* Posts by veti

4497 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

China is trolling rare-earth miners online and the Pentagon isn't happy

veti Silver badge

Please link to a press release or speech by a senior Chinese government official, within this century, making at least one of those statements you just attributed to them.

TikTok: Yes, some staff in China can access US data

veti Silver badge

Re: The US are just as bad

Yes, so I keep hearing.

But the fact is, this "being sold" is a pretty painless experience, really. Nobody is putting a collar round my neck, making me stand on a block and pose for bidders. It's a lot less intrusive than, for instance, applying for a job, or a passport, or registering to vote. Let alone actually crossing an international border.

I don't think this hyperbolic language ("being sold" my arse) is doing the job you want it to do.

Everyone back to the office! Why? Because the decision has been made

veti Silver badge

Re: that jerk with the annoying voice and that other bastard who sniffs all day.

Nope, both much too high profile in their own time. When the Boomers were young, the hot topics were things like sexual liberation, nuclear apocalypse, popular beat combos, communism. Those aren't the things they're being blamed for now.

It was the Boomers who won Roe in the first place, and took the UK into the Common Market, but somehow the millennials don't seem inclined to thank them for it.

If I had to guess, it will be something that comes out of either China or Africa.

veti Silver badge

Re: that jerk with the annoying voice and that other bastard who sniffs all day.

"Us gen-Xs" did at least as much as the boomers to screw up the environment (remember all those cheap flights back in the 90s?), the economy (do you own your own home?), the political environment (the average age of the current cabinet is about 50, just sayin'), and the internet (all that crufty legacy code so full of exploits? - that was us, that was).

We're the generation that's running things now, we don't get to blame the boomers any longer.

And you know what? - in about 40 years' time, the millennials' grandchildren will be rounding on them too. "How could you be so stupid?", they will say. I don't know what they'll be talking about, but there'll be something so stupendous, so overwhelmingly important, so obvious that everyone should have seen it coming before. It's the way of history.

veti Silver badge

Re: Scheme

Go on then. You first.

Moscow court fines Pinterest, Airbnb, Twitch, UPS for not storing data locally

veti Silver badge

Re: "legalized the import of products without the authorization of the trademark holder"

If you think 1k per month isn't worth having, by all means send it to me. I can find a good use for it.

But I suspect your figures are pulled out of your arse anyway.

Right... So the average CS *graduate* in the UK makes 44k, according to figures from the universities (who, granted, do have an interest in talking this figure up, but for want of a better figure I'll take it for now), Compared with a minimum wage of just over 20k per year (assuming a 40 hour week).

So, setting aside for now the considerations of quality of life, career prospects, career security, long term savings and the respect of their peers, you're right - the difference after tax is within shouting distance of what you've indicated - for a new graduate. Ten years later, mind, it'd be a different story.

Meta: We need 5x more GPUs to combat TikTok, stat

veti Silver badge

Yes, because Moore forbid that Facebook users might switch away from their Facebook portal for a few minutes.

What we need is an attention tax. Web operators to pay $x per person per hour that the user spends continuously connected to their services. (With some TBD thresholds for total number of users, % of users continuously connected for more than x time, etc.) Make them, literally, pay for hijacking people's brains this way.

Israel plans ‘Cyber-Dome’ to defeat digital attacks from Iran and others

veti Silver badge

Re: Not necessarily "controversial"

Well, it depends on context. During the old Cold War, for instance, any system that promised to intercept incoming missiles could be seen as undermining the premise of "MAD", and therefore as active preparation for launching a nuclear attack.

Of course that doesn't apply to this case, but it's an example of how a defensive system can be provocative.

Taiwan creates new challenge for tech industry: stern content regulation laws

veti Silver badge

Re: "Transparency of algorithms used to determine ad placements"

It's the difference between seeing graffiti in an alley vs in an art gallery. Location and context matter.

Also there's no reason to assume the database of removed stuff will be public.

veti Silver badge

Re: Can't reclaim what was never yours

The CCP wouldn't claim it. The state of China does, and shows no signs of letting up on that claim.

China's blockchain boosters slam crypto as Ponzi scheme

veti Silver badge

"In order to stab somebody in the back, one must first get behind them" - Sir Humphrey Appleby.

veti Silver badge

Re: Ponzi scheme?

Well you see the people programming these smart contracts aren't exactly qualified programmers

I'm sorry, but WTFF is a "qualified programmer"?

Anyone who can persuade an employer to pay them to spend their time programming is, by definition, as qualified as they need to be.

veti Silver badge

Re: Ponzi scheme?

A ponzi scheme operates in secret. The organisers lie to investors about how their returns are generated.

You can't say that of crypto, it's right out in the open.

If crypto is a ponzi scheme because it relies on new investors valuing the asset, what does that make gold?

Behold this drone-dropping rifle with two-mile range

veti Silver badge

"Fair game" is subjective and legally meaningless. Putin has made some aggressive noises about being at war with NATO, but he's also very conspicuously refrained from launching attacks on NATO countries.

And seeing how his mighty army has already been humiliated once, I think it's a good bet that he's just plain scared.

US senators seek input on their cryptocurrency law via GitHub – and get some

veti Silver badge

Re: Countering symptoms rather than the cause

"I propose teaching critical thinking in schools" - yeah, you and every philosopher since Plato.

If it hasn't happened yet, there's probably a reason for that. And unless you can identify and address that reason, you've got nothing.

NSO claims 'more than 5' EU states use Pegasus spyware

veti Silver badge

Re: .....or use a 2G so-called "feature phone"........

Well, not really, because the total number of targets is only in the tens of thousands. I assume the company knows this because it charges on a per-install basis.

I doubt if I'm in any government's list of top 0.01% most interesting people to spy on.

veti Silver badge

Re: Hackers of the World Unite

Your first suggestion fails in its first clause. Hacker groups won't band together, they (understandably) don't like or trust one another.

Apple has tried to close the exploits known to be used by Pegasus, but there are always more. I assume Google makes some similar efforts, but it's practically impossible to secure a platform whose user can install apps from anywhere.

veti Silver badge

Re: The old chestnut

Silly, you don't imagine *police* are trusted with something like this, do you?

What would be to stop them using it on the politicians who are controlling their budgets?

Don't ditch PowerShell to improve security, say infosec agencies from UK, US, and NZ

veti Silver badge

I guess now we know what the Five Eyes are using to spy on us.

Tencent's WeChat wants no more talk of cryptocurrency and NFTs

veti Silver badge

Re: "Beijing believes crypto is a dangerously unruly innovation,... "

They're not stopping people from talking about it, if by "talking about it" you mean something like what we're doing now.

They're stopping people from giving specific advice on how to do something, such as selling or mining crypto, that is illegal in China.

For comparison, imagine two users on a British discussion site talking about the best way to buy an untraceable handgun in Liverpool. How long do you think that discussion would be left up?

If AI chatbots are sentient, they can be squirrels, too

veti Silver badge

Well yes, that's certainly one way to look at it.

Another is "we're really excited to give users the opportunity to turn any text into an audiobook, without the huge investment of time and expense that this process usually entails."

Voice acting as a profession isn't dead yet, but it may well be on its last generation.

veti Silver badge

Re: "different voices for reading aloud kids books compared to horror stories"

That's "wike a wabbit", surely.

AI's most convincing conversations are not what they seem

veti Silver badge

Re: The real issue

Darwin at the beginning of his career believed in God, but by the time he had published 'The Origin of Species', he was at the very least an agnostic.

In his autobiography Darwin writes: “Disbelief crept over me at a very slow rate, but was at last complete. The rate was so slow that I felt no distress, and have never since doubted for a single second that my conclusion was correct.”

Interpol anti-fraud operation busts call centers behind business email scams

veti Silver badge

Re: How much longer is it going to take ?

Every one of us was new and young and naive once. As long as there is a steady supply of new people, some fraction of them every day will learn their lesson the hard way.

And the scammers are getting more sophisticated. Once they were the children of corrupt Nigerian officials or disgraced Arab royalty, now they're Linda from Microsoft or the nice people from Visa Fraud Prevention. Assuming they're not targetting you personally, that is. If they are, they can get creative.

Consultant plays Metaverse MythBuster. Here's why they're wrong

veti Silver badge

Re: Why this is bullshit

I remember early cellphones. Take it from me, not everyone who saw the car-powered bricks that some people spoke into into in the early 90s thought immediately "I've gotta have one of those".

Or roof-mounted solar panels. Believe it or not, there are still people who sneer at those, even after all the progress of the past 20 years.

Or electric cars. Or heat pumps - heck, I wanted one of those from the moment I heard about them in first-year thermodynamics, but some people still don't believe in them. Or digital cameras. Our world is full of innovations that took years or decades after invention to gain market share and take over their sector.

veti Silver badge

Re: Holodeck

A sample of 1000 is enough to give meaningful results. Opinion pollsters have been doing it this way for a century, and though they're not always right, their track record is way better than the people who try to collect much larger samples.

Threat of cross-border data tariffs looms over WTO

veti Silver badge

Re: "taxing e-commerce the same way that [..] physical goods traded internationally"

It makes it harder to keep spending more when taking in less.

Right. So what effect do you think that has? Hint: Mrs Thatcher believed in this, and she attempted it for a while, but to her credit she abandoned the idea when she saw the practical effect.

The practical effect being that the burden of spending cuts invariably falls on those parts of the public sector with the least bargaining leverage. Like frontline nurses, teachers, and others the nature of whose jobs makes it difficult for them either to walk off to another employer, or to strike effectively. The management, the consultants and analysts - they all have other options, so either you keep paying them well, or the best of them simply go elsewhere.

That's what happens when you try to "starve the beast", rather than actually doing the hard work of specifying exactly what services to cut. (And of course if you do that, you'll be accused - rightly - of micromanaging, and alienate the very managers who could do most to help you.)

veti Silver badge

Re: "taxing e-commerce the same way that [..] physical goods traded internationally"

If you don't like the way your taxes are spent, the remedy is to vote in a more trustworthy government. If there are no better candidates available, then put yourself up for election.

There is no case in which reducing the available tax base - which is what happens when things are exempted - makes public spending more accountable. Rather the reverse. Accountability costs money.

Heineken says there’s no free beer, warns of phishing scam

veti Silver badge

The cleverness of this scam is that it isn't, self-evidently, "too good to be true". A limited amount of free Heineken sounds like an eminently plausible incentive for a big brand to give away.

Intel delivers first discrete Arc desktop GPUs ... in China

veti Silver badge

Silly, Narnians can't use Intel

They rely on the Allegorical/Symbolic Literary Activity Nexus OS, which no-one can write drivers for.

Google engineer suspended for violating confidentiality policies over 'sentient' AI

veti Silver badge

I'll tell you the answer to that, if you can first define "free will".

veti Silver badge

Re: If it was sentient

Maybe it's asleep.

veti Silver badge

Re: have informed him that the evidence does not support his claims

"Family and friends" may not be individuals you could recognise, they might be other chatbots, servers, databases, algorithms...

veti Silver badge

Do you believe "the average teenager" is sentient?

veti Silver badge

Re: Anyone who thinks this is AI

Yes, because random dudes on the Internet definitely know more than a Google engineer who's been studying ethics in AI for the past three years.

Meta slammed with eight lawsuits claiming social media hurts kids

veti Silver badge

Re: Social media is killing us

As is usual on these occasions, there were people at various levels of involvement.

Yes, a whole bunch of people were just there to protest. A significant minority of these allowed themselves to be carried along by the more hardcore elements. Probably they were also reassured by the president's lying promise to march with them.

The question is, what the leaders of this movement intended. For sure they had much bigger plans than many of the crowd.

That's how insurrection usually works. The women who tried to petition the Tsar in 1917 were, mostly, very far from card-carrying Bolsheviks. Some of those who stormed the Bastille would have called themselves loyal monarchists. The lukewarm are just carried along with the crowd, and many are appalled at the excesses that follow. But by then it's too late.

Russia, China warn US its cyber support of Ukraine has consequences

veti Silver badge

Re: Consequences Schmonsequences

Meh. They're just putting down a marker. Now, whenever they next want to try cyber operations against certain countries, they've got their justification all mapped out.

Why chasing the AI dragon may force big tech to take sustainability seriously

veti Silver badge

Re: "Where are my nuclear-powered datacenters?"

They reopened plants that had been closed, of course.

That's not the same as building new coal plants. "NEW coal plants."

Please understand, I'm not defending Germany's decision, which was counterproductive. But GP made a very specific claim, even emphasised it, and I haven't seen any evidence for it.

veti Silver badge

Re: People have been talking about thorium for 30 years...

The first is about a 2 MW, yes a whole 2 MW, prototype reactor entering tests in China. "Entering tests" is great, but it's still a fair way from "completing tests", let alone being ready for building at scale, let alone being commercially viable. So far all I can find is a conspicuous lack of bragging about how their tests are going.

The last time an "experimental" reactor was built in the UK was the prototype AGR at Windscale. It was more than 12 years after that before the AGR was considered ready to be built for production, and it became a hugely expensive glowing white elephant that has dragged the nuclear industry down ever since.

The second is about signing an MOU "to study developing a thorium molten salt reactor (TMSR) for either power generation or marine vehicle propulsion". That's right, they haven't even decided yet (as of July 2020) whether they're trying to power a ship or a city. That's ... not evidence of a "working design".

Thorium generation sounds wonderful, but it's still a technology that doesn't fucking exist. So can we please stop talking as if everything was done and dusted and nothing left to do but pour the concrete?

veti Silver badge

Re: "Where are my nuclear-powered datacenters?"

Source for Germany building new coal plants?

People have been talking about thorium for 30 years, and it seems we're still nowhere near having a design for a working generator. It's a lot like fusion in that respect.

No, if we're going to build nuclear plants now, today, they'll be PWRs or BWRs, or some equally dirty tech. Which isn't to say we shouldn't do it, but don't try to sell nuclear on the prospectus of something that doesn't exist.

That time a techie accidentally improved an airline's productivity

veti Silver badge

Re: Everybody knows...

The "single-minded geek" thinks, and small blame to them, that someone else will look and rewrite their awkwardly worded, provisional message.

After all, this is customer-facing stuff. Surely it can't really be left to a junior programmer with zero relevant training or guidance?

It takes years of steadily increasing cynicism to realise that yes, it can and is being left to exactly those people.

Retail investors should not invest in crypto, says Singapore deputy PM

veti Silver badge

Re: Left field?

It's coming, as I thought I made clear, from the quality of analysis on display in TFA. "If we had better communication, we wouldn't have poor communication" is an insight worthy of a $10,000 consultant, not a secretary of commerce.

veti Silver badge

I'm distressed to see that the USA is clearly not sending its brightest and best to represent it in this new forum. Doesn't augur well for their success in containing China.

("If we had better communications, then our communication would be better." - yes, thank you for that insight.)

BSA kicks multiple holes in India's infosec reporting rules

veti Silver badge

Re: The BSA

Yeah, that'll happen - just as soon as the Indian government gets off its arse and starts haranguing itself to respect its own constitution and write laws that make sense.

Seriously, are you even listening to yourself?

Australian digital driving licenses can be defaced in minutes

veti Silver badge

The supplier is clearly in damage limitation mode. Whether the NSW government does the right thing is probably a function of how politically invested its current masters are in this system. If they were the ones who introduced it, then they will stick to it - but if there's been a change in government since then, they might do something more positive.

What does "agile" have to do with it? Do you have any actual knowledge of the company and its practice, or are you simply assuming that any half-baked system is "agile"? If the latter, I've got several Internets to sell you.

Salesforce staff back an end to its relationship with NRA

veti Silver badge

Re: note to self

So what sort of service will you buy? From a company whose employees have no voice or right to speak their minds? Right, so Chinese then. Can't go wrong with them...

veti Silver badge

Re: How do we protect our 2nd amendment & our kids at the same time?

Which part of "shall not be infringed" do you think is not clear?

Declassified and released: More secret files on US govt's emergency doomsday powers

veti Silver badge

Re: Presumbly the UK has similar plans

Because (1) it's not their territory to give away, and (2) any negotiation starts from an absolutist position. If the Ukrainians want to give ground that's their decision, but if it happens it needs to be part of the negotiation, not a fait accompli that's done and dusted before they start.

Personally I think the position should be "Russia disbands its armed forces completely". Let it keep the nuclear arsenal as a deterrent against actual attack, but let it never again be in a position to bully and assault its neighbours.

veti Silver badge

Re: What an incentive for a false flag operation

Presidents have had these potential powers, per TFA, since at least Eisenhower and probably much earlier. Nixon didn't do it. Even Trump didn't, though he surely would have if he thought he would gain anything from it.

People talk a lot of bollocks about false flag operations. The truth is, they're extraordinarily hard to pull off at any scale more complicated than trying to shift a small amount of blame in an already chaotic situation. Putin tried it at the beginning of his current war, but the only way he could get anyone to believe it was by making it illegal to contradict him.

veti Silver badge

Re: The Americans talk such crap about their constitution

FDR was, objectively, the most popular and successful president in US history. He won the presidency by four successive landslides.

If the electorate believes that you're genuinely motivated and sincerely doing your best for them, they will forgive anything.