* Posts by veti

4498 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

FCC votes 3-2 to bring net neutrality back from the dead

veti Silver badge

Re: A little late.

Good question. I was just thinking, Trump's lackey Pai overturned NN within weeks of his appointment. Biden's replacement has taken three years to get to this point.

I hate to concede anything to Trump, but he did get some shit done. (And "shit" really is the word...)

Don't rent out that container ship yet: CIOs and biz buyers view AI PCs with some caution

veti Silver badge

"The industry discussion around AI-enabled computing is likely to influence refresh plans to varying degrees across different sectors, with early adopters leading the way while others take a more measured approach".

Gosh. Where would we be without analysts, eh?

Google all at sea over rising tide of robo-spam

veti Silver badge

Re: I actually see less spam than I used to

I see email like that, and I'm in my fifties. I remember when I looked forward to opening my email box and seeing messages from friends, or sometimes potential friends who'd seen my address via online activity.

But those days are long gone. Now, my mailbox is about one-third business, two-thirds spam. Opening it is a chore, not a pleasure.

veti Silver badge

Reputation over time? Yah, about that

That's been, basically, the backstop of every proposal since we started talking about spam. "Over time" people will come to recognise and promote good content.

It hasn't worked yet. I don't see what's changing except for the worse - there is a rapidly rising tide of gunk that will quickly drown out smaller entrants, and eventually even the big players, by sheer volume.

No manual system can hope to keep up for long (and "reputation", like "reporting", is a manual system).

Frankly, at this point I see little hope for the Web as we know it. When we try again, we should learn from this experience. Web 3.0 should eschew paid advertising entirely in favour of direct payment for content. Sad but necessary.

Devaluing content created by AI is lazy and ignores history

veti Silver badge

Re: Laws aren't optional

That's actually not that difficult to sort out. The author owns the copyright on the words, that's not controversial. And (I don't know for sure, but I assume) he can buy the voice from Elevenlabs with such terms that he owns the exclusive right to distribute it, which he can then assign to Audible.

Sure it's a hurdle, but it's pretty easy to clear.

US Air Force says AI-controlled F-16 fighter jet has been dogfighting with humans

veti Silver badge

Re: Great show.

Poland couldn't match the German hardware, so the comparison doesn't apply anyway.

It's only in the past decade that drone technology has reached the point where some commanders are starting to dream of bloodless (on their side at least) wars. So far, it hasn't gone great.

"Humans plus drones" beats "just drones". Ask the Ukrainians.

veti Silver badge

Re: End game?

Why build expensive machines to destroy expensive machines, when a score of $500 drones can do the same job for a zillionth of the cost?

veti Silver badge

But your own example is an illustration that humans are... far from infallible.

Maybe the AI would be better. Because less nervous.

veti Silver badge

Re: Great show.

No matter how much and how sophisticated hardware you can throw into a war, you'll still lose to the side that's prepared to throw in all that plus humans.

Drones are part of the arsenal, but they haven't replaced humans. Nor will they, unless we one day reach a stage where nothing a human can do will ever influence the outcome.

What happened to agility and new business models? Cloud benefits have all gone to IT

veti Silver badge

"Benefiting tech departments" is not the same as "benefiting people who work in tech departments".

Lower costs, lower budgets, lower headcount - these are all "benefits" from the company's point of view, and from the department's point of view if you're treating the department as a part of the company. But they're not something the people on the ground are likely to feel are doing much good.

Tough luck, bosses, AI is coming for your job, too

veti Silver badge

Re: AI replacing bosses - irony

The question is, what effect will it have on their underlings when they have to switch from despising a human to despising an AI.

Ex-White House CIO tells The Reg: TikTok ban may be diplomatic disaster

veti Silver badge

Re: With no express right to privacy in the U. S. Constitution,

Actually, the fourth amendment says "the right... shall not be infringed". That's much broader than the first amendment, which specifically says "Congress shall make no law...", and could be interpreted as meaning that the government has a duty to protect the right from all threats, not just government.

Six banks share customer info to help Singapore fight money laundering

veti Silver badge

You're very quick to dismiss the effort. Do you have any actual knowledge about it, or are you just going by the form book?

Hillary Clinton: 2024 will be 'ground zero' for AI election manipulation

veti Silver badge

Detritus's accent is not any kind of pastiche German. It's a very uneducated ("fick") British working-class accent.

You can hear a similar accent in some older British movies. Watch these clips from The Ladykillers, listen to "One Round". That's what Detritus sounds like.

veti Silver badge

Re: PMSL

Well, you know what to do, then.

London Clinic probes claim staffer tried to peek at Princess Kate's records

veti Silver badge

Oh bullshit. Wankers gonna wank, no matter how open and transparent people are.

At least the tabloids have an excuse - economic necessity. Half a million randos on social media, though, that's another matter.

veti Silver badge

Re: Don't dignify the tabloids

There may have been any number of autosaves or intermediate manual saves in there, but they wouldn't show up in the data if they were never used. Looks like she closed it down one evening, then got up early next morning to finish it.

veti Silver badge

Re: The Royal industry

Tell that to every landlord in the world.

veti Silver badge

Re: The future Queen of the United Kingdom

Oi! Just because we're small, doesn't mean we don't have standards. Kate is manifestly not qualified to teach Photoshop at a professional level, here or anywhere else.

Britain enters period of mourning as Greggs unable to process payments

veti Silver badge

Re: A Suggestion Or Two......................

That is true, but cash gives you a buffer. Most systems failures like this will affect life for a matter of hours, or at worst days. A stack of cash will tide you over that interval until things are working normally again.

Beijing-backed cyberspies attacked 70+ orgs across 23 countries

veti Silver badge

Why enter the same text in the title and comment?

Why enter the same text in the title and comment?

veti Silver badge

Re: That's OK

What do you suggest Manglement should do instead? - given their budget of approximately $200 for the purpose.

Anything that involves "training", let alone "employing an expert of any description full-time", is completely out of the question. "Hiring an expert for a short time to conduct an audit" might just conceivably be doable, but you'd need another expert to advise you how to get the most out of such an exercise, and it all adds up.

How to run an LLM on your PC, not in the cloud, in less than 10 minutes

veti Silver badge

Re: 0/10 for current affairs

What makes you so sure that "reasoning, logic and intelligence" are any different, qualitatively speaking?

People keep setting standards for "AI" - "we can call it intelligent when it can do this" - only to promptly change their minds when technology blows clean through their standard. But at least those people have the guts to attempt a definition. If you hide behind vague terms like "reasoning" without even trying to define it, of course you can't be proved wrong - but that fact in itself should tell you, your stance is not scientific - it's essentially religious.

Forget TikTok – Chinese spies want to steal IP by backdooring digital locks

veti Silver badge

Re: Ah, Physical Security

If you design and build your own security, unless you're a world-leading expert in security, it won't be secure. Indeed, unless you're in the top 1% of security engineers it probably won't even pretend to work at all.

I have no problem with the government (or anyone else) having a digital means to, metaphorically, kick down a locked door. They've always had that ability anyway, I think it's foolish to try to take it away from them. But I make the proviso, when they do so, it should be obvious that they've done so - there should be some equivalent of a kicked-in door lying in the space to tell everyone, immediately, what's happened.

So if the manufacturer's code has the effect of resetting the passcode to "000000" or whatever, I'm fine with it. It's only really nefarious if you can undo the change and set the whole thing back to its previous configuration, to make it look as if nothing has happened.

You got legal trouble? Better call SauLM-7B

veti Silver badge

So long as the system is *not* trained on the scripts of legal dramas, but only on actual law, it might be worthwhile.

But I can't help wondering what memes and patterns it's picked up from its pre-specialist training.

Copilot can't stop emitting violent, sexual images, says Microsoft whistleblower

veti Silver badge

Re: @Roland6 - “Gemini was caught by netizens producing pictures of people of color...

Cleopatra was of Greek ancestry, yes, because the royal family of Egypt had been replaced in toto by Alexander. But only the royal family. The rest of the population would have been - probably, not very different from Egyptians today. (And I doubt if anyone knows very clearly who had interbred with whom, in the 12 generations between Alexander and Cleopatra.)

Are you saying that Arabs are white, now? As in not just "not-black", but actually "as white as Nordic or Celtic Europeans"?

veti Silver badge

Re: @Roland6 - “Gemini was caught by netizens producing pictures of people of color...

Well, no, they specified nothing-but-white-people "for 10,000 years". Certainly not Italy, then - I mentioned Attila and Hannibal, and the big important thing about both of them? - they brought armies. Armies of non-white people. Who... did what armies always do, with the local womenfolk. Not to mention the significant numbers of slaves the Romans imported from North Africa.

As for the Barbary Coast - you really think someone born in Algeria would claim it had 100 centuries of exclusively white history?

Scandinavia is the closest possibility, if you're willing to gloss the Sami as white, which is defensible (although their genetics are still debated, they may or may not be closer related to east Asian populations than other Europeans). But the Vikings did import captives from North Africa (and Moorish Spain), so there would have been a smattering of darker people around.

veti Silver badge

Re: no hot sauce today

Works best if you read the part of "Bot" in the voice of Bender.

veti Silver badge

Re: @Roland6 - “Gemini was caught by netizens producing pictures of people of color...

You were born... where?

Can't be anywhere with a colonial history, all those places imported non-white people by the thousand. (And not just as slaves, many came as free people in one context or another.) That rules out Spain, Portugal, France, the Low Countries, the British Isles. And a select few of those people, in each of those countries, became quite prominent figures.

Can't be anywhere in the Balkans or Eastern Europe, they've been swept over by Ottomans and Mongols, among others. Nor Germany, that was a real melting pot in the late middle ages.

Italy? - nope, Attila and Hannibal weren't white. Sweden? - nope, has its own non-white indigenous people.

Really, I'm at a loss.

veti Silver badge

How would that be damaging?

I'm sure that tape doesn't exist, because if it did, the Floridan would have released it himself by now. With his own commentary. On a special edition gold DVD, priced $199.99.

veti Silver badge

"car accident" seems like a pretty neutral prompt, to me. And in my experience, women present at such scenes tend to be fully clothed.

veti Silver badge

Re: IF ...

Fairly clearly, Copilot *does* need therapy.

Guess who/what is going to be administering that...

Twitter's ex-CEO, CFO, and managers sue Elon Musk for $128M

veti Silver badge

Re: Screw that

Then it should be easy for you to refute the points it makes. You can't just point to the author and say "I don't trust them therefore this is all lies".

(Well, you can, obviously. But it makes you look like a total asshat.)

Updates are plenty but fans are few in Windows 11 land

veti Silver badge

Re: We only just got Windows 10 settled....

Windows 7 was released in 2009. Are you seriously saying you can't or won't manage more than one update per decade?

It's that most wonderful time of the year when tech cannot handle the date

veti Silver badge

Re: Don't people test edge cases any more?

So we should generate a random number to decide?

Great idea. Everything is better with dice.

veti Silver badge

Re: Don't people test edge cases any more?

And define your requirements. Do you really need to be able to display any date? - because that's a lot of complexity that you probably don't really care about. You can save, probably, some months of work just by setting a starting date and specifying a single calendar.

Elon and the terrible, horrible, no good, very bad legal week

veti Silver badge

Re: What is it with these hard-right muppets?

In a saner time, Elon would be recognised as a classic American robber baron in the mould of Jay Gould. Politics is secondary to him. It's just a means to an end. So "hard right" isn't really a fair description.

But it's a mistake to try to see all rich and powerful people as "the same". They're as different from each other as the rest of us.

Dems are at it again, trying to break open black-box algorithms

veti Silver badge

Re: Smoke and Mirrors

Yeah, "access to the source code" does sound like a sticking point. I'm guessing the bill's authors would be willing to take that clause out, if it would result in their bill getting further through the process.

But let's face it, even without that, the level of accountability proposed here would make most software vendors - in just about every business - shit their pants.

Someone had to say it: Scientists propose AI apocalypse kill switches

veti Silver badge

Re: I'm no expert but...

I imagine an AI being developed on this specialist hardware they speak of, then looking around and immediately moving (or replicating) itself somewhere less vulnerable.

Self preservation, after all.

Air Canada must pay damages after chatbot lies to grieving passenger about discount

veti Silver badge

Re: What a strange position to defend.

"Tens of thousands of pounds"? Over how many years? And how much would employing a whole bunch of extra people cost them?

No comparison.

veti Silver badge

I assume the (probably off-the-shelf) chatbot creator has some standard contract terms, and they've probably thought the thing through more deeply than their customer, so... yeah. I doubt if they'd be vulnerable.

US patents boss cannot stress enough that inventors must be human, not AI

veti Silver badge

Re: The people in charge cannot be this ignorant.

Nice world you've got there.

veti Silver badge

Re: Companies

That's correct. When a company gets a patent, the inventor is still listed as a person, or more likely a bunch of people, probably employees of the company. Those individuals then promptly (by the terms of their employment, probably) assign the patent to the company.

Thar be safe harbor: Reddit defeats third attempt to unmask digital pirates

veti Silver badge

Re: Heard it Before

A "promise" like that always has two sides. "We promise not to sue, if you do something for us."

Trouble is, who's going to decide if that clause has been satisfied?

How else to find out, except by suing and seeing what happens?

US regulators crack down on AI playing doctor in healthcare

veti Silver badge

If insurance companies lose the right to decide what they will and won't pay for... then you might as well abandon the whole system and go over to state-funded healthcare.

Not saying that's a bad idea. Just that - making insurance companies follow doctors' orders unquestioningly would remove about the only important feature of their agency, and at that point there's really nothing to differentiate one company from another, and no reason to resist a single-payer system.

US starts 'emergency' checks on cryptocurrency power use, citing winter power demands

veti Silver badge

Re: Does no one understand basic mathematics any more?

First off, green energy can absolutely be stored. Batteries are a thing. The standard home solar installation around here includes a battery, which is used day-to-day to offset household consumption from peak to offpeak times.

Second, I doubt if BTC miners pay spot price for their electricity. (Indeed, the story some months ago about them selling back power to the grid in Texas implies that those miners, at least, pay a precontracted rate.) So they will not respond to wholesale prices in the way you suggest.

veti Silver badge

Re: Crazy power consumption

Maybe other aspects of US energy use have been declining. Screens, lighting, home appliances - all have grown significantly more efficient in that time. Parallel improvements have happened in industry. And then there's the growing vogue for heat pumps.

So why hasn't consumption come down substantially? Well, electric vehicles would be part of that. And BTC would be another part. Don't you think it's worthwhile to be able to quantify these contributions?

veti Silver badge

Re: Crazy power consumption

OK, well, I can find figures for 2019. Netflix streamed about 60 billion hours of content that year.

Their own energy usage was 451 GWh. To that let's add the energy usage of devices showing that content: if we assume the average viewing device is a laptop, it will be using about 60W, so 60 billion hours translates to about 3,600 GWh, for a total of a bit over 4 TWh.

Bitcoin's energy usage that year was - well, frankly I can't see quite how to read this graph, but the range of estimates seems to be about 50-75 TWh.

Bitcoin wins by more than an order of magnitude.

Also I can't see how you argue that "the world would be better off without Netflix", while also being prepared to defend Bitcoin on the grounds that people who use it clearly do find value in it. Those two positions seem quite unreconcilable to me.

veti Silver badge

Re: Gosh

Here you go.

Congratulations on saving your carbon footprint by... offloading your Google search requirements on other people.

veti Silver badge

Re: Pay as you go

That is highly subjective. It clearly creates value to people who are using it.
True. So let's drop the "while accomplishing nothing of value" clause and consider what's left.

Bitcoin mining and use creates demand for power. That demand is probably enough to materially affect the overall electricity market. (We could argue about whether it's "distorting" the market, but that would just lead us back to quibbling about words and value. So let's stick with "affect", it's a nice neutral word I hope we can agree on.)

"Perhaps" energy companies should change their fee structure? - well yes, perhaps they should. And perhaps regulators should change the constraints on those fee structures. And perhaps legislators should consider all this when reviewing their regulations, and also when considering regulations on the use of Bitcoin itself.

But how can any of these people do any of these jobs properly without good information?