* Posts by paulf

1250 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Aug 2009

IBM CEO Ginni Rometty also cool on EMC/Dell

paulf
WTF?

Unsurprising

"IBM's CEO Ginni Rometty has offered a guarded-but-mostly-negative opinion on Dell's acquisition of EMC."

I can't help thinking "Well she would say that, wouldn't she". It's not like she'll stand up at a big event and say, "Oh, fuck, they did us over good with that acquisition; and they'll be better placed to eat more of our lunch as a result. But never mind our $20 EPS plan is all hunky dory so lets continue with the off shoring and shafting our dwindling customer base".

It would be interesting to read more detailed analysis on the VMWare side of the EMC acquision. Most commentators seem to be concentrating on Dell selling it.

In 2015, your Windows PC can be owned by opening a spreadsheet

paulf
Mushroom

Re: Hidden W10 upgrade updates are back again!!!!!

"For users running Windows Update, the October updates should download and install automatically."

No they bloody well won't be - for this very reason. That auto install option was one of the first things I turned off along with the "Give me recommended updates the same way I receive important updates" option.

Microsoft can shove their creepy stealthy Lets-Out-Google-Google telemetry customer experience grenade up their backsides and rotate on it. Pic - they can pull the pin out before they shove it up.

Netgear prodded into patching SOHOpeless broadband router

paulf
Thumb Up

Re: No surprise with Netgear

@aftermath99

I've not had to replace it yet so not investigated in anger. I probably ought to on the assumption it's almost certainly not secure! I was freed from the crappy ADSL firmware side two years ago when I went FTTC so now its Ethernet WAN port plugs into the BT Openreach VDSL modem (which has been pretty flawless). I suppose that's the really frustrating thing - I've always found Netgear hardware to be pretty solid (in my experience - YMMV) but the software is left to bit rot within 12 months of launch.

I was going to say that although I've not bought one myself I keep hearing good things about DrayTek's products when this kind of thing comes up on El Reg, although they are expensive. I see two others have also commented positively about DrayTek so they're top of my list when the Netgear does go pop.

paulf
FAIL

No surprise with Netgear

When they EOL top of the range routers within a year of release the only surprise is that they're bothering to put out a patch at all. I can only assume bad publicity does focus minds in these companies so good on El Reg for the SOHOpeless campaign.

I bought a DGND3700 v1 back in 2011 that went into EOL 9 months later despite it still having various bugs in the ADSL modem part of the firmware. Cost was about £120 so not exactly a cheap landfill router flung out for "free" by an ISP. Only constant nagging at support about it got a solution through a Beta version of the firmware (still not published on their website) which mostly fixed the problem.

As a result, that was my last Netgear product which is a shame. Oddly they still fling out occasional security updates to their SPARC NAS boxes even though they're older than my router.

Faked NatWest, Halifax bank sites score REAL security certs

paulf
Big Brother

@ DaLo (3d Secure) Re: The banks can help here

When I get the 3D Secure box it used to show a short passphrase I entered when setting up 3D Secure for that card e.g. "Yes, you div, type your stuff" so I would know the frame was definitely connected to my card issuer. It could have been obtained (either by the payment processing site or a third party) using screen scraping stuff in the browser but I don't know how possible that would be.

I don't know if they still do that since I haven't been asked for 3D secure credentials for what feels like years now - the box appears but the card issuer bounces back approval without asking any questions. I would optimistically put that down to my Bank realising the purchase is likely legit from my transaction history, but there's also a chance they can't be arsed...

paulf
Holmes

The banks can help here

It would be nice if the banks didn't use different URLs for their OLB sites thus making phishing sites sound that more plausible. Having SSL on by default would also help!

For example, the main Halifax website is the rather predictable (note, not secure by default):

http://www.halifax.co.uk/

Their Online banking site uses this innocent sounding URL (thankfully it does use SSL):

https://www.halifax-online.co.uk/

Nationwide used to be just as bad using this URL for their OLB until earlier this year:

https://olb2.nationet.com/

I'm sure there are plenty of other examples since the article notes Natwest uses www.nwolb.com

Android users left at risk... and it's not even THEIR FAULT this time!

paulf
Holmes

HTC off the radar now?

A little off topic but it's interesting to note HTC's latest quarterly loss (early Oct 2015) was reported by the Beeb but not on El Reg (at least not that I noticed). Perhaps El Reg could just have a cut and paste template story ready for the inevitable in Jan 2016?

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-34451104

Straying back towards topic a little, it's something other Android handset manufacturers should take note of. HTC's problems are down to reaping what they've sown for years though their egregious neglect of customers, especially WRT security updates and bug fixes.

Web ad tried to make my iPhone spaff a premium-rate text, says snapper

paulf
Devil

Re: The best and worst features

I mostly agree with you - Safari (and other apps) should be much more limited in the way they can call other apps. All it takes is for a bit of fancy javascript to make Safari think a link has been clicked and off it goes to the App store or somesuch. I know I've opened (mostly reputable) websites and been thrown straight to the App store by an ad, before the page finishes loading, which is utterly wrong, but I disagree that a complete block is suitable as there are times when that integration is useful.

As I understand it any request in Safari to open the Dialler to call a number pops up a dialogue asking if you're sure you want to call that number. That should be the case in all "other app" calls e.g. "Are you sure you want to view SuperApp in the App store?"

It doesn't stop PICNIC/ID10T errors clicking through all the dialogues but does give another layer of protection against ads, which it seems are all malicious until proven otherwise!

Pic = Advertisers.

HP's Mad King Léo ignored Autonomy iceberg, emails claim

paulf
Holmes

If financial markets are rational...

Apotheker apparently said "If financial markets are rational, we should be rewarded by a better P/E multiple as we move toward this objective."

Financial markets are rarely rational c.f. every sodding day.

The lack of due diligence is cited as the reason HP pushed ahead with the ill advised acquisition. From what I can see looking at the published the DD docs it did pick up on problems ahead of the acquisition but HP manglement (primarily Apotheker) were blinded by their own hubris.

You call THAT safe? Top EU legal bod says data sent to US is anything but

paulf
Holmes

I expect the reaction of the ICO was to start melting when someone tried to make tea in it.

My repeated experience with the ICO suggests that comparison is an insult to chocolate teapots. Even when I had wrong doers banged to rights (violated Sect 11 C&D orders etc.) the ICO felt giving them a slap on the wrist was a bit harsh. They probably only support Safe Harbour as long as it saves them doing any work to protect data.

Hats off to Nintendo’s platform supremo Super Mario Bros at 30

paulf
Happy

Re: Other platforms

I remember the Game and Watch devices. I had two, Mario Bros and Balloon Fight:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Game_%26_Watch_games#Mario_Bros.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Game_%26_Watch_games#Balloon_Fight

Both were still in working order last time I checked. Fairly simple game play but still addictive and fun. I hadn't realised quite how many there were until I checked.

Unfortunately I never owned a console until I bought someone else's unwanted Gamecube so Game and Watch was my only experience of Mario Bros for some years.

Ouch! Microsoft sues recycling firm over 70K stolen Office licenses

paulf
Unhappy

Re: But why?

Unfortunately (at least in England and Wales - IANAL) if you buy something from someone who didn't have proper ownership of that thing in the first place* then it isn't yours. (So they're not really legit customers). The item in question still belongs to the original owner and your claim is against the fraudulent seller for the money you gave them. It might sound unfair on the buyer who likely acted in good faith but I suspect there is a bit of unintended consequences avoidance here to avoid stolen property being laundered by "selling" it.

That's not to say MS wouldn't do a deal to the 70,000 to keep them sweet and stop them going to another Office product but I'm not convinced MS under SatNad is that way inclined (if indeed they ever were under Gates/Ballmer).

* - I'd say stolen property but that can be a bit emotive around software so I've tried to tiptoe around it.

Thousands cut off from email after EE bungles domain renewal

paulf
Stop

Re: 1 year renewal

I suspect @xeroks was considering the PO approval process in a company like EE where the PO has to be completed (perfectly, natch) get signed off by the boss, then sent to accounts, then to Purchasing (Procurement?), then to a Senior Director or Veep for extra approval (it's cumputters innit, must be important) then back to Accounts, then over to Purchasing and finally send the money to the Registrar by which time it's been nabbed by an opportune cyber-squatter and it's flinging out Malware and V1agr@ adverts.

There's no swimming in treacle icon.

paulf
Coffee/keyboard

Re: Correction

Thank you, I've just received funny looks for laughing at that in the office. So very true regarding EE who must have a most egregious infestation of PHBs. Perhaps they should call Rentokil?

Unfortunately my need for a new keyboard means no Beer icon.

How a massive campaign of booby-trapped web ads went undetected for too long

paulf
Holmes

Dear Internet Ad industry

This is why I run ABP on all my machines.

If you want to compare me to a Thief for using ABP, then I compare you to a Newsagent that sends someone round to drain all the fuel out of my car when I buy a paper.

Sincerely

Long term ABP user

PS - Sort out your Malvertising delivery networks (along with less intrusive ads and an end to the stalker like creepy tracking that facilitates delivery of said Malvertising) and I may consider white listing sites

The ONE WEIRD TRICK which could END OBESITY

paulf
Facepalm

Doggy bag

As said above - making portions smaller means fatties will buy two.

If you are eating out and have more food on your plate than you can reasonably finish then ask the waiting staff to pack it up to take away with you. You can then have it for lunch the next day. I understand Chefs much prefer to package up left overs for diners to take home with them than see the food they've cooked get chucked in the bin. I've never had a problem having my left overs packed up like this and the staff are normally happy to do it.

If you're eating at home you can always do the same - pop left overs in the fridge for the next day.

Vodafone 'fesses up to hack of journalist's phone, denies 'improper behaviour'

paulf
Big Brother

Downloaded text messages

One thing not discussed so far is this: "I have since learnt that immediately after the release of my story, a Vodafone employee accessed and downloaded a copy of my text messages and call records."

Firstly it isn't clear whether she is talking about the content of her text messages or just the absolutely harmless* meta data about who she texted and when but not the actual content.

Secondly if Vodafone did retain copies of the content of her Text messages why the fricking hell did they do it and did no one think this was a bad thing? I'm not familiar with the more arcane parts of Oz telecoms regulation - is there a requirement to retain this kind of thing? Did someone at VHT just wake up one morning and say, "Lets retain all of our customers' SMS without asking them". Just yeek.

* As our highers and betters in <span class="strike">GCHQ</span> Westminster define Meta data.

Don't want to upgrade to Windows 10? You'll download it WHETHER YOU LIKE IT OR NOT

paulf

See my comment above

http://forums.theregister.co.uk/forum/containing/2629476

It looks like the back porting telemetry patches appear as Recommended updates so you should be safe from these providing you untick "Give me recommended updates the same way I receive important updates" in the windows update settings. Do that and you should be safe from the Win 10 downloads - until MS set them as Important :(

As mentioned above I never saw the point of the recommended updates as they only fix obsure inconsistencies (not even bugs)

paulf
Big Brother

Re: I've yet to see the upgrade icon

I've looked into this - it was a question I was going to ask about the latest update files too.

For reference I'm looking at three machines which run Windows 7 x64 (my home machine, my work machine, and my parent's machine).

From what I can see the recent Telemetry updates to Windows 7, which caused the previous recent brou-ha-ha about Windows 10 tracking being back ported to earlier versions, come as "Recommended" updates. I've always unticked "Give me recommended updates the same way I receive important updates" in Windows update which has stopped these being installed. I never saw the point as Recommended updates only seemed to fix obsure things like a key combination bug when editing a Spanish Word document imported into Excel. I have Important updates set to "inform but let me choose to download and install". Since Windows 10 update nags haven't appeared on these machines I suspect the Windows 10 stuff is set as Recommended updates rather than Important updates. This may explain why you've not seen updates.

Unfortunately I suspect it's only a matter of time before MS change them from Recommended to Important to make sure they ensnare everyone.

So my question - is the update that downloads the Windows 10 update files - is this a Recommended or Important update? I suspect and hope it is the former - it certainly doesn't qualify as the latter by any conventional definition of the word.

The work machine has it's windows update settings configured by a group policy so updates are auto installed but only those updates approved by our BOFH and Windows 10 is firmly verbotten on all work machines.

Samsung’s consumer IoT vision – stupid, desperate, creepy

paulf
Unhappy

Re: Why....just why?

"Many people say they want the durability of the Miele,"

Something I've never understood about Miele is the way they advertise their machines as having 20 year durability on normal usage, then offer a 2 year warranty with the option to pay for an extended warranty of up to 10 years:

http://www.miele.co.uk/domestic/warranty-479.htm#p3491

I'd spend £1000 on a washing machine if it came with 10-15 years warranty but 2 years makes me think they don't quite want to put their money where the marketing droid mouth is...

Court battle date set for £300m BT Cornwall termination dispute

paulf
Boffin

Re: Wait for the evidence?

Some evidence:

BT Cornwall Strategic Partnership Review

https://democracy.cornwall.gov.uk/documents/s77905/Strategic%20Partnership%20Review.pdf

"KPI Measures achieved 185/289 = 64%", p3

"Delivery ... IT incident resolution having dropped from 96.6% in September 2014 to 70% in

February of this year ..."

From http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cornwall-34120656

A Strategic Partnership Review by the council in April said BT had promised it would create at least 197 extra jobs in Cornwall over the life of the contract.

It also said 111 of those would be delivered in the first two years, but only 35 had been created.

Microsoft backports data slurp to Windows 7 and 8 via patches

paulf
Unhappy

Recommended update

It looks like the primary offending update KB 3068708 is a Recommended update. I've always unchecked the "Give me recommended updates the same way I receive important updates" option in Windows Update since most of those updates tend to only hold some nice to have patch for some obscure HDD running on some other more obscure Motherboard. Great if you have that HDD and MB but I've never found anything in there of use.

That could all change if MS decide that updated spying^H^H^H customer experience telemetery is now an Important update...

Trying to out Google Google - I can only see that working as well as it did when they tried to out Apple Apple (Zune anyone?)

Euro telly bods say 'non' to spectrum sharing with mobiles

paulf
Boffin

Re: Eh?

GIYF

NHS to go paperless by 2020. No, really, it will, says gros fromage

paulf

Re: Take their printers off them

The guy sounds nuts but I'll defend photocopying faxes if only because that long ago suggests the fax machine used thermal paper which has a habit of fading. Photocopying it at least preserves the content beyond the original fading.

Legal eagles accuse Labour of data law breach over party purge

paulf
Alert

Re: The Labour Party...

Partly related.

Something I'm seeing a lot more is the: "By <interacting with us in some way that hands over your personal details> you consent to us contacting you for marketing purposes. If you don't want your details used for these purposes please contact us by <postal address> to opt out".

In other words you cannot tick (or untick, or "don't not untick the box if you never want to not get our advertisers' shite") the box to opt out at point of first contact. You have to go to the added effort of contacting them separately after the first contact. Make it harder to opt out and fewer will bother. I can't see how this is informed consent when the only way to withhold that informed consent it not dealing with them in the first place.

Worryingly I find this more prevalent with Charities so I don't donate to those which pull this nasty little trick. My donation is the money I give you not my personal details for you to flog off to all and sundry via your marketing dept.

Holes found in Pocket Firefox add-on

paulf
Thumb Up

Re: Phocket

@Dan55

I found browser.pocket.enabled was already set to False in my FF. Since I've not modified it myself I think this must have been disabled by the option in Classic Theme Restorer to disable Pocket completely.

I've made the other changes you recommend though!

FCC: No, Dish, you're not a 'small business' so forget the $3bn price cut

paulf

Re: I wonder...

It probably covered 6 months of interest payments on the $10tn debt?

Vodafonica’s Cornerstone missing its UK coverage target, says report

paulf
Boffin

Sub-head: "If only it was all share and share alike for O2 and Vodafone"

The sub-head suggests the two halves of Vodafonica* have not worked equally towards their coverage target. This isn't referenced further in the article that I can see. I understand that the Sub-head may be written by a Sub-Ed rather than the article author but some clarification would be useful.

*"Vodafone will be looking after network maintenance in the West of the UK and Wales, while O2 will be looking after the East, including Northern Ireland."

http://blog.vodafone.co.uk/2012/11/20/better-coverage-fewer-masts-your-complete-guide-to-our-network-joint-venture/

Dixons Carphone still has 7.5k Windows XP EPOS systems

paulf
Boffin

Re: So?

You're assuming the flesh sacks that occupy the "air gap" are 100% trustworthy and 100% alert to the risks of introducing infections to the internal network. All it takes is one underpaid till monkey to be offered an envelope of money to "Just plug this USB stick into the till so I can get some diagnostic information". Even if the USB sockets are glued up (as they ought to be on EFTPOS machines, other than possibly a debug USB socket behind heavy physical security) the Ethernet port (or something else) will be accessible...

As the saying goes - the target has to be lucky every time, the perpetrator only has to be lucky once.

Labour Party website DDoS'd by ruly democratic mob

paulf
Megaphone

Re: I'd like to know..

Lots of rail points here:

"how Corbyn plans to finance any of his nationalisations"

It doesn't have to be cash raised in the normal manner. He could issue Government debt to buy up the private assets in question. This is how the big four railway companies were nationalised in 1948, their shares were exchanged for Government bonds. The risk, as another commentard said, is that the bond markets would [potentially] nuke him from orbit.

Note that issuing debt like this is covering the "defect" between Govt revenue and spending.

"BR was a disaster, chiefly because one uppity union rep could shut down the whole network."

Taking that one point - the messy structure introduced by the 1993 railways act was in part to smash the power of the unions. The upshot was the unions adapted and became very effective at playing one TOC off against another. Perhaps not good at closing the whole network, but good at getting pay improvements.

"[Other european contries have...] Progressive unions that don't strike"

I'll leave this here with no further comment

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/may/20/train-driver-strike-paralyses-germany-rail-network

"Ninth walkout in 10 months leaves millions stranded as sympathy for workers involved in industrial action nosedives "

"Tube drivers push a button to open and close doors."

On the Victoria line yes, as it uses Automatic Train Operation. On other lines, this is not true and the driver actually drives as well as operate the doors, etc. Note also that trains need some kind of track side competent operator on board. DLR tunnels were built to modern standards with evacuation walkways but the original tube lines are barely big enough for the train so evacuation is through the train onto the track.

Note also that it's shift work with incredibly unsociable hours and carries a lot of responsibility not to mention route knowledge. I'm not necessarily saying they're right to strike but it's much more than just pushing a button.

"I read somewhere he would fund it by printing money and calling it "QE for infrastructure" or something stupid like that."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-33884836

"the rolling stock is not so easy."

The original BR rolling stock was split up into three ROSCOs (Angel, Porterbrook, and Eversholt) and sold off. This hasn't generated the competition hoped for. Car leasing is easy, you're buying a commodity product with a 10 year life. Once the initial 3 year lease is up you know there is a market to sell the vehicle into. Rail vehicles are bespoke modifications of a specialised product, aimed at a particular line, with a 40+ year life span. Why would you invest in new rolling stock unless you were certain of it being used, thus making your return over that 40 year life? Even in BR days leasing wasn't allowed unless it was at least as cheap as buying. Buying back the ROSCO stock would be difficult and/or costly.

"What's the situation with the freight train operators"

They are not franchised nor subsidised, providing you don't include implicit subsidy from the occasional building of new chord/link lines for freight operation. These often free capacity for passenger services so it isn't exclusively for the benefit of Freight operators.

HTC shedding 15 per cent of workforce in 'strategic realignment'

paulf
Mushroom

Re: Bye bye HTC

@GrumpyOldBloke

Exactly right

In the early days people thought HTC Sense WAS Android. If HTC played that early and significant lead correctly they could have owned the Android market. But they majorly messed up because they didn't understand that what happens after the money is in the till WILL have an influence on that person's next purchase.

I was cut twice by HTC, the second much deeper than the first. Full of bugs, updates that never came, disgraceful support. I swore off them completely at that point and as the general techie support dogsbody person for the family I made sure that everyone who asked me avoided HTC like the plague also. When you look at recent problems of finger prints being stored in unencrypted "clear text" picture files that any dodgy app can access you can see they've learnt nothing from the "apps that collect all user information then report it home" problems they had years ago.

It's always hardest on the employees who take the fall, and I don't like to see people put out of jobs, but the HTC that exists today will be no loss if it disappears.

If you installed Windows 10 and like privacy, you checked the defaults, right? Oh dear

paulf
Big Brother

Re: 'Cheap' in terms of food, now means selling your privacy too.

@Greg D

"AFAIK a number plate is not private information."

No, it isn't. However my payment card is private information, while details the shopping I've bought is semi-private; and they're trying to link all three at the checkout. Note that it's trivial for anyone to look up the car make + model from the registration (i.e. is it a Bentley or a banger?) so they suddenly have much better knowledge of their shopping demographic. Maybe they have the ability to link payment card to the billing address from another source - another aspect of the demographic is how wealthy your 'hood is. We don't know what information the other side of the equation has access to...

That all assumes they're only interesting in knowing their shopping demographic better and not the usual targeted ads crap.

Paying cash is one thing but not many people carry enough cash with them to cover the weekly shop and if you only find out when you've packed your shopping and are about to pay it's a bit late to say I'll pop to an ATM. That said I'd probably empty my bags, buy the minimum shopping with cash to avoid a parking ticket, leave them to put it all back on the shelves and sod off to a shop that doesn't feel the need to track my every move!

It's enough to get your back up: Eight dual-bay SOHO NAS boxes

paulf
Alert

Re: Comparative reviewing

I'd like to know how often the vendor will release software updates and what their roadmap is for EOL, especially considering El Reg's SOHO-peless "campaign" on updates to home/home-office networking kit for critical security flaws.

I've got four ReadyNAS Duo v1 (Sparc) units - the last update was Oct 2014 which works out at 3-4 years from launch. I don't know if they'll push out any more updates - I'm guessing probably not but I was surprised to see the last update come out.

People might grumble at "only" 3-4 years but this is pretty good in comparison to my Netgear home router which was EOLd about 6-9 months after launch. I'm currently running a Beta firmware from Tech Support to fix the ADSL problems I had but the various beta updates were never released.

Ofcom wants to ease the pain of switching mobile networks. Good luck

paulf
Thumb Up

Re: Slamming protection first please

This is the main (only?) aspect that makes the current system worth retaining. Getting a PAC from the current network should reduce to almost nil the changes of slamming (a popular practice in the Energy industry or have regulator memories forgotten this?).

It should be possible to get the PAC via the current operator's website (I think the story notes this as an option). People calling their current operator should get through to the right person within 5 minutes. The PAC should be issued (verbally and by SMS) within 5 minutes of the call being picked up. Fine all violations of these times at £10k per occurrence. This keeps the slamming protection of the current system but ensures minds are focused to prevent existing operators taking the piss by making it obscenely difficult to get the PAC.

I've only moved operator once - from Orange to Vodafone in 2006. Orange claimed they couldn't give the PAC over the phone or by SMS and could only post it for security (total BS!). Voda held the agreed deal until I got the PAC then did the port. Since then I've called Voda several times for my PAC as a starting point for contract renewal and always been given it within 10 minutes of dialling the number (YMMV as always!).

paulf
Headmaster

RAS Syndrome

"...get a PAC code,..."

"...keep the PAC code..."

"texting you a PAC code"

Sigh. As mobile correspondent you really have no excuse for not knowing what PAC stands for.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porting_Authorisation_Code

Austrian court rules online radio streaming is not broadcasting

paulf
Boffin

Key point here is Austria

Austrian court with jurisdiction only in Austria makes decision based on Austrian law regarding activities in Austria, that applies only to Austria.

Yes, BBC this is all about you. Do something about it now!

Moneybags Bloomberg whips out checkbook to gobble spoof website

paulf
Pirate

Symantec

"the company said it had hired Symantec to verify every [.bank] application"

What could possibly go wrong?

Loan application data hacked, company responds: Meh, not our customers

paulf
Pirate

Really?

"We automatically delete all of the stolen data once a full payment has been made.”

Sure they do.

Trebles all round: The BBC's won this licence fee showdown

paulf
Facepalm

Re: But....

As I mention further up:

"I don't watch ITV, listen to commercial radio, or read a printed newspaper yet I, unavoidably, pay towards all of these through the money my supermarket, bank, power supplier, phone manufacturer and others spend to advertise on these services. Unless I manage to track down businesses that don't advertise (an activity made harder by its very nature) I'm paying for all these services whether I want to or not. At least with the BBC I can ditch the telly and cancel the TV License!"

paulf
Boffin

@SuccessCase nailed it

@SuccessCase

Yours is the first analysis I've seen that nails what is really being played out here. This isn't about free TV licenses for old folks. One comment (Chris Ship, ITV News) nailed the superficial aspect of this, "Will the Government demand Energy Companies pay the winter fuel allowance, and Stagecoach pays the free bus pass". Before anyone says these companies don't get an equivalent of License fee money; among other things, the former gets subsidies for green energy and the latter subsidies for provision of services that cannot be run commercially - all paid for through mandatory taxation even if it isn't directly attributable in the way the license fee is. The former already has precedent for Government raids through funding energy efficiency schemes in private homes.

As you point out the real play here is a stealthy and tactical move that would push the BBC into a corner with regard to moving to some form of subscription model the BBC's critics (of which Orlowski is a typically vocal one) often demand, by allowing the BBC to require some kind of payment to watch non-live streams on iPlayer. I'm not aware whether this would require a separate subscription or simply requires a TV license but my understanding is it would be the latter not the former. As you say - once it's established a fee (i.e. TV license) must be paid for access to iPlayer catch up streams (whereas before no license was required and use was free since it wasn't live) it undermines the existence of the License fee for the reasons you cite.

My response to anyone who shouts about how unfair the "Telly Poll Tax" is because they don't watch the BBC is to remind them that advertising is a tax on all of us regardless of what we do. Even though I don't watch ITV, listen to commercial radio, or read a printed newspaper I quietly and unavoidably pay towards all of these through the money my supermarket, bank, power supplier, phone manufacturer and others spend on advertising. Unless I manage to track down businesses that don't advertise (an activity made harder by its very nature) I'm paying for all these services whether I want to or not. At least with the BBC I can ditch the telly and cancel the TV License!

HTC in crisis: How did it get to this point? How did it get this bad?

paulf
Thumb Up

Re: Their (lack of) support killed my interest in HTC

HTC "support" initially thought the battery also and offered to send me a free replacement - but only after a had to throw a major tantrum at their insistence I pay for the replacement! The new battery didn't resolve it and from reading around the interwebs neither did the next HTC solutions of Factory Reset and replacement handset. There was a major version update and a couple of patch updates that didn't resolve the bug. It would happen to me mid-call, while using the browser and even when it was on standby in my pocket or on the desk.

There was also a fix to a bug that leaked user info to HTC's servers without permission (remember that). Then there was all the built in HTC apps, not possible to uninstall and demanded every permission going.

It is sad really, if only for the Engs and Devs that have/will lost/lose jobs. HTC had such a major lead in the early days. If they'd launched fewer better supported handsets (rather than the chuck handfuls of variants at the wall and see what sticks) and not treated their fanbase with contempt they would easily seen off the later challenge from Samsung (IMO). HTC failed big time because they didn't realise customer satisfaction was a pretty important part of being successful.

paulf
FAIL

Their (lack of) support killed my interest in HTC

HTC were a very early yet clear leader in the Android market IIRC with handsets like the Hero, Desire and Desire HD, giving them a good lead early on in Android's life.

I had two of their handsets - a Hero which I upgraded about 18 months later to the Sensation when it was launched (bought outright for £400 and £450 respectively). After 10 years of Nokia handsets (followed by one Sony Ericsson) I was keen to find a good supplier of Smartphone handsets I could commit to (while the iPhone was of interest it wasn't suitable for me).

The Hero was underpowered for what it was expected to do but it was at least functional. Then the upgrade from Android 1.6 to 2.1 kept being kicked into the long grass until it showed up 9 months after the originally promised release.

The Sensation was utterly useless and a complete waste of a large amount of money. I suffered from the random turn off bug (not widespread but I found various other users with the same problem) where the handset would just switch off suddenly and ungracefully for no reason. I never managed to diagnose the cause. HTC support was useless and I was glad to see the back of that handset 20 months later.

In all I wasted almost £1000 on HTC handsets that were utter crap and that is why I will never buy HTC again. They had the chance to build a very loyal fanbase of Android users (in the early days people tended to think HTC Sense WAS Android) but through their own greed/ineptitude/dire support they squandered it and they're now reaping what they've sown.

</rant>

Ditch crappy landlines and start reading Twitter, 999 call centres told

paulf
Thumb Up

Re: Fantastic

Upvoted simply for the comment

"How much whalesong did they consume before suggesting this?"

I must remember that for my next meeting that involves hipsters (thankfully few and far between)

Home Office kept schtum on more than 30 data breaches last year

paulf
Holmes

Re: This is why informing the ICO should be mandatory

It won't get watered down in the negotiation process. That happens in the massive lunch and brown envelope process.

Chair legs it from UK govt smart meter installation programme

paulf
Holmes

Re: "I thank Baroness McDonagh for"

@Ledswinger

"...everything that is wrong with the Conservative party, and with the depth, breadth and quality of our rotten and useless parliament (and things are no better on the opposition benches)."

I think you're right there. You only have to look at the way Michael Dugher (Shadow transport sec) has been blocking experienced and knowledgeable railway journalists, because they keep challenging him when he spouts rubbish in public, to confirm things are about the same on both sides of the house.

Google on Google: The carefully collated anti-trust truth

paulf
Pirate

Re: My 2 cents

My £0.02 back on this.

I avoid price comparison sites like the plague. Whenever I've landed on one (perhaps because I've clicked on the link presented by Google thinking it was a retailer rather than a PCS) it usually presents a load of links to the product I'm looking for that are either:

1. Links to other price comparison sites claiming to have links to retailers for even cheaper (which eventually link back to this PCS)

Or 2. Links to retailers that either don't have the product in stock any more or never did in the first place.

PCS are a complete waste of time IME so perhaps this explains why you never got any decent business from the click throughs they generated to your site.

Not that I like Google, their creepy web stalking, or the behaviour alleged by this article; my only point is PCS are worse than useless as they claim to be able to source the item you're looking for when this isn't the case. Perhaps PCS ought to be reclassified as Click Bait sites.

Vodafone hikes prices to 37.5p/min – and lets angry customers flee

paulf
FAIL

Re: " write to us"?

Based on my recent experience with the Red Apostrophe, dead tree plus snail mail is probably the most efficient way of solving problems. Five phone calls later and I STILL can't access my on line account despite the usual myriad of promises to sort it ASAP.

The most amusing attempt to login was when I got dumped onto an error screen from their Oracle back end servers telling me to contact the sys admin.

They haven't a clue about website stuff. Their social media escalation page (code is WRT165 if you're keen) demands a whole bunch of info through an insecure page!

http://www.vodafone.co.uk/contact-form/index.htm

British banks consider emoji as password replacement

paulf
Trollface

Patent?

"...the concept is likely not able to be patented but is probably the first of its kind."

It's ok, we've just found the USPTO and they've granted us a patent with no questions asked as long as we paid the fee immediately (cash only).

Zionists stole my SHOE, claims Muslim campaigner

paulf
Mushroom

Re: Anyone remember the Sunday Sport ?

My favourite was when they reported this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQo6t9vcZYc

as "Anthea Turner's head explodes"

These days I prefer Viz - at least they don't pretend what they're publishing isn't bollocks.

Cheaper Apple iStuff? Foxconn eyes costs-busting Indian move

paulf
Holmes

Apple reducing prices because their subcontractor moves the assembly factory to a cheaper location would only lead to a cut in the selling price if there was any connection between the final selling cost and the cost of assembly/BoM. As is often suggested in these very forums it's unlikely such a direct connection exists.