* Posts by AndrueC

5086 publicly visible posts • joined 6 Aug 2009

EFF urges Chrome users to get out of the Privacy Sandbox

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Adverts? What are them then?

Not seen any on my web browser since installing UBlock Origin. Not seen any on TV since deciding nearly 20 years ago to stop watching it live.

The home Wi-Fi upgrade we never asked for is coming. The one we need is not

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: An awful lot of the UK housing stock

Been a race to the bottom for a while now. Minimise build costs, minimise land usage.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: An awful lot of the UK housing stock

Unlike the USA where STUD walls dominate much of the UK housing stock has brick or breeze block walls which are a problem with 5G signals.

I'm not sure it's as 'bad' as that. My house was built in 1991 and has stud walls so that would lead me to assume that every house built in the last 30 years does. Given how many houses have been built since then I'm not convinced that solid walls 'dominate'. They might even be the minority.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Lol, this is not a new idea. I'm still using my original BT supplied HG612 in modem mode and my own supplied Vigor router doing all the clever stuff.

I would never use an ISP that insisted on me using their router and as I've posted here before I dislike ISPs that promote themselves on the basis of their router's Wifi capabilities. I will never believe that an ISP supplied router (nominally supplied for free) will ever be as good as a router that I have chosen myself and have paid money for.

I'm with IDNet and although they will sell a router it's a reasonably good off-the shelf router and all they do is configure it for your account. You don't have to buy it and they are quite happy to let their customers use their own routers and will even try and help you with them although understandably they advise that if they didn't supply it there might be a limit as to what they can do.

The alternative to stopping climate change is untested carbon capture tech

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Carbon sinks

Those sinks are only temporary. Trees die for various reasons and the carbon is released back into the environment. Planting new forest is useful initially but existing forest somewhat less so.

Switch to hit the fan as BT begins prep ahead of analog phone sunset

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: I wonder

Well, except for the batteries, generator, and redundant switching equipment. All the things which make the ordinary telephone network far, far, more reliable and resilient than a broadband internet link.

The question was concerning the cost of making a call, not the reliability.

The clue is in the way it was phrased:

How much it will be to make a "phone" call to another digital only user across their "phone" network?

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: I wonder

It'll cost the same as now or less. From the consumer's point of view it's a like-for-like change.

99% of a telephone call in the UK has been digital for several decades now. Even System X is digital.

"Each analogue line module unit converts analogue signals from a maximum of 64 subscriber lines in the access network to the 64 kilobit/s digital binary signals used in the core network."

All that's happening here is the removal of the last remaining analogue component in the last mile..or perhaps more correctly moving it from the exchange into the subscriber's home.

Lawsuit claims Google Maps led dad of two over collapsed bridge to his death

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Pointless to complain.

I reckon my request to Google is way down the list. I just want the sat nav voice to say 'Pavillons Way' rather than 'Pavilions Way'. The map has it correctly marked so it must just be some kind of vocalisation issue. Perhaps the logic just refuses to use French words when outputting directions in English.

Getting to the bottom of BMW's pay-as-you-toast subscription failure

AndrueC Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Bolted Horses @SonofRojBlake

In case people had not noticed, Sky has a large number of broadcast channels that are not easily available elsewhere

Most of my viewing is Discovery, Sky History, Crime & Investigation and ID (I wish they'd provide an HD version of that) and other than VM I don't know if any of those are available elsewhere. Nat Geo used to be another popular one but seems to have gone off the boil for me recently.

People have this view of Sky subscribers as only wanting to watch all the latest US dramas but not all of us do. I only have a few Sky owned channel in my favourites list and of those the most watched - Sky History - has only recently been taken over.

Most of what I watch is carried on relatively minority channels and whilst it might be possible to find things elsewhere I doubt it's as convenient. And convenience (aka 'inertia') is a significant factor not to be overlooked. I could spend my time trawling the 'net trying to find stuff or else I could do what I've done for years. Browse the EPG during quiet moments and mark things to be recorded. When it comes to watching I just fire up the box and TV and look to see what's already on the box waiting to be viewed. My 2GB Sky Q box is currently 62% full with new programming waiting for me to watch.

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Bolted Horses

It still baffles me how Sky+ subscribers are happy to pay money for the ability to record broadcast programming they can otherwise freely receive on a hard disk that sits under the TV they'll watch them on.

Not all of the programming available on Sky is available on free platforms. I haven't kept up to date with channel line-ups across platforms but many years ago I had a Freesat recorder and some channels that were available on 'Free TV from Sky' were not available on 'Freesat'. There were quite a lot of channels that were restricted to Sky because while they were FTV (Free To View) they weren't FTA (Free To Air). Freeview was another option I had and again a slightly different line-up.

It's possible that some people felt it worth paying for Sky+ in order to be able to view their favourite 'free' channel.

But I suspect inertia was also a factor. Either that or some people actually like to keep copies of programmes to watch over and over(*) so might have kept paying the fee to ensure they have access to their library.

(*)I've never understood why. There is almost nothing that I would wish to watch more than once and so much new stuff coming out that I'm happy to spot the rare example and record it again. I have a strict record-watch-delete policy :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Bolted Horses

What bugs me about Sky is that they want you to pay £X per month and still shovel adverts down your throat.

Without the adverts it would be £X+Y per month. But why let it bug you? Sky's service is not and never has been essential. It's a luxury service and entirely optional. Either you consider it worth the money or you don't.

And if adverts bother you then stop watching live TV! If you record everything you can skip the adverts quite effectively. Fastforward can be tedious but many years ago even Sky finally relented and implemented the 'jump 30 seconds' feature. I haven't watched live TV at home since Sky+ was first launched for just that reason. Skipping over an ad-break becomes quite automatic.

It's also worth noting that not all the channels (not even the majority) available on the Sky platform are owned by Sky. Channels that don't have 'Sky' in their name are independent and are just paying to be listed on the EPG and (if they want/need it(*)) to have their data stream encrypted using the Sky system.

(*)One or both of two reasons: One because they are renting space on a satellite that covers multiple regions and have to be able to demonstrate to rights holders that they can control which markets have access to the programming (viewing cards are tied to postcodes). Two because they rely on the Sky kickbacks and want to prevent people watching their output without a Sky box.

Scientists trace tiny moonquakes to Apollo 17 lander – left over from 1972

AndrueC Silver badge
Trollface

One born in the U S of A!

I was watching a show about car renovation recently and two of the engineers were arguing over fractions of an inch while trying to calculate a centre line and cutting point for a box. I so wish I could have been there to turn their rulers the other way round and measure everything in millimetres.

God bless America..because they need all the help they can get.

IBM Software tells workers: Get back to the office three days a week

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

You only need to heat the room you're working in. So close the door and use an oil filled radiator. If it's a small room it shouldn't take much energy to keep it warm between you, the computer, monitors and the radiator.

The walk to/from a chilly kitchen ain't gonna kill anyone so just let the rest of the house cool down like it would if you weren't there.

22 million Brits suffer broadband outage blues and are paying a premium for it

AndrueC Silver badge
Stop

Re: Turning off copper phonelines

BT who own the network, wants to turn off all copper phone lines (PSTN) by 2025.

No they don't (well they might want to but they know they can't). What BT is turning off is something called WLR which is just the wholesale voice service. Copper lines will remain active and in use across the country and will only be turned off if/as/when an exchange reaches an FTTP threshold of 75% (presumably at that point they will also fill in the remaining 25%).

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: We have bigger things to worry about

Your ISP should be able to provide you with a plug and play solution. If not just sign up for a VoIP provider and port your number. I signed up with Vonage and they just send out a small box that you attach to your LAN and that has a normal telephone port. No config required.

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: Big city not always better...

Sorry but what you're describing, 60Mbps, is not good, is not broadband, isn't speedy. That should be the lowest by law.

What is that you can't do with a 60Mb/s connection? Even when shared by a family. Tell us what makes it inadequate, please, because 60Mb/s is enough for two or three UHD streams with plenty left over for email and gaming(*).

(*)Admittedly not if you include game updates but that just requires patience or scheduling the updates for when no-one is stream UHD video.

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Lateral thinking

I live in a town that has 50K population and has been around for 70+ years.

Large sections are Not spots for Mobile coverage and Telephone networks are also mostly 50 years old as well .... i.e. Old copper mostly routing where the population is not !!!

In short, Broadband is quite bad and mobile cover is also. Not in prosperous south so not pulling in money to encourage investment in inproving our lot !!!

No need to be coy - name and shame.

Use this site to show us the availability.

AndrueC Silver badge

Hmm, I believe people in UK typically buy the only thing available at their address, which in 99% of cases is ADSL (so no broadband).

Rubbish.

https://www.uswitch.com/broadband/studies/broadband-statistics

"UK broadband statistics show that there were 27.8 million fixed broadband lines in the UK at the end of Q3 2022—an increase of 91,000 (0.3%) year-on-year. Of these, around 70% (19.4 million) were predominantly FFTC or full fibre variants"

That's nearly two years ago.

https://www.cable.co.uk/broadband/guides/broadband-availability-snapshot/

"Broadband Technology Availability Percentage

ADSL 97%

FTTC 96%

FTTP 22%

Cable (Virgin Media FTTC) 53%"

Almost every property in the UK has access to VDSL.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

I doubt it. Time and time again the UK core network has been shown to have ample capacity. Everyone suddenly working from home didn't bother it. Apple releasing an iUpdate doesn't bother it. Major sporting events don't bother it. There is no issue with the capacity of the core networks (there are multiple such networks) and historically no reason to think that is going to change.

AndrueC Silver badge

UK infrastructure seems to be stuck in the 2 tin cans and a bit of string era

Not really and by 2026 the figure should be over 90%.

If everyone in the UK took the highest speed service they could get our average would be a lot higher. However people in the UK typically buy on price rather than speed. To be honest given how few services actually need more than 20Mb/s that might be quite sensible. A 60Mb/s FTTC connection would be more than adequate for most families even if they enjoy UHD streaming.

And I do suspect that most of these issues are down to the ISP rather than the physical connection. That's based on my own experience (a couple of complaints from neighbours but perfect service for me) and from following forums like Thinkbroadband.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Most Brits find broadband outages to be almost as annoying as someone jumping a queue? If it is that annoying how come so few people are willing to spend an extra £5/month on a decent ISP?

I agree with you and yes it depends where the fault really are. Were they in the cabinet, exchange, backhaul or their actual ISP's servers?

Mind you I suppose we could argue that if everyone was prepared to pay a bit more then it would filter down to the underlying supplier thereby addresses issues in the last mile.

Mozilla calls cars from 25 automakers 'data privacy nightmares on wheels'

AndrueC Silver badge
Headmaster

Re: Tesla Dashboards

You don't really own modern cars. Yes, you might have paid a load of £££/$$$ for it and have not only the receipts but the V5/title but if the maker can brick your car at will then... who really owns it? They do.

The UK V5 document never did indicate ownership. It only records who the registered keeper is ie;who will be assumed to be responsible for any offenses committed with/by the vehicle.

Microsoft billing 3 cents a minute to revisit tedious Teams meetings via API

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

The best thing about meetings was when they were over. I have never felt the urge to revisit them so why would I want to add notes?

Intel seems to think Wi-Fi 7 is too cool for old-school Windows 10

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

application developers have learned not to ask for admin privleges unless they really need it.

So a success in that area at least. As a developer one aspect that irritated me was the installation process and especially the weird changes and choices around installation folders over the years.

Trying to create an installer that could handle ever scenario (corporate and consumer) was a pain in the arse.

China's top EV battery maker announced a breakthrough, but top boffin isn't convinced

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: Charger power rating

Most people charging at home will only be topping the battery up.

If chargers are readily available the driver just has to make a minor mental adjustment. Instead of running the car until it's almost out of charge (like most of us do with ICE(*)) you charge them every time you park them. Most cars only do about 30 miles a day so even if your employer or shopping centre doesn't offer a charging facility you're still only putting 10% of the battery capacity in when you get back home. Most EVs will be recharged within fifteen minutes even on a slow charger.

(*)Okay so the more sensible of us think about refilling when the gauge says half empty but still. EV charging should be a different mindset. Very few car journeys require the vehicle to be driven for hundreds of miles between recharge points and if charging points are frequent enough it just isn't necessary.

80% of execs regret calling employees back to the office

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

What they did was worry about the state of their business and tried to make themselves feel more in control by forcing their employees back into the office. "I can't control the sales but by Tutatis I can force my employees to be sat at their desks by 9am!"

For some managers it might even just be a pathetic attempt to create value for their position. They have realised that with no-one in the office and everyone working happily from home they had no purpose any longer.

I retired rather than go back into the office. The company lost one of their best and most experienced software developers. Good strategy, guys.

Google launches $99 a night Hotel Mountain View for hybrid workers

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Bye-bye!

After praising management for seeing sense last year and not asking us to return to the office they've changed their minds and now want us in two days a week. So I've handed in my resignation and will be starting my retirement a few months early. Viva la resistance!

Soon the most popular 'real' desktop will be the Linux desktop

AndrueC Silver badge
Trollface

So what you're saying is that Linux is going to be left behind again. "Billy no mates" in the cloudy digital age.

At least it's doing well in the server market.

MIT boffins build battery alternative out of cement, carbon black, water

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: For lazy Americans (most of us), cement = concrete

Yes it's tortoisesturtles all the way down :)

Florida man accused of hoarding America's secrets faces fresh charges

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: You sure are preoccupied by Trump and Musk!

NO ONE is above the law in the US or Canada, not even a Prime Minister or President.

That has yet to be proven.

Being accused of something is not the same as being convicted of something.

What does Twitter's new logo really represent?

AndrueC Silver badge
Trollface

Re: Musk deserves all the bile he gets and more

The son of prominent basketball player LeBron James.

Who? What's 'basketball'? Is it like netball?

Logitech reports broad declines as pre-pandemic buying cycles return

AndrueC Silver badge
Unhappy

I'm going to cry the day my Harmony remote finally fails. There seems nothing else on the market to replace it.

Linux has nearly half of the desktop OS Linux market

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Like the other 95% of desktop users I've been using 'something else'.

Linux on the desktop is an almost vanishingly small minority not helped by all the stupid spats over which 'distro' is best. Nothing that happens in the 'Linux desktop arena' is of any importance beyond the handful of people still clinging to it.

Face it. As a desktop operating system Linux is an abject failure. Possibly not for technical reasons but still - it is providing a desktop experience to such a small percentage of users that really if it reverted to being nothing but a console-based server OS the world wouldn't care.

AndrueC Silver badge
Trollface

It's funny because it's true.

And also because it matters not a jot. Linux is just not and never has been a factor on the desktop.

First of Tesla's 'bulletproof' Cybertrucks clunks off production line

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Joke

Just drop the engine first. It only takes a minute.

Mind you that puts me in mind of the Haynes instructions for gapping an Austin Metro's distributor.

"First remove the radiator as described in chapter...".

Actually all you needed was to grab a passing street urchin and ask them to remove the cap.

Miscreants exploit five Microsoft bugs as Windows giant addresses 130 flaws

AndrueC Silver badge
Facepalm

Visual Studio is a big enough time waster as it is without becoming a platform for malicious attacks.

NASA 'quiet' supersonic jet is nearly ready for flight

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: less-noisy maybe but still un-sound

I was playing golf when the jets were scrambled a month or so ago. A mate of mine is a bit miffed that he took his swing about half a minute before the boom. It would've been so much more impressive if it had coincided with the boom.

Actually it wasn't so much a boom as a bang.

The number’s up for 999. And 911. And 000. And 111

AndrueC Silver badge

Re: I still have analog landlines.

BT switching off POTS does not directly impact the copper wires and does not imply or require that FTTP be available.

All BT are doing is withdrawing their WLR (Wholesale Line Rental) product. Any CPs that have unbundled their voice service (eg; Talk Talk or Sky) can continue to offer an analogue service if they want to although I'd guess that they too would rather see the back of it and will see this as an opportunity to get out of the market as well.

In any case the ending of WLR or whatever voice service you have just means that you will have to switch to a VoIP service. Whether that VoIP service is carried over copper, FTTP or waved flags is irrelevant.

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: Multiple redundancy

I talk to people who say, I'm ditching my landline because money, and I say, don't, because when something happens the mobile network will be locked up and I quote "I'll just connect to a different mobile tower" *sigh* and this from a person using a Hubitat smart home...

Another issue is that if some scrote breaks in to your house and burgles you they might take your computer and your mobile phone but they are unlikely to bother taking a an old landline handset. Thus when you get in/wake up you still have a means of contacting people to sort the mess out.

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: How about 112 and Advanced Mobile Location?

Yes (sort of). When I subscribed to my VoiP service I had to supply an address that was linked to the device. I forget what the wording was but it implied that was a legal requirement and me it clear it had to be the address where the device was located.

I wrote 'sort of' because I don't think my VoIP box is tied to my IP address so if the box could be moved and would probably still work thus invalidating the location information.

Microsoft puts profanity filter on %@!#ing Teams transcripts

AndrueC Silver badge
WTF?

Re: whose swear words?

They also seem a lot more precious about it. I remember several years ago while on a business trip watching daytime TV. One of the characters got their head blown apart by a gunshot quite graphically but their partner's response was bleeped out.

WTF kind of country is it that considers the gore of a head being blown apart to be fine to watch whilst objecting to profanity?

AndrueC Silver badge
Mushroom

They could reduce the amount of profanity I use by spending some time fixing the bugs in Visual Studio.

It's 2023 and memory overwrite bugs are not just a thing, they're still number one

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Backward compatibility is probably the biggest issue for Windows (it being driven by the marketing and finance department the next biggest).

Truth is that software development resources are hard to find (have been for decades) and most managers can't afford to have them working on stuff that has no financial or marketing driven purpose. People continue to use old applications because they are used to them (warts and all) and the sheer number and variety of users it directly supports imposes a massive burden on the Windows development team.

Linux has - possibly - more people overall dependant on it now but the vast majority are only secondarily dependant (they do things that rely on a Linux server backend). That reduces and simplifies the interface between old and new code.

Microsoft investigating bug in Windows 11 File Explorer that makes the CPU hangry

AndrueC Silver badge

Meh. It's part of a theme. Visual Studio takes 15% of my CPU while idle. Just all part of Microsoft's cunning planshitty programming.

If I wasn't going to retire within the next 12 months I'd give a shit.

Amazon Prime too easy to join, too hard to quit, says FTC lawsuit

AndrueC Silver badge
Happy

Re: It is not just Amazon

On the other hand when I called Sky to cancel Netflix last year they offered to let me have my package (ie; everything except Netflix) for half price if I just agreed to sign up for another 12 months. I didn't have to ask and there was no hard sell. The lady just removed Netflix then said something like "Oh, you know what? I could reduce your subscription by half if you are happy to sign up for a 12 month contract".

Since I hadn't intended to leave anyway it was a no-brainer :)

AndrueC Silver badge
Mushroom

The UK judgement appears to have achieved nothing. For the past few months I've had to scroll back up the order form to confirm that I really don't want Prime after I select the free delivery option.

It's a shit UI and someone at Amazon should be ashamed.

I don't want their free TV and music and I don't give a toss when items actually arrive. I just want to pay the lowest cost possible and I actually enjoy the randomness of free delivery.

Fuck off and stop trying to get me to subscribe to Prime or I'll go elsewhere,

Florida man insists he didn't violate the law by keeping Top Secret docs

AndrueC Silver badge
Unhappy

What a knob he is.

Google changes email authentication after spoof shows a bad delivery for UPS

AndrueC Silver badge
Boffin

Re: "Based on the message trajectory from email headers"

Another problem (arguably what's at the heart of all email issues) is that the headers can be faked anyway. The headers need not be (and usually aren't) read by the receiving mail server other than perhaps a cursory syntax check.

The mail delivery process is basically 'Hi, my name is Beelzebub. Please chuck these bytes into this/these mailboxes.'.

The sending machine can put anything it wants into these headers. The actual content of the headers is unimportant and ignored by most mail servers. This is why I can send you an email that is apparently addressed to someone completely different and sent from someone fictitious. If you've ever received spam that claims to have been sent by yourself then this is how. The sender just puts your email address into the 'Reply To' or 'From' field and the server doesn't care.

The only sure fire way to know where an email came from and validate the recipient is to monitor the initial handshake process on the server. The SMTP command 'RCPT TO' is what directs the email to an inbox not the 'To' field in the header. And it's only at the point of handshake that you can be sure who the sender is because you know the source IP address and can trace the sender from there.

This is why I continue to run my own mail server. It has the ability to filter on 'RCPT TO' and do other good things at the handshake level. I really can stop the spam at the front gate and senders can't mask their identity. I use a Disposable Email Address system and give every contact their own unique address. In conjunction with RCPT TO filtering I know who is responsible for every email. And if I get spam sent to an address I only gave you then I have the option of blacklisting the address thus stopping future spam and not bothering to issue you with another unique address thus severing our email relationship.

Google HR hounds threaten 'next steps' for slackers not coming in 3 days a week

AndrueC Silver badge
Meh

Re: if it ain't broke, don't "fix" it

It was difficult to get through to HMRC twenty years ago. It's always been difficult.

Man sues OpenAI claiming ChatGPT 'hallucination' said he embezzled money

AndrueC Silver badge
Joke

Re: > OpenAI shouldn't put out "AI" that consistently spews complete bullshit,

It's certainly not berry good.