* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

Mobile tech destroys the case for the HS2 £multi-beellion train set

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: It's more binary than how many minutes are saved

"The lack of the Concord-NT has a lot to do with the scum of the earth aka Greenies. They basically castrated the Concord with "environmental laws" restricting it's full use."

Partly true, but think on this.

Concorde was a joint English/French government programme to carry 100 people at a time at M2.2 (and its prototypes had to be re-designed because the French insisted it did not need to be that big).

According to British Airways

it took them about 30 years to transport 2.5 million passengers.

A US report estimated the programme cost governments c$770m in 1965 dollars.

If you're balking at the cost of HS2 think what a modern 300 seat M2.2+ passenger plane will cost. You can bet no plane maker (or more probably consortium) would go into this without strong government backing.

John Smith 19 Gold badge

Re: Is Tim London based?

"No, I'm a sub-sub unit of El Reg's Iberian offshoot. Rural Portugal for me."

Interesting.

I had thought by your comments about rare earths you we're based somewhere around the North East (or at least had a place there).

But to be clear this is a purely academic issue for you, yes?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: Not the full picture

"I've always found that you get a heck of a sight more done and some actual ruddy decisions made, in a two hour face-to-face meeting than in a whole day of conference calling."

Now that sounds like someone whose actually done this.

Post 9/11/01 I'd expected video conferencing (and the telephone companies stock prices) to go through the roof.

Never happened. It seems IRL there's still a lot of times when humans face to face meetings matter.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

Re: Infrastructure and dick-swinging

"5hitload of jobs? You mean a few thousand navvy jobs, probably all foreign employees of the sub contractors that will tender cheapest because we slavishly apply EU procurement rules."

You might like to look up the Channel Tunnel for some idea of the numbers involved and the skills required.

Try 10s of 1000s of staff over decades As for the last batch of Network Rail trains coming from Germany talk to Tony Blair. EU procurement rules have specific options for "regional development" that allow local development factors (or damage to local industry) to be taken into account if the govt uses them.

"Aren't tied to our 1900's legacy? Our trading partners will judge us on our airports and telecoms, not how quickly we move fat Brummie councillors to their conferences with DCLG."

The will when it means they can get on a train at Frankfurt,Paris, Munich or Brussels and get off in Birmingham.

"who built the Eurostars."

That would be Bombardier, using (IIRC) factories in Britain. UK skills are in Alstom (formerly GEC) and cover things like signalling and control. Unlike road signals rail signals are inter linked across the whole network and designing, building and testing them involves high level safety critical software and hardware design. It's not as high profile as military or nuclear applications but it's higher volume and very serious.

John Smith 19 Gold badge

" but there are going to need to be some funky long-lobed directional antenna deployments to minimise the handover rates."

Or (just throwing this idea out there) they put the a base station on the train with linking into a "leaky" coaxial antenna laid by the side of the track.

Kind of like the plan for the London Underground.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

HS1/HS2 link not HS capable

"Yes, trains running on the HS1-HS2 link will be limited to non-HS speeds. They will be able to pass between the two lines, but slowly."

Annoying but it stops the whole unload/move/load for freight between the lines.

Avoiding that process saves major time and costs for a freight operation.

Which is quite important if you're planning to do something like IDK "Re-balance the economy" toward manufacturing and selling stuff to foreigners.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Re: It will only work to move people around the UK if the tickets are cheap!

" But the 4 hr round trip "

Is that your current round trip by train?

Because the idea of this is to shave about 1/2 an hour (depending on how far out you are from London) on long journeys. That's 1/2 each way.

How does that work for you?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

"Department of Choo Choo"

"But if Department of Choo Choo are trying to make an economic argument, it's a lot of cash to spend and - unfortunately "

I think you'll find that 70%+ of the Department is about building and maintaining roads.

Nothing else. Just roads.

In the UK every means of transport not involving private cars on public roads are a very small part of Departments business.

Murdoch hate sparks mass bitchin', rapid evacuation from O2, BE

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

According to Dave's (current) favorite "net nanny" Cathy Perry

There are just under 500 ISP's in the UK.

Granted many of them will be quite regional but so what? The point is there are alternatives. Ideally people would go to the biggest of them. Hopefully allowing them to plough back their increased revenue (partly) into increased speed or expanded operating area.

Of course that statistic was from the women who wanted to age rated every web site on the internet.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: I'm going

"so made the move to Plusnet"

Plus net are now part of BT.

Biological chips go analog to boost efficiency

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

And so the analogue men rise again.

Perhaps. George Philbrick would be pleased.

In the 80s and 90s Carver Mead's team at Caltech adapted standard CMOS fabrication to mimic the huge dynamic range of natural audio and visual signals as artificial biological systems.

Now the work comes full circle with DNA being adapted to make biological artificial systems, also with large dynamic ranges.

I'll note that memory functions have always been a bit problematic for analogue systems but it's early days.

Thumbs up

NASA: Our ALIEN HUNTING star-scan 'scope is KNACKERED

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Pint

Sounds like at least on eof the situations Hubble found itself in.

I'm guessing they have the procedures used then to compensate for uncommanded motion. However I'm not sure if the level of precision that will get them will allow them to continue planet hunting.

IIRC Kepler had bumped up the list of definite extra solar planets into the 100s and the possibles into the 1000s, some even relatively close to Earth, Earth sized(ish) and in the goldilocks zone (Although IIRC someone pointed out that Earth is not in the zone, except for the global warming produced by trace CO2).

I think the time is coming when they will have to retire it. It's delivered solid results, told NASA a lot about what their next planet finder should look like. It might have been a single function spacecraft but what a function.

I salute you.

Tech startups, Silicon Valley, not all they're cracked up to be

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

I think it will make a nice rug in my living room.

Other than that.....

Good question about Amazon. People have called it an internet company but really all the tech is just to enable its core biz of shifting lots of stuff very quickly. You could equally call it the worlds largest (virtual) department store.

Australian Gartner chap slams gov-funded IT education boost

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Jester.

Not joking.

I'll get my Drizza. It's looking like rain.

Acorn founder: SIXTH WAVE of tech will wash away Apple, Intel

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

"Historical inevitablility" yadda yadda.

B***cks.

A cursory look below the surface of of any major change quickly shows there are always places where "The Revolution" could have gone in a different way, or just pettered out.

Marx's inevitable "dictatorship of the proletariat" turned out not inevitable after all. And really how much better does most software adapt to its users? It's got lots of options but how much of it "self tunes" based on users identity (and can you override it if it gets it wrong)? Maybe that's because no one trusts its, maybe that's because doing it right is damm hard work.

Let me suggest all successful large scale changes require a)Funding (could be peanuts, could be billions) b)Organisation (right people with a good plan and peanuts can beat wrong people with a fortune) c)Security, which may be simply that no one believes they can do it in the first place.

AFAIK the only things certain are that 90% of the human race will definitely pay taxes and 100% of us will die barring some really major medical advances.

So let me suggest that Dr Hausers is one possible future. Wheather or not it's one you want to be a part of and want to help make real is another question.

Why UK slid £150m to tax-exempt phone-mast master Arqiva

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Holmes

So even when they don't start *out* as defacto monopolies infrastructure systems *become* 1

Simply because it's the best way to maximize profit and minimize costs and improve (or possibly enable) interoperability.

Mr Holmes because IMHO it really is a case of "No s**t Sherlock."

Currant Bun erects £2 paywall: Wraps digi-paper around free footie

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Murdoch "unrecognisable as part of the Daily Mail".

He's seems to be saying it like that was a bad thing.

Personally I think it appeals very well to the desires of may core Daily jailbait Mail readers.

Marlinspike: Saudi mobe network tried to recruit me to sniff citizens' privates

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

How long before HO press release "UK falling behind Saudia Arabia in being able to spy

on people."

Fibre system reach doubled in university study

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

Unfortunately submarine FO cables do use laser amplifiers

So while the process avoids the need for photo/electric/photo conversion it's not clear if you can retrofit this to the shore stations only.

I'd say the juries still out. It sounds like a good idea.

Astronaut Chris Hadfield's Space Oddity ends in Kazakhstan

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Pint

If you want space to be a place, not a programme

You need to feel that real people could go there.

And he did.

This is a great opportunity and I hope the Canadian Space Agency follow up on it.

I'll raise a glass to a safe journey home. He's still got a fair way to go.

Sun lets loose with THREE record eruptions in 24 hours

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

But hang on

IIRC that private VC funded trip to Mars was meant to be set for 2018 to hit a solar minimum

That would put us 1/2 way through a cycle.

Hm, disk drive maker, what's that smell lingering around you?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

For some its all about access time / MB

for others its all about $/GB (or perhaps $/TB.

HP wanted to offload Autonomy on SAP, says SAP co-chief

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

BTW

I looked up HP's share capitalization today.

It's c$41.5Bn.

That $8Bn write down made c19% of the company disappear.

Now being stupid is not a crime but it's hard to believe that no crimes were committed in the process of deciding $11Bn was a fair price to pay for Autonomy.

What those crimes were and who committed them should be questions for a court to decide.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

"Very well-payed humans"

Who just managed to destroy $8Bn of shareholders money.

Let me just repeat that amount

Eight Billion dollars of shareholders assets have just disappeared.

In the UK the pension funds shareholders would have just shrugged. After all it's not their money. But it seems at least some US stockholders are a little more active in their stewardship.

I hope they go for the relevant directors personal fortunes. That's the only way this s**t will ever end

UK.gov blows a fuse at smart meter stall, sets new 2020 deadline

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: Electric supply for GAS smart meters

"The gas meters have a battery installed and therefore don't need a mains connection. Which means in about 10 - 15 years the meter needs changing out. I asked the guy whilst it was installed in our (rented) house all about it whilst he was installing it."

How odd.

The last time I checked this at least one utility was phasing out electronic gas meters as they found the cost of replacing the battery every 5 years too expensive.

These are the type without a radio transmitter that were less accurate than the mechanical type they replaced.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

Apparently the utility will still have to ask customers if they want one.

Tricky question..

Might I suggest "No" ?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: Yay for government

"What is not to like?"

What is there not to believe either?

MI5 spymasters axe intel database upgrade, pour '£90m' down drain

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: And the other half the story....

"I highly suspect that similar leadership/organisational issues are at the root cause of many UK government project failures..."

Should read.

"I highly suspect that similar leadership/organisational issues are at the root cause of many project failures..."

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Let's see

Client side.

Uncertain requirements analysis constantly shifting x feature creep

Con-sultant side

"We can't get a straight answer out of them, lets go to plan B, "income protection," charge them for every change.

The only full figure given for the Govt Interception Modernization Programme was £12Bn. Does anyone think that would have been any better managed?

Does anyone think the £500m the Snoopers Charter wants to dish out to ISP's is the whole budget?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Big Brother

Re: Makes Me Glad the Snoopers' Charter Has Been Scrapped

"Wonder how much money that would've wasted! If it has been scrapped..."

In the words of the first supervillain (Dr Fu Manchu)

"The world shall hear from me again."

BB (and because it's the nearest to his 'tash)

Government admits seizing two months of AP phone records

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Re: They have the authority

"Franklin was correct in his thinking, however back then there wasn't air conditioning, fast food, or communication devices like we have today. If he was alive today, I don't believe he would of found the time to stop checking his email in a drive thru window on a hot summer day to make the statements he did. Even in that thinking, he was still correct to point, but is that point the point where we are at?

I have to wonder sometimes what we give up, and what others have never had. There is currently no bombs going off over our heads. There isn't multinational firefights occurring in our streets. Many homeless beggars pan handle daily enough to live on for days.

Is something growing ever wrong in our government, sure, like any other. Is it to the point were we need to load our weapons? I don't believe so. But maybe we also could be charged guilty of believing we should live in utopian polished perfect world, instead of the one we have."

Parsing failure.

Meaning unknown.

Drone to deliver beer-as-a-service

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Pint

Beer deliverd by drone.

Finally! The future has actually started to arrive (sort of).

What else as an icon.

You want to put 3D gun designs on the web? You'll need a 2D printer

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Interesting. P**s away $850Bn in banks and your *not* liable but 10g of Hf and you are.

Now had that been the other way round things might be different...

ITAR, Making every foreigner feel as welcome as the leader of North Korea.

Your Flying Car? Delayed again, but you WILL get it, says Terrafugia

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

The cycle on doubling capacity for battery technology has been 35 years.

So on an 8-10 year development cycle you should get some meaningful improvement.

If you don't run out of money in the meantime.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

An intriguing road map

I'll note they talk about 3 landings where the vehicles is going from forward flight to sitting on the ground. IOW once the rotors are up to speed it could be more a case of them autorotating and acting as spinning parachutes.

The take off pulse is nothing like a Tesla's cruise load. It's nearest equivalent would be more like that of a fully loaded Tesla at a stop light drag race when the driver floors it. That profile suggests completely different choices for the power electronics and the batteries. I'll note the Russians were claiming a super capacitor powered bus running in 1993 with the necessary capacity. A lot depends on how long that takeoff transition lasts. A 1 sec takeoff with a 5 sec charge time would probably snap necks. 1 minute takeoff would probably need the whole vehicle to be a battery. It's another vague CGI detail.

I like Lewis's plan to build out from the current model. I'm not quite ready to believe this is scam but if the want to be taken seriously they need to focus on putting something in the hands of their paying customers. Sometimes SF is a very bad guide to what to expect for V0.9 tech. As they are learning just making a car that can fly (never mind hover) is (in the words of Elon Musk) "Super damm tough."

UK superfast broadband crew: EC competition bods are holding us up

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

"As long as every SME (they'll be the "beneficiaries")hooking up to superfastaccleratedinterwebnettubes signs a 'de minimis' confirming that they haven't received more than €200,000 over three years (that's a shed load of connectivity) then you can shovel State Aid as much as you like. Secondly, there's a State Aid test: "Could the measure affect trade between one or more Member States within the European Union?". Actually, it can't cos those fat pipes don't stretch outside of the UK. Do what you like inside your borders, as long as it doesn't get out. Lastly, you can push State Aid on individuals as much as you like: State Aid is only considered naughty if it goes to enterprises.

But supporting these arguments is beyond most of the Guvmint."

Really? I found your explanation fairly easy to understand.

Clearly I lack the skills for a career in politics.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Re: No Surprise

"So once again we find the EU is protecting us from our own government. No wonder they are trying to persuade the country to pull out."

A very good point that should be made over and over again.

IMHO a lot of the cruft the EU issues (like IDK the EU Data Retention Directive) originated in the UK to begin with.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

So *thirty* years after "privatization" BT still has an effective infrastructure monopoly.

Oh gosh who could have predicted that.

public monopoly -> private monopoly.

cash flow -> Treasury (with some possibly paid back to BT becomes

cash flow -> Fat pay rises to executives (doing the same job) + dividends to share holders (mainly pension funds, like every other major company in the UK)

Bottom line

Public investment -> private profits.

The BT of the early 80s was a very different beast from now but it's debatable if the improvements (and there have been some) could have been produced by civil servants with a clear mandate and a bigger set of b**ls.

'Zombie hunter' task force unleashed on the UK tech biz

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

More like a seen from the film "Goodfellas"

Remember the restaurant owner who take the Mafia crew as a silent partner.

Overpriced services. Funnel ingredients out the back door for re-sale and don't pay the supplier.

Then when it all gets too much have a fire

Is anyone seeing an analogy here?

Brits' phone tracking, web history touted to cops: The TRUTH

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

WTF is this "line rental" b**locks?

Seriously.

What line?

I'm wondering if there is in bulk buying cell phone "lines" adding a small charge with the specific goal of not supplying any further information. IOW all billing details to all lines end up at the offices of (for example) "JS Enterprises." As to whose really using them, no need to ask, no need to know.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Re: This is all entirely legal ?

" which (in the light of the Phorm affair) supposedly made it unambiguously illegal to intercept and disclose the content of communications without explicit consent from BOTH parties."

Perhaps so but this is not "communications content" but "communications data".

This is the stuff the snoopers chart is designed to hand over (for free, en mass and identified) to HMG.

What we have here is more like the FBI putting one of those GPS trackers on a car owned by an alleged organized crime figure without a warrant. The judge (IIRC) decided actually your location is nobodies business but your own.

But it's still pretty dispicable.

Analysts brawl over 'death' of markup language

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

So for big companies who do big things yes it is.

For everyone else, not so much.

On the hunt for a new ampere

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

The problem is how many electrons in an Ampere.

It's a lot.

The current devices (no pun intended) would take 1 x 10^13 secs to count that many electrons, the new hotness could knock that down by a factor of 10 000, which would still mean it takes about a year to run (roughly pi giga seconds in a year).

Thumbs up for upping the frequency of these little critters by a factor of 10 000.

Which in most other industries would be considered quite impressive.

Open source cellular targets rural comms

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

Ah the possibilities for improving life in (say) rural Arkansas.....

"You gonna be on youtube. Now squeal like a pig."

New Ubuntu for phones due 'by end of May' – usable this time

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

"a short list of modest, yet achievable goals."

Which IMHO sounds a hell of a lot better than grandiose takover-the-world plans.

Now if they could keep doing an update a month (a mix of new stuff and gradual refinement of the placeholders) this might start to get some momentum.

So thumbs up for this and hope they keep it up.

Penguins in spa-a-a-ce! ISS dumps Windows for Linux on laptops

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

Re: Send Anode up there with it....

"hey should have gone for BeOS..... FAIL"

Maybe 5% of the people reading that have any idea what you're talking about.

And that's the problem.

This is embedded land. Everything that goes up to the ISS has to be qualified and they don't want to change horses. Likewise they know there are lots of Debanian sysadmins and developers out there.

That's how professionals think.

Degenerate dwarfs tear neighbors limb from limb

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Oh Noooooooes Only 4 *billion* years left.

I don't think I'll give up on the human race just yet.

RTFM! NSA tome reveals THE TRUTH behind spooks on the web

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Erudition should not be surprising.

The NSA deals with communications intelligence and data retrieval.

Early selection tests were an aptitude for cross word puzzles.

Perhaps they still are?

Good point about checking the .pdf in case they've left an Easter egg or two in there.

Identity cards: How Labour lost power in a case of mistaken ID

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Re: Could someone please explain me this British anti-ID obsession?

I had not realized you had only just joined El Reg.

Hello Titus.

Welcome back.