* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

UK arms industry 'same as striking coal miners' - Army head

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Defense business accounting does not help

In *most* industries a new product is priced roughly by taking the startup costs and production costs and working out what price customers will *likely* pay for the goods. In reality it's likely in several price points will be worked out and from those a "break even" number of sales worked out. *If* product sales > break even -> Profit on *any* further sales (and the element in the costing to cover start-up is now *also* profit). If not tough.

In defense.

There is typically *one* customer. (Pop quiz. How much of UK designed stuff, mostly from BAe, found *other* foreign customers *outside* the original customer or partnership?)

When you've *finally* got a workable design (AFAIK still a pretty profitable process as I suspect Cost+ is still pretty common in the UK defense biz, although *perhaps* not quite as common as it was).

Tot up *all* the start-up, mfg costs and divide by the number of unit the MoD is asking for.

*That* is the price they pay. It also the reason why the next (if there *is* a next) batch ordered in a reasonable time frame (IE before they lay off the workforce and break up the tooling) is substantially cheaper.

It's a subtle difference but quite an important one. It makes the defense biz about a^&e backwards to just about *every* other product in the world.

Mine will be the one with some spare Ferranti f100L's in the pocket. The world's first (and only) bipolar single chip microprocessor sold AFAIK to 1 customer.

Care to guess who?

Aus politicians puppeted by hackers

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

@Kevin Rudd, PM

There comes a time when you have to accept some unpalatable truths.

The PLP think you're rubbish and reckon their only chance of winning the next election is by electing a women for the first time ever to the top spot (Bit like the British labor party with Tony Blair but with an *actual* election. Look how well that turned out).

Time to choke it down, keep your head high and make a dignified (and *permanent*) exit to spend more time with your lovely wife, kids and sheep and not to start blubbing to the press.

Of course this still leaves that nutter Conroy running around loose. He might make Labor unelectable for a generation if enough people realise what he's got planned for them.

Good night and God bless.

I think this is your coat.

US energy-weapon project going well

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

At least 4 groups will be cheering

1)Laser confinement fusion looks a *bit* more plausible as the efficiency levels go up and (IIRC) the emission frequency moves down.

2)Space launch by laser also benefits. The classic method uses focused light onto the rear of a highly reflective craft to heat the air behind it (while in the atmosphere). More recent approaches use a high temperature absorber to heat a fluid (usually expected to be Hydrogen) before exhausting it through a nozzle.

3)Laser ignited pyrotechnics should be a lot less prone to electrostatic discharge and lightning in particular. More powerful diodes -> smaller numbers to fire multiple devices. To put this in perspective the space Shuttle had 300 pyrotechnics, of which 100 are routinely fired. Each has 2 pyrotechnic ignitors. All are electrically driven. The Shuttle cannot launch in bad weather at *all*.

4)Evil billionaires looking at a more viable piscine mounted weapon for disciplining unsatisfactory subordinates, secret agents etc.

Big EU imports of Sahara sun-power coming soon?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

Some other solar chemical alternatives

One of the other paths the Solchem project looked at was making "Producer gas," which is a mix of Methane and Hydrogen from passing water and CO2 over a (solar) heated catalyst.

The U of New Mexico got a pilot plant working before the project was shut down.

Slightly more recently (and somewhat more radical) was a 1994 US project in solar thermoelectrochemical conversion. This split a salt (unspecified which) back into a base + acid then recombine them in a fuel cell in a continuous loop. the unclassified summary indicates Hughes were getting something like 30-40-%. Note this is *direct* heat to electricity. Depending on volume the 2 reactants either allow carriage of electricity without needing large chunks of Aluminium or Copper, or *indefinite* stored electricity in large tanks. Note such a system has (in principle) the quick starting of a turbine power station while maintaining efficiency. Unfortunately the full report still seems to be under a secrecy order for some reason.

Further details at http://www.osti.gov/energycitations/

Which makes a fascinating burrow through the DoE archives.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Jacob Lipman

Well my 2 minute of Google says HV DC has a 25% transmission loss but it's the cheapest way as it needs 2 conductors rather than than the 4 or 6 people need for AC. If *any* part of route goes through sea water that makes the AC cable a *lot* less efficient (the water acts like a giant capacitor that is being charged and discharged)

So no, 1 way loses at most 25% (which should drop with ever improving power electronics and better cooling of the devices). Including the line loss knocks the overall efficiency down to 11.6% by my calculations. Note however that their is *no* raw material cost as with coal, oil or *any* combustion source.

The Sahara is a very great deal of not very much. Not unlike the N'gev, Mojave or Nevada deserts. You'd need to take up a *lot* of most of them before anyone really cared. Power generation and its export (at a fair price) would be quite a reasonable use for them.

I cannot understand the point of the rest of your comments.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

@Richard Foersom

"CSP has the added benefit that you can integrate a "heat-battery" with molten salt so you can generate power after sun-down. Look up Andasol and PS20 for more info."

Quite so. IIRC the storage CSP plants have used Sodium Nitrate (Ammonium Nitrate could be used and might be cheaper but with the addition of some fuel oil would convert it into the mother of all fertilizer bombs. Not good in Algeria which has been have a few problems with fundamentalist whack jobs of late).

A landmark study for all this was done by the US Navy's ONR in the late 70's-early 80's. Their "Solchem" project was designed to make the US Navy self sufficient in oil but only using US sourced raw materials. They planed to use solar thermal heating of receivers made of clay to drive the Haber Ammonia reaction and store the energy as warm piped high pressure ammonia which could then be run over a splitter catalyst to release the heat into spray cans full of more-or-less table salt (eutectic sodium/potassium chloride mix at c500c). High temperature (but only in the heat store and receiver. Most of the high pressure piping is fairly cool) on demand for steam raising or chemical processing (Fisher-Topsch, synthesis from Methane upward?)When you're planning to build infrastructure to replace the oil needs of the US Navy, large scale economics matter a hell of a lot. They were thinking in terms of "Quads" equivalent.

Reagan got elected, proclaimed the era of cheap oil, shut down most of the DoE programmes (who were pat funding it) and the ORL went back to weapons research and SDI.

I think Australia has continued work on the concept.

You can guess what reports in my pocket.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

6.8% my extrordinarily large backside. V. Poor journalism.

As El Reg knows full well the people pushing this proposal are looking at a solar *thermal* system using trough reflectors heating glass tubes carrying some kind of oil* to drive what is basically a steam turbine power station. Given that Schott glass is one of the major contributors to the design this should not come as much of a surprise.

Modern steam generated power plants can hit 33%. In principle this could be generated at DC and sent directly down a DC line to Europe followed by a DC-AC conversion but I'll assume its a AC-DC then DC-AC link with 95% efficiency (IIRC this process has been done at 98% both ways)

So 976 (actual solar constant, not that it's particularly constant) *33%*95%*95%*0.5 (for that 1/2 the full power output)

I make that 14.8% *average* efficiency per year.. Powered by the sun for the next several million years.

Very poor research. That 6.8% is a 1st generation lab system. *ALL* PV systems only *efficiently* absorb energy around the band gap. the rest is lost as heat. Solar thermal absorbs as a *black* body, at *all* parts of the spectrum.

(I'd still like to see Gallium, which would remain liquid up to 2000c, as sadly would most reasonable containers).

Garage card scammer jailed

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Dom1

"Why don't they use fingerprint confirmation, like ATM's in Brazil?"

Simple. They *pay* for the scanners, but at present in the UK *you* have to prove it was theft. And the only people you can report the theft too is..

The CC company.

Upgrading their hardware would mean spending *their* money to help *you*.

No secret to stopping XSS and SQL injection attacks

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@RichardIV

"Don't forget user permissions "

You sir get the "Chief Programmer Team" award for solving the problem in the simplest, most general and highest level way *first*.

0 lines of code written. Security significantly improved from day 1. Box in the user at the *highest* level.

Seriously I like the idea of remote managing web sites from home as much as anyone but allowing casual visitors to a site and expose *that* level of power to them seems like asking for trouble.

"XSS is flipping hard to deal with when working on legacy code! Add a "Does this look like it's OK" function "

Subtle point. Many developers would think them more or less synonymous. I sense management types whining about "But it *might* reject legitimate users, and loose us business". This is where you need to devise examples of how tough it would be to *be* a

legitimate string which wasn't designed to hack the site and give them some numbers about what it would cost if the site crashed.

"Alternatively, institute a "no Irish, no yahoos with multi-barrelled surnames" rule on your site. There can't be too many of them ;)"

This *might* be a bit more contentious. Mostly from the population of the Irish Republic, about half that of Norther Ireland and all those merkins of such descent (at least half of Boston for a start).

.

Government delays ContactPoint closure

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

@Melkisadek

A simple childcare question which should have a simple answer.

IIRC correctly the average number of children known to Social Services across the UK who die each week is between 7 and 10.

Has that dropped since Contactpoint was introduced? Only by now this system *should* have had a measurable effect on child death rates. I'm pretty sure that figure is available at the relevant government department.

Victoria Climbie and baby Peter *only* made the news for the *severity* and long term nature of their abuse, *not* the fact it happened.

Another kid on a councils at risk register dies. In new terms, so what?

IMHO Trained professionals who actually do their jobs (like actually *seeing* the child their meant to) and use the full range of their powers stop children dying.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Cost benefit anlysis

Something I *seriously* doubt was ever carried out when this thing was started.

It's been running long enough that *some* benefits must have surfaced, even if like the NHS system the are "Difficult to quantify"

I was going to ask why it's still running but probably because the control-freak civil servants who pushed for it behind the scenes are still very much in place.

And I'll bet that like the eCRB system it's a wonderful tool for CMA, "Look, I *did* put them on Contactpoint. OK I didn't actually go out and visit them for the next 6 months but they were *there*"

Bloody George's Budget: How bad is it really?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Oddly

"showing that a stimulus of government investment increased GDP by 9 times the amount of an identical stimulus used for reducing corporate taxes. "

Perhaps I am being a little dense here but wasn't that what the *last* government tried? Something they called a fiscal stimulus package (although it seems to have all gone to UK banks)

This also implies you have some money *left* to inject into the economy.

That does not seem to be the case with the UK governments finances.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

"Tobias and Jocasta's second pony groom"

Nice.

Seriously this does seem like a fairly reasoned budget. I would presume that Osborne would *not* have picked 28% at random when he had the whole Treasury modeling team to give him a clear picture of what would (and would not) work.

I also suspect the public sector freeze on people *above* £24k will seem pretty reasonable and diffuse any cries of "Unfair to the nurses/cleaners/porters etc".

It's impossible to say but I wonder if it would have been *so* reasonable and balanced *without* it being a coalition?

Aussie pols want compulsory AV software and firewalls

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

AC@08:57

"Only if you belong to the church of "State Control of Everything".

Which, you'll be pleased to know, is pretty much morality-free."

As did the "Rev" T. Blair.

The UK got rid of their bunch.

Perhaps it's time the people of Aus who are not afraid of the rest of the world to clean out their their nations closet.

Just a thought.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Has Aus been infected with the religeous nutter meme?

I think so.

Osborne promises to curb deficit in five years

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Rogerborg

"I see the grown ups are back in charge "

Not quite fair.

Pop quiz

Which party (when in power) would order the Bank of England to cut interest rates prior to a general election to trigger a personal credit boom and "Feel good factor" to get re-elected

3 times in a row.

I suspect that historically setting a *legal* minimum wage and giving the BoE independence may be two ( of a *very* short) list of *real* Labor party achievements of the last administration.

I would not include the £12.7 Bn (originally c£5Bn) NHS IT (some of which is good but *so* interlinked with a *lot* of rubbish), the massive schools and hospitals PFI programmes (IIRC creating £40Bn of assets with £60Bn of *taxpayers* money), and a couple of massively expensive and it would seem futile foreign wars on that list.

Flying-boat tiltrotor catamaran design wins NASA compo

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

4 rotors?

I think Ryan looked at that in the early to mid 60's.

As others have noticed the rotors on that rendering of the winning design are definitely off scale.

Watchdog questions mass US data grab

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

A fiar price *might* be the *only* curb on their enthusiasm

As it seems the charges ISP's and Telcos are one of the *few* curbs on law enforcement fishing trips under RIPA.

Small biz grits teeth over Bloody George's budget

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

"Vintage Thatcher"

I think not.

Letting 880k off the bottom of the tax system *entirely*

Rather on the damp side of Thatcherite behavior.

No public sector pay rises for earners *over* £21k

I'd say that's that would be the reverse of her policy.

Minimum wage not abolished.

Thinking the the plebs had some sort of *right* to a wage they could live on.

A levy on UK banks to protect depositors.

Practically Marxist.

All told a budget practically slopping with wetness and guaranteed to make the rust spots start breaking out on the iron lady.

US attacks Europe's perv-scanners

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

"Mary Ellen Callahan, head of data protection"

Irony alert!

This is the outfit that wants to hoover up the personal details (and credit card details) of *everyone* coming to the US.

This is the outfit that wants to hoover up financial details from the EU in large chunks while requiring *named* searches for it's citizens.

This is the outfit that allowed private contractors to set up "Accelerated" checkin services for frequent (top class) passengers and whose contractors then had their details (on an encrypted laptop) stolen from a secure area in an airport.

That outfit.

Old timer cleared of extreme porn charges

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@John Sturdy

"We should definitely ban pictures of knee-jerking. And written descriptions of it. (Whoops, that bans Hansard.)"

Indeed. It starts by knee jerking. But this can clearly lead to something else, and I think it's pretty clear* that that might lead to something else.

I can't be much clearer that that.

*Clear that is if you're a labor back bencher and part time Lenin impersonator that is.

Telespial Systems Trackstick Mini GPS

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Quite a neat data logger

Handy for various transport and wildlife studies. It'd be interesting to find out if it works inside a container on the back of a lorry for things like refrigerated meat transport.

Probably a bit big for tracking a lot of smaller mammals but OK for bigger things like wild boar, deer, bears etc.

The review says an 80 hour life on a standard charge but I suspect that's at a 1 sec sample rate. At a 15 mins sample interval (900x slower) that's nearer 1200 days, over 3 years of use.

I'd guess the other popular options would be pressure and light sensors but you can't have everything.

If they give bulk discounts they could be onto a winner.

Antarctic glacier melt maybe 'not due to climate change'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

So when you don't have all the facts

and have not *noticed* you don't have all the facts

You can generate doom laden explanations (glacier sliding faster -> glacierheating up) for behavior which can be have much less harmful explanations (basically the lower level of friction of the surface the glacier is now sliding over).

I really begin to think that a course in basic magic tricks should be a part of *any* Science curriculum.

If you can't see *all* sides of the problem (and once again it seems not even *looking* for them) how are you going to know if you've missed any *big* factors.

Now lets run some of those climate models with the data that's been collected over the last 30+ years and see what they say. No twiddling, no fudge factors. We're *living* through the real answer. Let's see what they say.

Amazon slashes Kindle price to $189

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

E-ink is not an accident

It's *critical* to getting the kind of long battery life people have started to *expect*.

Yes I get you can do an Android running LCD screen thingy for c£200, which is what $300-350?

So what. It's a lite netbook or PMP, and probably has battery life like a lite netbook or PMP. Why would I pay a *premium* for that when I can already get something very similar.

As volume ramps up and these too (and hopefully others) start to seriously compete we might see them at a reasonable price.

Let's be honest. They are currently bookstores who sell a reader. Perhaps it's time for them to start looking at the mobile phone model or the games console model. A portal device (possibly supplied at below cost) they supply to encourage people to buy *more* books at prices people think are *reasonable*. What is a novel in data terms? <100MB? 10c of disk storage? Dead tree prices for something that's *never* been near a tree, dead or otherwise.

BTW if someone were *really* serious about running with this some heavy investment in translation support (I doubt machine translation is anywhere near yet but machine *assisted* translation could keep the roll out time short. Once set up it could keep a translation team permanently employed). It's likely that it would not *all* be from English either. There appear to be a number of Russian rocket engineering textbooks which are substantially more up to date than the leading US introductory textbook, which if anything seems to have regressed in what it teachers

<rant>

(An engineering text book with *no* software included, pump performance specs for the V2 and a tone which can be summed up as "Rocket engineering is *hard*. We can't teach it too you in a textbook. Hire a company to do it for you, OK?")

</rant>

1 book. 1 launch. $1. 200 languages from day 1.

Giving poor kids computers, internet makes them stupider

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

AC@15:07

25 lines. No paragraphs.

Your point?

Tech resource woes won't be solved with Afghan minerals

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

All handed to 1 US conglomerate in a no bid deal

Like Iraqi oil and Haliburton perhaps?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@VeganVegan

"For those depressed by the ignorance of our actual overlords, perhaps some of that Afghan lithium would help, but you've got to get it out of the ground first."

Err, that's for manic-depression. I don't think Stephen Fry has been running for elected office lately.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

for those with *long*memories

His testimony mirrors that of the former head of ITT in the 70s about either payments to the Campaign to Re-ElEct the President (CREEP. Not a good choice of name for an organization to support an incumbent president) or their assistance in handing over *all* foreign cable and telex traffic to the US Govt (should have been the NSA but IIRC it may have been the FBI).

He was a famously autocratic micro-manager. The sight of him denying this, forgetting that and "Not being aware of" the other stretched credulity a long way past any limit.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

I'd always thought Gallium was expensive because it was *rare*

Apparently not.

Seems to be virtually non toxic. Can almost be melted in vigerously rubbed hands (some alloys melt around body heat), fairly inert and does not boil below 2000c.

I'd say it's nearly idea for a filler for solar thermal power systems.

LibCons bin £2bn of late Labour projects

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Sheffield Forgemasters. More of the Dark Lords work

It seems it was a promise of Lord Mandelscums opening of the empty chequebook.

Looked up the PR about the 15Kt press. It seems there are 5 companies *globally* who can forge this kind of stuff at this kind of size.

While in *theory* banks should consider this as a reasonable business proposition I'd love to find out how well the UK domestic banking (Barclays, LloydsTSBNAtwest, HSBC) actually handle these sorts of requests. Badly I suspect. Nowhere near the 3% they were *offered*

BTW Forged components have the highest mechanical properties and can be near net shape (little or no final machining) giving a complex part made in nearly 1 step.

Flame because giving people such hope *knowing* there is not a cat in hells chance of funding it is just about the lowest kind of political opportunist.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Nathan 13

"We need to get the deficit to zero pronto "

I guess you didn't know that £66bn was the deficit when Margaret Thatcher (always a favorite with the slash and burn school of government finance types) came to power in 1979 or that it was about £122Bn at the end of her first term.

The deficit before the banking collapse was c£67bn, it was through to have gone to about £168Bn

but actually turns out to be about £155Bn and the interest on it is still bigger than the spending on schools in the UK.

Now you know something useful about the scale of the problem perhaps you might like to say something useful about it.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@olems

"What about IMP"

Excellent question. *very* big savings at a stroke.

Of course that *might* upset that bit of BAe systems they were going to get the snoop boxes off of.

But then again there is the NSF report rubbishing the idea that "find the comms pattern, find the terrorist" works.

BTW Isn't David Davies the current Home Sec and wasn't he the MP who got arrested or is he the one with a CS degree? If so he should smell BS when it's stuck under his nose.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

The last Labor governement's behavor sounds like a guy

Whose wife's left him and taken the kids, jobs gone and his life's down the pan

What does he do?

Max out *all* the credit cards and party like there's *no* tomorrow.

Because that *appears* to be what labor did.

The only one *I* would have liked to see was the Forgemasters 15k ton press. These puppies are *very* rare anywhere and companies which have them get international business as a matter of course. In days gone by this would have been government funded as a "Strategic" investment in British industry.

It's unclear to me if this was a cheap loan or simply a guarantee to any lender that they would get their loan repaid. £80m is pretty small beer versus the SAR chopper project or the a whole hospital.

Thumbs up in general. It does look like they just blue pencilled *everything* after Jan1st 2010.

Sex offender downloads child pr0n to get back into prison

John Smith 19 Gold badge
IT Angle

Amusing comments but there is a serious point as well

Newly released prisoner (although it did take 2 years to get him wound up enough to do this) + no permanent home +doubtful job prospects -> desire to *want* to go back to prison.

At c£35k/PA of UK taxpayers money.

AFAIK one of the new super-duper Offender Management Systems (The one the UK GAO described as a "Masterclass in poor project management") aims was joined up handling of the newly released (so the 5000 non UK residents could come straight out of the prison gate into the van taking them to the airport) which cost UK taxpayers c£400m (Nice work EDS as was).

Their new version IIRC is scoped at c£200m but will remain 3 separate systems (consolidated from standalone systems per prison) and *might* have a nationality field included.

Anyone think he's the *only* person whose decided prison is better than living for 2 years in what I suspect is a hotel (and which AFAIK in the UK can charge market rates for the room he's in. Knowing you're living in a dump and the owner is charging through the nose for the priviledge)

BTW UK repeat offenders were c66% under the last Conservative government. Under Labor that went up to 77%.

EDS (now HP). The company that just keeps giving (customers S£$t).

Windows Phone 7 compass mandatory but broken

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

There is an internal cross-model MS WIndows API

But developers will not be allowed to see it.

Oh wait wasn't part of MS anti-trust settlement something about revealing *all* their Windows API's?

Guess that doesn't apply to Mobile.

Ho I expect this to play out.

Divide the competition.

Watch product launches using this feature (and on what phones) carefully.

Select features from the best.

Build cross-model version of product with them in it.

Destroy competition.

Start charging.

Only US phones mandate GPS on *all* models. Elsewhere download-able maps + built in sensors can give adequate position and orientation. For directions *attitude* is more important than location to the nearest metre.

thumbs down for MS BAU.

Facebook's critics 'unrealistic', says US privacy law expert

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@wallyb132

++good

DoS attack stuffs Turkey's internet censors

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Might cause some annoyance in Turkey

But how much work goes through these websites?

OTOH were the ministries to find all outgoing calls on their PBX's barred they might find that rather more inconvenient.

Just a thought.

Laser-toting robots take over UK hospital

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

But robots don't need work permits and passports

OTOH having an undefended robot carry valuable drugs around a Scottish hospital does sound a mite unsafe.

Mine will have a copy of "Trainspotting in the pocket"

Choose life, eh?

Oz Attorney-General wants ISPs to hold data for 2 years

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

So what *is* the Australian terrorist threat this is all for?

Authentic/Continuity//Real/Accept-n0-substitute IRA?

Would they not be more likely to be blowing stuff up in NI, or the UK mainland?

Fundamentalist Christian anti-abortionists?

Not that barking mad.

Aboriginal rights?

Hardly likely to be in the ANC catagory.

Seriously, when was the last terrorist "incident" on Australian soil?

So WTF is this pervasive surveillance *meant* to be countering?

Birmingham jihad-cam network suspended

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Arnold Lieberman

"If those scary Christian "fundamentalists" actually went around blowing up, or planning to blow up, e.g. a gay nightclub or a mosque/synagogue etc. then they too would be under heavy surveillance."

You missed abortion clinics, a *real* favorite of their US fellow travelers.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Troll

RE Titus Technophobe

Symbol says it all.

Terror data handover seriously flawed

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

For all European Reg readers

There is a *vote* on this coming up.

Perhaps its time *all* European Reg readers put pen to paper and reminded their "representatives" that this is *grossly* asymmetric, rather like the UK/US extradition treaty which (the Home Office seems to having second thoughts on.

Just a thought.

"Take back your government" is not just for Merkins.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Very intersting

And your point is?

Report damns health records scheme

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

How many reg readers are thinking "Healthspace"

What's that?

Note the fact that the *real* (as opposed to the claimed) benefits are difficult to measure does not *necessarily* mean they were not worthwhile.

The question would be how *much* of that £12.7Bn was spent on this part of the project.

£10m would make it a pretty good ROI.

£100m. Not that bad (in context of a £12.7Bn, which IIRC is roughly a 1005 overspend)

£1Bn Taking the p£$s.

I've not kept an eye on the details of the project. Perhaps someone can put a number on its share?

But until I see otherwise.

Googlegate: Mapping a scandal of global proportions

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

No accident.

Thank you for a lucid and balanced view of Google's behavior.

This sounds like a RIPA violation.

Did ID card applications surge after scheme was scrapped?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

AC@11:40

"I read that as "Former Lobster ID minister Meg Hillier"

Wot. She wanted to issue ID cards to lobsters as *well*

The woman is unhinged. Unhinged I tell you.

NASA: Civilization will end in 2013 (possibly)

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Captain thratron

"Whatever happens, there will be plenty of hams around with old shortwave tube rigs, car batteries, and diesel generators."

I am reminded of some of the sort of precautions that EMP hardening would need. Perhaps now would be time to start a modest investment in Faraday caging some of your kit as well, along with a meaty line in lightning surpressors.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

OMG It's pedantogeddon!

Thanks to all lovers of the late Jimmy Edwards. At the risk of being pedantic my original post described a solar storm as a cloud of charged *particles* mostly Protons.

That's Proton with an "r", not Photon with an "h".

By "Fraction of the speed of light" I should have included the word "significant". Given I was talking about sub atomic particles I thought it was pretty obvious they'd be moving *fairly* fast, outside of a particle trap. A quick BOTE (93 million miles to Sun, roughly 15 mins warning) gives a cloud speed of about 0.55c.

While there is likely to be a radiation, visible and UV release as well (which I think is what the NASA probe can see, hence the early warning) it's the particles which may be the most damaging. Fast moving with high momentum they will take quite a lot of stopping, producing *lots* of ionization in the upper atmosphere.

BTW thanks for that nice quantum description of Cherenkov radiation.

My apologies for my lack of clarity.

BT signs first smart meter deal

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Sillyfellow

"..it's absolutely not going to happen at my house."

Laudable.

I think you'll find it's called a "Statutory right of entry" and a surprising number of UK bodies (many of which are now public companies but were part of the state) have it.

OTOH if you were arguing that being forced to place an insecure, remotely overarideable power or gas controlling device in charge of your household utilities would threaten your safety you might have more of a point.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

How it will be done

Simple

26 million meter replacements by 2020 is 2.6 million a year

That's *quite* a lot above the annual replacement level give IIRC a 30 year minimum life expectancy.

So they'll buy off the shelf models like those rolled out in the US market.

Some of which *have* been tested by security researchers (although it has become a *lot* harder for them to get meters in for testing) and found to be *very* hacker friendly.