* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

Flat-pack plug designer wins top award

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Damm

That is neat.

Welsh auditor in court over child abuse images

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Legal English

Limping into the 20th Century.

Who knows? In another 100 years it might make it into the 21st.

Might I nominate "Originated" to identify the person who 1st created these images, and (presumably) actually abused (or recorded) the abuse of children.

That would imply *many* creators, but 1 originator. which seems to describe the actual events better and leaves the current definition intact. Still not very good however.

thumbs down for such behavior.

Manchester's on fire for ID cards, claims ID minister

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Matt Hawkins

Nice summary. All used. All *total* BS.

Thumbs up for handy reminder.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@John Lettice

"The only thing that'll shift a Hackney Labour MP is the Hackney Labour Party. "

That was lazy of me. Checked Wikipedia just after posting.

Not necessarily. Remember the Speaker's constituency in Glasgow? c26000 Labour majority. IIRC it went to the SNP with around a 4000 majority. I think the safe seat MPs also had a disproportionate involvement in the expenses scandal. Ms Hillier seems to have avoided getting covered in too much of that.

I'd guessed her willingness for this project was her snowballs chance in hell of being re-elected, hence seeing weather she could push this thing through so far that it could not be canceled. Obviously she fully expects to stay in.

"I did that once, you know... (-:"

I salute you.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

@ElFatbob

"Her pedigree is impeccable by Labour standards though...

Oxford educated in PPE -> Librarian -> Journalist -> councillor -> mayor -> all women shortlist (htf does that work with all the 'equality' legislation these communists have brought in?) -> MP -> junior government minister (just about as soon as she's in the door)...."

Actually it's impeccable by any government . I've lost count of the number of Oxbridge PPE's who end up somewhere in the reptile house.

The former heads of MI5 and 6 (including the one who went on to head the SOCA, the lead agency for IMP) have all done the course.

Like the US funded officer training college in Panama many of whose graduates have gone on to mount coups in their homeland this seems to attract students of a right thinking law and order point of view.

Thumbs down for a complete and expensive waste of time.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

ID card minister makes stuff up.

Channeling Wacky Jacqui perchance?

Why do I keep picturing the Identity Card Publicity Office as being located in a small town called "Denial?"

86 days max, 51 days likely.

BTW does anyone know Mad Meg's electoral majority?

Thumbs down because.

Feds sue Russian for stock pump and dump hack

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

If only it had been Phorm

sigh

Navy, NASA 'committed' to restoring Silicon Valley Colossus

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Go

so damm big it's hard to believe *no* one can find a use for it.

300 ft wide is enough for some *very* large aircraft. Is there no runway nearby?

US Marine robot supply skyhook compo: Enter the A160T

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

How tough did the DoD think was?

Within scope of similar sized crewed vehicles (IE doable now but this would be a safer option and *might* give a bit more payload)?

DARPA tough. IE Order of magnitude improvement needed.

12000 ft is quite high so any one doing this should be thinking about a much bigger set of rotor blades. IIRC the environment is also pretty warm, knocking down engine performance further.

As a performance spec 5000Lb across 75 miles does not *seem* excessive, but the hit from altitude and temperature may be bigger than it looks. Designing that into an airframe from scratch on a short time frame is looking pretty tough. The Boeing effort does not look like it's in the running.

Robot mini space shuttle is go for April, says US air force

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

7 feet long by 4 feet wide

That's a 48 inch chair.

That Club class is it not?

7 feet would be a bit short for 6 people though.

Also note, unlike the Shuttle it has *no* side door.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

@Dave Bell

"I see that the X-37 uses essentially the same propellants for the on-board rocket motor as the British satellite launch used--hydrogen peroxide and kerosene."

If they are still going ahead with that plan the engines they are using were actually *built* in the 1950s, originally to act as either reusable rocket assisted takeoff packs or as high altitude boosters. Reliability was preferred over absolute performance since the low (by rocket standards) T/W of 40:1 (A state of the art 1950s jet was around 5:1)

BTW the Black arrow engines had a similar pedigree, cut down versions of the Blue Steel standoff missile. sadly it's a myth that Blue Streak was a peroxide launcher. *Half* of the velocity was imparted by the "Waxwing" 3rd stage solid rocket motor.

Mine's the one with the JBIS special edition in the pocket.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@sandman

"How many iron bars can you pack in it?"

Doesn't matter. Steel will vaporize long before it gets to the earth.

OTOH Tungsten survives quite well (Like Carbon-Carbon it melting point may be >3000c but it starts reacting with air at *considerably* lower temps) and its mass is a positive benefit in this application. I suggest a search for the phrase "A rod from God."

Precision strike is one of *potentially* a lot of applications which a reusable space vehicle could support. Hence presumably the ongoing secrecy over planned payloads.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Rapid response.

From the late 1950s to 2010 that's 50+ years to get a missile launched hypersonic glider into orbit (Although with a mission duration of 270 days that a bit longer than the X20 Dynasoar was hoping for).

It has some interesting possible uses but they really need more than 1 flight vehicle (historically X programmes have had 3. I gathering data, 1 being modified with the results from the last test flights and 1backup/spare parts/revert to previous working configuration)

Its real benefit may be to get people thinking about the benefits of designing to a known payload bay layout and the advantages of having their satellite core hardware in a vehicle which can be recovered for further study.

Note that while refurbishing and refitting this thing *should* be fairly cheap (by USAF standards. Using the standard storeable propellants will jack up the price quite a bit given their safety precautions) the problem is the *huge* 2 stage expendable rocket it sits on.

Finding ways to eliminate *that* (and get them funded) would be a real achievement.

ID cards have three databases, says minister

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

And now consider data growth.

Start with a 70 million record database, which is quite substantial by quite a few yardsticks.

Multiply by the number of updates/additions per year (we wont need deletions for at least a century) *including* death notifications and c1500 births a day over (say) 120 years just to be on the safe side.

Don't forget the separate biometrics database. Image compression on passports is quite efficient so say 70m x 100k or 7TB

And of course you'll be wanting to back this lot up on a regular basis.

No wonder IBM got the contract.

After all IBM Germany wrote the book on fine tuning a nationwide database to efficiently identify people for special treatment.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Pirate Slayer

"I don't see why they would require an address history in this whopper of a database. Surely they only neeed your MAIN residence (like with driving liceneses)...my god the politicians will have to exempt themself ASAP."

1)How else will they be able to cross reference all the *historical* surveillance data without it?

2)Because they can.

Boffins builds lithium battery that can't explode

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Jobs Horns

Will leak detection become a lot easier

Just follow your nose to find the bad battery.

Finally a product of the horned one worthy of his talent.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Go

Looks impressive on paper

Just like other technologies did.

And "Silicon wire" for the Anode? sounds tricky to make and expensive.

Mole-cruiser planned to attack Iranian nuke bunkers

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

@RPJS

"Battle Beneath the Earth"

IIRC It was a mole using lasers.

The Sandia idea was *much* more futuristic.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Does look more of a first strike weapon

The sort of thing you'd use *before* anyone realized you had it.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Tougher than it looks

All conventional systems have big power systems have big drive systems to power them. making the whole lot self contained is unlikely to be trivial.

However in the 1960s & 70s one of the US National laboratories (IIRC Livermore or Sandia) proposed the subterren to melt its way through the earth, providing a smooth self supporting tnnel ideal for underground transportation systems.

However it did need either a nuclear reactor or a *very* big cable to power it.

EU fails to shift unwanted perv scanners

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

This seasons must have accessory for the evil villains lair

Just a thought

'Phantom Eye' hydrogen strato-spy drone starts building

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

Still unclear why Hydrogen?

It burns hotter than most fuels and its very low ignition percentage (Not sure if its for air or 02 but H2 will explode at a level of 4%H2, making even small releases quite dangerous) means in principle it could be run at a very lean mixture ratio but it's hard to believe either of those will counteract the fact that it is a PITA to store any significant mass (Liquid H2 is roughly 10x less dense than any hydrocarbon)

LPG, Butane, Methane should all be a *lot* easier to store and take up much smaller room.

I guessed the developers just though it would be cool to build a hydrogen powered aircraft.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Troll

@Cheeky Chappie

"Oh of course, silly me, petrol is far more expensive than mere hydrogen that is more freely available, as well with a really noxious substance called water as a byproduct not that nice carbon monoxide stuff that's so good for our lungs."

You're also ignorant of chemistry. It is true that Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe, often located in *huge* natural deposits called "Stars."

Anything on this planet has it tightly bonded with a large range of other elements. Separating it from *those* and storing the result needs a *lot* of energy to begin with.

GCHQ loses Top Secret laptops

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Precautionary principle?

They're gone. Asses what's on them and how well it's protected. How fast to crack the security?

Then consider what they are they going to do about it.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Sounds a *bit* too reassuring to me

Wellllllllllllllll

We did lose 3 laptops 5 years ago.

But they all *very* secure and we are sure if there were problems with data leakage we would have heard by now.

And it can't happen with the new system. No siree.

Good to know they did *finally* get round to mentioning it to eh "Oversight" committee in the end.

Elon Musk's Falcon 9 suffers rocketus interruptus in pad test

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@Rick Brasche

"Try doing *anything* on most launch systems after a t-2 abort, much less in two or three days. "

That has little to do with rockets and a *lot* to do with their design. Cartridge starters, 1 shot use ablative panels that are difficult to replace are a legacy of the ICBM based designs. It looks like SpaceX have recognized that in a real commercial launch environment time is money and rather than hope nothing will happen plan to deal with it when it does.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Anonymous John

"A valve on a ground based high pressure helium line didn't open because the launch sequence computer wasn't programmed to open it. The ground equipment at the Texas test stand doesn't have that particular valve."

Interesting if accurate. This suggest (again) the importance of configuration control (not just on the SW but the the ground equipment) and version control (Different ground HW ->Different control SW).

And what happens when the relevant sections are not kept in synch.

However the real story is their system *worked*. Trouble spotted, handled before it got out of hand. A useful reminder that Nemesis awaits anyone believing they have all the options wired.

Home Sec says 17m ID cards in circulation by 2017

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

@Rob Burke

"They've already started targeting the young..."

Sounds like online grooming. I thought that was illegal in the UK?

thumbs down for the whole idea.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Home Sec thinks he will still be in power in 2017.

I doubt either belief is *any* more likely than the other.

Conservatives want big IT deals delayed

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Ascylto

"All the Tories have to do is say "We're gonna cancel any contracts we don't like AND we'll introduce a law which gives us the right to do so which trumps any contract law."

The IT companies will run a mile."

As it happens the US Govt reserves the right (and has done IIRC since its founding) to cancel *any* contract it's in at *any* time *without* compensation tot he contractor. It is one of the shaping forces of gubmint con-tractors

1)Big (hidden) cash reserves to handle the *years* of screwing about while Washington decides what they want.

2)*Very* close links to politicians through assorted lobbyists to make sure it won't be canceled.

3)Charging for *everything* over and above the baseline contract requirements, so they get back *all* the money they wasted (which would have been lost if they lost the bidding competition)

A more practical Act might be one outlawing the insertion of "Poison pill" clauses (EG Cancellation of our ID card contract will require HMG to pay us 100% of our *expected* operating charges to them for our projected contract length) in government contracts.

Or something which gave the "Traffic light" reviews actual power to stop things happening. A Red means *no* further work until issues are resolved.

Most people find contract law and procurement slightly less exciting than train spotting but above watching paint dry. However when *billions* of pounds are at stake (Or 10s of Bn with the NHS IT project) the payoff could be quite substantial.

The world has enough HP/EDS, CSC's, CAP Gemini etc. It *really* does not need to create any more.

UK is safer from al-Qaeda 'bastards', says security minister

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Lord West's masters seem keen to give everyone

experience of what a *real* police state feels like.

Why?

Just because most people have not eaten their own feces does not mean they *have* to try them to know it's not very nice.

Just a thought.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@The Other Steve

"http://www.ico.gov.uk/ESDWebPages/DoSearch.asp ACPO's registration number is Z127313X"

Thanks for that. It was exactly what I had in mind.

I note "Family, Lifestyle and Social Circumstances" comes up quite a bit, and presumably the suspect files they are keeping on people would come under "RECIPIENTS OF POLICE SERVICES" no doubt including surveillance and dumping their phone and email records.

I note that the ICO did take action against that nasty blacklisting company in the construction industry a while back.

As to who cares that depends if you think it right that what is basically a private services and consultancy firm is advising (and in some cases setting) Home Office policy is the right way to run a democracy.

Microsoft offers SMEs cash to use Dynamics ERP software

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Stop

I wonder houw sales have been going

It's been a few years since MS bought up Great Plains and Navision (2 deeply different software packages) for their respective user bases in the US and Europe.

Oddly when I was last involved with them companies were strangely reluctant to bet their whole operation on what had become an MS product.

Somehow being a multi-billion dollar corporation (with a huge back catalog of fail) didn't seem to reassure them.

Drought effect on rainforests is negligible

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

A lot of this stuff seems due to Working Group 2

Who (according to the Guardian article) deal with the effects of climate change and *not* with the underlying science.

They seem to be *very* slack in checking the provenance of their sources.

Y2.01K hits Garmin satnav

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Coding like it's 1979

Or some other time when it was thought the turn of the century was *so* far ahead all the software would be re-written by then.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@pctechxp

"Personallly I've never been on the internet and find this assumption that everyone is on it quite irritating."

I think you'll find he's playing the "Grumpy old man" routine. ¬serious.

Virgin signals start of telegraph pole broadband test

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Good lord an FO cable with a metal wire support core

Whatever will they think of next.

Oh wait. Phorm.

TSA worker tried to sabotage terror database, feds say

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

The TSA, your CC details and travel plans safe in their hands

Or rather, not.

Does anyone think *any* part of TSA security is *not* sensitive. I think the words "Travel" and "Security" suggest it all might be.

US comp-boffins claim fix for multicore 'concurrency bugs'

John Smith 19 Gold badge

@BristolBatchelor

"Occam"

Takes me back a few years. Along with Amdahl's law.

I wonder if there is any mileage in a super-duper new software development tool using some BS description of it but which in reality:-

1)Re-writes the FORTRAN/C/C++ program into Occam

2)Runs relevant optimization rules

3)Reads description of processor array

4)Distributes relevant bits as communication sequential processes.

Government spends £11k on ID card 'branding'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

I quite like the idea of government branding.

But I'm undecided.

Dry ice or hot metal?*

Any preferences?

*Naturally this would be a purely voluntary procedure for all staff to show their unwavering commitment to this plan and not some kind inhumane torture.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@MadonnC

"is not to be cynical, but to simply accept the wondrous gift the government bestows up on us?"

Well being cynical about it kind of implies that is exactly what you *will* do. The more people think something is inevitable the less likely they are to fight it.

For 70 years (1919-1989) the triumph of Communism was "Historically inevitable."

Until it wasn't. The laws of physics are inevitable. where human societies are concerned things are more varied. If you don't vote you signed up for *anything* and *everything* whoever wins wants. Most real political change (good or bad) is so gradual people don't notice it unless they are opposing it.

For beginners. Find out who your MP is. If they are Labour find out who the runner up is and vote for them. Encourage you friends and family to do likewise. If your MP is Labour tell them *why* you're not voting for them (The UK also allows 24 days detention without trial, the *highest* in Europe, despite the shutting down of the IRA over 10 years ago). For the runner up. If they are Conservative, remind them of David Cameron's pledge to scrap it (and make sure they are aware of the NIR and what it holds). If someone else ask them what their policy is, and why.

Advanced. Identify which Politicians (and senior civil servants) believe in a democratic process (and don't see a need to collect much information) and those who are basically authoritarian. Whatever party they are a member of their *goal* is the collection of as much information and its most efficient use in controlling people. Make people aware of exactly what sort of package they are voting for/appointing.

BT rolls out new, 'competitive' consumer deals

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

*potentially* 20mbs

Do the ASA have *no* say in allowing that one from *any* ISP?

Home Secretary swats away calls for Mosquito ban

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

There's always one who quite likes ol Frank

But I figure 1 Robbie Willams per million of the population is an acceptably low risk. Beside his tax revenue in later life should more than make up for any minor irritation earlier on.

Crap Scottish weather favours ginger hair

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

Sadly

For every Julianne Moore, Clara Bow, Gillian Anderson, Molly Ringwald, Nicole Kidman, or Evan Rachel Wood

there is a Mick Hucknell.

Sigh.

Apple's draconian developer docs revealed

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@The Other Steve

"How many of those allow *you* to sell *your* product *through* *their* *shop* with all the advantages *that* brings ?"

That simply reflects the question back to me. On the assumption you are not a troll let me try again.

IMHO there is *no* console maker who has the level of control over what is loaded on the machines they have sold. It is not an area I know well but I don't think *any* one dictates to their community in the way Apple does. If I wanted a game for various consoles I'd walk in a shop and buy it. Now try that for an app for an Apple/whatever.

It is not that they don't allow you to use *their* store to supply your product. It is they make it impossible to supply it *anywhere* else.

"And yet, they won't tell you except in very general terms, because of the NDA clauses in their developer contracts, which are standard. "

If you've read the article and followed the posts you know the level of control Apple has and how it has used that power.

My belief is that is *substantially* above other similar product mfgs require. IE withdrawing products which they don't approve of (why did they allow it to be sold in the first place?), arbitrary decency concerns (girl in bikini =porn?) and preventing sale *anywhere* else.

I didn't ask for details of specific platforms. I stated my belief that this level of control is *much* greater and more actively used than in other similar products. I asked for opinions (preferably based on experience )

If you have experience in the area I would expect you to have an opinion based on that experience. That was what I was asking for. Not a clause by clause analysis of whatever NDA you signed.

UK pol touts canine chip implants

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

why am I reminded of the film "Snatch"

"You like dags?"

Only I can think of quite a few people who won't be signing up to this.

UK.gov urged to slash DNA retention plan

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@John H Woods

"Why not just store a partial hash of EVERYONE's DNA? Hashy enough to ensure about 50-100 duplicates for any given sample."

They *do* store a partial hash of DNA at present.

"When a sample from a crime scene does get matches you can use REAL POLICE WORK to find the culprit, as you only have a few score of suspects. "

Which I suspect is an order of magnitude above what they have to investigate now.

Despite numerous cop shows in *reality* they will look for the 1st candidate who is a) on the database b) in the area and c) has no or little alibi. And remember if they don't get a conviction ("But I'm 110% convinced he did it"*) they will re-try the case as the UK scrapped double jeopardy following the Stephen Lawrence retrial (with a little help from the best DS that money could buy).

They would not *have* to eliminate you from their investigation if you were *not* on the database to begin with.

Thanks for the warning. You were quite correct.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Headline should read

Power crazed maniacs who thought this up are encouraged to slash their own wrists and donate a litre sized sample to the database*

*This is not glorifying terror, merely encouraging them to demonstrate that if they have nothing to hide, they have nothing to fear. Although I suspect quite a few people would be more than happy to assist them if they find themselves getting a bit squemish. I'm sure it's nothing a little band aid would not stop although IANAD.

Young people are lazy, think world owes them a living - prof

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Gates Horns

AFAIK things did get better in the US 1930-1970

So while people may have worked hard their was an *expectation* that I would work less hours than my parent and (generally) have a better standard of living.

It is my *impression* that since then while salaries have risen (how could they have not with inflation) so have employer expectations of hours to earn them (so actual hourly rate has effectively gone down). Bringing a return to the working hours of previous generations.

Mind you a *lot* of this does come under the heading of "It's the end of civilization as we know it! Run for the hills! This generation is a bunch of illiterate slackers! it was all so much better in my generation."

In perspective. Average life expectancy for Victorian England town dwellers 43, Average life expectancy for Victorian England country dwellers 53. Infant mortality rates 50%+

The good old days weren't.

Icon for one of the compaies that have done 8so* much to encourage a long working hours culture.

NY chef offers mam cheese canapes

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Heard of this before

Saw it on a documentary of unusual foods and what they can be made into. When tried it was commented that human breast milk cheese is *very* sweet by comparison with various more common varieties.

I hate to be a kill joy but I've a nasty feeling public health will complain that it's not pasturised and could act as a growth medium for dangerous (in some cases lethal) bacteria.

Now while some suppliers do use un-pasturised milk for their dairy products AFAIK they have fought an uphill battle to *prove* their plant is antiseptic and kept that way.

BTW A cow IIRC can produce 4litres per session. I doubt *any* human female could do that. Better place those orders *well* in advance.