* Posts by veti

4492 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

DeepNude deep-nuked: AI photo app stripped clothes from women to render them naked. Now, it's stripped from web

veti Silver badge

Re: Benny Hill

You're saying you have trouble finding pictures of underdressed young women to look at?

Have you considered trying the Internet?

veti Silver badge

Re: Time passes...

In the first place, is it "the same people"? You would need to cite specific names and posts to establish that.

in the second place, your starting and final positions look like caricatures. If they are only slightly more nuanced, your point disappears. For instance, "should" can cover a wide range of meanings, from "this is how things would be in an ideal world" to "everyone is morally obliged to feel this way" - there's a lot of ground between those positions.

In the third place, lots of things have changed in the past 20 years. If you haven't changed your mind about anything in that time, you're not thinking.

In the fourth place, "SHAME ON EVERYONE!" is a strawman position in itself. If you really don't think there's something a bit off about faking nude photos of real people and distributing them on the Internet, then please come out and say so - then we can argue that case on its merits, whatever they may be.

Good news: NASA and Homeland Security just passed their government IT exams – and we really mean *just*

veti Silver badge

Re: Uses for a Homeland Security Report

Both Homeland Security and NASA have seen budget increases in the past couple of years. The DHS in particular - locking up children, conducting dawn raids on immigrants, putting up hundreds of Secret Service agents at every major golf course in North America... none of these things come cheap, you know.

US cop body cam maker says it won't ship face-recog tech in its kit? Due to ethics? Did we slip into a parallel universe?

veti Silver badge

Note this is only possible because Axon is in a privileged position within the market, it has a near monopoly on this equipment and cozy relationships with police departments.

If anyone were realistically placed to compete, they'd see this as an opportunity. But it'd take a competitor at least a couple of years to build themselves into that sort of position, and long before then Axon will see them coming and, presumably, reassess their ethics evidence.

Remember that crypto-exchange boss who mysteriously died after his customers' coins disappeared? Of course he totally stole them

veti Silver badge

Well, let's see. He emptied a lot of other people's accounts, in a manner that is trivial to detect if you have access to the records, then - took the key with him on holiday to India, and next thing anyone knows he's "dead" and the accounts can't be accessed.

The timing is suspicious, to say the least.

Of course, since Ernst & Young have evidently hacked the accounts, it's also possible they've helped themselves to the money and set the guy up. But I'm discounting that because E&Y are still here, and their reputation is worth more - despite everything - than the contents of a few crypto wallets.

veti Silver badge
Facepalm

I am shocked

Shocked, to hear that financial instruments created specifically to avoid regulation are being used to... avoid regulation.

Out of Steam? Wine draining away? Ubuntu's 64-bit-only x86 decision is causing migraines

veti Silver badge

Re: Mint

I suspect Ubuntu needs Steam far, far more than Steam needs Ubuntu. Why should Valve pay for Linux support, when less than 0.5% of their customers use any kind of Linux?

(Source.)

Queue baa, Libra: People will buy what Facebook's selling. They shouldn't, but they will

veti Silver badge

Re: As a Facebook refusenik I see a time when

Don't worry, we're already past peak Facebook. What we're seeing now is a Facebook that's increasingly desperate to remain relevant.

The press has turned against it, and politicians have followed. Now the politicians are starting - not a minute before time - to talk about treating Facebook as a publisher, rather than allowing it to write its own special rules, as it has for the past 20 years.

Alexa, am I having a heart attack? Here's how smart speakers could detect their masters spluttering to death

veti Silver badge

Re: Going to hell in a handy basket of apps

If trading some of your (increasingly illusory) privacy gives you a longer and richer life, why do you call it "dumb"?

We've been making trade offs like that since before we were even humans. It's sometimes called "the social contract" - it's the same thing.

veti Silver badge

We're still a long ways from that. But it'll come.

UK.gov must sort out its crap data and legacy IT, warns spending watchdog

veti Silver badge

Re: AI database

Your example is awful.

Not only is "joy" clearly a name in this context - no English speaker would use the noun like that - but also you can't dismiss the possibility that it's Bob who trains a lot.

What, you think the name "Bob" can't take a feminine pronoun? Much to learn, you have.

veti Silver badge

Which still qualifies as progress.

If you can make your mistakes faster, you can correct them faster. What's needed is to combine the crappy system with a robust and high bandwidth method for people to appeal against them, and get a resolution from a different system within a matter of hours, not weeks.

The first step in correcting data is to create a channel for entering corrections.

You're Huawei off base on this, Rubio: Lawyers slam US senator's bid to ban Chinese giant from filing patent lawsuits

veti Silver badge

Look on the bright side

If this passes, the US will have withdrawn from WIPO, so we'll all be free to copy as much of their tech as we can get our hands on.

Sounds like fun.

A $4bn biz without a live product just broke the record for the amount paid for a domain name. WTF is going on?

veti Silver badge

Re: Meh.

I was planning to go with "indifference", myself.

But then that's how I've always treated Facebook, so what do I know.

veti Silver badge

Re: "Has whoever sold the domain actually got the money?"

Somehow I don't think the author of that release thinks "cash" means - what I think it means.

Or what did GoDaddy do - slip a brown envelope under the door?

Now you can have a twist of 2019 in your 2012: Microsoft goes back to the future with Edge on Windows 7/8

veti Silver badge

Yes, you are. They canned XP, and that was before they put on the whole song and dance routine about predictable lifecycles. They'll do the same to 7.

Bot war: Here's how you can theoretically use adversarial AI to evade YouTube's hard-line copyright-detecting AI

veti Silver badge

Internet rules

"Link or it didn't happen."

"We can't show you these products because that would be ILLEGAL but we'll show you this one (even though it's just as illegal), sorry it's a bit crap."

That's some weak sauce, right there. The story reads like a sales pitch aimed at YouTube themselves, which must mean they've already failed to convince them directly.

After years of listening, we've heard not a single peep out of any aliens, say boffins. You think you can do better? OK, here's 1PB of signals

veti Silver badge

Re: Misleading headline

"Galactically speaking", the whole of recorded history - about 10,000 years - is the blink of an eye, though. Exactly how much work should we put into this effort, on the basis that it will continue forever and will very likely never turn up anything even then?

Maybe the others never used radio comms. After all, why would you need it, once you discovered slood?

veti Silver badge

Re: Misleading headline

... So how do you feel misled, exactly?

veti Silver badge

Re: A significant part of the problem

5G can barely reach the next street, let alone the next star system. Broadcast signals get weaker with every generation - which is a good thing, they waste a lot of power.

Freaking out about fiendish IoT exploits? Maybe disable telnet, FTP and change that default password first?

veti Silver badge

Re: How many home users *need* the admin password anyway ?

And the other 20% would go to the scrapheap having never been used, because the poor owner had no way to configure them.

Yeah, I can see that generating some bad press.

'AI is not the cause, it’s an accelerant. The pace of change is challenging' Experts give Congress deepfakes straight dope

veti Silver badge

Re: Blockchain technology in AI database as a means of combating fake news

Why does this comment read like a slightly overwrought bid at beating the Turing test?

Oblivious 'influencers' work on 3.6-roentgen tans in Chernobyl after realising TV show based on real nuclear TITSUP

veti Silver badge

Re: iPhone?

To be fair, that's perfectly reasonable.

If you're socialising with someone, on virtually any level, there's an excellent chance that sooner or later you'll find yourselves eating together. It's one of the biggest social rituals we have. When that day comes, you wouldn't want to unwittingly take the poor broccoli-botherer to Hagar's House of Ribs, would you?

'Cynical and bullying' TalkTalk hackerhacker getsgets 4 yearsyears behindbehind barsbars

veti Silver badge

Re: I've been caught ...... I must have Asperger's.

We don't know when he was diagnosed with Asperger's, but it must have been a while ago because the condition doesn't exist any longer - it's called ASD now.

It would help to explain why he thought the hacking was harmless fun. But when it comes to 'bullying, intimidation and extortion', I'm inclined to think it would take more than ASD to get him off the hook for that.

US border cops confirm: Maker of America's license-plate, driver recognition tech hacked, camera images swiped

veti Silver badge

Fun with definitions

The claim that "No CBP systems were compromised" seems a bit - optimistic, all things considered.

If the wholesale downloading of data to an unsecured facility - which is what they've admitted happened - isn't "compromising", what is?

Worried ransomware will screw your network? You could consider swallowing your pride, opening your wallet

veti Silver badge

Re: "Where's "here"?"

The point I'm getting at is, with kidnapping you need a good degree of certainty that the ransom will be paid. Without that, the economics just don't work. If you can prevent payment in just 75% of cases, nobody will risk kidnapping.

With ransomware, preventing even 95% of payments makes no real difference. So this approach doesn't work. You could try banning cryptocurrency, but I think we all know what that would lead to.

veti Silver badge

Re: "Where's "here"?"

That's a straw man. Nobody has suggested that paying a ransom is a substitute for security.

Security is hard, and sometimes it fails. When it fails, a rational manager should consider all the available options.

veti Silver badge

Re: 'Paying the ransom isn't going to make a difference' - Wrong

But it IS profitable. That much has been established, you can't wish it away. Saying "it wouldn't be profitable if..." is about as useful as saying "wouldn't it be nice if there was no crime?"

veti Silver badge

Re: "Where's "here"?"

Very different economics. Kidnapping people is extremely high risk, requires a huge reward to make it a viable business.

Malware, not so much. The marginal cost per infection is zero. So if 99% of your victims don't pay, no problem - just infect another million.

We've tried preaching "don't pay, ever", and it's been about as effective as abstinence-only sex education. Maybe acknowledging reality isn't such a bad idea.

veti Silver badge

You have a very firm idea about what's right, but how do you come to that conclusion? What weight do you attach to "don't reward wrongdoers" vs "be a reliable business and employer"?

You can't act as if there is only one moral requirement to consider. Well, you can, but then you're not being very moral.

veti Silver badge

Re: Just no

It's easy to talk big about ethics, when you're not being asked to decide whether 10,000 other people will have jobs tomorrow.

People who do make decisions like that, know that there's a balance.

Crime doesn't pay? Crime doesn't do secure coding, either: Akamai bug-hunters find hijack hole in bank phishing kit

veti Silver badge

Re: Good hackers aren't always good coders ...

I agree. In the same way, good coders don't generally make good testers, or vice versa.

Breaking things is a fundamentally different skill from making things.

veti Silver badge

Criminals have PHBs too

And they're just as clueless as their commercial counterparts.

So there's an underling coder who knows (1) that his boss isn't going to rigorously review the code, (2) that his boss is a criminal, and therefore (3) his own long-term job prospects aren't great. Why wouldn't they insert some extra backdoors in the code, so that they can continue to profit from it after they bail from the current gig?

Google may have taken this whole 'serverless' thing too far: Outage caused by bandwidth-killing config blunder

veti Silver badge

Re: The Cloud...

Only a sysadmin could write that.

To a user, local storage is just as much "other people's computers that they have no control over".

Uncle Sam wants to read your tweets, check out your Instagram, log your email addresses before you enter the Land of the Free on a visa

veti Silver badge

Re: What about the antisocial?

I don't think enforcement is the point. It's just another obstacle to filter out people who are less committed to visiting, and another tripwire that can be used to summarily throw them out of the country if it's expedient to do so.

Nobody cares about or is going to do anything with the information. It's the act of providing it that matters.

Sex and drugs and auto-tune: What motivates a millennial perp?

veti Silver badge

Re: "does not make....sense"

One trouble of such systems is that they inevitably depend on the input of many people. Some of those people are aware of what they're doing, others not. Some are consciously or subconsciously trying to manipulate the outcome. Nearly all are manipulating the data, if only to make themselves look better.

All have subtly, or not so subtly, different ideas of what's relevant to the question.

Then all this bullshit gets fed into a system designed by a psychopath to solve a problem that is about four orders of magnitude more complex than anyone concerned realises.

veti Silver badge

Sex and money aren't real? I think you'd have trouble defending that.

veti Silver badge

I'm confused. If that's what illogical decisions are based on, what exactly drives the "logical" ones?

veti Silver badge

Re: Well there might be a bright side

What sort of taste do you expect, from "the estate of Donald Trump"?

Introducing 'freedom gas' – a bit like the 2003 deep-fried potato variety, only even worse for you

veti Silver badge

Re: My main regret ...

That's a bit defeatist. Not the conclusion, I think she's completely right that there's no point in her meeting him, but the reasoning.

It is possible to change Trump's mind with science. Bill Gates famously talked him out of being anti-vax. But it's not possible on this specific issue, because it would be politically inconvenient for him to be converted. Truth is irrelevant, all that matters to him is winning.

veti Silver badge

Re: @ Geoffery Sleep is a Good Thing(TM)

Many, many people have tried to predict the precise time of the Rapture. To date, all of them have been wrong. And not just "wrong" in the sense of being out by a few hours or days or years because of some imperfections in their data, but in the sense of their entire argument being based wholly on fallacies.

Of course it's possible that one day someone may get it right, but at the moment they have a 100% failure rate in the same way as humans have a 100% mortality rate. There are people who have not yet died, so technically that rate isn't really 100% on a strict evidentiary basis, but most people are pretty confident of it.

WikiLeaks boss Assange acted as a foreign spy, Uncle Sam exclaims in fresh rap sheet

veti Silver badge

Re: I was fine with the first indictment

I think that's the idea.

Trump doesn't really want Assange on trial in the US, no telling what sort of embarrassments that might lead to. What he wants is to pose as a tough guy for his followers, provoke the press into attacking him, maybe provoke Congress into impeaching him, and provoke the Europeans into defying him. All of which will play directly to his standard speech about how it's America against the world and no one but him will stand up to them.

Assange himself is irrelevant, nobody except Assange really cares what happens to him. He's become a prop now. Potentially useful for all sorts of people and purposes, but only for what their posturing says to their own voters.

AI can now animate the Mona Lisa's face or any other portrait you give it. We're not sure we're happy with this reality

veti Silver badge

As I've said before, we urgently need camera makers to embed digital signatures at the moment of taking every picture. That would make the easier kinds of fakery easy to spot.

No Huawei out: Prez Trump's game of chicken with China has serious consequences

veti Silver badge

Re: Huawei forward

14th amendment (again):

"The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, [...] shall not be questioned."

veti Silver badge

Re: 5G patents....

Hmm. Delay 5G by five years? Not a bad idea.

veti Silver badge

Re: Huawei forward

Unless the Chinese govt rolls over and declares Trump the winner of his trade war, apparently. If that happens, all the security worries will blow away like a fart in the wind.

How does that work, exactly? Well, since Trump has never bothered to spell out what he wants the Chinese to do, he can declare victory at any moment, but he wants a statement of surrender to show the faithful.

Ahem, ahem... AI engine said to be good as human docs at spotting lung cancer developing

veti Silver badge

Re: Not a big fan of AI

The story says that the AI produces better results - both fewer false positives and false negatives - than the average human radiographer.

Presumably some human radiographers are more skilled than others. Maybe the best of them could still beat the AI, I don't know. But the thing is, not everyone can be screened by "the best" humans. Humans don't scale that way.

But AI does. So if the AI outperforms the average radiographer - which is what the story claims - then it's good enough, and adding a human review step to the process would likely reduce the quality - by introducing delay, and increasing the likelihood of errors (both ways).

Lyft, Uber drivers boost app surge prices by turning off, tuning out – and cashing in

veti Silver badge

Re: Fraud

They don't have to convince a jury. I'm pretty sure Lyft can boot a driver without dragging it through any courts.

Do Not Track is back in the US Senate. And this time it means business. As in, fining businesses that stalk you online

veti Silver badge

Re: Why do politicians want to make everthing overcomplicated.

And, make web hosts legally liable for the behaviour of every bit of code run on their servers...

... or in the visitor's browser...

... hmm, actually that's not as simple as it sounds. Basically, it means every line of Javascript has to be vetted by the hosting company. That's maybe not a bad idea, but it certainly changes the landscape, and not all those changes will be for the better.

For instance, it will hand yet another solid competitive advantage to Google/Amazon/etc., who could maintain their own solid libraries of pre-approved scripts. Good luck to up-and-coming hosts trying to keep up with those.