* Posts by AndrueC

5086 publicly visible posts • joined 6 Aug 2009

Your anonymous code contributions probably aren't: boffins

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: @Dan 55 (was: C++ ...)

FWIW I believe that the Windows kernel is also written in C but its data structures are objects so in that sense it is object orientated.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

The mainstream idea is that better programmers write shorter and cleaner code which contradicts with line of code statistics

It depends what is meant by 'cleaner' in this instance. Introducing an unneeded variable might be considered 'unclean' but it could improve readability and any half way decent compiler will optimise it out. In my experience short and concise code is harder to read and by trying to be too clever people are more prone to making mistakes.

Unless you're doing embedded coding you can pretty much rely on the compiler to generate better code anyway (especially with languages like C# and Java) so clarity of source is more important than keeping things short.

NASA probe snaps increasingly detailed shots of MOIST DWARF goddess

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Continuing a theme: Maybe it's the Gateway asteroid. Now there's a challenge. I've always wondered if that was one teat I was willing to squeeze :)

Give ALL the EU access to Netflix, says Vince Cable

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: TV Rights

Yeah, I don't know why I even mentioned Ireland. Maybe I meant to type 'Northern Ireland' (but that's probably an insult so let's assume not). Anyway it gave you a good reason to explain an even more stupid situation so that's good :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: TV Rights

There's also the issue of 'FTA' v. 'FTV' that impacts satellite broadcasters. If I'm a UK channel and I want to broadcast the latest blockbuster I don't want to have to pay for the rights to broadcast it EU-wide. Unfortunately if my channel is being broadcast from Eutelsat 28A that's exactly what I'm going to be doing. An unencrypted channel is 'FTA' (Free To Air) and from that satellite anyone of over 300 million people can watch my output. The only workaround if I'm using this satellite would be to encrypt the channel and require viewers to have an appropriate decoding card. If I don't charge more than a handling fee for the card it becomes 'FTV' (Free to View). I can satisfy the rights holders by ensuring that the cards can only be sent to UK addresses.

The better solution would be to broadcast from a transponder that, nominally at least, only covered the UK and Ireland. Unfortunately until recently the only satellite that could do this (Astra 2A) was pretty much full. The refusal to support encryption is why Freesat doesn't carry all the free channels that Sky does. It was also the cause of the delay in getting 5 HD to air. In the end they reached an agreement with someone else (the BBC I think) to sublet space on Astra 2A.

Hopefully now that there's a new bird up there some channels might migrate over but it depends how long their current contracts run although (for better or for worse) it seems like 5 are not interested in going FTA at the moment. They may have an arrangement with Sky which is more lucrative.

One issue around regional rights that might be relevant here is translation. Anything that has to be translated needs to either wait for all translations to be complete or else chances are it'll have been seen by everyone before the translation is complete which lowers the value/revenue from translation.

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: Cable and streaming

@Big_Ted: I think Timmay is trying to make a pun.

Vince Cable v. Virgin Cable

;)

DVRs at the ready tonight: El Reg's motor Vulture is on the tellybox

AndrueC Silver badge
WTF?

Not that long ago (fewer than 10 years) I was helping my Dad sort stuff out after my Mum died and was surprised to find he was renting his telly.

Apparently some people still rent their telephones from BT.

"For example if you are older, disabled or vulnerable you may find it preferable to rent a telephone so that BT will be able to maintain the phone for you".

'maintain the phone for you'. Um..whut? You mean like come out and give it a wipe down once a week?

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Freesat

Sky customers may be able to get it too?

I think it's around there in the Sky EPG as well. Even if not you only need the frequency/symbol rate/polarity and you can manually tune it in.

Edit: Looks like it might be channel 963. That's BBC One South East.

Alternatively unless you live in the provinces (Scotland or NI) BBC HD will be BBC London. They can't afford to carry as many different HD streams so they aren't very regionalised.

Hollywood vs hackers: Vulture cracks Tinseltown keyboard cornballs

AndrueC Silver badge
FAIL

Re: @AndrueC

it's a ploy to keep the un-enlightened on the phone for a critical 59-seconds in the hopes that they can get a local patrol car to the location

That's a pet hate of mine with a lot of cop shows. In the closing scenes when they've worked out where the bad guys are it's usually the main characters who have to get up from their desks, jump into their cars then drive out and storm the premises to make the arrest. In most cases it's going to be quicker to just alert nearby patrols who are probably far closer.

And even worse (Criminal Minds is a big culprit here, along with later CSI seasons) who the hell decides to send expensively trained and educated investigative officers into a probable firefight? You send in the relatively cheap and expendable grunts first not the poindexters!

Bah. I'm definitely sounding like I watch too much TV now.

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

What a terrible show NCIS is

It was okay for the first couple of seasons when it was just a variant of the old cop show format. I mean it was nothing stellar but it entertained. But then they began to develop weird, long running story arcs where they take on the world's most evil people and save western civilisation as we know it all the while trampling over the rights of the general public.

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: "it's a Unix system, I know this"

And I find it odd that you haven't included Jurassic Park.

Or one of the other novels he wrote, Sphere. There's a couple of classics in that. While investigating the strange signals they are getting they refer to them as being the 'Askey' code. Good ol' Arthur :)

Then later on there's a page of digits (and no letters). One of the characters says it's a hex dump (er..no way to know that given that there's no letters) then makes the comment that it can't be from a 68000 processor because they don't work in hex.

The mind boggles :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: CSI?

For CSI whenever they do a fingerprint search I have to resist the temptation to tell them it would be quicker if it didn't waste time rendering the image on the screen :D

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

I thought this was to prevent suggestible loonies actually trying to connect to that fictional IP address. If it's in a movie it must be real, right?

I suppose it could be,actually, although using one of the private ranges would be pretty good.

Similar to the non-existent 555 exchange or area code used in telephone numbers.

Yeah. I think the UK system is better. It makes it harder to spot a fictitious number. Oh and I always rewind to take a quick look at the source code. It seems to nearly always be C.

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Ah, Hollywood and IT. So much unintended humour.

Like IPv4 addresses where one or more octects is often greater than 255.

Or locating someone using the IP address of an email.

Or referring to a GPS device as a 'tracker'. In one example they chose a GPS device because the vehicle was going where there would be no cell phone coverage.

To say nothing of the infinitely zoomable digital image.

NCIS had in intriguing one last week. A laptop that they plugged a USB stick into which managed to infect their network through the power cable. My first reaction was to laugh.

Why would the technician allow the USB device to infect the laptop in the first place? But it's possible to imagine that as the only way to see what it did (a VM might be a better idea but it depends how good the sandboxing is). And she did put the laptop into a Farraday cage to prevent the infection spreading over the wifi network (and a clever virus could switch the wifi on so that was sensible). So that just left the question of an infection spreading through a power cable. Stupid? Maybe not. Perhaps all their laptops come with power-line networking support. Not completely impossible for a covert agency. But frankly I just ended up laughing..which annoyed the other person who was avidly watching it.

But for me the big annoyance is the way Hollywood still insists on having people stay on the line for at least half a minute so that the call can be traced. I don't think that's been needed in the Western world since before the turn of the century.

What will happen to the oil price? Look to the PC for clues

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: Get hungry, not starve...

If I follow one of the many rivers then I won't even get thirsty.

You might get very sick though, unless you boil or filter it. How good are you at fire lighting?

:D

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

Re: Transport counting as survival

Last time I looked, the total human food supply was more than enough to feed everyone but there are still people starving

That's true but there's also a lot of wastage in the system. And I define 'wastage' as being food thrown away and also food being eaten by people that don't need it.

Professor's BEAGLE lost for 10 years FOUND ON MARS

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

former spacecraft like Beagle 2

That made me smile a bit. Yes. After smashing into the surface of Mars it is no longer a spacecraft.

DAMN YOU! Microsoft blasts Google over zero-day blabgasm

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

This does seem like Google being unnecessarily intransigent. The problem is that agreeing to defer the release could be the start of a slippery slope. It's not like Google have sprung this on MS - they've known it was coming for 90 days. And one advantage of Google doing this is that now MS know that when Google says 90 days they mean 90 days.

Speaking personally I can only applaud that particular view. I'm a very punctual person and when I say "I'll be there in five minutes" I mean 300 seconds not some arbitrary and variable time in the future.

I think this is relevant here. The software industry has a bad rep for meeting deadlines already.

Tax Systems: The good, the bad and the completely toot toot ding-dong loopy

AndrueC Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: I wonder - North London commuters

Wouldn't buying a few more coaches for the commuter trains be a bit cheaper?

Figuring out how to save them having to make the journey would be even better. I have to travel 60 miles to get to work (albeit the hour on the train is actually quite pleasant thanks to Chiltern). Yet I have everything I need at home. Okay not everyone does but how about investing in local rentable offices for all major towns. It seems silly to me that any office worker has to travel more than five miles to get to a desk they can use.

An e-reader you HAVEN'T heard of: Cybook Ocean 8"

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

I don't agree about the swipe action being a good thing. I much prefer to have a button under my thumbs that I can just press. That's why I've stuck with my 4th gen Kindle for so long.

Saudi Arabia to flog man 1,000 times for insulting religion on Facebook

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

How ironic that the deified prophet Muhommed is so thin-skinned and fragile that he must rely on these barbaric thugs and atrocities to defend him.

Most of these deities seem pretty weak right from the off. The Christian God (who might well be the same as the Muslim God) apparently gets so lonely that he requires you to talk to him every day. Several times a day if possible. Mind you on the other hand He must be very tolerant because if I had to listen to the moans, whines and pleadings of several billion human beings I'd get out my smiting stick.

AndrueC Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: Stupid Human Tricks

It boggles my mind that most humans still have yet to figure out that religion is completely made up bullshit

Part of it I think is that everyone wants to understand the universe they were born into - they need to understand the world so that they can function in it. Science explains the universe in great detail which can be very difficult to understand and as new discoveries are made it keeps changing its explanation. Religion has the fall back phrase 'Because God made it that way' to avoid complications and because it's mostly the product of imagination it doesn't have to change unless someone wants it to (and look how much trouble it causes when it does schism).

This all means that it's easier to rely on religion to explain your place in the universe so a lot of people do. Relying on science means accepting that we know very little about anything that happens outside of our own minds and for most people that's unsettling.

Up to this point it all just looks like a psychological crutch and if that's what people need to get through their life then fair enough. The problem is that some people have worked out that if you are responsible for explaining another person's view of 'the universe and their place in it' then you have very effective control over that person. It's all downhill from there.

Frontier wipes credit of Elite: Dangerous 'billionaire' badboys

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: A correct decision at the end

CCP's mods might not be the best choice. Their process for deciding to ban players is both opaque, and inconsistent,

It also deliberately tough. Eve has always prided itself on being vicious or to be nice about it they expect players to take responsibility for their own actions. If you fly a Bestower (cheap and cheerful freighter) around with a hold full of Zydrine (usually the most expensive mineral) and get ganked at a gate don't bother crying to the mods. They'll tell you it's your own damn fault for not using any of various alternative game mechanics to transport valuable cargo.

You have to really push the boundaries before the mods will crack down on you. Even camping at a gate and ganking anyone and everyone that comes through is considered acceptable game play. If you complain about it they'll just tell you to find a better route or organise a group of players to take down the gankers.

Mind you toward the end of my time in Eve I used to seek out gankers and fly my Nighthawk back and forth through the gate. A well defended Nighthawk can (could back then) survive almost any practical gate camp and give them a bloody nose while sailing happily toward the gate. I couldn't destroy them but I could waste their ammo and irritate them :D

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Mostly Penniless.

The Spectrum version of the original Elite had a really simple bug. Launch the game, then immediately save the commander. The result was a much improved commander. But then again hacking the save file was easy enough. I remember that you could give yourself 25.5 light-years of fuel ;)

Erik Meijer: AGILE must be destroyed, once and for all

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

My recollection is it mostly involves going nowhere at loggerheads, and kicking each other in the shins.

With your hands or even your head jammed between another player's thighs. I think we've all been to meetings like that.

Alien Earths are out there: Our home is not 'unique'

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Although by the sound of it, any super-intelligent hive mind civilisation, collection of beings of pure light or similar that might have the astro kitchen to actually follow this recipe might not bother.

I think that any super advanced civilisation will build its own space habitats and largely ignore worlds with natural ecosystems. The damn' things are so fragile and getting goods up from the bottom of a gravity well is such a drag. Far better to build an orbital. You control the thermostat if you want to leave it you just walk off the edge.

It's 2015 and ATMs don't know when a daughterboard is breaking them

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: First rule

Mostly because it's a waste of everyone's time

I agree but I've taken that a bit further and hardly ever use cash(*). At a guess I have to get some twice or maybe three times a year. Even then I usually get it from colleagues by offering to put the Friday lunch bill on my plastic if they give me their paper :)

(*)That was a problem for a while because I almost completely ran out of coins to put in parking meters but then someone invented pay by phone and now that doesn't matter(**).

(**)Although I wish they'd agree on a single app for all car parks to use and there is small additional charge for the service.

Renault Captur: Nobody who knows about cars will buy this

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

my Wifes Megane 1.5 replacing the headlight bulbs entails jacking up the car

My Honda Jazz is similar but apparently if you turn the wheels, have thin hands and can work blind you can skip the jack and wheel removal.

The weirdly-synched life of the Google Nest household

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Smart Thermostats

Are there any that can just learn how long your home takes to warm up and have a facility so you can tell it "Don't come on this evening, I'm off to the pub instead"?

The former, yes - just search for Optimum Start. I bought my Honeywell CM67 over ten years ago. There's no specific function for 'don't bother this evening' but I can tell it I'm on holiday until tomorrow which should have the same effect.

AndrueC Silver badge

How can you do this if it has no remote control. You are on business, you then find you are going to be away a couple of extra days

Sorry, I misread what you wrote(*). Obviously that wouldn't be possible. As I wrote a bit later on remote control could occasionally be useful. What I'm taking issue with is the idea of it turning my heating on based solely on a location change (or lack thereof). In most cases that would be too late to do anything. I have a 90 minute commute but during winter that often wouldn't be long enough for it start the heating. If I had a more typical half hour commute that'd further reduce the usefulness of the feature.

(*)Distracted by work. I seem to have broken something this morning :-/

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

you are going to be away on business for a couple of extra days with the house empty you can just let your thermostat know to remain on a low setting for a few more days

Which mine can also do. I can also tell it that I'm going to be at home tomorrow so use the Sunday program. Or I can tell it I'm having friends over so run the Sunday program for the next few hours. The only thing I can't do is remotely control it although apparently there was once a telephone remote control module you could buy for it.

My main issue really is with the heuristic guessing logic and the much vaunted 'just in time heating' which was what I was complaining about here. It's a bit like cooking dinner for your partner. If they say they are going to be an hour late that's fine. But if they say 'I'll be a bit late' it throws everything into question. It'll be a sad day for humanity when your thermostat responds to a command by asking 'Yes, but how late is late exactly?'.

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

change your thermostat settings when you arrive (warm the house up)

Which at this time of year means that the house should be nicely up to temperature a few hours later. Just in time for me to go to bed. This idea of the heating going on and off with my movements seem to completely ignore the inherent latency in most heating systems. My heating manages to raise temperature at 2 degrees an hour during winter, sometimes less on a really cold day. At this time of year my heating needs more of a head start than 'oh look, he's putting his keys in the front door'.

Luckily I have a thermostat with optimum start that I bought over a decade ago. It's not connected to the cloud but it does know how long it takes my heating to do things so it ensures that the house at the temperature I want when I need it.

UKIP website TAKES A KIP, but for why?

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Damned web browsers. Coming over to our server and taking all the data. We'll put a stop to that!

Beyond the genome: YOU'VE BEEN DECODED, again

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: @Trevor

I care not what role mosquitoes serve.

On that subject there's a curious (and quite readable) book by Amitov Ghosh.

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: Odd statement

iI'd like to know which species tried and failed to decode their own genomes.

Melopsittacus Undulatus. The project was going really well at first but then one of them invented the mirror and funds were immediately diverted into finding out who was doing all the cloning.

Healthcare: Look anywhere you like for answers, just not the US

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: I don't get the mentality of the US healthcare consumers.

From memory, so don't take this as gospel, NHS spending per head of population is some $3,500 a year. So $7,000 vfor a couple ain't that different really.

That was more or less the conclusion me and my ex-US colleagues came to when we compared life on both sides of the Atlantic. From a purely financial point of view it seemed about equal. There seemed to be only three significant differences:

* A lot of what they bought was bigger or 'better' in some other way. Housing being an obvious example although I was told that on the Eastern seaboard the difference isn't quite as extreme with land scarcity being an issue there.

* They get more choice. They don't have to lose a chunk of their income to pay for health care if they don't want. Possibly it's a Hosbon's choice but choice is usually a Good Thing(TM).

* In the UK if you're one of life's losers life is a bit naff but you're usually healthy and can get by. In the US if you're one of life's losers life is hell. We reckoned that it was a lot easier to become a loser in the US if things went wrong. That is to say that the my US colleagues were a lot more scared about how they'd cope if they lost their jobs than we were.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Thoughts

The big problem for the NHS is mainly inefficiency on the clerical side.

A couple of years back my optician referred me to my GP and I spent two years having regular appointments to see a specialist for monitoring. The appointments consisted of half an hour for an eye test and half an hour to discuss the results. So they'd book me in for an hour. When the confirmation came (and the reminder nearer the time) I'd get two letters, one for the first half hour, another for the second half hour. Something of a waste of postage methinks :-/

Thankfully nothing was found to be wrong. Well..sorta. I still didn't do very well on their visual field test but the consultant's view was that since the machines claimed I was half blind and couldn't read and since we spent ten minutes comparing golf stories he thought the machines were wrong. His parting comment was "If it's not bothering you, it doesn't bother me."

This one shall pass! Not even a flesh wound from ‘Monty Python’ SPACE ROCK

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

An asteroid. An. Asteroid.

30 years ago today, the first commercial UK 'mobile' phone call was made

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Meanwhile back in the early 70s

Cannon used to have one in his car as well.

Mind you that was a dangerous car. It seemed like every time he got into it someone hit him on the head and kidnapped him.

Survey: Tech has FREED modern workers – to work longer hours

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: No Surprise

Email is down.

When algorithms ATTACK: Facebook sez soz for tacky 'Year in Review' FAIL

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

Re: Seems my most popular post was photos of the daughter I lost as well.

seems most people never think about life from any other perspective but their own.

Isn't that really why FB exists in the first place?

BT takes broadband to NEW PLACES. That's right: CITIES

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Who Pays

If I didn't want to pay the extra then I'd get copper from the cabinet instead of fibre just as BT seem to be currently proposing.

Well BT are already offering FTTPoD - FTTP on Demand - in several FTTC areas so the concept isn't new to them. I don't know what it would cost to pull fibre through a building but I'd assume that if there's service ducting it shouldn't be all that expensive. But then again the pricing for FTTPoD is knicker wettingly scary.

But does the tenant pay and accept they are improving someone else' property?

Do you try and get the landlord to pay?

Does BT just absorb the cost?

Frankly the latter two seem very unlikely.

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Even cheaper

IIRC most DSLAMs in exchanges are capable of VDSL2 but aren't allowed due to the apparent noise on the rest of the lines - though how this doesn't effect lines from the cabinet I don't know

ANFP. But for the record it's worth pointing out that this isn't some stupid government 'jobsworth' rule. Nor is it something BT have decided not to do for their own reasons. It's the considered opinion of skilled and experienced engineers across the industry who presumably know what they are doing.

BT are following the rules imposed on them. Bah, humbug :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

You would rather hope that having got fibre into the building, there might be an option to run it all the way to the premises

Absolutely. All BT needs is to agree with the property owner/residents who is going to pay to pull all the cabling through the walls, under the floors or over the ceilings ;)

Give nerds their own PRIVATE TRAIN CARRIAGES, say boffins

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Really Hard Living in London

Think yourself lucky you have some form of transport, most folks outside the M25 have to rely on cart tracks and charabancs

Oh not entirely. I'll give a grateful shout out to Chiltern Railways for managing a very reliable and pretty fast service between London and Birmingham. It's true that some people have to stand but usually only those who get on at the penultimate B'ham stop so it's only for five minutes.

Oh and CR offer free wifi. And quite zones (though sadly you do get the occasional bell-end who can't read or just doesn't care).

ICANN HACKED: Intruders poke around global DNS innards

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: Come on - TheReg should know better

I'd say it was then about time that a lot of people grew up. It appears that anyone with enough time on their hands will eventually find a term, a word or a phrase which offends them.

In my book, if you decide to behave like a c**t then you have to accept to be treated like a c**t.

That's apparently why the Honda Fit is called the Honda Jazz in EMEA :)

Ofcom mulls selling UK govt's IPv4 cache amid IPv6 rollout flak

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

'Infinity' is not another name for 21CN. It's sad how successful BT have been in making people think that it is - a bit like a lot of people still talk about using their Hoover when in fact most of us have vacuum cleaners made by other manufacturers.

Anyway to set the record straight: No, BT Infinity does not currently support IPv6. However Infinity is just a BT Retail product built using the BT Openreach FTTC infrastructure. The FTTC stuff is perfectly capable of carrying IPv6 traffic as it's basically just an Ethernet link(*). Several other ISPs offer IPv6 over FTTC (and indeed, over ADSL).

AAISP, IDNet are two and I think there are a couple of others. Even Plusnet (a part of BT these days) has had a trial running for a couple of years now. There are also rumours that some of PN's newer gateways support IPv6 so a roll-out could be imminent.

(*)Ignoring some fancy tunnelling behind the scenes.