* Posts by veti

4498 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

Are we springing into a Y2K-class nightmare?

veti Silver badge

Re: USA change its date format ...

Yeah, I used to think this. But then I discovered that, as recently as the 1970s, "March 16th" was the most common way of saying it in British English too. The whole "16 March" convention didn't really take hold until after computers were embedded in life.

veti Silver badge

Re: Shillings

That's an illusion. "25p" takes (very, very slightly) longer to say than "five bob", but it's easier to comprehend and less subject to error.

Imagine you're in a noisy environment. The "five" will probably get across, because the listener will be on the lookout for numbers, but the "bob" could take them by surprise. They might be expecting "shillings", "florins", "sovs", "pounds", "guineas". Or you could have said "a crown", for even more brevity and confusion.

"25p" removes a whole layer of potential ambiguity and misunderstanding.

veti Silver badge

Re: if programmed correctly, mean that a straightforward update will do the trick

Yeah, there's nothing new here. Countries all over the world have been messing with their DST rules non-stop since - well, since long before Y2K - and people have kept up somehow. Maybe there are a few problems, maybe some people miss meetings or automated emails get sent on the wrong days, whatever, but the world hasn't ended yet.

Unable to write 'Amusing Weekly Column'. Abort, Retry, Fail?

veti Silver badge

Good job making the message work-safe...

If there's one thing my time in development has taught me, it's that there is always a way to trigger the error. Likely you'll never know how, but with tens of thousands of users out there... someone will do it. It's only a matter of time.

Half of bosses out of touch with reality, study shows

veti Silver badge

Re: Too many meetings are now bad?

Email is dead. Killed by spammers and bots. I don't know anyone who can be trusted to read an email that requires more than 30 seconds of attention nowadays, because there are just so many of the bloody things.

veti Silver badge

Re: Easing?

Why do home workers need less management than office workers?

veti Silver badge

Re: Employees hold all the cards, it’s too late…

Apart from all that, we've become aware of how expensive it is, going to an office. Quite apart from travel costs, there's meals and drinks and social events... I would estimate, my last year in an office, I must've spent a couple of thousand dollars over and above what I would have done eating and drinking at home.

Incidentally, has anyone noticed that the loudest voices for return to office work are coming from Subway and Pret?

114 billion transistors, one big meh. Apple's M1 Ultra wake-up call

veti Silver badge

The whole point of improving performance is to shovel in more guff.

To be sure, you could have one without the other. But you'd have to pay through the nose for it. If you're on a budget, your guff will always slightly overfill the available capacity.

veti Silver badge

Re: "Testing more than any country in the world ( per capita per day )"

You're talking about the reported COVID-related deaths. GP was quite explicitly talking about "excess mortality", which is something quite different. It's a way of getting around the subjectivity and variability about how different countries count their "COVID-related" deaths.

See here for a detailed discussion.

I haven't crunched the numbers, I don't know if GP is right. But please, at least argue with the point being made, not with a completely different set of numbers. We're not politicians here.

veti Silver badge

Re: I was there

Okay, that's testing. Now let's discuss tracing.

For every person who tests positive, someone has to phone them up and spend probably a considerable amount of time finding out where they have been and who they've been in contact with, then follow up tracking down those people and telling them to get tested. You could pay a private detective to do work like that for hundreds of pounds per day - per person to be traced.

New Windows 11 build boasts inbox updates and UI tweaks

veti Silver badge

Yeah well, Android did much more the same thing to me. I couldn't understand why I kept getting notifications inviting me to look at the photos I took 3, 4, 5 or more years ago.

Then I realised every Google app, whether or not I had ever opened or used it, was sending me notifications. Great idea Google. I turned them all off, but for how long until Google decides I need to hear from them again?

Ukraine invasion: We should consider internet sanctions, says ICANN ex-CEO

veti Silver badge

Re: A sillly idea that unwittingly justifies the invasion

The war is controversial in Russia - or it would be if people were allowed to discuss it - but there's certainly a fair level of support for it. That's why Putin went to all the trouble of faking a justification for it - he never expected to fool us, but he wasn't worried about us because he knew we wouldn't do much anyway.

veti Silver badge

Re: It's over

The thing is, once ICANN sets the precedent that it has a role in imposing sanctions on naughty people, how exactly does it resist doing it in future?

Myanmar slaughtered the Rohingya and nobody said ICANN should do anything about it. China is "cleansing" Xinjiang and I haven't heard anyone say ICANN should cut them off. India is fostering hatred and suspicion of all non-Hindus, and nobody argues ICANN should be the ones to do anything about that either. In the modern era we've seen generally-agreed genocides in Darfur, Rwanda and Bosnia, and nobody has ever suggested ICANN should have anything to say about any of them.

Why should Ukraine be defined as the Rubicon that finally makes them abandon their apolitical stance and take a side? That looks like a very slippery slope to step onto.

Biden issues Executive Order to tame digital currencies

veti Silver badge

Thank you for your civil and reasonable reply.

To your first point, about value and governance, others have made eloquent and valid replies about the dread of deflation. I would only add that in the past century we've seen a wide variety of misgovernment in just about every country on earth, and only a handful of times has this resulted in runaway inflation. To borrow an old saw, monetary hawks have correctly predicted about 20 of the last 3 hyperinflations. To put it in more abstract terms: the government controlling the money supply is indeed dangerous, but when you realise that the alternative is the money supply controlling the government, it becomes pretty obvious which is the lesser evil. Nobody wants to play Russian roulette with an automatic.

The "convenience" argument - there are two likely scenarios. Either I'm paying money to an overseas business, or I'm sending it privately to a friend or relative because - reasons that are really no business of anyone else. In the first case (far more common in my experience), the whole thing is trivial - credit card networks solved this decades ago. In the second case, the whole thing used to be fairly straightforward, but has been made steadily more complicated over the past 25 years because of efforts to prevent money laundering. That tells me everything I need to know about where this "convenience" argument is coming from.

The third argument is really only relevant to people who want to keep their transactions secret from the government. Now, obviously there are such things as untrustworthy (in this context) governments, but if you have one of those, it's not clear how useful it would be to keep your finances secret from them. Look at Russia today. If you're a distressed oligarch, you're probably quite thankful for your cryptocoins right now. But if you're an opposition politician or just a regular plumber, it's not clear how they'll help you. If Putin wants you out of the way, Bitcoin won't help you.

veti Silver badge

What exactly is the case for cryptocurrency at all, if you can't launder money with it? That's what pretty much all the arguments I've ever seen advanced for it boil down to.

Enterprise IT finds itself in a war zone – with no script

veti Silver badge

Re: We've actually been at war with Russia, China and other nations for many years now

You can't compare US sanctions against Iran, opposed and undercut by pretty much everyone else, with what's just been done to Russia. It's a whole other thing.

I can (and do) still buy Iranian dates in the supermarket. Russian vodka, on the other hand, is gone.

Proprietary neural tech you had surgically implanted? Parts shortage

veti Silver badge

Re: Tak == OK in Polish

Tak == "thank you" in basically every Norse language, which seems just as likely a derivation.

Internet backbone Cogent cuts Russia connectivity

veti Silver badge

Re: Difficult choice to make

It was an independent state uniting multiple southern Slavic peoples, which was exactly what the Black Hand wanted. Fiercely independent - it stood up to the Nazis, the Soviets and Western Europe, alike.

The fact that it may not have been a huge popular success isn't really the point. It was the goal of the assassination. So the assassination itself can be considered a roaring success.

veti Silver badge

Re: The Internet isn’t what it used to be!

Well yes, that's about what I expect will happen. Although other carriers may have policies of their own. I would expect the throttling effect to be quite brutal for the average Russian Internet user.

veti Silver badge

Re: Conspiracies not all wrong?

What restrictions is "the west" putting on free speech? (Hint, there's nothing remotely free about RT - but other people are completely free to repeat their talking points, if anyone can be convinced to take them seriously.)

What restrictions has the west put on protest? It's Russia that's arresting eight-year-old girls for the crime of laying flowers outside the Ukrainian embassy.

To the rest of your rant, these are the same tired talking points anti-vaxxers have been using to prolong the pandemic for the past year. I'm pretty sure you already know the detailed rebuttal of each point you make. If by some amazing chance you're not, it shouldn't take more than about four minutes to find them.

veti Silver badge

Re: Difficult choice to make

Well, yes. The Hapsburg Empire was dissolved, and the Kingdom of Yugoslavia was formed as an independent state - a status it maintained better than anyone else in Europe for the next 70 years. The Black Hand would have been very proud of their handiwork.

BBC points Russians to the Tor version of itself

veti Silver badge

Re: The nuke power station attack was not accidental

I am so sorry. I know Ukrainians are desperate for help, and will spin every story they can to try to draw NATO into the war.

But it's not going to happen. We'll send money, and weapons, we'll take refugees (for now at least), and we won't stop volunteers who want to go - but, ultimately, Ukraine stands alone.

This is the kind of story that builds nations. I pray Ukraine survives to retell it.

Europe's largest nuclear plant on fire after Russian attack

veti Silver badge

Why not? I see no threat. You could maybe make a case for "incitement", but it's pretty mild by the standards of what's batting around the Internet right now.

Over on Reddit, someone dredged up an old (open) letter from Tito to Stalin: "Stop sending people to kill me. [...] If you don't stop sending killers, I'll send one to Moscow, and I won't have to send a second."

veti Silver badge

Re: "illegal, illogical, and inexplicable"

Well, only if you ignore geography.

First, as others have pointed out, EU != NATO.

Second, as a direct result of Putin's actions, there are today more NATO troops on Russia's borders than ever before. Thousands of troops, ships and aircraft from Spain, Denmark, the Netherlands, Britain and America, among other countries, have been deployed to Poland, the (formerly Soviet) Baltic states, and the Baltic Sea.

Third, if Putin succeeds in his declared aim of conquering and annexing Ukraine, that will give him new borders with Poland, Slovakia, Romania and Hungary. That simple geographical fact will at a stroke add around 200,000 more NATO troops sitting directly on his border. That's close to the total number of troops he's deployed in and around Ukraine.

Fourth, after decades of undermining western unity by his successful fostering of neo-fascism in places such as Hungary, Poland, the United States and Britain, he has suddenly and vastly reinforced it. The liberal/democratic order of Western Europe looks happier and more secure now than it has done at any time since the EU enlargement of 2004.

If "keeping NATO troops away from his borders" is the aim, it's harder to imagine - short of actually invading a NATO member - how he could have scored a bigger own-goal than this.

veti Silver badge

Re: Putin provoking NATO

And once again I find myself asking: "why?"

I'm perfectly willing to believe Putin has a secret agenda, but it should make at least some kind of sense.

Ukraine asks ICANN to delete all Russian domains

veti Silver badge

Only because he's telling them to kiss his arse.

veti Silver badge

If you've a nodding acquaintance with the events of WW2, you'll remember that it was an American embargo on oil and metal to Japan that provoked the Japanese to strike Pearl Harbor, staking everything on a very-long-shot war against a much larger power.

Appeasement doesn't work, okay. But sanctions have a much longer history of not working, going back to the Continental System of 1806-1814. More recently they haven't worked against Cuba, Iraq, Iran or Syria. Maybe this time is different, I don't know. But I don't see why.

Microsoft: Russia invasion of Ukraine ‘unlawful, unjustified’

veti Silver badge

Even in Stalin's day, Zhukov trumped Beria. It's not an easy thing to do, to police the army.

The last time the Soviet army attempted a coup was in 1991, but it was closely involved in politics again in 1993 (when it stormed the offices of the Supreme Soviet), and I doubt it's completely forgotten about that.

veti Silver badge

Re: Customers?

Yes, and when the mercs are filmed shelling hospitals and burning orphanages - as pretty much always happens sooner or later - what then?

Let people defend Ukraine for the love of their country and their people, not just for money.

veti Silver badge

What exactly would "going nuclear" gain him?

No, Putin made a number of gambles that looked to him like good bets, and they mostly turned bad. That happens to the best of us from time to time, but we usually have more sense than to wager our entire country on them.

I've no doubt that Putin will eventually identify some silver lining, and then he'll pretend that was all he really cared about all along. That's how unprincipled opportunists, like both him and his friend Trump, maintain their reputation for smarts. But so far he's managed to achieve everything he least wanted - including, worst of all, making his own army look incompetent. That's one of the few things that could cost him his job, and quite possibly his life, in a matter of days. Generals tend to have limited tolerance for that particular brand of blunder.

veti Silver badge

I'm no expert, but something tells me the quartermasters of the Russian army aren't using any version of Windows that can be so simply killed.

The Russians are many things, and yes they are quite often stupid (this whole war, for instance, is an act of almost unbelievable foot-shooting idiocy on Putin's part - joke's on me, all this time I thought he was clever), but if there's one thing they do know it's security.

A tale of two dishwashers: Buy one, buy it again, and again

veti Silver badge

Re: Adverts

That's what private browsing is for.

Well, I mean, that's the official reason for private mode in browsers. Of course it's not the most commonly used reason, but we can't talk about that.

Clearview AI plans tech to ID faces as they age, seek big government deals

veti Silver badge

What about the control group?

Did the ones who got no help do better or worse than the other two groups? And by how much?

Cyberwarfare looms as Russia shells, invades Ukraine

veti Silver badge

Re: Russia may not win this cyber war

Putin and his cronies have billions of dollars' worth of assets held in Western countries. UK, EU, USA...

Those governments should make it their priority to identify all that money, and simply trouser it. No "freezing", just grab the lot. It'd be a welcome cash boost for them, and it would hit Putin's henchmen where it hurts - force them to fall back on assets within Russia, thereby making them share in the economic pain of the country.

AI really can't copyright the art it generates – US officials

veti Silver badge

If his purpose was to register the copyright, that would be true. But it's clear that's not his actual goal. What he wants is for his AI to be acknowledged as creative; this application was a possible way to bolster that claim.

As for the Turing test, bots pass that every day and no one bats an eye. We need a better test.

veti Silver badge

Re: Couldn't Pay Off Congress Critters

And even then, you can only get incremental changes. And even those are hard fought.

veti Silver badge

Re: Waddaya mean ...

If it comes to that, humans don't create art unless they've been appropriately educated. I think I'm right in saying that every human work of art was produced by someone raised and educated by other humans. So what exactly is the difference?

It's strange to me that people who insist "machines can't do magic" can, in almost the same breath, argue that some vaguely defined thing that might be called "creativity" can only be produced by magic.

veti Silver badge

Re: Couldn't Pay Off Congress Critters

That is extremely expensive, and also very uncertain. Even if legislation made it into the house, it would then be open to lobbying by every other bugger who's interested. And even if it survived that, there's still an excellent chance it will be torpedoed by some grandstanding wanker purely because they hate the people supporting it.

Not a good investment, unless you're already a billionaire - and even then you have to pick your subjects carefully.

veti Silver badge

Re: Who gets paid?

The trouble is that if the AI is treated as human, then he can't own it. That would be slavery. So where exactly would the money go to? Can the AI spend it?

veti Silver badge

Re: Waddaya mean ...

A human may program the machine without initiating the art. That's not magic.

However, the idea that the public interest is served, or the constitution honoured, by granting copyright ownership to a piece of software... is an argument that I for one don't see.

Should we expect to keep communication private in the digital age?

veti Silver badge

Re: A fundamental issue with 'human rights'

You could move to a more open minded country. Here in New Zealand, I've been voting for as long as I've been a resident, regardless of citizenship.

I've been paying taxes even longer than that. And getting all the social benefits that they pay for.

The trouble with "not voting" is that it doesn't send any coherent signal at all. Is there value in knowing how many chose not to vote? What for? - I mean, what exactly do you propose to do with that information? And how do you distinguish between "didn't vote because hated all parties or candidates", "didn't understand issues", "didn't care", "didn't get the chance because of work or life", or simply "didn't know how"?

Russia 'stole US defense data' from IT systems

veti Silver badge

Re: Skid mark

There is no "backdoor" of the cloud mentioned in this story. It's straightforward spear phishing, which the cloud makes slightly easier but the principle works exactly the same for privately held servers.

As for the rest of your rant, I can't decide if you're actually that deluded, or if you're flying a false flag to make libs look even crazier than they make themselves look. Since you posted anon it's hard to tell. So, good job I guess.

Reality check: We should not expect our communications to remain private

veti Silver badge

Re: Do not have a poll with a negative in it

By adding the words "be able", you completely change the meaning of the question. Your version is framed as a mirror image of the question, but it's nothing of the sort.

"Should expect" is an inference based on observed facts. If we "should expect" something, that suggests "the observed facts and known laws point to this conclusion, it is too early to be certain but there is a strong likelihood that this is the case."

"Should be able" is quite different - it's a moral statement. The argument even says this much - yes, we absolutely should be able to expect privacy. But whether we should expect it is a very different question.

For what it's worth, my father told me back in the 1970s always to assume that phone calls and letters were not really secure, they could be spied on in many ways. Some of those ways don't even require much in the way of special resources or tools. I've made that assumption from childhood, and the Internet has done nothing to dispel it.

'Boombox' function sparks Tesla recall

veti Silver badge

Re: not really a recall?

Presumably the software is different not only for every model and year, but also for every possible combination of build options, as well as any later customisation. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that no two cars in any given city had exactly the same software.

So not much point trying to store the update locally, and most of the time to make the update is spent on diagnostics to determine which of the 14,223 images your particular car needs.

This malware gang plants incriminating evidence on PCs, gets victims arrested

veti Silver badge

Re: Shocking but unsurprising

That's bad, but it's a different thing. I remember several outbreaks of CP hysteria, and sometimes it seems like the press's bloodlust needs to be sated. I can see weak police chiefs yielding to that pressure in the sort of way you describe.

But it's not the same as concerted attacks on the regime's political opponents. The main difference being, political opponents have a network of friends and supporters. After two or three incidents to members of the same network, the remainder would start getting a bit curious.

veti Silver badge

Shocking but unsurprising

Modi is an evil thug. We knew this.

I like to think that in countries with a freer media, such tactics wouldn't fly - they'd be exposed in fairly short order, and honest judges would not only throw out the evidence but also instigate an inquiry into where it came from. But somehow I'm less sure about that now than I would have been six years ago.

UK, US, Australia issue joint advisory: Ransomware on the loose, critical national infrastructure affected

veti Silver badge

Re: Obviously

In the sense that it would stop most people from using computers at all, sure.

Microsoft to block downloaded VBA macros in Office – you may be able to run 'em anyway

veti Silver badge

Re: Ribbon - just say no

Menu technology was perfected circa 1990, and has only gone downhill since then. But one of the bad things that happened to it, in the late 90s, was when Microsoft made menus editable.

Stupid, stupid idea. It meant users accidentally deleting menu items (including, potentially, the very one they needed to undo the damage). And for expert users who knew about the feature and used it correctly, it meant they could no longer transfer their skills to anyone else's PC.

Reversing that cock-up was perhaps the only redeeming feature of the ribbon.

veti Silver badge

Re: A tighter security method.

Everyone agrees that 90% of the features in any advanced application are never used. We all know this.

But the catch is, when you actually burrow into the question, you find that no two people agree precisely which 90% of features they don't need. What looks like useless screen clutter to you, is a small but vital element of someone else's workflow.

That's why all applications acquire cruft over time.

This is going well: Meta adds anti-grope buffer zone around metaverse VR avatars

veti Silver badge

Re: It's as if Second Life never happened

How is that different from any other instruction manual, then?