web stores.

"immediacy of services (for cloud services at least) with no lead times"

The real value of cloud/xaas is lead time/time-to-market reduction (of the IT infrastructure) and the size of investment needed to trial something.

"outsource of infrastructure expertise"

Many business, particularly small businesses that don't run an IT organisation beyond a single person have already done this, so it isn't something special to xyz-as-a-service.

Here's US Homeland Security collaring a suspected arsonist after asking Google for the IP addresses of folks who made a specific search

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Anyone who expects Google not to track at this point

Re: black box

>They need to be compulsory for all vehicles.

There are moves to make dashcams compulsory in new cars - many manufacturers are starting to fit as standard, not exactly onerous given the cameras already being fitted for the driver assist functions.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Stupid Gets Caught

>Pretty sure that "carrier grade" nat would allow them to go beyond that router to the actual device

Nothing really to do with the "carrier grade" NAT bit.

All to do with the log files generated; forget to include protocol and port assignments...

Thing is with IPv6, given the way some implement it, there is a greater chance of the IP address (seen by the carrier and thus recorded in the logs) actually containing a real-world reference (eg. MAC address) that uniquely identifies the client device...

UK, French, Belgian blanket spying systems ruled illegal by Europe’s top court

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Not for much longer

>Interestingly it might not be possible for the EU to sue over the internal market bill, because its a bill not an act.

However, for the Internal Market Bill to have any real value, it needs to be on the status books before the end of the year; so a game of cat-and-mouse is probably being played: will the bill be an Act before the case gets a court date and will that date be before the end of the year...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Not for much longer

>"If a deal is agreed then the internal market bill would never be used & hence no case to answer."

Err no.

The IMB is to allow the UK Government (currently Boris and co.) to sign the deal they have agreed to and then throw it in the bin.

Wisepay 'outage' is actually the school meal payments biz trying to stop an intruder from stealing customer card details

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: "a URL manipulation attempt"

>Alternate payment methods ?

Cash...

Interesting to see that El BBC references El Reg but also indicate that this might be another Magecart

hack.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-54465359

Unis turn to webcam-watching AI to invigilate students taking exams. Of course, it struggles with people of color

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Why use the word racist.

Not yet been perfected?

I wonder if the problem is actually at a lower level ie. I suspect ExamSoft are using a third-party facial recognition engine, as it seems the UK Home Office are experiencing similar problems:

UK passport photo checker shows bias against dark-skinned women

Aside: What I like about this specific article is that at the bottom they give clear details of the method used to create their test data set.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Why use the word racist.

>This is just casual unthinking racism.

Aka Unconscious bias.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Why use the word racist.

>No it isnt. That is not discrimination at all full stop no way.

In the UK it is - such a website would not comply with the requirements of the Equality Act 2010 (which replaced the Disability Discrimination Act 1995).

Any one designing and/or developing webpages and/or websites in the UK would be expected know that their work must take account of this Act. So "I forgot" isn't a defense.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Why use the word racist.

>This is an algorithm that has not yet been perfected

Yes, and from the ExamSoft spokespersons comment: “the vast majority of those who have attempted to complete a mock exam have successfully done so.” it would seem they were totally blind to and dismissive of the bias in their solftware. That is unless the vast majority of candidates includes a substantial number of non-white candidates; but then if that was the case the spokesperson would have used different words....

Wind and quite a bit of fog shroud Boris Johnson's energy vision for the UK

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Great opportunity

>I think that Jobs are popular with a lot more people than just politicians.

But the politicians like to total all jobs 'created' across the life of a project to sway people - thus you can expect politicians to go on about say 200+ jobs being created. However, if you knew beforehand that the £1Bn investment would only result in 6 actual jobs after the opening ceremony, many would question the value of the investment.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Great opportunity

>So for only £160m you get £bn of green!

Plus all those jobs, you didn't mention but are so important to politicians...

A freshly formed English council waves £18m at UK tech industry, asks: Can somebody design and run pretty much everything for us?

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: £18m?

It's probably the figure their preferred partner came up with, just that they have to go through the public procurement process to be able to award the contract...

From the requirements list, it seems that a consultancy with an enterprise architecture capability is needed.

Cisco ordered to cough up $2bn – yes, two billion dollars – plus royalties after ripping off biz's cybersecurity patents

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Lots of Patents

That's Birmingham, England not Birmingham, Alabama - mostly likely named after Birmingham, England....

Nominet refuses to consider complaint about its own behaviour, claims CEO didn’t mean what he said on camera

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Complain to charity commission

However, to throw off the charitable trust status would seem to indicate that they once were a charity, which raises the question whether this process was correctly conducted, if not it can be rendered null and void...

Think tank warns any further delay to 5G rollout will cost the UK multiple billions – but hey, at least Huawei is out

Roland6 Silver badge

The absence of any nod towards the "massive jump" from 2G to 3G in the report, really says it all.

Reading the report it is clear the authors believe 5G to be synonymous with "Digital infrastructure" a and "Digital networks and services" ie. it is a replacement/upgrade of both 4G and existing (fixed) broadband. So are making all sorts of claims for 5G, that for anyone who has been involved in mobile the design of IT know can (and will) largely be met by existing technologies; just that the existing technologies -- like 5G need to be provide nationwide coverage...

It would seem the authors have taken the OECD statement "the extent of 5G gains depends on ‘the speed at which 5G will be rolled-out, and how quickly it will be taken up by businesses and consumers’ " and simply started running.

UK privacy watchdog confirms probe into NHS England COVID-19 app after complaints of spammy emails, texts

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: FFS!

>The problem is that GPs appear to have been told to break the law at scale by making unauthorised disclosure of PII.

You have not presented any evidence of this only wild speculation.

The only evidence you have presented is that you have received emails from the NHS at an address you supplied to your GP. Yes there is reason to question your GP about how this has come about - perhaps the NHS provides a bulk email facility to which GPs can provide a mailing list, tick a box, click okay and you get an email from the NHS in your inbox...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: FFS!

>Err. The app is NOT from the NHS. As we all know it was developed by a private company after the NHS were taken off the job.

Err the app is from the NHS, it is largely irrelelvant who actually developed the app. as they would have done it under contract to the NHS. The only relevant concern is whether the database is inside the NHS is external and the NHS only have access.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: FFS!

Yes GP's might be independent contractors, however, is your relationship with your GP: private or NHS; only private arrangements are truly outside the NHS and only then if they record the appointment on system separate to the NHS patient records system.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Only 12.4 M downloads?

>Why are the idiots-that-be claiming 12.4 M downloads as good?

Well to install you need either a device running iOS 13.5 (released 20 May 2020) or later, or a device running Android Marshmallow (6.0 released October 2015) or later.

Play are saying 5+M downloads, which would suggest circa 7.4M downloads from the iStore (actual figures not publicly available), which would seem to indicate that many iPhone users do keep their iPhones uptodate - with the numbers indicating that most users will be Joe Public and not El Reg readers.

It would be interesting to estimate just what the total potential number of compatible devices currently in use, so as to give an indication of market penetration.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: FFS!

>It arrived at an address which was given only to a specific private business, my GP.

Well GP's are in the business of delivering NHS services, so unless your GP is outside the NHS, all information you supply to your GP belongs to the NHS, with the GP as a data processor. So it is questionable as to whether your "email address has been shared".

The only other factor is the extent to which GDPR applies to GPs and the NHS and thus whether your GP should have sent out a consent form for you to complete, which would have contained a clause about data sharing.

I love my electricity company's app – but the FBI says the nuclear industry bribed politicians $60m to kill it

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Scandal, but not this

> realtime usage monitoring apps. No one uses them.

Not quite correct. People tend to use them initially to get an idea of what energy they are using, but once this is done there is no real need to look at them again unless an exception happens. I remember this usage pattern being reported on with the monitors supplied with new smart meters.

Microsoft lends Windows on Arm a hand with emulation layer to finally run 64-bit x86 apps at last

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: MS is between a rock and a hard place with desktop windows

The 286 was the min. cpu for Windows 3.1; Windows 3.0 supposedly could run on 8086/8088.

Personally, I never used it on anything less than a 386 with 4MB of RAM for Word, Excel, Powerpoint; now I use W10 and use some massively more performant CPU and 4+GB of RAM for Word, Excel, Powerpoint...

With so many cloud services dependent on it, Azure Active Directory has become a single point of failure for Microsoft

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: "we will never be able to avoid outages entirely"

>Where do you draw the line though?

<digression>

Suspect having a failover cloud on Mars is going a bit far, but it might come in handy when that asteroid hits...

</digression>

Windows to become emulation layer atop Linux kernel, predicts Eric Raymond

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: ROTFL!

>I've previously been a console gamer, and I was shocked at how much fiddling around with old versions of drivers and third party hacks it takes to get a lot of PC games running in a usable state under Windows.

That's because a console only has one specific chipset architecture, making it very simple for games developers. With the PC, games developers are free to specify their own graphics card and other preferences...

It's the reason why my son is only allowed a console, until such time as he can build and maintain his own PC's.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Am I the only one?

>The big gain here I think would be that printers, scanners, and a multitude of other useful peripherals might come with drivers that actually work in Unix.

Not explored CUPS 2 which contains support for Mopria?

Xen Project officially ports its hypervisor to Raspberry Pi 4

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Nice

>Easy micro farming on a Pi.

I wonder if Xen clustering will seemlessly work out-of-the-box on a Pi cluster...

The perils of building a career on YouTube: Guitar teacher's channel nearly deleted after music publisher complains

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Unfortunately....

It's a grey area because... its the music industry, which has its own idea on copyright. And from various cases over years thinks that if you are inspired to do something as a result of listening to a song and actually say they you were inspired by said copyrighted song, they are entitled to royalties...

See the same thing with Disney's actions against kindergarten kids drawings of Winni-the-Pooh etc.

Roland6 Silver badge

Youtube is like any business, it's run for the benefit of its owners. It isn't unreasonable for it to be over-cautious when setting policy, it needs to protect itself.

There is protecting yourself and protecting yourself. It would seem that YouTube is more concerned about being sued by a copyright holder than protecting the individuals who are bringing the money in...

First-world problems: The pumpkin spice latte is here, but the Starbucks loyalty card app has wiped my balance

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Spendy

>I remember being poured a cup from a jug almost as soon as I sat down, and having it topped up on a regular basis.

I always asked for a fresh coffee, not one from the jug that had been kept warm for an unknown number of hours... Having an English accent probably helped me get away with it. :)

Brexit travel permits designed to avoid 7,000-lorry jams come January depend on software that won't be finished till April

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: effective and simple to use

"This particular item looks as though the control is to produce a throttling of trade, what is the point of preventing trucks entering Kent "

According to the Brexiteer interviewed in the Express, this is supposed to put pressure on the EU to "force a deal", without giving any reason as to how having a border in Kent would put pressure on the EU (and not the UK). Laugh is that the no-deal Brexiteer's won't like whatever is in the deal and will vote it down regardless just to keep face.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: ...won't be finished until April...

>England can forget getting back in

Well on its own, but I'm sure, given the dire straits that would result in such an eventuality, I'm sure Nicola Sturgeon, would quite happily negotiate England rejoining as a Scottish region and Westminster would be glad she did so...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: More queues?

>It can only get better because...

it would remove 17m and thus greatly facilitate social distancing...

Scre-EE-m if you wanna go faster: BT's mobile network reigns supreme in UK-wide speed and latency tests

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: What about?

They do, however, you seem to need either a phone purchased directly from EE or a reseller as an EE network locked phone ie. contains EE firmware.

Aside: Not tried a non-EE phone to test this constraint.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: What about?

And BT Mobile (perhaps it was this that was being confused with Cellnet) - seems to still be around - is an MVNO on EE.

Roland6 Silver badge

"EE is the UK's fastest mobile network" with a median download speed of 25.7Mbps...

Interesting that these figures are well within 3G spec's. and mean there is no real point in replacing my LTE Cat4 USB dongle (150Mbps download/50Mbps upload) anytime soon.

Meet the ‘DPU’ – accelerated network cards designed to go where CPUs and GPUs are too valuable to waste

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Nothing new really

Not really, the big driver was cost reduction. With the PC, there was surplus processing time on the machines CPU, thus the "I/O Channel Controller" could be redesigned to use the main CPU rather than its own dedicated CPU - making NIC's affordable to the many. This thinking also lead to dumb modem cards and cheap printers that relied on intelligent drivers; all tied to the Windows OS...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Oh great. Yet another architecture to learn.

Smart NICs were normal before the PC - so with them back in fashion, it looks like the wheel has gone full circle.

>With a whole new batch of implementation flaws to code around.

Most probably as code design and implementation lessons are going to have to be relearnt.

It's powered by a mega-corp AI, it has a Liquid Mode, but it's not a T-1000. It's Adobe's PDF auto-reflow for mobile

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Just unfit for the purpose

Yes, I suspect in the current era, the problem lies in the tools...

I use Word/Libre etc. to produce a formatted document, which allows me to link elements together, the problems seem to arise when these documents are converted to some other format ie. PDF and HTML, where this linkage information seems to get lost.

Given the purpose of PDF is to preserve the look of a printed page across devices and printers, it is generally okay that PDF loses some of the metadata of the original document. It only becomes a problem when you wish to use the PDF as if it were a document format like ODF and Doc, ie. something PDF/Postscript wasn't intended to be used for .

However, webpage creators don't really have the same excuses; particularly when there is an expectation that the user will want to print the displayed webpage. It p*sses me off that web page producers don't understand the principle that I want not only to be able to display a webpage nicely on my screen, but also at times I want it to 'display' nicely on a series of A4 sized 'screens'. Strangely MS manage this quite well in Word giving the user multiple views of the same content. Interestingly, there are some websites that do understand that people want to print stuff and the print option reformats the content for printing (to printer or PDF).

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Just unfit for the purpose

>BTW, sensible use of a block level element will group the picture and caption together.

From having had to print webpages (eg. "for your records print this page") it seems many webpage creators don't understand "sensible usage".

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: RE: Ideal to proof read before printing

>PDF is a wrapper format - the contents can be a sequence of a load of words/letters, in which case liquid mode has a chance of working,

Well taking the simplistic approach, "Liquid mode" is just an ePub version of the document. Which can easily be accommodated in the PDF wrapper. (Back in the 90's we were using this approach to retain searchable OCR text of TIFF images within a single PDF document).

So this would suggest the 'AI' is all about creating that ePub version on the fly or from a hash lookup to see if the document has been previously rendered.

BT cutting contractors' rates by a fifth and halving notice period because 'coronavirus'

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: This years excuse

Of course there will be. There'll also be a term stating the rate. Changing the agreed rate unilaterally is where the breach is.

Only if they try to change the rate without giving notice that they are terminating the current contract.

As sysconfig noted "Yes it's shit, but it's not illegal." provided they do things in the right sequence... It's what the legal profession call a "technicality".

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: This years excuse

>It sounds more like breach of contract.

No, there will be a termination clause in the contractors contract.

Compared to how one company I worked for in the early 80's, BT is treating its contractors well - at that company they shed a load of contractors, giving 24 hours notice; off-site the following day complete with termination payoff.

All those ‘teleworking is the new normal’ predictions? Not so much, say bosses

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Not surprising for Aus

You made this key point first!

No where in the article or in comments prior to this is the quality and reliability of Home-Office comms raised.

NHS COVID-19 launch: Risk-scoring algorithm criticised, the downloads, plus public told to 'upgrade their phones'

Roland6 Silver badge
Pint

Be thankful it doesn't require a 5G phone - and a Huawei Chinese one at that.

We're not getting back with Galileo, UK govt tells The Reg, as question marks sprout above its BS*

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: "Europe (UK included) exist under the protection of the US military"

>It doesn't take a rocket scientist to see Russia as serious threat.

Trouble is, NATO is still largely of the cold war mind set ie. a Russian attack is something that can be repellec with nuc's and conventional military forces, not a long-term guerilla war: a Polonium laced cup of tea here, a quick spray of Novichok perfume there, a carefully orchestrated Facebook/Twitter campaign...

It looks like when there is something for NATO to attack the battle will already have been lost; to the Chinese.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: A dumb question but... where does NATO fit into this?

I got the impression that Trump was going to reduce US funding of NATO ie. pull the plug on NATO...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: You are joking?

>So why do you need an encrypted global positioning system independent of NATO - unless you want your own defense force.

Suggest you read the history of Galileo. At the time GPS was for the US military, civilian usage was secondary. Yes, you could for a fee gain access to the high res.. signals, but these still came with the US military first caveat - ie. the US reserved the right to modify (as it has done over the years) signals to give false positional data. If you want to build reliable commercial applications and you are non-US you can't rely on GPS.

Contractor convicted of pinching supercomputer cycles to mine cryptocurrency

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Economics 101

>Don't forget the electricity cost isn't $0

I had thought of that, however, given the organisation: Australia’s Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, I suspect they get fully funded to run the supercomputer 24x7 - or someone is p*ss poor at writing funding bids....

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Economics 101

It's a super computer being run on a bureau/cloud compute basis...

System idle time has zero cost until someone actually wants to use it at which point it has a price. So the AU$76,000 is what they would have billed a paying customer for the compute time used.

So moral of the story, if you want to make money mining cryptobucks, don't pay for compute time on someone else's machine.