* Posts by AndrueC

5089 publicly visible posts • joined 6 Aug 2009

Thatcher’s data protection legacy: Just fill out this 16-page form

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

So what you're saying is that we only have the current framework because the EU forced our hand. Well - that's interesting. A bit like of freedom of speech then. Maybe the EU is good for something :)

AMI PC firmware upgrade scare: The global security meltdown that wasn't

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

it could launch a hypervisor style of rootki

Ah right, I get you. Thanks for that update. It's been a long time since I worked at that low a level. C# and Microsoft SharePoint are a long way from the BIOS :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

This malicious code runs underneath the operating system, and could therefore set itself up to spy on everything the user does without being spotted.

It could inject very early in the boot process but I thought OSes kicked the BIOS out of the address space fairly swiftly. They certainly had to many moons ago because they were only designed to support DOS. Have we come back around now? Do modern BIOSes actually provide services that are useful to a modern OS?

Space elevators, vacuum chutes: What next for big rocket tech?

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

On the subject of space elevators Arthur C Clarke's The Fountains of Paradise is worth a read. In my opinions it's actually one of his best novels.

'North Korea Has Launched a Missile' tweet sent by mistake

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: Modern Media Management

I gather Stephen Fry is on stand-by.

Is that another emergency warning that has slipped out?

Bitcoin gets a $100 haircut on rollercoaster trading run

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: 'tarded

an overheating turkey vulture will urinate down it's own legs, in order to cool itself down.

Well - who wouldn't?

:D

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Love that pic on the WeExchange site

Marketing 101.

Buy this car, you'll enjoy traffic free roads and beautiful countryside.

Eat this cereal and you'll enjoy a happy family life with two kids (one of each sex) and a golden retriever.

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Every so often a market develops around something improbable

Gold, you almost have a point here, but gold has alternate applications where there are no alternatives. Additionally, people like shiny, shiny which ultimately pushes the price of it up given it's rarity.

Yah, shining nicely is an application the same as facilitating the free flow of electrons at connection points. Ultimately nothing has value outside of what humans credit it with. Everything is worth what the people trying to acquire it think it's worth - it's just that if you're basing off a physical thing then you're more subject to the foibles of the real world. Typically that tends to introduce price stability but it doesn't always.

It's all part of a game we choose to play called 'civilisation'.

And no, I don't mean Sid Meier's.

:)

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: 'tarded

Killraventard?

:)

Vinyl sales reach 15 year high, Blighty becomes No. 3 music buyer

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: The music industry: @Mark Honman

In addition, albums increased in length due to the limits in time being expanded by Tape/CD, and manufacturers often ended up trying to cram everything onto a single record

I remember my brother's copy of Olivia Newton-John's greatest hits(*) that came on a single disc. Each track was less than 10mm wide with almost no visible gap between them. I think it was about 90 minutes in total.

(*)Well, okay. I confess. I quite liked listening to it as well(**).

(**)Okay, okay. I also confess I bought the CD a few years back and ripped it to my collection(***).

(***)Which also includes a couple of Eminem albums and Cheryl Cole. I have wide tastes in music. Got some Beethoven on there as well.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: The music industry: Still late for their own funeral

I held out on digital downloads for a long time. Preferring to get the CD then rip to a lossless format for my server and players. But I gave in last year. I eventually got tired of waiting for lossless downloads and with the crappy production standards of modern music (things like The Loudness War) and advancing age I decided I was probably deluding myself that I could hear a difference. And if I could I might be hearing defects rather than music anyway.

I think the simple answer is that most people just don't care enough. A true music enthusiast might find that appalling but I'm more sanguine. Music doesn't exist 'just because' - it exists to entertain and give enjoyment. It still seems to be doing that so I struggle to get really worked up over the issues of delivery media.

Windows 8 has put the world's PC market to sleep - IDC

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: @ Neoc

Just hit the Windows key +D

True but that's an extra key press that ought to be optional. When you get there you discover that the Start Menu has gone. You can work round it (put icons on the desktop, task bar and use the Run dialog) but most users seem to find that inconvenient. Another problem is that with a multi-monitor set up there are glitches and gotchas that grate if you prefer the traditional desktop view.

It's not really 'Desktop Mode' at all. More like 'Desktop if You Really Have to' - like a separate part of the GUI that Microsoft have left in place for legacy applications. It can make you feel like a second class citizen for not using the computer they way Microsoft intend.

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Microsoft still hasn't learned..

Makes you wonder... if VS2012 was such a PoS, what are MS developers using to as a coding environment?

vs2012 is quite good in my opinion. Definitely better than previous versions. It does require you to install a widget to gain control of the colour scheme and another to set up better bookmarking keys (seriously why does MS think that 'go to next/previous' is enough. I want to be able to go to a specific bookmark not cycle through them) but overall it's a good release I think.

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Bottom line

Um, the GUI has been uncoupled from the Kernel for a long time. Probably for ever. The graphics engine got moved back in with the Kernel but not the GUI. You can replace the Windows 'shell' very easily and have always been able to.

List of replacement shells

Some of those are actual replacements, others just resource changes but Classic Shell addresses your main point by providing a Win7 or XP experience for Windows 8.

There's no technical reason why MS had to provide the same experience on all versions of Windows. It's purely a marketing choice. They obviously felt - wrongly in my opinion - that Windows should mean the same thing and look the same regardless of hardware.

Maggie Thatcher: The Iron Lady who saved us from drab Post Office mobes

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

Re: At least two sides to this story

The point is that these changes were abrupt and drastic and insufficient provision was made for things like retraining the people affected leaving them

No - or rather that wasn't my point. I do think there could have been easier ways for what she did. I think she expected too much of people - her insistence that everyone should look after themselves is laudable but a lot of people either struggle with that or else take it to the extreme and refuse to help others.

No, the point I was disputing is this insistence by some people that she should be blamed for the current state of affairs. There has been ample time for change since she left office(*) - and indeed a lot has changed. People should stop living in the past and look toward those leading us now. Or are people saying that she was such a powerful, insightful, capable politician that despite all that's changed since she left office there has still been no-one strong or clever enough to undo her work?

If so then they may not realise what a fantastic epithet that is :)

(*)Mauled by a sheep - the saddest and yet funniest part of her tenure :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: At least two sides to this story

There are still villages and towns today which are derelict and depressed, and full of unemployment and all the social ills.

Really? 30 years (an entire generation later) and you want to blame her? How about blaming the politicians who came after her. The world has changed a helluva lot over the last 30 years and to blame Maggie for the current state of affairs is pretty ridiculous. There's been plenty of time and opportunity for those who came after her to fix the damage. Or hey - maybe you want to go back and blame Gladstone next?

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: Between The Unions and Thatcher

The UK has F*&k all manufacturing base left.

Actually we're still in the top ten - number six or seven I think. But hey - with people like you talking it down all the time and putting people off careers in that sector it might eventually fall further. Way to go - nothing like supporting your own country, eh?

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

She mostly did well by the telecoms sector but one thing I feel she got wrong was denying BT a broadcast license in exchange for a national FTTP program in the early 90s. Now fair enough we don't know how much of its end of the bargain BT would actually have held up but getting foreign companies to come in and set up competing cable networks hasn't worked out very well. Their descendant - VM - had its first ever profitable quarter last year and still has mountains of debt. It's also in the process of being sold to a large US corporation - which may explain why it's suddenly started making a profit.

BT boss barks at TalkTalk for being 'copper Luddites'

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

I'm not sure what copper assets Mr Livingstone is talking about - the MSANs in the exchanges I suppose. I remember several years ago on Thinkbroadband saying that FTTC would be the end of 'true' LLU. TalkTalk will still have a use for their backhaul and the MSANs will still provide useful telephony service but the days of ADSL are numbered. Now that WB(M)C is apparently stable I suspect that the days of needing independent backhaul might also be coming to an end. I think that should worry the LLUOs more than copper assets.

BT have steadily eroded the advantages of LLU and unless FTTP revitalises them I think they may continue to fade. BT's end to end network is plenty good enough for most people and they are amongst the cheapest ISPs as far as the general public are concerned. In that sense at least Mr Livingstone may have a point - BT is not the lumbering laggard that it once was and I think LLUOs have cause to be concerned.

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

Re: Agreed

"BT generally only rollout FTTC in areas with a high concentration of Virgin Media customers

Your anonymous source was spouting crap (fairly typical for a BT employee). I have FTTC and Brackley has no VM presence. Almost all of Bicester can get FTTC yet less than a third of the town can get VM cable. My brother in Carlisle can get FTTC and there's no VM there.

It's true there is overlap but frankly VM should take some of the blame for that. After all the years they've been around they still don't have market dominance in the areas they serve. They are obviously doing something wrong given that cable is a perfectly reasonable way to deliver TV, phone and network services.

Cisco gobbles UK mobe mast maker - you know where this is going

AndrueC Silver badge
WTF?

Re: A precursor to Computing Teleportation

You may laugh, but it's fast becoming a reality...

Hur, hur, hur. Whut?

Swedish judge explains big obstacles to US Assange extradition

AndrueC Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Guarantee from Sweden

What pisses me off is the disproportionate approach taken by the UK. Assange hasn't been charged with any crime in the UK or Sweden, yet Bill Haig is happy to use force to try and retrieve him.

Breach of bail conditions is a crime and as another poster said there might be other charges if it could be shown to be pre-meditated.

William Hague has not yet authorised the use of force to go and get him and shows no signs of doing so.

What else can you tell us about life in your world? We eat bacon here.

Why do they even call it a backup appliance? Just call it an EMC

AndrueC Silver badge
Alert

Good lord. From time to time I have to test/adapt our software to EMC's latest offerings and it's the one I fear the most (NetBackup coming a close second). Typically it takes a few hours to get it installed and sort-of working(*) then actually kicking off the handful of manual backups I want is fraught. I vaguely recall having to create a schedule for manual backups or some-such idiocy.

I dare say for a seasoned admin it all makes sense but not to the casual user.

(*)Usually we get mired in DNS issues and end up being able to kick off backups using the client agent or from the server console but rarely both.

US funds Europa mission

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: Europa the funds

Sorry Luigi, you're reading it wrong. It's to fund a mission to Europa not Europe.

Model S selling better than expected, says Tesla

AndrueC Silver badge
Go

Re: Leccy? No!!

At least it's easier to clean up the pollution from a handful of fixed locations instead of millions of moving locations and easier/quicker to upgrade and take advantage of new generating tech. Both of those are advantages that go a long way toward offsetting any efficiency questions.

Living in the middle of a big city? Your broadband may still be crap

AndrueC Silver badge
Go

Certainly it's pretty good in some rural towns:

http://www.thinkbroadband.com/speedtest/results.html?id=136336489697193611829

But a lot of people are doing tests with wifi and that's generally a bad idea. The above is using a wired connection even though it's a laptop. If I did a wifi test it'd be about 30Mb/s.

BIGGEST DDoS ATTACK IN HISTORY hammers Spamhaus

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Spamhous must really be hurting those parasites

You're right. I wonder why I'm using redirect to 'no-one' then. I know that I've tried both but had an issue of some kind with the rejection option.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Spamhous must really be hurting those parasites

It's difficult to run a mail server at home any more due to the lengths mail server administrators must go through to limit incoming spam

I manage it. I'm not running it on a souped up Cray either. Just a Fit-PC2. 1.1GHz of Intel Atom goodness(*) with 1GB of RAM and Windows 7. On a typical day it gets several dozen spam mails sent to it and sometimes a week or two of someone attempting a dictionary attack. Seems to run fine for me. I'll concede that since we use disposable addresses 99.9% of the spam is sent to the bit bucket without ever reaching a users inbox but since I'm filtering by RCPT TO it still has to be downloaded.

Good old VPOP3.

(*)Stop laughing at the back. It consumes less than 10w of power an hour.

Wealthy London NIMBYs grit teeth, welcome 'ugly' fibre cabinets

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

Actually, the BT ones are very sturdy. They seem to have servers or some form of electric machine inside them as they require 230V and have a fan whirring away inside.

Um - that would be the whole point of the article. It's because the equipment is needed at street level that BT are having to install new cabinets.

Rubbish IT means DEATH for UK Border Agency, announces May

AndrueC Silver badge
Pint

Re: The rise of the machines

they are now computerized and that I need to show up 15 minutes early to fill in new forms

God that made me laugh. You, not so much I suppose.

Have a beer on me as compensation :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

You push the crap department out.

You pull the crap department back.

In, out, in out

Shake it all about.

You do the hokey cokey

And you turn yourself about.

And that's how you fuck it all up.

UK government does the Hokey Cokey.

Virgin Media boss to Osbo: Bung city fibre cash into small biz

AndrueC Silver badge
Pirate

Re: I agree that Virgin should expand their network

Virgin only make money because

Careful now. Last year was the first time they'd ever made a profit. And they still have an absolute fuckton of debt to service. Given the recent takeover I can't help wondering if their recent profitability has been some kind of accounting trickery. Not saying fraud but it's awfully convenient that they turn a profit just in time to be bought out and accountants have a lot of legal tricks they can use.

Security damn well IS a dirty word, actually

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Its the people, not the computer

Having an rough idea about the thing makes You able to use it better - and safer

Yeah that's true. It's also true that knowing the basics can make the other stuff easier. I've heard that knowing Latin make understanding modern languages a lot easier and as you say knowing roughly how a car works will help make you a better driver.

I'm not advocating the totally blinkered view. Just pointing out that life is a compromise and we should accept that and work with it rather than expecting the unlikely. As I suggested: Don't expect people to invest the time and effort in understanding black boxes. Just give them a better black box in the first place :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Childcatcher

Re: Its the people, not the computer

You don't trust everyone you meet face-to-face, so don't trust people you "meet" on the Internet.

Nor every aspect of the APIs you use :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Its the people, not the computer

Its not the computers which make everything easier; its the people who lost their curiosity and interest to find out and discover for themselves why and how things work

Or maybe they are paid for the work they actually produce and can't justify spending hours discovering how the wheel was invented.

Sorry. I didn't mean that to sound snide - you make a good point. I just don't think it reasonable to expect today's software developers to understand every last aspect of their trade. Or where does it end? Am I to be prevented from writing software until I can describe the design of logic gates for AND, OR, NOT? Or perhaps I have to demonstrate an understanding of electron flow inside a transistor? Or perhaps being able to quote Farraday's various laws is essential?

Unfortunately we have to draw the line somewhere and today's IT markets are fast paced and schedule driven. Very few people in IT can afford to devote time to wondering about the how and why of a black box whether it be a logical black box or one that a courier has just delivered. What we need to do is make better black boxes not require everyone to understand them :)

Anyway just to repeat, I liked your post :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Despite evolving existing interfaces

Or perhaps because of. It's good that they evolve but the likes of TIFKAM is a yet higher level abstraction and that requires even higher levels of protection underneath. It's the classic 'ease-of-use' v. 'safe-and-secure' balancing act.

Another side-effect it seems to me is that seasoned, experienced users (the ones best positioned to drive and influence security) tend to be alienated or even behind the curve on UI changes. One scenario I'm concerned about is that a lot of Windows software developers might stick with the traditional desktop and that's not where typical users will be. Yes we can develop for TIFKAM but I bet a lot of us will treat it like cross platform development.

Reg man goes time travelling at iconic observatory

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

A brisk walk up Bosley Cloud also offers a rather fine view over Jodrell and out across the Cheshire Plains.

We used to visit relatives in Leek and I always loved the view of Congleton at night as you came over The Cloud. It wasn't all that big a town back then (1960s/early 70s) but I loved the way it seemed to stretch out in front of you as you crested the top.

Quite, quite lovely. Sniff.

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: set the controls for the heart of the sun

The other kid then proceeded to drive it around some random and very unsolar directions :(

That was probably me. Back when I was young and daft. I'm not young any more though :D

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

I went there a couple of times as a young nipper - we lived at Congleton for a while. I remember eating in the cafe and playing with a control that allowed you to steer something. I don't know if it was a real dish or not. My memory says it was a small dish outside the but surely they didn't let kids steer anything real?

Oi, Microsoft, where's my effin' toolbar gone?

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: Probably a memory issue

You know that exceptions still implement a fixup/tear-down don't you?

Of course but you don't wrap every single allocation. You might perform 10,000 allocations but they will be grouped together so you just guard each group. You might even (esp using RAII) be able to get away with just one try..catch() around whatever passes for your main loop. Or your main event handling loop. Depends mainly on the granularity you want.

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Probably a memory issue

Is there enough memory to do this?

To play devil's advocate that's probably not want you want to do. The reason being that out of memory is actually a rare condition these days. So constantly checking for it is something of a waste of CPU cycles. What you should do is:

<try>

<begin transaction guard>

<do stuff>

<end transaction guard>

<catch>

<message user about lack of resources>

<end>

In other words you react to a rare condition rather than constantly checking for it. Not only avoids wasting CPU cycles but with the transaction guarding (or at least well implemented fixup/tear down) you only have to catch the error in a few places. If you use RAII it mostly falls out of the design as the stack unwinds while the exception propagates back up the stack looking for a handler.

AndrueC Silver badge
Go

Re: There is a simple explanation

That's an extraordinary claim, and as such requires extraordinary evidence.

Evidence 1

"Usability at Microsoft has come a long way in the 10 years it's been around. When the group started, there was one small lab in building 5, in the middle of the oldest part of the Redmond campus. Today there are over 30 individual labs, and even more usability engineers that work with product teams to run the studies"

Evidence 2

Just sayin' ;)

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: There is a simple explanation

It never ceases to amaze or sadden me that apparently the Word UI is the result of extensive testing in usability labs. I'd like to meet some of the people they've been testing it on. Or maybe not. I suspect some of them may not be house trained yet.

AndrueC Silver badge
Unhappy

This is exactly the problem with a lot of technology: they try to shape usage in preconceived patterns.

As you say - if you drive the software like a noddy you have fewer problems but as soon as you try to drive it like someone who knows what you're doing it starts to go pear-shaped. Perhaps we need a special 'geek' mode where the UI doesn't do anything more than is directly requested by the operator.

And is this intelligent UI the reason why basic functionality seems flaky now? Going back to text selection - why is that in recent years it's been so easy to miss the first letter off what you want to select? It's like the OS hesitates before accepting what you're doing as a selection. Or how come sometimes the clipboard just doesn't accept new items? It's odd. Back in the 90s the Windows UI seemed fine but it seems to get less responsive and less reliable as time goes on now.

AndrueC Silver badge
Flame

Word (and it's evil brethren Excel) have a lot of idiocy and most seems to be the result of the application 'knowing best'. I've done what I can to tame mouse selection but it still selects things I don't want - like the start or end of the next paragraph. Delete one paragraph at the end of a section and the heading for the next section changes styles. Nice :(

And on the subject of idiocy - could my fellow developers please consider adding 'Paste as Text' to their friggin products? I know it's kind of cool and sometimes useful to have formatting and colour in the clipboard but a lot of the time it's right pain in the arse. I tend to keep Notepad open these days as an intermediary to strip out the formatting.

I've said many times that over the last decade computers seem to have started getting more and more irritating to use and a lot of it is coming from 'usability' studies or as the author says 'intelligent' software interfaces.

Review: Renault Zoe electric car

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

That’s equivalent to just over 50 litres of unleaded at pre-Budget prices.

Oh. So twice as much as I currently spend on fuel for the Honda Jazz that I use for my 25 mile round trip commute. Plus (I assume) charging costs for leccy. It's the best deal I've seen so far but still not very attractive. Doesn't seem to make sense for town drivers or your typical commuter unless my calculations are off :-/

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

around Lisbon on roads that looked like they had last been repaired just before the Romans pulled out.

So - better than UK roads then?

Review: HTC One

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Why have an extra battery floating around in your pocket...

Because it makes the phone bigger and heavier in almost all cases

Of course if having a svelte phone is a major feature then it's not for you but modern phones are already more than light enough and more than thin enough so doubling either measurement doesn't really make much odds. It's not like you're suddenly turning the clock back thirty years and walking around with a house brick in your pocket :)

As for functionality the only change I've noticed is that if the phone crashes it sometimes can't talk to the battery and won't charge. You have to re-insert the battery to get things back. But it doesn't crash very often (two or three times a year perhaps?) so of no consequence.

AndrueC Silver badge
Go

This does not mean anything

Well..okay. I wasn't going to bother quantifying it but as you asked:

Very few calls or texts.

Checking my POP3 server every 10 minutes.

Listening to music for an hour every day.

And a little bit of general use now and again but not that much. For what it's worth on the standard Desire battery I could just about go 24 hours between charges but that meant charging when it was showing orange. At present I'm charging on Monday mornings and Friday mornings and the display is still green.

I'm just not that much 'into' phones. Never have been. It's just a useful thing to have in my pocket (the sum of it's features rather than any single feature and making calls/texts is actually the least used) and I don't want to become a slave to chargers or be constantly bothering people to borrow theirs.

If I get invited to a dirty weekend on Friday (sadly, not common) I can just get in the car and drive off without having to worry about charging my phone. I know it will comfortably get me through to Monday.

NASA chief: Earth is DOOMED if we spot a big asteroid at short notice

AndrueC Silver badge
WTF?

cataloguing nearly 93 per cent

Out of curiosity - how do they know it's 93%? Surely that implies that you know exactly how many there are in the first place?