Re: Radio 4 this morning.
What Tierney is saying is that a commenter does not have the right for the article to be removed from the search results, because their privacy is not being breached. At least, not by the CJEU's criteria.
But Google removed it anyway.
Remember that Gonzalez only won because the law had not kept pace with technology; a) the info being continually re-published is irrelevant and out of date and b) Google is a massive, pervasive information source, with huge social impact, and it's continually republishing this info via its search results "snippets".
A responsible search engine would have done this:
"Oh, hello, we've got a request from a commenter on some page we've indexed. We'll reject it and they can complain to the ICO".