* Posts by veti

4489 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

UK Supreme Court unprorogues Parliament

veti Silver badge

Re: Regardless of which side of the fence you are on.

No, parliament's duty was - is - to govern the country. The referendum was advisory only, it didn't change anything about "their duty".

As for being sacked, that's for their voters to say - MP by MP, constituency by constituency. Nobody else has that right.

veti Silver badge

Re: Regardless of which side of the fence you are on.

We settled that one back in 1649. No British monarch since then has claimed to be above the law.

veti Silver badge

Re: Except it’s not is it...

Because no-one bothered to take him to court over it. Duh. Assuming there was any such court in those days, before the "Supreme Court" existed.

If no-one feels strongly enough even to try to stop them, then the person who acts, wins by default. And you can't (re-)litigate it now, because the cause for action no longer exists.

veti Silver badge

Re: Regardless of which side of the fence you are on.

"A very good case" being, "yes unelected judges can overrule Parliament, but at least they're British unelected judges dammit!"?

veti Silver badge

Re: Damning...

The queen may be called many things, but I don't think you could defend "bureaucrat" as one of them.

veti Silver badge

Re: Damning...

Almost - except that it's not the PM Parliament can ignore, but the Queen (because she was acting on wrongful advice).

Calling all the Visual Basic snitches: Keep quiet about it and so will he...

veti Silver badge

Re: Do the right thing?

Questions like that aren't necessarily as dishonestly-motivated as they appear.

Sometimes, they originate from middle management, or even auditors, asking "how can we be sure this isn't happening? How can we prove it to our auditors?"

veti Silver badge

Re: Do the right thing?

Sounds like a sting to me. You were probably talking to the Daily Mirror.

veti Silver badge

Re: Risky business

It seemed to me that that remark, from someone working in investment banking of all industries, suggested a great obliviousness to the big picture.

If investment bankers, even in the noughties, didn't think all the time about risk, then they deserved everything bad that happened to them and so much more.

veti Silver badge

Re: Sounds Awful

What is this "must" you speak of? Where does this compulsion come from?

If it's anything other than "the laws of physics/mathematics", then it's "just another requirement", no less negotiable than every other requirement in the spec.

veti Silver badge

Re: something that is broken today might simply be fixed tomorrow.

Hello. Welcome to IT. I see you're new here.

It's theoretically possible that at some time, someone, somewhere has sold someone a piece of software that wasn't broken, but I've never heard of such a thing and frankly I doubt if it's ever really happened.

World's largest heap of untreated nuclear waste needs more bots to cart around irradiated crap

veti Silver badge

Re: Does not compute

The problem with that proposition is that nuclear power has, in its 70-plus-year history, never yet been "done right".

And there is no reason to believe it ever will be. Or can be.

Every generation, no pun intended, of reactors has been claimed to be the greatest thing ever, completely safe, completely clean and ridiculously cheap. That was Magnox, it was AGR, PWR, ABWR. And each time, that promise has turned out to be false on every count. If you think "thorium" is the magic word that's going to break that pattern, I have an Internet to sell you.

The '$4.4m a year' bug: Chipotle online orders swallowed by JavaScript credit-card form blunder

veti Silver badge

It's kinda crazy that they even allow a user type in a year, rather than selecting from a drop-down menu.

Typing is bad, m'kay?

Of course sometimes it can't be helped, but a "year" field - particularly when there's only likely to be a selection of four or so to choose from - is not one.

Emergency button saves gamers from sudden death... of starvation

veti Silver badge

Re: Publicity friendly.

So what if they did? Should such enterprise go altogether unrewarded?

ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?

That time Windows got blindsided by a ball of plasma, 150 million kilometres away

veti Silver badge

Re: Sometimes I miss...

Logitech make the bestest mice. Hands, no pun intended, down.

My version has the best of both worlds - ball and lasers. And it works on any surface, including my knee.

German ministry hellbent on taking back control of 'digital sovereignty', cutting dependency on Microsoft

veti Silver badge

Re: The long term

The only problem "open source" really solves is the one about having too many qualified applicants for your vacancies. Go OS, and basically you need to become a software company - with all the headaches that involves - in addition to the business you actually make money from.

veti Silver badge

Re: Do you want to be held hostage by Microsoft?

i see your point, but how exactly can you avoid it? Any government may decide to come after you. Case in point, the US government has been picking fights with several US companies (Amazon, Ford, Microsoft). It's not clear to me how hosting their data anywhere else would make any of them more secure against gov't-level interference.

Particularly if the gov't is prepared to ride roughshod over the law, in which case - even if your "rights" are cast-iron in legal terms, it can still take years to assert said rights.

Basically, there's no realistic defence against government-level attacks on your business. At least, not in the sense of preventing them. There are some mitigation strategies, but I'm not sure if "hosting your own data" would qualify as one.

Call-center scammer loses $9m appeal in stunning moment of poetic justice

veti Silver badge

Re: The thick twat

Yeah, I'm sure suing the senior scumbags will work out for him. Surely he knows their names and addresses, what specific laws they broke in whatever jurisdiction they happen to be in, and I'm sure his inbox is overflowing with offers from high-powered lawyers eager to help him out...

Seriously, where does anyone imagine this idiot is going to get $9m from?

This image-recognition roulette is all fun and games... until it labels you a rape suspect, divorcee, or a racial slur

veti Silver badge

Re: Quis custodiet ipsos custodes

Another way of putting that would be, we need better AIs.

A problem with the present generation is that they, by default, tend to treat all input as equal; it's all learning, right? If we could instil them with a child's ability to lend greater weight to some sources (like parents) than others, that might give us a way to teach them "values" that they could then use to filter their wider input.

Of course there will follow much mud-slinging about whose values should be instilled, but we get that anyway about children, so I don't see why that should stop anyone.

Australia didn't blame China for parliament hack in case it upset trade relations – report

veti Silver badge

Re: Can the "Five Eyes" be trusted with attribution

Meh. The Americans are the ones who have turned their backs on the South Pacific, why should we care what they think any more?

And Bridges is a loser, but he's right: it makes perfect sense for NZ politicians to form relationships with powerful figures in the Chinese government. After all, it's an extremely stable government - someone with power there now is very likely to still be in place after the next two NZ elections, which is more than you can say for the US.

UK Home Office primes Brexit spam cannon for a million texts reminding folk to check passports

veti Silver badge

No, the Tories would clearly win that election, leaving Farage in his rightful place. We'd be right back to where we are now, but with two more years of this nonsense to endure.

veti Silver badge

Re: It's sore loser syndrome

Let's be clear, there were horrible people on both sides. Sure there were racists voting leave. I'll bet there were some voting remain as well.

And let's not forget, other "remain" voters included - David Cameron, Tony Blair...

So trying to smear "everyone who voted the other way from you" by describing (what you imagine to be) the worst of those people, is not an exercise that is going to go well for anyone.

veti Silver badge

Pro tip: when you're posing as a Brit commenter, set your spellchecker to British English.

You're welcome.

The results are in… and California’s GDPR-ish digital privacy law has survived onslaught by Google and friends

veti Silver badge

Re: admit defeat?

"Eternal vigilance" is good. "Revolutionary fervour" is the last thing you need.

The trouble with revolutions is, they happen, and then everyone pretends everything is different - whereas in fact all that's happened is a change of personnel in certain positions. But everyone has fought the good fight, they're feeling good and upbeat and optimistic, and if you try to tell them that nothing has really changed - they won't take it well.

Two years ago, 123-Reg and NamesCo decided to register millions of .uk domains for customers without asking them. They just got the renewal reminders...

veti Silver badge

Re: Spot the Difference

Why exactly is Nominet a for-profit company in the first place? Whose idea was that, and what else did we expect when it was made so?

veti Silver badge

Re: Inertia selling

I'm sure the police will get right on to that... just as soon as they've followed up on my spam reports from 2002.

Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Google told: If you could cough up a decade of your internal emails, that'd be great

veti Silver badge

Re: Something like..

Apart from the "<=" operator, and throw in a few clauses about "To:" and "From:" fields, that looks about right.

veti Silver badge

Re: Another song and dance

"The 24/7 news cycle" will have forgotten about this story by the end of today. That's what it's for. If you think the action happens "before the story fades", then I'm not surprised you're disappointed.

If you want to achieve - anything, you need to keep your attention focused on it after everyone else has moved on. That's how you achieve anything.

veti Silver badge

Re: Small change

Alphabet (Google) spent $20 million on lobbying last year, enough to put it in the top 10 contributors.

If they all have to pony up $100 million, that would be extortionate. (Yes, I know what you're thinking. But let's try to keep the orders of magnitude within the bounds of plausibility.)

veti Silver badge

Re: Re "....10 years' worth of emails between top executives."

Seriously, what law is there obliging them to keep every email for that long?

I know if someone asked me to produce my business emails from ten years ago, I'd laugh in their face. I'm reasonably sure that information no longer exists, unless maybe in the NSA's database of course.

Whoa, bot wars: As cybercrooks add more AI to their arsenal, the goodies will have to too

veti Silver badge

Re: Oooh, deepfakes - I'm scared! (Not)

I'm not sure I'd call the "fake news" excuse "win-win", given what it's led to so far.

Time for another cuppa then? Tea-drinkers have better brains, say boffins with even better brains

veti Silver badge

Re: Smarts drink tea or Drink tea makes smarts

And there was I suspecting that the truckers' traditional love of caffeine had more to do with not being allowed to sleep more than about three hours a day...

Things are somewhat different now - but that's quite a recent change, and old habits die hard.

Cloud, internet biz will take a Yellowhammer to the head in 'worst case' no-deal Brexit

veti Silver badge

Re: What's in a name?

That's some way short of "clearly stated in the booklet sent to every voter".

That's more like "clearly posted inside the disused cubicle in the basement with the sign on the door saying Beware of the leopard."

The gig (economy) is up: New California law upgrades Lyft, Uber, other app serfs to staff

veti Silver badge

Err... you don't think healthcare is linked to corruption and extortion? Suggests you haven't been paying much attention lately. And healthcare is tied to public health, which is necessarily a public (shared) good - if there's an outbreak of, say, cholera in your city, it's very much in your own interests that it gets dealt with quickly and effectively, even if you and yours may have ironclad health insurance for yourselves.

veti Silver badge

Why are you willing to accept single-payer provision for policing, courts, defense and fire protection, but when it comes to healthcare, that's "Stalinism"? Why draw the line there?

Do you want fr-AI-s with that appy-meal? McDonald's gobbles machine-learning biz for human-free Drive Thrus

veti Silver badge

Don't be silly, you won't drive anywhere. The whole thing will be delivered to you by a drone, probably owned by Uber.

veti Silver badge

Now all they need is a robot to cook the "meal", one to package it into the greasy paper bag, and one to extend it out of the kiosk into the driver's window. Then more to take customers' orders at the desk, process their changes-of-mind, accept their payments, smile at them, and above all, clean the damn' restaurant. Continuously.

The fully automated McDs may be a horrifying vision or a utopian ideal, but either way it's some way off yet.

Breaking, literally: Microsoft's fix for CPU-hogging Windows bug wrecks desktop search

veti Silver badge

Re: Fixed

Well, that depends how many times it retries to launch, and how many parallel instances it spawns while it does so...

UK ISPs must block access to Nintendo Switch piracy sites, High Court rules

veti Silver badge

Re: Aren't UK laws optional these days ?

Laws are always optional. All it takes is a willingness to accept the consequences of breaking them.

veti Silver badge

Re: Let the whack-a-mole begin

No security is impregnable, but it doesn't have to be. It just has to raise the barrier enough to prevent X% of the loss, where 'X' is a closely guarded secret.

Huawei thanks Uncle Sam for returning its seized comms kit ... two years later, ya jerks

veti Silver badge

So they have to drop the lawsuit saying "give us our kit back", because the cause has gone away.

Doesn't mean they can't file a new one for "abuse of process" and "tortious interference with legitimate trade", or whatever the correct legal jargon would be.

Facebook: Remember how we promised we weren’t tracking your location? Psych! Can't believe you fell for that

veti Silver badge

So, split the Facebook app into two parts. One part, "Facebook", being the presentation layer, the other - something anonymous, like "Networking Services", being the layer that slurps data and feeds it to "Facebook".

Alert changes to "Networking Services is trying to access your location."

Like a grotty data addict desperately jonesing for its next fix, Google just can't stop misbehaving

veti Silver badge

Re: Not once have I been harmed by them having access to my data

Oh please. You're saying your political views are immune to the information you see? That they can't be affected by the news?

How does that work, exactly?

veti Silver badge

Hey, don't blame Google for Amazon's simplemindedness in ad targeting. That's Amazon's own biznai.

Blame where it's due.

eBay eBabe enigma explained: Microsoft bug blamed after topless model slings e-souk's emails at stunned Brits

veti Silver badge

Look, if you want to see pictures of boobs on your computer, they're not exactly hard to find. Having one pop out at you when you weren't looking - is probably unwelcome in many more than 50% of cases.

The wheels on the bus go round and... Oh dear. Chancellor Sajid Javid unveils spending review

veti Silver badge

Re: "the opportunities created by Brexit".

As I interpret it, what's happening is that - well, farmers need to be subsidised somehow. In the EU, that happens by taxpayer-funded subsidies handed directly to farmers. In NZ, it happens through (indirect) price controls artificially inflating prices, so the buyer (rather than the taxpayer) pays.

But the need for someone to pay that subsidy isn't going anywhere. Assuming you want there to be a UK farming sector - and I don't know of anyone who doesn't want that - then someone is going to have to pony up the money currently coming from the EU to support them. Direct government subsidies (as now, but paid directly by the government) would presumably be a good deal - but it would further dent the UK budget. The alternative is basically to double the price of everything.

Q. If machine learning is so smart, how come AI models are such racist, sexist homophobes? A. Humans really suck

veti Silver badge

Re: So AI in this instance got it right

In case you hadn't noticed, the University of Southern California isn't in the UK.

Racism in the UK is very different from the US. It exists in both places, but the historical background and processes and manifestations of it are completely different.

veti Silver badge

Re: How come AI models are such racist, sexist homophobes

That would mean the AI should take a negative view of people in general. It doesn't explain why it should associate different qualitative values with people of different races.

veti Silver badge

Re: Pimp or madam?

Not quite. It can also be used to demonstrate the fact that biases do exist in the source material.

A surprising number of people still doubt this.

Another sign of the End Times: Free software guru Richard Stallman speaks at Microsoft HQ

veti Silver badge

Not so surprising. Both Stallman and Microsoft have been mellowing.

Of all the tech giants, currently I regard Microsoft and Apple as the two most likely to be on my side on any given issue. (Because they give me the option of being their customer rather than their product, that's why.) They're no longer the threat they were - if only because they're no longer in a position to be.