* Posts by Roland6

10751 publicly visible posts • joined 23 Apr 2010

We never agreed to only buy HP ink, say printer owners

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: I very much doubt razor handles are or were ever sold at a loss

>It never occurred to me until today that I’ve no idea how they got the names, DOB and addresses of basically every teenager in England - creepy.

Electoral Role.

If you were on the Electoral Role, political parties, companies etc. could pay to blindly send a mailshot to all newly turned 18 voters. Obviously, if you were on the public Electoral Role, they can directly send personalised mailshots to you.

Similar applies to births, deaths and marriages.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: I very much doubt razor handles are or were ever sold at a loss

>I wouldn't be too sure about razor handles not being a loss leader.

Trouble is, yo probably think the handle is worth more than it actually is.

Going through the catalogues of marketing giveaways, I suspect the true cost of many mass market premium razor handles is sub 50p.

Roland6 Silver badge

HP claimed it went "to great lengths"…

> … to let customers know its printers are intended to work only with cartridges with an HP "security chip."

Just visited PC World, none of the HP printers on display or in their (HP) shipping boxes carried any label to this effect.

As these shops store both OEM and third-party inks, the normal member of the public would assume the printer can take any displayed cartridge that claimed compatibility with their printer.

Also the “security chip” was only introduced to prevent customers from using third party inks…

Fancy building a replacement for Post Office's disastrous Horizon system?

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: EPOS - not Tesco

Not got a packet of stamps to hand, but from that picture it looks like the stamps might have individual serial numbers, so what’s happened is someone forgot to scan the packet/sheet to change its status to released for sale/use.

OR… the behind the scenes issuing/sales system didn’t correctly record the sale/issuing of the stamps… and if that system is … Horizon, this would be par for the course…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: EPOS isn't just the terminal in the shop

> That’s why they couldn't/can't just modify an off-the-shelf retail EPOS system.

Current generation EPOS systems are obviously a lot more limited than the systems I used and greatly modified/enhanced circa 20 years back through the use of EAI tools…

Roland6 Silver badge

> (in over 11,500 branches, each of which might have two, three even four active terminals at any one time)

Based on a own datacentre system I designed and installed in circa 2004 that’s:

A top end Z-Series fronted by 4 mid-range “Unix”(*) boxes, double it for failover and add a third as a spare/tertiary failover configuration in a different data centre.

Although with the number of back end integrations required, I would probably replace/supplement that Z-Series with a two-tier configuration of high-end Unix servers, making it easier to add/remove bespoke servers for specific product/service lines.

Obviously the in-branch server will also be a reasonable “Unix”(*) box, so most of the traffic will be transactions rather than terminal sessions.

Alternatively, you could go the web server approach, which would require a larger server infrastructure. in which case the in-branch server is minimised, but has the limitation that a loss of service would mean the counter closing rather than not being able to process particular services.

I suspect cloud providers will push this load on their rebranded version of IBM cloud.

The issues in development and testing is that, at this scale, is you don’t use the apps and dev tools out-of-the-box to build the production system, so many of the developers will have had no experience of this style of development.

I remember from that project the main DB application provider saying stuff could be done overnight, until we confirmed they had only used their toolset on DBs up to circa 400GB; we were going to be using them on a 4TB DB…

(*) By Unix I mean a Unix/Linux box actually designed to be a server to support high levels of I/O, rather than a beefed up PC running Windows/Linux.

Roland6 Silver badge

Impossible, only the post masters have access to the data, so they must have altered it ….

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: EPOS

> POL and Royal Mail are different organizations.

I seem to remember the in Post Office systems are operated through Post Office Counters Ltd.

I suspect this permits greater clarity over transactions and avoids monies destined for say Royal Mail appearing on and thus distorting Post Office Ltd accounts.

Roland6 Silver badge
Joke

Re: I'll do it!

Sorry, we have no record of contributions to the Conservative Party, otherwise you look like just the sort of enterprising person this country needs more of.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: EPOS

> Furthermore, the systems used in Asda for monitoring sales and reordering stock are going to be very different from the integration required at the post office for renewing passports, currency exchange, parcel tracking, etc

They are just back end integrations driven by the barcode. However, some do require front end integrations, which can be achieve in the same way web browsers run applets for passports, phone credits etc. with the applet selection also being driven by the barcode…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: EPOS

> ASDA PoS will not simultaneously be handling sales for Tesco and Morrisons as well as their own.

Suggest you visit Asda’s, Aldi et al.

Aldi are a concessionary for the National Lottery, to buy a ticket, just scan the bar code and the till will generate a lottery ticket as well as a sales receipt.

Asda etc. whilst being a consessionary for National Lottery, also enable you to top up mobile phones, buy iStore, Amazon etc. vouchers

Just because it goes through a single till doesn’t mean it is handled the same way in the backend and accounts.

US Air Force secretary so confident in AI-controlled F-16s, he'll fly in one

Roland6 Silver badge

As Ukraine is showing, the jet fighter has an increasingly limited role to play.

Also given how the US is struggling to build the current generation of jet fights in a significant quantity, I suggest defence monies would better spent on making existing tech more reliable, eg. having missiles that can handle being flown more than a couple of times before they need their gyroscopes etc. recalibrated (biggest cause of sidewinder failures).

Huawei Cloud reveals the dynamic traffic allocation system it uses to cut bandwidth bills

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: 10 times the peak bandwidth ?

> Maybe Huawei will accept meeting with Western engineers and sharing the technique ?

That would mean admitting Huawei is ahead of the US; can’t see that sitting comfortably with the MAGA crowd and their rose tinted views on American tech.

As for sharing the technique, the simplest will be to purchase some Huawei networking equipment; which the MAGA crowd have been doing their best to prevent people from doing…

Irish power crunch could be prompting AWS to ration compute resources

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Did you ever hear about...

> I did wonder why Apple would be the one to pay for Ireland breaking its agreement with the EU

Agree, this aspect of the case was not well explained by the media.

Basically, the EU ruling was Ireland gave Apple illegal state aid, and thus Ireland needed to collect the backdated illegal state aid from Apple and pay the EU its slice from it. The Irish government with Apple jointly appealed. The media to keep things simple, claimed the EU was wanting the money directly from Apple. The Irish government were happy for Apple to be in the limelight rather than themselves…

Given the amount of EU reconstruction monies that Ireland took in the 1990s and early 2000s, the Irish government really were trying to pull a fast one on this, particularly when they said they didn’t need the tax revenues and thus under pay those who financed the economic development of Ireland.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Irony

> apologies if this gets too much into nitpicking waffle

Accepted, apologies for not correctly labelling my comment as nitpicking mockery about the status of the Isle of Man.

Totally, agree over the decades TeamGB selectors have been flexible with the nationality requirement, when it comes to outstanding athletes. Yet we all cheer when they win for TeamGB.

Personally, having met and spoken with the guy (several times), Mark Cavendish is a really good ambassador for cycling. A few years back he spent an afternoon at Silverstone individually talking to a couple of dozen young riders (8~16 year olds), giving each 5~10 minutes and having his picture taken with each of them, one of those 12 yo kids subsequently went on to become the UKs junior road racing champion and is now targeting Los Angeles 2028, she still remembers that afternoon.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Irony

:)

I was alluding to actual zero carbon emission(*)ie. Nuclear rather than accountancy zero emissions …

(*) just to be up front, nuclear does have emissions, just not CO2.

If we locate the bit barns and population directly next to Sizewell, we are basically saying we don’t need nuclear to be miles away from people…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Did you ever hear about...

Lots of people until you start counting full-time equivalents…

Just been through this locally, with a bit barn development, now it’s been constructed and populated total on-site full-time head count 20 people.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Did you ever hear about...

Re Apple sweet heart deal

The Irish government wanted its cake and to eat it. Then got upset when, to be expected, things didn’t t work the way they thought they did and they got found out…

The issue wasn’t t the EU, it was Ireland deliberately deciding not to honour pre-existing undertakings it had made. By making such arrangements in private etc. just confirms they knew what they were doing was wrong.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Economics are a PITA, aren't they?

> Then they don't create tax revenues either, because they're almost always a cost centre.

Trouble is, as we learnt from the fall out from the Apple sweet heart deal, Ireland doesn’t actually want the tax revenues. Clearly Ireland doesn’t want to be another Kuwait…

Personally, I would increase the rate of tax on bit barn energy and accept that most of the actual business profits will be whisked away to some tax haven.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Economics are a PITA, aren't they?

> It's inevitable it WILL happen, it's only a matter of time.

Dear children, sorry we burnt the planet and used up all the resources, but believe me it will be worth it, just think in a 1,000 years your descendants will be able to enjoy a lifestyle you can only dream about…

Having written that, it reminds me of the “god squad”: your life is and will be hell, but think of the reward awaiting the faithful in heaven….

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Irony

But the Isle of Man is part of the British Isles, hence why Mark Cavendish could ride and win gold for TeamGB.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Irony

> Anyway, they would have bags of fibre.

Wool fibre?

Round here the bags will be full of a different fibre; the fields are growing wheat for weetabix…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Irony

> If I was building a Bit Barn . I'd put it West of Sizewell, Suffolk.

Or fund the building of a new zero carbon emission power plant near to where there are data centres in use and under construction eg. West London. The only question is whether a bit barn is more profitable use of land than an airport…

Google is wrong to put AI search features behind paywall, says HPC leader

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: The problem is that AI costs a lot of money

Depends on how it’s accounted for.

Normally, if you are treating R&D as investment for tax purposes, it needs to come out of gross margin, although some costs will get treated as normal opex. This is where a good accountant is necessary, so you are maximising your tax kick backs.

Roland6 Silver badge

Interviewer missed asking the obvious follow on question: are Northern Data Group also going to democratise access by providing public (for free) access to their “ state-of-the-art generative AI cloud platform”…

What isn’t entirely clear is how Kincaid thinks Google giving AI stuff away for free will generate the revenues and market demand necessary to purchase the hundreds of HPCs she is hoping to sell.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: If Google puts AI search behind a paywall

They can be applauded for their ethical management (of AI) decision.

Kincaid totally fails to convince; I suspect Northern Data Group are worried Google’s actions may result in reduced demand for HPCs…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: The problem is that AI costs a lot of money

Whilst a good pre tax etc. margin, not excessive; Microsoft’s was 42%, Apple 30%.

US insurers use drone photos to deny home insurance policies

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: State Farm are the worst

But have you ever claimed for anything like roof damage…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: As usual, it's cover for taking advantage of old people

The house we grew up in the 1960s had the original roof from when it was built in 1903. Interestingly, a bomb dropped in WWII caused some movement of the timbers, it some additional bracing stopped further movement. Had reason to visit early this year, still had the old clay tile roof…

AI researchers have started reviewing their peers using AI assistance

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Embarassing? Elsevier are beyond shame

> since the year 2000

That’s just the papers they are admitting to. Elsevier have been trying to inflate their worth for decades, even in the 1980s anything with Elsevier’s name on it was going to be expensive.

AI will reduce workforce, say 41% of surveyed executives

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: C-Level Execs are #11 on the list of easily replaceable jobs.

I would like to know how AI will replace data entry clerks.

If you are still using data entry clerks after the decades of OCR, Workflow & Image scanning, BPR/BPI I can’t see how AI is going to change the requirement.

Going through the list, it’s hard to see how many of the candidates senior management would wish to do without through automation, would actually be replaced by AI. Perhaps they think AI is like the robots I I, Robot…

Roland6 Silver badge

It would possibly be more useful as it will have read the articles rather than just looked at the covers and a few flicked through pages.

What can be done to protect open source devs from next xz backdoor drama?

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Open Source Quality Institutes

>"because there’s no business case for paying people to take care of it."

Government can change this, by requiring quality assessed Open Source, vendors wanting to do business with government will need to ensure their Open Source is of a suitable quality and thus will pay.

In some respects this has similarities to Open Systems in the 1980's where governments did fund the creation of testing lab's and got industry buy-in; only for the government to back track muttering "market forces" and other things. Which over the decades had directly lead us to the current sorry state of affairs.

UK govt office admits ability to negotiate billions in cloud spending curbed by vendor lock-in

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Cloud

Agree, the point was the government by investing up front encouraged those teams to be properly supported by their employers.

The question about in-house is perhaps more grey than black and white. So if the government had built its own cloud, it doesn’t mean all the people working on it had to be government employees working in government facilities etc. The government was a sufficiently important customer that they could force software etc. to be open and thus unencumbered With commercial considerations.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Cloud

> GCloud would be running into a wall of patents already held by the usual suspects.

Not really, as the government would be funding the R&D, it will naturally be engaging “experts in the art” and thus any patents enforcing Ed can be dismissed as being obvious to those skilled in the art.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Cloud

> Show me the commodity equivalent of AWS Nitro System

Trouble we are comparing current cloud offerings….

If the UK government had gone with an in-house G-cloud based on open source, from the outset, there would most probably be an equivalent now.

It is perhaps noteworthy, that with Covid vaccines the UK government decided to do the upfront investment rather than simply let the market come up with a vaccine…it can be argued that had the government invested in open source cloud, the market would look very different today.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Good news

Which means they will be susceptible to a new discount pricing structure and warm words about openness etc. ie. An approach that can be announced as a success which requires little investment by the new government.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: shocked

I think you meant 45 years: 1979-2024, but as you note we’ve effectively had 45 years of Tory policies…

But don’t disagree with the prognosis…

Whilst people may dislike Blair and what his government actually did and achieved, in the run up to the 1997 election he was able to make people feel good and want to vote Labour; dont get the same vibe from Starmer…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Cloud

> a (massively underfunded, underskilled, underpaid) public sector workforce

That’s a political decision, made by those that don’t like the idea of a vibrant public sector…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Those who fail to learn from history

> Is there any reader who remembers the CCTA writing about all this in about 1995

The CCTA still had teeth in the 1980s - remember GOSIP, ITIL etc. until Thatcher removed them in 1989…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: shocked

The die was cast by Thatcher, who removed the teeth from the CCTA based on the idea that government should be a consumer subject to “market forces” not a market maker.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Cloud

No it’s an indication of the scale of progress.

In the mid 1990s it was a little awkward facing down a mainframe salesman, looking to sell a £17M mainframe replacement contract, and telling them that with a little redesign the workload could be handled by a dual processor NT box…

Obviously, we didn’t actually propose an NT box to the customer, but it forced people to think about the customer’s existing business processes the IT system would be supporting and the new processes it would be enabling.

German state ditches Windows, Microsoft Office for Linux and LibreOffice

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Desktop OSs are so passé

If you don’t want to carry around a paperweights when there is no Internet connection, you need a desktop OS and l applications capable of being useful in standalone mode.

Agree offline working does make collaboration systems more complex due to the re sync issues, but most of the time it isn’t a problem because the document management system handles it.

What is passé is building an enterprise application, where some level of collaboration would be expected and for it not to be able to handle the collaboration. The catch is collaboration needs a server which today means a cloud SAAS. Aside I wonder whether AWS et al are offering an orchestration and collaboration broker PAAS, which would greatly facilitate the creation of joined up collaboration applications,

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Outlook/Exchange ?

> You might have a chance with 80, but 800?

Personally, in the absence of any other information, I took the 800 figure as a raw figure from the device management system.

A client uses a small (circa 12) set of desktop applications, however, the device management system reports a few hundred different applications because it regards application xyz 10.1.1.1 as being a wholly different application to xyz 10.1.1.2, obviously this happens because each system is at a slightly different stage of the regular patch cycle.

Roland6 Silver badge
Joke

Re: making the use of libre office mandatory

> My solution as a consultant is to fire anyone who claims to depend on Power Point.

Clearly not a management consultant then…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: It wont be technical issues which sink this

> I'm amazed that the NHS hasn't, considering their size.

Legacy and (Tory) government policy.

Remember, the NHS, like government in general, has a lot of legacy dating back at least as far as Windows XP/2k3. Back then Linux wasn’t anywhere as good as Windows, so applications got developed for the Windows platform.

What is sad is that many missed the wake up call when XP, when EoL and MS messed up with W8, and invest in enterprise open source. Perhaps if this had happened, LibreOffice (or Calligra et al) for example would be much more of an Office killer.

However, given the wakeup call the UK government has been given ( https://www.theregister.com/2024/04/04/uk_cddo_admits_cloud_spending_lock_issues_exclusive/ ) things might change (not holding my breathe).

Iowa sysadmin pleads guilty to 33-year identity theft of former coworker

Roland6 Silver badge

Perhaps she was the clerk from the bank he used for Woods account back in the early 90s, or the salesperson from whom he purchased cars…

Hillary Clinton: 2024 will be 'ground zero' for AI election manipulation

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Solution seems obvious...

>” Unverlangte Werbesendung, unfrei zurück an den Absender"

Just imagine imposing this on social media… charging the sender/reposter say 1 euro for each returned post….

Obviously, people would need to add and maintain a current payment card on their account, but it might help reduce some of the worst excesses of abusive posts..

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: The burden of proof

> in the hands of a judge who may be a political appointee

If this is the case, you don’t have an independent judiciary…

Want to keep Windows 10 secure? This is how much Microsoft will charge you

Roland6 Silver badge

.. This is a far cry from when Microsoft was ramming the OS down users' throats…

It’s to be expected, ever since MS decided to end game XP.

Whilst MS had to be dragged into doing something, they subsequently discovered just how good a money spinner it is, particularly with business and especially with governments.

I expect when Windows finally goes subscription, MS will still offer a subscription add-on so people can stay with a version of Windows for a few years longer rather than taking the forced upgrade.

A question is whether MS will maintain the 6 year gap between Windows releases, so Windows 12 gets released in October 2027, or because of “AI” launch it in 2024~2025. Perhaps going for that extended support on W10 might enable the evaluation of W12 and the skipping of a version…