* Posts by big_D

6775 publicly visible posts • joined 27 Nov 2009

Samsung cops to data leak after unsolicited '1/1' Find my Mobile push notification

big_D Silver badge
Paris Hilton

Re: Lost in Translation

The question still remains, how many millions of emails did The Register receive last week. ;-)

The Wristwatch of the Long Now: When your MTBF is two centuries

big_D Silver badge

Re: Beware survival bias

On the other hand, how many smartphones and smartwatches from 5 or 10 years ago are still getting regular security updates? How many are still working? How many will still be working, let alone safe to use, in another 10 years?

It is true that many old watches will not still be working, but, treated well, they have a chance. Modern tech pretty much doesn't. It isn't designed to last and it probably won't last very long. Ceased disk drives, corroded circuits etc. You can't repair them as easily as you can a simple mechanical device.

We don't buy Internet of Trash stuff. We tend to buy the best quality "non-smart" stuff we can afford and, where some form of "smarts" is useful, we add a cheap "smart" to it. For example, the TV is just a TV, we plug in a FireTV for streaming "smarts", because it is cheap and can be replaced every 5 years or so, the TV on the other hand was expensive, so needs to last at least a decade. Will it last that long? Who knows, but if it was "smart", the software support would stop after 2 - 3 years anyway!

But even that is short term. Our first colour TV was bought in the early 70s. My father was still using it when he died 30 years later. My mothers Sunbeam hand mixer was a wedding present in the 50s, that worked for nearly 50 years, before the brushes in the motor burnt out - and she used it at least a couple of times a week.

How many smart mixers from today will still be working in 50 years?

Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to save data from a computer that should have died aeons ago

big_D Silver badge

Serial overflow...

I was working in Beeston on a corporate reporting system, which was based in Luton.

HP 3000 mini in Luton and me sitting in front of an HP dumb terminal. Connected at 9600 baud to the local board, to a central point at 19,200, to a modem at 2,400 to a Kilostream to the MUX at the other end, to the HP 3000... Serial really doesn't like bouncing up and down those different baud rates!

Using the line editor (think "vi"), it would take around 20 minutes to display a line of text. So it was enter the line number, Enter, count the positions in the listing for the first insert, n X space, "i" for insert, then the text to insert, escape, spaces to the next bit, "d" to delete, "i" to insert etc. All blind. Go away and drink a coffee, come back and see if you got the right number of spaces! Press enter, rinse and repeat.

It took them about 2 days to sort out the problems with the buffering and get everything running smoothly. As it was changing reporting templates, following a takeover, for the corporate monthly reporting system and it was 3 days before end of the month, there was no sitting around and waiting for the comms problem to be fixed, I had to soldier through with the long pauses and get the new templates finished...

Apple drops a bomb on long-life HTTPS certificates: Safari to snub new security certs valid for more than 13 months

big_D Silver badge

CA verifies the key pair has been changed, too. And that the customer isn't just cycling between a couple of key pairs, and so on.

That is all in place now and well defined by RFCs. Just it is too much like hard work, so most browsers just ignore the process completely, pushing responsibility on the end user to manually double check the certificates haven't expired (ain't gonna happen).

big_D Silver badge

Re: Commercial Products

We are talking switches, routers, internal-only firewalls, ICS devices etc.

big_D Silver badge

Re: There is a way around compromised certificates

Then don't use Chrome, because it isn't safe...

CRLs are there for a reasons, use them! It's not rocket science. But these companies can't be bothered doing it the standards compliant way, so everybody else has to suffer.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Super slowmo

Except Let's Encrypt can't see isolated devices behind a firewall to issue the certificates.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Super slowmo

Most of our kit can't be automated. We have to manually issue certificates from our cert server and manually install them.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Super slowmo

Exactly. Or you could just revoke the certificate(s), but the browsers ignore revoked lists.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Commercial Products

How can you implement Let's Encrypt for a device which isn't visible from the Internet?

big_D Silver badge

And if they've been compromised after 1 week? They are still going to be accepted for the next year or so as valid...

That is why there are revoke lists, which most of the browsers seem to ignore.

There are mechanisms in place for this sort of thing, but it is easier to ignore it and push the work on the site administrators.

big_D Silver badge

Re: I understand

And don't forget that Google and Firefox are dropping Extended Validation certs in Chrome (you know, ones where the cert authority actually check out the applicant in the real world, to ensure they are who they say they are).

It is making a mockery of the whole process.

big_D Silver badge
Mushroom

Revoked

You can revoke certificates that are no longer required, have been technologically supeceded or have escaped into the open... But, wait, Google and Apple ignore the revoked lists, so it is up to the site owners to not only revoke certificates, which is essentially pointless these days, but to renew their certificates twice as often as they used to, because the devs are lazy.

I hope that the one year certificates only cost half as much, or can we provide Apple with a bill for the extra cost of the certificates, plus the increased labour in having to replace the certs twice as often?

What with Google and Firefox ignoring extended validation - something every critical site, like banking, cloud services etc. should have - and Apple reducing the life expectancy of certificates, they are making a mockery of the whole idea of secure sites. Why don't we do away with "proper" certificates altogether and just use Let's Encrypt, which requires no validation, other than you have access to the website...

Hey, Brits. Your Google data is leaving the EU before you are: Hoard to be shipped from Ireland to US next month

big_D Silver badge

Re: "they would have to store it in the UK"

GDPR states protection equivalent or better than the EU/UK. The US is a looooooong way off from providing that!

https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/third-countries/

one must check in a second step whether transfer to the third country is permitted. One must differentiate between secure and unsecure third countries. Secure third countries are those for which the European Commission has confirmed a suitable level of data protection on the basis of an adequacy decision. In those countries, national laws provide a level of protection for personal data which is comparable to those of EU law.

...

Andorra, Argentina, Canada (only commercial organisations), Faroe Islands, Guernsey, Israel, Isle of Man, Jersey, New Zealand, Switzerland, Uruguay, Japan and USA (if the recipient belongs to the Privacy Shield).

But the UK is no longer part of the EU and therefore Privacy Shield does not apply to UK data, so a new treaty between the USA and the UK will be needed, before UK data can legally be transferred to the USA. And the USA is still dragging its heels on Privacy Shield, they still aren't compliant with the treaty after nearly 4 years - for example they still haven't assigned a permanent ombudsman for privacy matters, as required under Privacy Shield.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Convenient BS from Google...

It does and the DPA 2018 still covers the UK, so if Google classes the data as no longer European, they would have to store it in the UK, until the UK has a treaty with the USA, otherwise they are breaking the DPA 2018 (the UK implementation of GDPR, which will remain in effect until it is changed by Parliament).

big_D Silver badge

Re: Convenient BS from Google...

Interestingly, nothing changes, legally, because of Brexit. The UK DPA 2018 is the implementation of the GDPR in UK law, so it still stands, until repealed. Therefore, moving the data to the US would be illegal, but I'm guessing that Google reckons that they can hoodwink the UK public and Government, before they realise what is going on.

'An issue of survival': Why Mozilla welcomes EU attempts to regulate the internet giants

big_D Silver badge

Contrary to the spirit of GDPR? It is illegal under GDPR. You can't refuse access if the user doesn't opt-in.

You can't collect or use information without an opt-in and you can't refuse access if they don't.

Cookies are a sticky subject though. Essential first party cookies (which page you visited last, are you logged on etc.) don't necessarily need to be agreed to, but anything that collects PII as you move through the site does, as do all third party cookies.

big_D Silver badge

That photo!

My grandmother wants her specs back! She had a pair like that, back in the 70s! What is old is new.

Forcing us to get consent before selling browser histories violates our free speech, US ISPs claim

big_D Silver badge
Paris Hilton

Have they never heard?

that if Google and Facebook are allowed to sell their users’ personal data then ISPs feel they should be allowed to as well.

Have they never heard, that two wrongs don't make a right?

Why does the 1st Amendment even apply to a company? I thought the Constitution applies to citizens?

“The Statute is preempted by federal law because it directly conflicts with and deliberately thwarts federal determinations about the proper way to protect consumer privacy,” the lawsuit argues.

You mean the fact that the FCC believes consumers shouldn't have any privacy?

What do a Lenovo touch pad, an HP camera and Dell Wi-Fi have in common? They'll swallow any old firmware, legit or saddled with malware

big_D Silver badge

Re: So what?

You can't make your own signed firmware with the public key. You need the private key to do that and that is exactly what he mentions, the "signing certificate".

big_D Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: So what?

Being able to get the signing certificate on request is exactly the same as having unsigned firmware updates. The hacker just needs to contact the manufacturer, requests the certificate, makes his contaminated firmware patch, signs it with the manufacturers certificate and hey presto, he can infect any machine with the manufacturers hardware installed!

big_D Silver badge

It is a question of cost and size against security. Are you willing to pay more for your laptop, which is thicker, because the Synaptics trackpad is thicker and includes a beefier processor capable of checking the keys on the firmware?

And that multiplied around wireless chipset, camera, USB hub etc.

Most people want a "cheap" device (cheap being relative to what it would cost to provide a secure device), not necessarily a secure one - they don't understand the problem, for a start. That means that the security conscious are left with having to take the insecure stuff and doing what they can to minimise risk.

At worst, just disallow write access to the chip. I know that sometimes customers might need to update the firmware, but tough cookies, it's a security risk to these very customers.

I assume you mean read access... But even so, they should throw out that $2,000 laptop, because the wireless/trackpad/camera has a critical security issue and can't be updated?

Oi, Cisco! Who left the 'high privilege' login for Smart Software Manager just sitting out in the open?

big_D Silver badge
Facepalm

No Huawei!

You see, this is exactly what the NSA has been on about! You just can't trust Huaw... Oh, wait, this is Cisco. Isn't Cisco American? Hey, this can't be!

Xerox hopes wining and dining HP shareholders will convince them of takeover

big_D Silver badge

I don't get the joke icon, shouldn't it have been Sherlock?

Icahn't is the poster child for everything that is wrong with stock juggling these days.

C'mon SPARCky, it's just an admin utility update. What could possibly go wrong?

big_D Silver badge

My favourite was Directory Opus on the Amiga. It is still around, but doesn't wake those memories somehow.

big_D Silver badge

I had an Xi, now that was a great little machine.

10MB hard drive, GUI, C interpreter (!!), C compiler, BASIC compiler, dBase, Multiplan, WordStar and still 5MB of space for data.

The A:/C: thing nearly caught me out a couple of times, but I never did. On the other hand, Norton Undelete was a tool no serious PC user was without back then. That and Xtree.

How the US-China trade war is felt stateside: Xilinx trims workforce after lucrative Huawei sales pipe blocked

big_D Silver badge

Re: So who is actually happy?

The Feds are trying to make somebody buy a controlling interest in Nokia or Ericsson, so that they can smile again... Hopefully Europe will tell them where to get off.

25 years of Delphi and no Oracle in sight: Not a Visual Basic killer but hard to kill

big_D Silver badge

Re: Interpreted?

Which is exactly what I said.

If VB was interpreted, it would use the source code, like BASIC did. But VB compiles to pCode and that goes through a JIT. The VB code itself isn't interpreted.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Language!

I see your P*w*rB**ld*r and raise you an RPG/II and ABAP.

PB was bad, but there are worse tortures for unwary programmers out there.

big_D Silver badge

VB used Dim, which was perverted from just dimensioning arrays. You didn't need to define variable, but you could force it to require variables to be define (Option Explicit).

big_D Silver badge

Re: not Cool

Yes, Pascal was a "language for students" to learn programming.

It wasn't C/C++ and it wasn't VisualBasic, it sort of sat in a bit of a noman's land, it was a well defined academic language, but "real" programmers used C or C++, if they weren't quiche munching beardies and for corporate quick and dirty prototyping, Visual Basic was quicker to get into and, as was pointed out, integrated well with Office.

big_D Silver badge

Re: Pascal has always been great

I remember programming the Mac Plus in Lightspeed Pascal.

big_D Silver badge

Interpreted?

There were some issues with VB, though. It was an interpreted language, which meant applications were dependent on installing a runtime, and it was slow in comparison to C or C++.

No. VB wasn't interpreted, it was compiled to pCode and executed from there. It isn't as efficient as compiling and linking to native code, but it is faster than interpreted code.

I also wrote several libraries to harness Win32. It wasn't integrated, but it was, for the most part, available, if you knew what you were doing.

Microsoft also upped its game. VB's compiler improved

We actually had Borland come and demo the product to us at work (I was at Cap Gemini at the time), but as the article says, most corporate customers wanted to stay with Oracle or Microsoft products.

Erm, yes. My point exactly...

Tilt.

Call us immediately if your child uses Kali Linux, squawks West Mids Police

big_D Silver badge
Big Brother

Re: Be a government informer! Betray your family and friends! Fabulous prizes to be won!

Erich Honecker would be proud.

big_D Silver badge
Childcatcher

Re: Maybe...

Yes, it is a recruitment drive:

VM tools - operators

Discord - emergency calls

Metasploit - data forensics experts.

TOR - Special Branch, they know how to cover their tracks.

/sarcasm

The icon is obvious.

Can AI-enhanced virtual sports presenters do the job? It's a big ask

big_D Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: To be fair...

One system in Germany had an unencrypted login and could be exploited, but it had to be Internet connected, you had to punch a hole in the firewall to your central heating, if the boiler couldn't contact base, your warranty was void and the heating wouldn't heat...

Not a Genius move after all: Apple must cough up $$$ in back pay for store staff forced to wait for bag searches

big_D Silver badge

Re: Good

I've worked at secure facilities and government institutions, where the conditions weren't as draconian or were better organised than Apple.

Voatz of no confidence: MIT boffins eviscerate US election app, claim fiends could exploit flaws to derail democracy

big_D Silver badge

Re: The name was enough

The literary crowd is in good form this morning.

big_D Silver badge

Re: The name was enough

I thought so.

big_D Silver badge
Pint

Re: I'm baffled

Have one of these this lunch time --->

For the Douglas Adams reference.

Huawei to the danger zone: Now Uncle Sam slaps it with 16 charges of racketeering, fraud, money laundering, theft of robot arm and source code

big_D Silver badge

Re: Wow, DC is really out to get Huawei...

The US Government is like the child that cried WOLF!

They have made dozens of allegations over the last couple of years, without being able to back them up.

Now it just sounds like desperation, although there could be something behind this one. But people have become so weary of the US Government in Jumping Chimpanzee mode, that it will be hard for them to get people to believe the accusations, even if they are true.

Microsoft brings the pane: You'll be looking at Xamarin and React Native to design apps for dual-screen gizmos

big_D Silver badge

Re: The Microsoft dung beetles have added yet another layer...

They've actually split it out into various dung balls, the core OS dung ball should therefore be lighter. Legacy Win32 runs in its own container and UWP applications in their containers.

Depending on what you actually use, in the way of software, it could be a lot slimmer and faster, at least in theory.

Oracle tells Supremes: Fair use? Pah! There's nothing fair about 'Google's copying'

big_D Silver badge

Re: Lifes not fair, life's just life...

"Oracle has declared to American Supreme Court justices that no company would make an "enormous investment" like it did in Java SE if rivals get a free pass to copy code simply because it is "popular" and "functional"."

Hmm, let me see, Linux Foundation, Red Hat, SUSE, Ubuntu, Greenbone Networks, Mozilla, I could name others, but there are lots of companies that invest heavily in open platforms.

Microsoft and Oracle, sitting in a cloud... in-ter-ope-ra-bi-li-ty: Friends-with-benefits deal is working out nicely for both

big_D Silver badge
Coat

Re: Oh, joy!

There's a firewall for that.

Razr sharp foldable: Samsung whips out Galaxy Z Flip – and, oh snap, it's £1,300

big_D Silver badge

Yes, most people I know balk at paying 500€ for a smartphone.

Aw, look. The UK is still trying really hard to be the 'safest place to be online in the world'

big_D Silver badge

Re: Inevitable

I think you mean startups have to follow the laws, but the incumbents are so big, that they just complain it is impossible to do at scale and it is cheaper to just pay the fines...

Once the fines start reaching 4% of turnover, they might actually take notice.

S20 Ultra 5G: Samsung unfurls Galaxy flagship with bonkers 108MP cam, 6.9-inch display

big_D Silver badge

Re: 108 Mpixels in a phone?

Take a look at the image in the article, it is flat, pixelated and, well, bloody awful...

big_D Silver badge

Example photo...

That has to be one of the worst quality photos I've seen in a long time. Not a good advert for the S20 Ultra..

B-but it doesn't get viruses! Not so, Apple fanbois: Mac malware is growing faster than nasties going for Windows

big_D Silver badge

Re: It's an obvious target, no?

I bought a 2007 iMac 24", it cost (with educational discount) about the same as an equivalent desktop + 24" display, which were damned expensive back then.

When I went to replace the iMac, the prices had increased, even though the prices of the hardware, especially the display, had plummeted on the PC side. In the end, I looked at a MacBook Pro, but they didn't have a quad core i7 at that time, just dual core, and a quad core i7 Windows laptop from Sony cost less than half what the Mac cost... As all the software I needed ran on both platforms, I saved myself about 1,500€.

Uncle Sam: Secretly spying on networks around the world without telling anyone, Huawei? But that's OUR job

big_D Silver badge

Re: Good Guys??

Cisco has spent the last 2 years removing one backdoor after another from its code, after they had been "discovered" by security researchers and alleged internal audits.