* Posts by Peter2

2945 publicly visible posts • joined 12 Jun 2009

NSA: We 'don't know when or even if' a quantum computer will ever be able to break today's public-key encryption

Peter2 Silver badge

Sorry, no fiver. :)

One time pads are a pretty obvious solution to getting virtually unbreakable encryption; coming up with a digital version of this isn't exactly rocket science. The only real question there is if he got the idea from hearing of an actual implementation of this, which wouldn't surprise me. It was my first thought, so i'd be surprised if there weren't hundreds of independent implementations of this from places like the CIA who wouldn't want a risk of somebody recording their satellite traffic and then decoding it, even 20 years down the line.

Picking a combination of some form of external input is also reasonably obvious; anybody going to this sort of paranoia induced extent is hardly going to rely upon a pseudo-random number generator as you'd assume the worst case that the RNG might have some kind of a deliberately inbuilt pattern to it that might compromise your encryption scheme.

Microwaving the CD's though as a destruction method is something i'm not sure about, i'd have thought that would just destroy the plastic and risk leaving the data layer alive, which could possibly be recovered by somebody sufficiently determined in a lab. I'd have thought a metal container, a can of lighter fluid and a match would have been safer. :)

Peter2 Silver badge

Quantum proof encryption? It's not actually that difficult to come up with completely impregnable methods of dealing with cracking keys. Using one time pads would be utterly Quantum proof if the concern is basically brute forcing keys as so far as I can see, and with modern hardware could be implemented relatively easily.

Take two 8TB hard drives full of a solid block of data, and put one at two locations to be used as encryption keys between them. Then encrypt each character going over the connection with that data, deleting it when used. There would be enough data on the drives to encrypt all traffic going over a 100mbps connection for 7.7 days, assuming my math is right. (A 100 megabits per second line divided by 8 to get from bits to bytes is 12.5 megabytes a second, and taking a 8192GB drive, which is 8388608MB divided by the 12.5MB/s gives you 671088.64 seconds worth of use, which is 11184.81 minutes, 186.41 hours = 7.7 days)

Key exchange would be a pain in the ass because it would have to be done by physically delivering drives by somebody trusted, but even at constant 100mbps use maxing out the line it'd only need doing once a week so it's not unfeasible; it'd also be utterly impregnable and perfectly suitable for use between you and your bank, or for VPN's used in a hub and spoke model. Where it falls down flat is between you and random websites that you wouldn't have a one time pad from.

Well, that and acquiring 8TB worth of random data without using a RNG that could be cracked, but you could get pretty random numbers via things like instruments attached to a computer such as digital thermometers tracking the temperature to 20 digits and the same with EM field sensors etc.

Logitech Bolt devices support secure Bluetooth Low Energy – but forget the 'Unifying Receiver'

Peter2 Silver badge

To be fair, I have an office full of their low end wired gear (eg K100, M100 etc), which is very good value for money compared to any of the competition at a similar price point.

Most cheap stuff is pretty crap; with keyboards the legs break or keys die, mouse buttons/wheels break in normal use etc. With the Logitech stuff the biggest problem is that the lettering eventually wears off from many hundreds of thousands of keypresses.

Children of China, your state-sanctioned hour of gaming begins … now!

Peter2 Silver badge

Back in ye old days we had games that travelled around on floppy disc or CD/DVD. These were good, and aimed to be so much fun that you'd tell your mates about it and get them to buy a copy too, and be inclined to buy their next game.

Playing computer games didn't used to prevent you from socialising or playing outside; we built gocarts etc as well as gaming when I was younger.

Then came internet based games, and the subscription model. This was really more of the same, with the challenge being to get the player to want to keep buying the subscription each month.

Then comes the next business model, the "freemium" model. The people coming up with these things are literally employing psychologists to help them create games that are addictive to keep people playing them and then trying to separate more money from the person a month that they would spend buying a game back in ye old days. Things like lockboxes get added, which is simply unregulated gambling.

And this then extends into offline games; you buy the game at the full retail price and only get half of it and can only access the other half if you hand over more money, unlike ye olde days where you got the entire game for the purchase price, and then might get an expansion pack that included as much content as the original game for less than people currently pay for one bit of DLC.

So as problems that I can immediately see are basically:-

1) Addiction with online (primarily freemium) games which are designed to make themselves addictive to keep people paying as well as playing.

2) People playing online to absurd extents do not possess the basic level of social skills that were accepted as a norm 20 years ago and appear increasingly incapable of communicating, relating to or functioning in society.

3) All other forms of media break taboos to shock the audience and are having to get more and more extreme to shock people. People are getting increasingly desensitised and people argue that there is a correlation or causation with people then doing these things themselves.

So the CCP regulating the amount of time that people can spend online might make an impact on point one, but is probably more likely to just make these things go to a single player offline model. If coupled with further restrictions on playing offline it might have an effect on point 2, but as it stands the same people are probably just going to play offline games or watch TV/DVD's which isn't going to help, and it's unlikely to have any effect on point three.

Judge dismisses objections to spaceport in Scotland from billionaire who also wants to build spaceport in Scotland

Peter2 Silver badge

It depends on the sort of orbit that you want.

Most usable orbits (eg geostationary etc) benefit from being launched as close to the equator as possible to obtain an instant speed of ~1kps from the earths rotation. Such satellites tend to orbit around the earth basically horizontally around the equator.

You can however go for a polar orbit where the satellite orbits vertically around the poles of the planet, which is about the only thing I can imagine launching from Scotland would be useful for.

A man spent a year in jail on a murder charge involving disputed AI evidence. Now the case has been dropped

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: do people have a propensity to try to abuse AI systems?

Having a grid of microphones and recording where shots are heard is a perfectly legitimate use of technology.

But what I don't understand is that if somebody is shot in a car and there is a computer system that says "there was a gunshot here at the time" then... how in the name of all that is holy did this come to be seen as being cause to lock somebody up?

Boston Dynamics spends months training its Atlas robots to perform one minute of parkour almost perfectly

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Quick learner

The robot probably "worked" either 8 or 24 hours a day learning.

A human probably goes to a club once a week for an hour, of which roughly half of which is general socialising with people you haven't seen since last week, and half an hour is actual training.

Elevating bork to a new level (if the touchscreen worked)

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: "A touchscreen, by itself, is not going to enhance anything"

In ye oldle fashioned lifts with buttons, you can still have hidden floors.

I was working with the landlord at one point and he had a key which inserted into the lock on the panel gave two additional options. Turn to the left and go to the basement, and turn right and go to the roof level with all the A/C units etc.

The web was done right the first time. An ancient 3D banana shows Microsoft does a lot right, too

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Maybe Windows 3.1 was a sweet spot?

I'm still getting value out of X Tree gold, PSP8, Winamp and a few other bits of ancient software.

if old versions of software I own can still [can be made to] work then I see no reason to buy another bit of software to do the job. This sort of thing is of course on the way out; because there is little to no point upgrading software on the basis of required functionality companies have gone with forcing people into buying subscriptions so you perpetually hire software and never own it.

Activist raided by police after downloading London property firm's 'confidential' meeting minutes from Google Search

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: In France, someone was convicted for nearly the same thing

That's France though, and an excellent example of why businesses from all over the world come to England to use our courts to settle disputes; they produce outcomes that make sense.

Tesla battery fire finally flamed out after four-day conflagration

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Extinguishers...

IMO grid-scale storage is a dead-end anyway; it's only being pushed to try and paper over the problem of renewal intermittency.

Could we call it "solar and wind intermittency". If we rebuilt every waterwheel in the country and added new ones on wiers then the energy produced would only be intermittent on the occasions that the water in the rivers stopped flowing.

Precisely why everything was pinned on wind and solar i'll never know; other than it's cheap and favours large land owners.

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Extinguishers...

They really ought to have piping to inject fire suppressants.

While Halon is expensive for firefighting these days as production stopped 20+ years ago there are alternative products these days that have the same insanely beautiful chemical reaction of taking the heat out of the fire when they are more than x% concentration in the air. Eg Fm200 or Novec 1230. (Halon does not remove the oxygen; that's a CO2 flood. With apologies to BOFH fans the resulting mix is not dangerous and will only give you a headache after about an hour working in the area after the alarm has sounded)

And frankly, while Halon is a CFC and was contributing to eating holes in the Ozone layer using some of it to put a fire out is a lot more environmentally friendly than letting a fire burn for 3 days kicking out epically horrible chemicals such as hydrofluoric acid. (According to the Material Safety Data Sheet of any lithium based battery this is released on contact with the battery electrolyte with moisture in the air, or if somebody is spraying water on the fire to put it out...)

China tightens distributor cap after local outfits hoard automotive silicon then charge silly prices

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Smugglers

The thing is that as soon as something is made illegal the supply collapses, and the demand mostly doesn't.

Via the immutable laws of supply and demand the prices then leap. If your earning the minimum wage and somebody offers you ten years worth of your wages in exchange for smuggling a small packet with little risk of getting caught then many people tend to be willing to give it a go, especially if they don't think it's harmful. (ie; many people won't smuggle hard drugs but will cheerfully smuggle computer chips, prohibited books in workers paradises and the like.)

Right to repair shouldn't exist – not because it's wrong but because it's so obviously right

Peter2 Silver badge

For most purposes it really doesn't matter how old the CPU's are. It's not as much of a bottleneck as people make out.

My previous (gaming) computer was one of the original "buggy" AMD Phenoms that would crash if you hit 100% utilisation on all cores and threads. I never noticed any problem with this, and it lasted 13 years in service before it got to the point that I decided it wasn't really capable of running modern games and retired it to a friends kids. It did get a new mid range graphics card every 4 years or so just to keep it competitive, but...

At work we had a bunch of core 2 duo boxes that due to tight finances were retained in service. I filled them full of memory, replaced the HDD with an SSD and gave them a quadro card for 2 screens and they lasted in service from something like 2008 through to Jan 2020 when Win7 support ended.

Due to not having enough laptops available for staff at the start of the pandemic in March 2020 these boxes which were still kicking around ended up being wiped and gifted to staff as thin clients so everybody had a decent home setup for working from home, and as only one of them has come back they are probably going to do another 5+ years service from now.

My point simply is that if a 12 year old CPU is still task adequate for general purpose use, there is no particular reason why a 5 year old one should be a problem. It's not like 2000 where we moved from a 25Mhz 386 to a 1Ghz processor in 5 years.

Euro watchdog will try to extract $900m from Amazon for breaking data privacy laws

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: But will they actually have to pay?

Amazon can appeal, but the levels of appeal are pretty limited.

Just saying, but Intel still haven't paid the file for paying the major distributors to not stock the AMD Phenoms from like 2007.

Scam-baiting YouTube channel Tech Support Scams taken offline by tech support scam

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: @Peter2 -- Always trust Microsoft reports - not

I'd say bloody evil personally, but then I also think scammers deserve everything they get.

The funniest thing is that even if they hang up on you shortly after getting the card details chances are that they are still going to waste yet more time from several people trying to get payment out of the card afterwards. ;)

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Always trust Microsoft reports - not

Oh yeah, so many things you can inflict on scammers. And they deserve every bit of stress you can inflict; anybody trying to scam pensioners out of their money is fair game imo.

I'm really surprised that they are still calling you though John, I'm pretty sure they've blacklisted me!

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Always trust Microsoft reports - not

Yes, I have often thought that it's a terrible oversight when doing this sort of thing. As I say though it's irrelevant; I don't get scam calls anymore because (presumably?) i'm on a blacklist.

If anybody is working for a bank then consider suggesting this in an internal meeting; it'd be an obvious way of adversely impacting scammers. Just wasting half an hour (and seriously stressing the spammer out though is a worthy exercise in it's own right though because it stops them from scamming somebody else in the meantime.

About the stressing the scammer out bit? Essential work that.

Me: I'm stuck.

Scammer: What do you have on the screen?

Me: It's telling me to press a button to continue and I can't find it on the keyboard.

Scammer: Which button does it want?

Me: The "Any" button.

Scammer: The which button? There no key called that on keyboard

Me: That's why i'm stuck.

Scammer: . . .

Scammer: Just press any button on the keyboard

Me: <distressed>I just told you I can't find it!

Scammer: <getting quite irritated>

Also don't also forget the "overly literal" entry of instructions when they don't have remote access.

Scammer: Type Control Panel.

Me: Controlpanel?

Scammer: Yes

Me: Controlpanel not found

<several minutes of debugging later>

Scammer: Did you type Control Panel with a space?

Me: No, you didn't ask me to.

Scammer: <snarls> Type Control SPACE Panel

Me: Controlspacepanel not found

Scammer: <loses temper>

Me: <sob> i'm just doing exactly what your telling me to do!

You can have soooo much fun with this sort of thing. Usually best to placate with a sense of progress when you get them angry which lets you keep pushing them over the edge at will. Don't forget to complain about their attitude and customer service skills, and ask to speak to their manager if you think your close to them hanging up on you. I'm fairly sure that I had one chap ranting about me in the background, bless. (not that I could understand with it not being in English, but the tone of pissed off ranting sounds pretty similar in Indian)

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Always trust Microsoft reports - not

Probably. I wasted half an hour of the time of the first scammer who ended up frustrated and screaming down the phone at me and I then feigned being horribly upset and asked to speak to somebody else, and allowed his manager to calm me down and agree that their customer service could use some work before stringing him along for another ten or so minutes before he eventually slammed the phone down so hard it must have damaged the handset.

Look, everybody who works in IT must have dealt with a huge number of painfully clueless users over the course of your career. Pretend that you are a compilation of the most worst of the lot running on a really old computer.

I pick an old slow Win98SE box running purely in my virtual nightmares. Let them talk you through enabling remote access (they generally want to RDP in; which wasn't possible on 98SE...) at which point they'll give you a link to download a bit of remote access software. Be as obtuse as possible in getting the website up. You can get the URL wrong a few times, not press the enter button after typing it in and then be told that IE4 won't open the webpage and let them talk you through installing chrome or Firefox.

Then you can say that the firewall blocks the site, the AV blocks their remote access tool (you can let them talk you through uninstalling them sequentially and rebooting at each point only to discover the next problem) and then do a "not compatible software" error or BSOD on them.

Treat it as a game; and score yourself. The longer you keep them on the phone the higher your score.

As a rule; they must feel that they are making progress to keep on the phone. It can be helpful to google "test credit card numbers" if you think that you re losing them and offer them one of them so they can take "payment" for their "services". A test card number is intended for verifying integrations work correctly and when used will appear to work properly and produce a confirmation report as if it works, but won't process a payment. ;)

The problem to getting a really high score is that they realise that they are being played and they will put you on a blacklist which appears to be shared between scammers so you can't keep playing. :/

New York State Senate first to pass landmark right-to-repair bill – but don't go popping the Champagne just yet

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Anyone remember Haynes Manuals?

A couple of decades ago people owned their cars and houses, which came with a drive, a garage and a garden big enough for a workshop. This enables space to store certain bits of kit to do basic work, such as axle stands etc.

Now people don't own their cars (which are on perpetual rent schemes like PCP's) so your not allowed to do that sort of work in the first place. Even if you were, the houses with a drive, garage and a large garden with a workshop are priced well out of the point that normal people can afford which prevents people from being able to do work on their own cars since most of the time doing jobs on the road is a bit dodgy.

Add to the fact that even if you do a job perfectly mechanically, the car will demand that it's plugged into a authorised garages computer to do things in software before it will work again, and you can see why DIY jobs are less popular these days.

For a true display of wealth, dab printer ink behind your ears instead of Chanel No. 5

Peter2 Silver badge

The main reason for buying a inkjet printer is that they are cheap. This is however offset by the fact that a set of cartridges can cost (as per article) £107.98; and the cartridges supplied with the device will be a fifth of the size of the normal ones.

Laser printers are more expensive, but at a rough guide to costs:-

An ink printer will cost something like 8-20p per page

A desktop laser will cost around 2-10p per page

A network laser will cost around 0.2 - 1p per page

So succinctly; in almost all cases it's cheaper to buy a second hand laser printer from ebay than buy a replacement inkjet cartridge.

Hole blasted in Guntrader: UK firearms sales website's CRM database breached, 111,000 users' info spilled online

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: @AC

If you are law abiding then you won't have that many problems obtaining a firearm for a lawful purpose.

If you just "want a gun" though then yes, you shall no doubt find innumerable and impassible obstacles that keep firearms out of your hands.

In a complete non-surprise, Mozilla hammers final nail in FTP's coffin by removing it from Firefox

Peter2 Silver badge

Be honest; did you actually use FTP in a web browser?

Web browser clients only offered the ability to download; for uploading even windows explorer was a better solution than offered by any of the web browsers.

Which is a moot point, given that everybody used Filezilla for FTP sites because it was the best tool for the job.

Make-me-admin holes found in Windows, Linux kernel

Peter2 Silver badge

The writer either has a meaning and cannot express it, or he inadvertently says something else, or he is almost indifferent as to whether his words mean anything or not. This mixture of vagueness and sheer incompetence is the most marked characteristic of modern English prose, and especially of any kind of political writing. As soon as certain topics are raised, the concrete melts into the abstract and no one seems able to think of turns of speech that are not hackneyed: prose consists less and less of words chosen for the sake of their meaning, and more and more of phrases tacked together like the sections of a prefabricated hen-house. I list below, with notes and examples, various of the tricks by means of which the work of prose-construction is habitually dodged.

From George Orwells's essay on English Language:-

https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/politics-and-the-english-language/

IPv6 still 5-10 years away from mainstream use, but K8s networking and multi-cloud are now real

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Is this the most sensible Gardner report ever?

*tricks*?!

Every web server on the face of the planet serves a different website depending on the domain name in the GET request as a core competence.

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Is this the most sensible Gardner report ever?

Decades on, I still think that the winning solution would have been just to add another two numbers to the scheme used by IPv4 and leave everything else alone. It'd easily have hit 100% utilisation by now because everybody would have switched to it without hesitation.

This would take you from 4.1 billion addresses to two hundred sixty eight point eight trillion addresses, with the point eight at the end being two hundred times larger than the existing IPv4 address block.

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Is this the most sensible Gardner report ever?

Anyone creating an IPV6 only website will be shooting themselves in the foot commercially because most of their customers are IPV4 only

Given that you have have thousands of websites on a server cluster behind a single IPv4 address there is no particular reason to ever end up in this situation.

LibreOffice 7.2 release candidate reveals effort to be Microsoft-compatible

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Use early Microsoft formats where possible for interchange

Personally I hate when general senders email us their DOC or XLS file directly. Thanks to VBA et al, it is a giant security risk to open up anyone else's files (even though I have auto run turned off on my own desktop, of course).

You do know that you can force security options that the users can't change via group policy, right? You can force disable unsigned VB scripts, disable office downloading content from the internet etc.

This is the data watchdog! Surrender your Matt Hancock smoochy-kiss pics right now!

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: 'In the Public Interest'

A jury in the UK can reach any conclusion for any reason. It is known for a jury to declare that somebody who did commit the act was "not guilty" despite this being blatently the case. It's technicaly known as "Jury Equity" in the UK.

To avoid this whomever did it will be tried by a summary offence at the magistrates court instead of via a jury trial.

Facebook pulls plug on mind-reading neural interface that restored a user's speech

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Common Good?

The purpose for Facebook's point of view was obviously to come up with a form of neural linkage directly to a computer for a mobile phone to replace the voice interface.

Anybody passingly aware of the state of the art in Neurology knew and said in el reg's comments on this years ago that this was not remotely feasible; they are funding the neurology equivalents of the Wright flyer expecting that it was going to be a modern airliner.

Western Approaches Museum: WRENs, wargames, and victory in the Atlantic

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Seems a security risk

There was no fortune involved. Google the "Double Cross" system to read about what MI5 was up to during the war; by 1941 they had captured every single German spy in Britain with the exception of one, who had committed suicide.

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: a quote from American journalist David Fairbanks White, …

It certainly is quite a claim, when compared to the much larger area east of Poland where the Wehrmacht met its match.

Arguably, but if we'd have lost the battle of the Atlantic then if you look up the percentage of British supplied tanks at the Battle of Moscow (between 30-40%) and where the machine tools and raw materials that the Soviets were lacking while relocating and building new factories came from you can't help but think that those latter victories rely in turn on this.

And this also relies upon earlier victories and things like the Polish work on breaking the early Enigma machines; the war was a gargantuan team effort.

NHS contracts for document storage, digitisation three years after paperless deadline

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Put it to scale..

I worked in NHS IM&T a decade back. At that point, everything had switched to digital X-ray machines.

IIRC The downside of this was that the software for the multi million quid x-ray machine only ran on XP and the manufacturer had no plans to migrate the software off of it despite the extended support ending something like a year or two later.

Focus on the camera, mobile devs: 48MP shooters about to become the sweet spot

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Why the obsession with MP?

Because a decent lens is largely a function of focal length, which is the physical distance between the camera lens and the image sensor. In cameras these are measured in CM; typically 5.6cm for short range work and 12.5cm-50cm for a telephoto lens.

Even a 5.6cm lens is obviously much thicker than the mobile phone, and a tele lens is getting on for the total length of the camera. This leaves mobile phone manufacturers with no alternative than to push crazy numbers of megapixels and then play with them digitally to try and generate a good photo because they don't have (and can't have) a decent lens.

To give them their due however, I was convinced that it would be impossible to get as good photos out of a pancake lens as they have done by pushing the megapixels and fixing it with software.

While I doubt that they are going to get as good as a DSLR they have improved to a point that a phone has essentially replaced a compact camera.

Intel's Foveros tech hits a speedbump as Lakefield gets canned – one year after launch

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Two littles

Because they'd locked AMD out of the market back back when via the anti competitive shenanigans that I still don't think they've paid the fines for, and didn't expect their only competition to produce a competitive CPU again.

That AMD produced a genuinely competitive chip despite having a total net worth of something like 1.5 billion in 2015 compared to Intel being worth a quarter trillion or so is to be fair pretty amazing.

That this chip happened to come around shortly before Intel got caught with their dodgy speculative execution code was doubly unfortunate for Intel, since AMD hadn't been doing dodgy process execution the intel parts losing ~20% of their performance made AMD's chips suddenly gain this much performance.

Microsoft patches PrintNightmare – even on Windows 7 – but the terror isn't over

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: It is about time

Probably because if you set things up so that nothing runs unless specifically authorised then the people who don't have a f*****g clue kick off because their programs don't work?

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: It is about time

How in the world can something be taken seriously if clicking an email, adds in a website, harmful URL's or PDF's result in encrypted drives and databases, and that we came to a level where it seems normal like a car accident and organizations can insure them selves for damages incurred due to this backward and retarded operating system technology.

I have no idea. It's never happened to me since I used the free options provided out of the box to prevent unauthorised applications doing this. Notably the much mocked Cyber Essentials scheme configuration guide would block all of these problems if implemented; most people appear to be saying "yes we do this" despite clearly not doing so and then when they get hit are fraudulently claiming on their insurance.

If *nix was the main OS of choice for servers in business then you'd have idiots running as root all the time as they do in windows and then having the same problems and claiming that's crap. In reality, neither is.

And yes, I know a more nuanced view is about as popular as a migraine to enthusiasts. ;)

UK enters negotiations on a digital trade agreement with Singapore

Peter2 Silver badge

That's Nazi Propaganda from WW2.

British minister claims technology makes maritime cannibalism obsolete

Peter2 Silver badge

As you will no doubt know, the ship lost back then was a coastal sailing yacht being sailed across an ocean for a new owner. Coastal sailing yacht's as well as race craft still have sails and precisely the same thing still happens in the same locations, ie Loss of masts in the southern ocean during a storm with the ship reduced to a sinking state:-

https://apnews.com/article/sports-europe-international-news-latin-america-europe-sailing-a5e76d241f1e4330a45544f7c86ba2cc

And despite that, a ship was diverted to sail 2 days out of it's way to pick her up because as I said in my original post, the response is directed these days rather than just hoping somebody sails within sight of your lifeboat.

Peter2 Silver badge

Under the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea since 1993 all ships over 500 tons are required to have a Global Maritime Distress and Safety System installed.

These days in those circumstances where you lose your masts you can put in a distress signal before taking to the lifeboat (or even aboard it with a satellite phone) and you'd get a helicopter or ship pick you up long before you needed to kill and eat the cabin boy since firstly the response is directed rather than random, and secondly lifeboats have to have 3 days worth of food per person the lifeboat is rated to carry. (which would probably be several times the actual occupancy)

I was fired for telling ICO of Serco track and trace data breach, claims sacked worker

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Whistleblower protection

Yes. It says "should not" and is a trivially worked around rule that doesn't provide any actual fine etc, rather than a short and simple bit of primary legislation that defines unfair treatment, and says "if treated unfairly as judged by the courts then the company treating the staff member unfairly will receive a fine of 100x the workers annual salary".

Which would pretty immediately end the problem.

Backbench Tory campaigner promises judicial review of data grab of English GP patients unless UK government changes tack

Peter2 Silver badge

Replying in Parliament, Health Secretary Matt Hancock also appeared to advocate the OpenSafely/TRE model, but with one crucial difference. NHS Digital, effectively a branch of the government, would extract GP patient data into a central data store, and then apply the TRE model, rather than applying it to data where it already resides in GP systems.

If your in A&E unconscious then you probably want enough records available to the A&E staff (ie, blood type, allergies to painkillers) to be available to those staff, rather than to your doctor who's off for the evening/weekend.

Apple scrambles to quash iOS app sideloading demands with 'think of the children' defense

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Sideloading no, better revenue model yes

The visible debate is really about money. If Apple can lower its tariffs (which others have already done), that's one way, but the real problem is that Epic doesn't want to hand off 30% of its revenue, and blames Apple for asking for it, conveniently foregoing the fact that they would not have the remaining 70% if it wasn't for Apple creating that eco system in the first place

If Apple hadn't created that eco system in the first place then everybody would be using either an *nix/android or a windows device, which don't charge you 30% of your revenue to run your applications.

If Apple charged a single rate of £100 for adding the application to the store (which would more than cover it's costs if the people checking things are spending less than an hour doing the checks) then the objections go away.

And this is the real issue; should a company be able to charge 30% of your revenue for running your application on their platform?

UK urged to choo-choo-choose hydrogen-powered trains in pursuit of carbon-neutral economic growth

Peter2 Silver badge

Oh, we can electrify lines alright. The issue as the article says is the economic feasibility of doing so.

Main lines are electrified, and the branch lines used by a couple of trains a day get a diesel train instead because it's cheaper, and it's apparently it's cheaper to design trains just for those lines than electrify all of them.

Boffins promise protection and perfect performance with new ZeRØ, No-FAT memory safety techniques

Peter2 Silver badge

There are plenty of ways of doing this. Like many other people I am blocking my users from receiving programs, and also blocking them from running them just for good measure. You can actually stop office/adobe from running unauthorised scripts using group policy options available free of charge across your entire network in mere minutes.

However after a certain point one gets bored of arguing with people who want their systems configured to run everything, and then act surprised that eventually something runs that they didn't want that screws up everything on their network.

Peter2 Silver badge

Because as was obvious at the time of release, Spectre and meltdown are really serious issues if you are running a cloud, but irrelevant if your running a server because by the time somebody can run the code your screwed anyway.

UK health secretary Matt Hancock follows delay to GP data grab with campaign called 'Data saves lives'

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Fix the existing problems before making a profit

I think that saying the hospitals are separate entities is slightly disingenuous. The hospitals are grouped together under regional trusts, which have between 1 and 9 hospitals depending on their size.

Have you worked in NHS IT, and if so do you recollect hospitals using the same systems as everybody else in the county?

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Fix the existing problems before making a profit

Of course if you wanted to be able to quietly sell it off eventually it would make sense to split it into different competing regions / hospitals / trusts

Which highlights the main problem with the so called debate. Barely anybody realises that actually the entire system was fragmented like this from day one, because the system started off as private entities who billed the customer being allowed to bill "The NHS" for each job that they performed instead, and that beyond being split into counties for administrative convenience the design has barely changed since.

And thus your GP is a private, for profit business that is an external contractor to the NHS and not part of it. Practically every single hospital out there is it's own NHS trust so they can run their own systems the way that they want without being bothered with having to use the same systems as everybody else in the county etc.

Any time anybody suggests doing something sane, like allowing any part of the NHS to having access to your medical records rather than having to beg your GP for them who might provide said records within working hours on promise of an appropriate fee people scream "SaVe teH nhS11!1!!!11".

And the same frigging people then bemoan that we still have a system that on a good day knows who it's patients are because HMRC tells it whom taxpayers eligible for treatment are, but the NHS itself doesn't know basic information it will predictably need if you have an accident and turn up in A&E like say, your blood type or if your going to have an anaphylaxis reaction if they give you various types of medicine, even if your GP knows this.

It's literally insane, yet apparently unchangeable because of how ignorant people are about "The NHS".

To CAPTCHA or not to CAPTCHA? Gartner analyst says OK — but don’t be robotic about it

Peter2 Silver badge

The analyst suggested that good CAPTCHAs should do more than ensure users provide a correct answer to a challenge

They do already! They ensure that humans put unpaid labour into classifying things in the Google driverless car database that their algorithms can't figure out.

You know what they are having trouble with by what they are presenting, which appears pretty ominous given that they keep presenting traffic lights, pedestrian crossings, bridges etc etc etc.

Hubble Space Telescope sails serenely on in safe mode after efforts to switch to backup memory modules fail

Peter2 Silver badge

Re: Wishful thinking...

Why bother to service Hubble? Asking SpaceX to launch the *pair* of unused spy scopes the NRO donated to NASA a decade back would surely be a better move.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_National_Reconnaissance_Office_space_telescope_donation_to_NASA