* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

The Cameregg plan: Who got what?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

@Cynical Observer

"Mr Darling is gone as well"

And this is a bad thing because?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Pretty good.

I'd bet dumping the "Interception Modernization Programme" would save cash on the sort of scale needed to make some real differences.

I predict a fair number of civil servants will become "Surplus to requirements."

German net crippled by top level glitch

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Sounds like human error of some kind.

But wouldn't such a critical process be automated?

Is loading a blank zonefile a recognised procedure to do anything?

Seems a bit draconian.

High Court rules software liability clause not 'reasonable'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Hotel "Can we look at the manuals"

Supplier "No"

Hotel "How can we *find* out if it will do the job we want it to"

Supplier "You can ask us."

Hotel "Will it do the job we want it to."

Supplier "Absolutely"

The judge understood this is exactly what happened. The supplier ( if they are *any* kind of expert in the hospitality industry, which has had IT systems installed for at *least* the last 40 years) either *knew* the software could not hack it (so they lied when they said it could) or were so clueless about their business they did not know either way (and guessed).

Thumbs up. You've got to wonder how many other suppliers have pulled this routine in their T&C's. This stripping will continue until more customers take some *responsibility* for their purchasing decisions and give cowboy suppliers a kicking.

Osborne to 'get Britain working' - except for ID contractors

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Has to be said

Cable, unbound and let loose on UK Banking industry.

Biometric passport 2.0 scrapped alongside ID cards, NIR

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

IPS like a malignant weed

Lop off the top and it's roots continue to grow.

Needs something strong and long lasting to kill this madness stone dead.

The whole *concept* of the NIR needs to be put "Beyond use."

Now that's tricky.

But thumbs up for starting this hard work.

UK hot-swaps leaders - Brown out, Cameron in

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Compromise already seems to be happening.

Clegg scraps the mansion tax, Cameron scraps the tax break for millionaires, *both* raise the threshold on *paying* tax, leaving more money in the hands of UK tax payers.

This is starting to look like an *actual* coalition.

Darling reckoned it would cost £40m to cancel the ID cards project. A bargain versus the £10.4Bn estimated over the 10 years (does anybody think that number would go *anywhere* but up?)

Honoring the ECHR ruling on DNA should lower admin costs.

Reviewing *all* big spending projects (and when a traffic light review says "Red" it *means* no moving forward until the issues are resolved) for value for money would seem a good idea. The NHS IT project is an obvious one.

The problem is the Gordon saddled UK PLC with c£110Bn of additional debt. You need to make *big* savings and scrapping a Trident replacement would lop roughly 20% off the top in 1 go. IMHO the terms payed to operators on *all* PFI rojects are remarkably generous (Banks seems quite happy to hand them the cash for the buildings *once* they saw the repayment terms). I think re-negotiating them would save money on the kind of scale needed.

Some solid work should be possible on the Foreign and Defense departments. WTF is the MoD head count as big as the British Army?

Thumbs up for the start of (possibly) something big.

'Phantom Ray' robot stealth jet rolls out

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Perhaps rather obvious

but it looks like a scaled down B2 bomber. Nothing wrong with that but control issues are bit tricky.

Depends who your opponent is. The Taliban have (I presume) access to heat seeking missiles but no radar.

As always in the killware biz it's important to play the FUD card as "We don't know what the world will be like in 20 years time. It could be a (God we're hoping) Cold War".

Just a thought.

NASA appoints new CTO of IT under CIO

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@dogged

"looks like William Hague with hair."

Now that's just nasty.

Miracle mono-molecule material could quench hot chips

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

Read the abstract

It explains what happens if you make the graphene layer too thick. While you might think thicker layer -> more material to conduct heat in *fact* the thermal conductivity *drops* by roughly 1/2. They explain partly why, and why you want to operate with 2 layers (2800 w m^2) Vs 4 layers (1300 w m^2)

Incidentally this implies that their is a *maximum* power you can put into such a layer. Too much and you can't get it moved with just this bilayer.

As for all the oh so smart comments about warm laps it's also about *spreading* the heat load. That processor is what 1 inch square? That's 1/94 the area of an A4 page, The surface might be close to 150c, but there is (in theory) *more* than enough area to drop that temp right down.

BTW The idea of Asbestos just stops your legs getting warm. You still have to dump the heat *somewhere*.

I think as a super heat conductor this is a bit of a red herring. It might have other materials properties. Graphene and other "Diamondoid" materials were predicted to be *major* product of a working nanotechnological production system. OTOH work on high emissivity coatings (radiating the heat at *high* efficiency in the infra red band) *might* pay dividends.

US patent office gives i4i Word up in Microsoft snub

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

US PTO Issues *Valid* patten

Oh wait, it was the Canadian patent office that issued one.

The US one issued to MS is worthless.

I don't like *any* software patents. But this looks remarkably like the system working *properly*.

Thumbs up for that.

Lindsay Lohan to pull off Linda Lovelace

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

I find my self wondering

Is the moderatrix a possessor of the red gene?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Mage

"No connection to the Ada Lovelace film, not even a lesser known relative?"

Could be she asked for the *wrong* script.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

No swallowing jokes please.

We can work most of them out for ourselves.

It's not really a coat, more an off color Macintosh..

Fujitsu demos next-gen color e-paper

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Better

Not brilliant. Not perfect. But perhaps the start. of some actual competition.

So far *only* kindle breaks the 10mm barrier IE the thickness of an 80 sheet pad of A4 paper.

HP's webOS tablet 'due in Q3'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Grenade

Apple buys Palm

Build quality of hardware goes where?

Doctors aim to have Chief Medical Officer struck off

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Medical jobs database euthanised @ < £7m

Now that's what I call *prompt* triage.

Pity they couldn't manage to terminate a few others while they are at it.

Interesting he was described as the "architect" of the system.

Lot of experience in database design? Long track record of rolling out high volume secure browser based apps? Keen grasp of privacy issues?

Secret forum reveals Oz firewall backroom dealing

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

The Big Yin

"We know that X will never work and will waste billions, but it will make us look good to the poorly educated* and gutter-press reading masses,"

If Conroy *knows* it won't work but advocates it *anyway* he's clearly the worst kind of rabble rousing bottom feeding politico. His only conviction is a burning desire to be re-elected. another government department that seems to have had a "Fact" finding visit to the UK recently and *liked* what they saw.

What is the equivalent of The Scum in Aus? Would it by any chance also be owned by a certain R Murdoch?

Cameron aims to bring LibDems into government

John Smith 19 Gold badge

Brown *appointed* Prime Minister. *Never* elected

Which is *another* point people might like to keep in mind.

He retains No10 as his address *solely* because the *rules* say the incumbent holds the right *wheather* or not they have an overall majority.

It would seem that this is a nice example of the law of unintended consequences. What is meant to improve continuity and stability has the *opposite* effect.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

*Why* do people assume parties would *not* change under PR?

Right now if a party has a big majority in a constituency they can more or less ignore it at campagn time (and do the bare minimum the rest of the time) knowing they will be re-elected as long as they have an effective majority (in principle 1, but I've heard of Labor wins with a majority of 40).

Why *assume* that *no* party (under *any*) PR system could not get a mandate *within* a constituency of 60% *outright*.

A PR system would *force* parties to *evolve* to the new reality. The *major* complaint about PR seems to be it makes majority rule *unlikely*. It does not make it *impossible* , but parties would have to work a *damm* sight harder for their electorate to gain that majority.

Politicians working harder on your behalf. Subversive stuff.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Mike RIchards

<Description of PR system selected by Jenkins Commission>

Excellent point. Cameron's offer of a commission is *redundant*. the choice is already been made. What it needs is *implementation*.

The devtail in PR was *always* the detail. Anyone with a background knowledge of control systems would see 1st past the post as a system with strong *positive* feedback. It's a Bang Bang machine, like your central heating thermostat in a limit cycle.

Does that sound to *anyone* like a system which would give *any* kind of policy stability longer than the life of a parliament *except* at the mercy of senior civil servants.

Germans plan to make 'synthetic natural' gas from CO2

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Maurice Shaekshaft

"However, our Government/banks are quite prepared to invest/spend £Billions on NHS IT, identity cards and some aspects of road and air transport infrastructure and PPP & PFI projects were a very dubious case for RoI is made "

Well several of those relate to Government projects and given the fight it's taken to pull even a *few* of the traffic light reviews on the ID cards from the grasp of the relevant office RoI has *never* been discussed. As for PPP/PFI projects the financiers have bleated on about how little they make and (again due to Government policy) the civil servants have been instructed *not* to argue this is BS. According to at least 1 documentary the drill is, raise the cash for the school/hospital/bus station etc then do a re-financing which turns decades of risk in decades of substantial profit.

"The "duck" and "snake" and "tidal power" ideas have been developed and would not be being exploited in Scandinavian if they kept breaking. "

This again comes down to government policy and IIRC a stunningly biased report from Harwell in the mid-late 70s. BTW You might like to not the 20GW of tidal and wave power systems being trialed in 10 projects by the Scottish Parliament.

"There is a strong argument for improving the UK engineers approach to business management if we are to fully exploit the UK technological developments but this is a chicken and egg situation, surely?"

Why. *Not* improving it virtually guarantees should a UK engineer come up with a profitable idea they will be nearly clueless as to how to exploit it. Coupled with the ongoing "Starting a business is not for the likes of us" mentality. This leaves most such ideas in the hands of investors. A case in point has been the observation that their are *very* few UK based *global* pharmaceutical companies, *mainly* because where one has produced a viable (or apparently viable) product it has typically been sold off to the first big pharma player the investors could find. The idea of *gasp* going it *alone* to form their *own* conglomerate is *far* too risky to UK investors.

"If we don't make the investment in developing and trying to commercialise engineering in the UK then we will be condemning future generations to a '3rd world' economics because we will have little intellectual property to exploit into commercial ideas."

Agreed. It's rarely mentioned in economics text books that the share market does *not* create money. It *convinces* people to hand some of theirs over to someone because they *believe* they will get something which will become more valuable in time. OTOH it may turn out to be completely worthless.

Agriculture, mining and manufacturing OTOH turn raw materials (as raw as soil, air and water in the case of farming) into cash.

But that's hard work. Just a thought.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Eirkur Eiriksson

The CRI technology looks further along but there is an existing Methane distribution network. However the *option* to make *either* which are both important chemical feedstocks and fuels, would definitely add flexibility to the options.

Both look like good retrofits to existing fossil fuel power plants. I note they share the electrolysis of water to get Hydrogen as the feedstock.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Not quite as bonkers as I thought

At first I was comparing it with traditional Methane production methods (thermochemical, biological) which are very well known.

But as a way to convert electricity into a storeable, moveable form and plugging it into a large *existing* infrastructure it may be close to perfect.

To H2 lovers. It's a *nightmare* to store and transport. Short term storage would have to be *very* short term. So far its room temp high pressure (5000psi in carbon fibre overwrapped tanks. Not quite the 1 piece Titanium but not exactly cheap) or liquefy at -253c.

To Propane lovers. RTFA. Propane was *not* the object of this research. However that's not to say that under a different set of conditions (possibly a catalyst) Propane could not be made as well.

The joker in the pack is the bulk CO2 supply. However given CO2's inertness you *could* run a pipe to each generator (wind turbine, PV array etc) from a bulk CO2 source, tap off some CO2 and inject the newly made Methane back into the same pipe.

It's a tricky solution, but maybe it's the simplest solution which meets *all* the non obvious problems that start to come out of the wood work when you try to implement "green" energy for real.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

AC@14:44

"It aggravates me to distraction that our technologists and engineers cannot or will not be funded by banks (!!!) and UK Governments to develop the ideas yet these self same British owned organisations are quite content to sell off or see them sold off to continental (Portugal, Spain, Nordic) for exploitation and then buy them back later at a higher price."

I think you'll find it has quite a lot to do with something called "Return on Investment." The UK governments level is or was something pretty stupid and UK banks is.

A look at the history of UK developed ferroelectric (no DC power LCD. Like eInk but potentially allowing TV level frame rates) is instructive.

Technology 18-24 months ahead of the world (That's a monopoly position) but needed the funding for effectively a new LCD factory for volume production. Break even in 3 year.

Too long.

You'll find that ROI and the UK banking industry (personal loans, funding bridges across the bospherous no problem) explain and the traditional problems of scientists and developers communicating with them and forming teams to handle the less interesting (but vital) nuts and bolts of *running* a company explain a lot about UK failures to implement profitable (as opposed to novel) technology.

Election losers? Our clapped-out parties

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@BristolBatchelor

I think they have most of this in US Congressional politics.

Does that sound like a system to aspire to?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Only 4 countries in *all* Europe have outright majority rule

Greece was one of them.

Stop/go politics -> boom/bust economics (at least it did when the Bank of Englands monetary policy was set by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. Removing this from government control, and the statutory minimum wage *may* be the only good things Labor is remembered for).

Fail because as other have noted UK ballots have no "None of the above" option.

Microsoft: 'Prepare for 15 billion more clients'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Camilla Smythe

"I really would like to pass a meaningful comment on that one but I will just squeeze out a monstrously huge and smelliliciously obnoxious fart capable of assaulting all Eighteen senses"

You are a *lady*.

Sheffield hospitals pay thousands for dodgy software

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@A J Stiles

""Both kinds" in this case having something in common. Can you spot what it is?"

Of course I could. I *think* the OP was making the point that giving (or expanding if it has one already) the NHS an in-house software development team does not guarantee the result will be *any* better than the heavily moded package bought in.

This does look like a *real* dilemma. Historically companies developed bespoke systems either to give them competitive advantage, or because nothing in the market served their needs, or both.

While FOSS has generated a number of "horizontal" apps the number of people who *would* commit the time and effort to create a vertical market app (and know *enough* about that *specific* field to make it a reasonable choice) is pretty small.

It's not impossible but it's going to have a *fairly* small number of sources. My guess would be (in the hospital management software context) a company goes to the wall and decides to "Open source" given it's had too few sales to justify listing the code as a major asset, or it

is built to support say some kind of community hospital and *might* be flexible to be bespoked for the UK market.

Both seem like pretty long shots to me. So how *do* you incentivise knowledgeable developers to build something whose source is completely visible?

I don't know.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Dick Emery

"The original programmer and mainainer had long since left and there was only one guy who was a temp consultant who knew how it worked and hot to manipulate it (to a small degree)."

"They also used Sage for accounting and that was a pain in the backside to work with too (and cost a fortune on contract)."

So bespoke closed source software written by a single developer with *zero* documentation is bad.

Closed source commercial software is awkward to use and expensive to support as well

So your POV is both kinds of software are crap?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Pirate

I think you're confusing the ICO with FAST

FAST is *not* a public institution.

That money will go into FAST's coffes, or be distributed to its members.

What *might* make large institutions care a bit more about this is if it was distributed to whoever turned them in. IE A reward.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

AC@11:38

But no doubt it will be the *only* one with the Special Sauce (c LewisPage) that some package or other simply *must* have in order to run.

Jacqui Smith and Charles Clarke shown the door

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Big Brother

The Doomday scenario

Broon declares that he can best "Serve the country" by invoking emergency powers and instituting direct rule by the cabinet as a "temporary" measure.

You just *know* he's not going to leave the No 10 bunker without a fight.

On a happier note.

It was never really likely Blunkett and Johnson would be dumped as well. A truly *clean* sweep was too much to hope for. Dumping Johnson (and 1 or 2 of his junior henchpersons) might have thrown another spanner in the ID card works however. As it stands they sound like the leads in really bad 70s cop show.

B

The internet, as imagined in 1965

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Amazing.

Maurice Wilkes is still *alive*

Jeez.

His paper introducing the idea of microcode was written in 1951. I thought he'd shuffled off the mortal *decades* ago.

Met issues internet cafe terror warnings

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Big Brother

Words are so 20th century.

The icon with a Met badge below it is all that needs saying. Go on, you know you want to.

EFF fights Facebook bid to outlaw one-stop social apps

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@grumpy

That was a *very* emphatic denial. Me think you doth protest too much.

California's 'Zero Energy House' is actually massive fossil hog

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@jake

"People are actually allowed to openly carry guns and knives."

California is an "Open carry" state?

Who knew.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@jake

"Incorrect. Anybody who hasn't been convicted of a felony can openly carry an unloaded weapon pretty much anywhere they want in California. With several full clips on the same belt, I might ad ... and a concealed carry permit isn't all that hard to get, if you are sane."

An interesting trade off between the legal and the illegal.

IT consultant gets 5 years for plundering $2m

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@z0mb13e

"Anyone else get the feeling that IT folks (from sys admins to casual password guessers) are being manoeuvred into the firing line more and more these days?"

Yes and no.

This guys fall was all his *own* work. However management definitely created an environment which *allowed* and *encouraged* him to do it. This means they either don't know what they need to do about ensuring good security or don't care.

Palin email witness decries 'dog and pony' prosecution

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

"Dog & Pony proscution"

Do you have video of this?

Soot, hydrofluorocarbs 'low-hanging fruit' to fight warming

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Go

Available technology could do a lot of this

It's estimated half the world's population cook using very *low* efficiency (c6%) stoves burning, wood, coal, dung. Better stove designs exist which can up this 5x (to 30%).

The fumes and smoke kill an estimated 4-5million children a year.

Shifting to a shared biogas system gives clean heating, cooking and lighting (gas mantles may not be very high tech in the developed world but they are pretty effective if you've no infrastructure for *any* electricity and AFAIK last quite a long time).

Getting people to go with this is another matter.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Is that in America or Europe as well.

Europe tends to be a bit stricter in this stuff.

Report reams IT admins for secretly snapping student pics

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

*but* you've *got* to think of the children

And it would seem the admins were doing just that.

Still not to worry. Those pix won't show up anywhere.

Except

mmm.com

nnn.org

and traded in a few chatrooms.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Now this *could* be a few pictures of every student

But that sounds like a *lot* of pictures of certain students.

The hotter looking ones perhaps?

OK we know IT tends to attract technically adapt but not very well socialized individuals, but it's pretty hard to believe that the phrase "Violation of privacy" did not enter anyone's mind at *some* point.

Who watches the watchers?

Nokia and Intel defensive on MeeGo Linux patents

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

"You hurt me. Give me money"

"How did I hurt you?"

"If I have to answer that question you give me *more* money."

This is the MS FUD blower running in overdrive.

Icon says it all.

US data-collection bill gets chilly reception

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

AC:04:52

"What is this new urge to pass any bill that purports to do something without thinking it through?"

I think they may have been on a fact finding visit to see how the British government operates.

US Army portaloo-full-of-missiles project for the chop

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Possible interesting use for the rocket motor

It seems to be a solid variable thrust type using a moving pintle.

An interesting project for some of these (now surplus) motors would be to fire some of them vertically with the pintle programmed to move to compensate for the surrounding air pressure changes. A solid propellant Altitude Compensating Nozzle test.

Just a thought.

Labour manifesto changes a byte bit

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Andus McCoatover

I think you have spent a little too long in those cold Scandinavian climes studying some of the more specialist literature.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

The elephant in the room

UK government finances are in the hole big time. From "normal" c£69Bn to c£178Bn. Mostly (it seems) to buy near total control of Lloyds-TSB_HBOS-Norther_Rock or whatever it's called. Not they would *dream* of actually *managing* it given that level of control through share ownership because "It's simply *not* done" for civil servants to implement government policy through direct changes to operations.

*No* major party has come clean on how big the cuts will be. The figures put out by the Lib Dems were the *most* honest and covered 25% of them. Labor's admitted cuts only cover 13% of what they have said they *have* to make. Given they have had 13 years access to the UK national accounts this is not exactly transparent government (The Conservatives numbers add up to 15% of their planned savings, but *they* don't have sight of the national accounts).

What they have *admitted* is like a band aid on a minor cut to someone whose had their chest cut open with an axe.

Given the UK voting rules either support your incumbent ( if you like them) or dump them by voting the runner up last time.

A vote for no one means you rolled over for *everyone*.

Lost mental hospital memory stick had health records

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

AC@14:28

"someone could go through the effort of changing whatever details they can change, and the present the Trust with the bill, and sue through civil court for the loss."

This looks like the *only* way they start taking notice. One off fines they will no doubt put in a budget increase for. This is more like slow starvation.

What's worse is with stuff like TrueCrypt available for free even *if* (and I agree mos justifications for doing this are rubbish) it had to be downloaded it could still be protected.