* Posts by Charlie Clark

12166 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

Meta sued by privacy group over pay up or click OK model

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How much does FB benefit from nonFB users ?

That's not quite right. As I said, the contract is initially between your contact and Facebook. Certainly, they are then contractually obliged to store and process that data only in accordance with… and maybe they do: it's all hashed and used only to provide the services to the user…, or as many of us suspect, they're using the data to build their own shadow networks. Personally, I don't trust them, have never used any of their services, and have them blacklisted on most devices,

Have you been in contact with them to see what data they have on you? Somehow I suspect the conversations might be similar to those the FBI had with Philip K. Dick.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How much does FB benefit from nonFB users ?

The breach is technically being carried out by the person who uploads the data: we're all under an obligation there. After that, we don't have any proof as to what they're doing, though we suspect it. It's possible, of course, that they're using one way hashes which might get them out of the "processing personal data". I guess this is why we haven't seen any lawsuits.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How much does FB benefit from nonFB users ?

The shadow profiles they build are not necessarily a breach of GDPR: the data has been provided freely by other people.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I personally like to send and receive birthday and Christmas cards; I gave up giving them to all sundry long ago. And I very much dislike seeing the same trending clip or GIF repeatedly. It takes a couple of minutes more to send a card, that means you're making time to do so.

Musk tells advertisers to 'go f**k' themselves as $44B X gamble spirals into chaos

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Delusional narcissist

I certainly agree that his personality traits quickly come to the fore: he loves to attack, makes insincere apologies only when he thinks he has to, and quickly goes back on them.

What investors should worry about is that the companies who are withdrawing their accounts now, are the ones with the beancounters telling them to do so. Those with a conscience left a long time ago. Those who stayed, stayed because they thought it was still good business. Having seen a couple of commercial presentations from Twitter I at least understand the pitch they were trying to make. It was sketchy then and that was, for better or worse, when it had a near monopoly in some areas: politics, fashion, music. Fashion and music have left, leaving pretty much only the politicians and lazy journos. Difficult to see Disney's or IBM's target audience being there.

Goldman sacked: Apple 'wants out' of credit card collab

Charlie Clark Silver badge

For a while Google was threatened with being regulated as a bank because it was so cash rich.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I just don't get ..

Ah, so another loss leader to atract customers.

Tesla sues Swedish government after worker rebellion cripples car biz

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Postal Service

It does say this: The Swedish Transport Agency has now received an interim decision from the Norrköping district court to consent within 7 days to Tesla collecting license plates directly from our sign manufacturer. It appears from the decision that our sign manufacturer has announced that it is prepared to provide the signs directly to Tesla.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Postal Service

Tesla can go and collect them.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: FFS

In much of Northern Europe the governments prefer to keep out of collective bargaining negotiations. This means less politics and more leeway for unions and employers to find agreements that suit the situation. Consensus generally means higher productivity and fewer days lost to strikesWe had a couple of decades of government involvement and this didn't work very well: politicians often made bad laws to look good.

Don't forget that all tax returns are public so workers will know if they're earning more or less than their colleagues.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Tesla should deal

I'd question the veracity of such sources. Collective bargaining is standard in Sweden and this kind of posturing will do Tesla no good there. If Musk doesn't like the labour practices in the country nobody will force him to do business there.

FFmpeg 6.1 drops a Heaviside dose of codec magic

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Version numbers are not what you think

The pace of development of FFmpeg has been speeding up slightly in recent years, given that it took 13 years to get to version 2.0.

For a long time, you couldn't tell much from a software projects version numbering which many of them particularly keen to avoid major releases – think of the openssl scheme. But more and more have since adopted more lax definitions of major.minor.patch or have gone all the way to time-based-releases.

I would also question the author's assertion tht FFMPEG is used by the streaming services. They may well use it in some areas but only when they can't use hardware compression, which depending on OS and hardware isn't always available.

And FFMPEG, while great, is a beast so many of use frontends like Handbrake to handle most projects.

BOFH: Groundbreaking discovery or patently obvious trolling?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Pint

That's going to be a whacky off-licence when it opens!

What could be better than living above an off-licence?

Living in one!

My favourite Comic Strip. https://youtu.be/xtUPJZfHmz8?t=608

German budget woes threaten chip fab funding for Intel and TSMC

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Good

I don't mind subsidies for strategic challenges, but both these projects were going to just more expensive white elephants with subsidies per created job in the millions of Euros. That money could be much better spent on infrastructure, just not the roads.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Debt brake released

We've had lots of such declarations since the debt brake was introduced, this one will pass and be legal. The amount of borrowing for 2024 and beyond could be more difficult to obtain.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Debt brake released

Yes, but that won't give them all the funds they want for these jollies.

Europe's Ariane 6 rocket rated 'ready to rumble' after passing hot fire test

Charlie Clark Silver badge

ESA in one of its regular, but fortunately not frequent, spats about politics and money.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Capacity that made it competitive with SpaceX's Falcon 9.

It's back-to-front, because the Ariana 5 has been going for so long. Ariane 5 was for a while to only alternative for commecial satellite launches and was itself the benchmark for SpaceX.

Sam Altman set to rejoin OpenAI as CEO – seemingly with Microsoft's blessing

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Mmmmm

It sounds like you still don't understand that the OpenAI company is a subsidiary of a non-profit. This is why Microsoft never got a seat on the board.

SpaceX celebrates Starship launch as a success – even with the explosion

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Re: Ariane 240/250

This contradicts what you say above.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Ariane 240/250

Being your own best customer isn't always a good thing: ask any barman! One of things it does do is muddy the accounts and this is true across many of Musk's companies.

OpenAI meltdown: How could Microsoft have let this happen after betting so many billions?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

OpenAI is not a company

Most coverage of this story, including this article, ignore the formal structure of OpenAI where the commercial entity is subordinate to a non-profit. Hence, Microsoft's investment is only within the commercial entity. But governance is important and it has long been reported that Altman's desire to raise the value of the commercial entity has put him at odds with the aims of the non-profit parent. This will make any resolution tricky and it also means that Microsoft might end up with another turkey: copyright suits against Microsoft can expect much higher settlements than against a non-profit.

Your password hygiene remains atrocious, says NordPass

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: What about sites that force you to make it easier?

Note, the new authentication methods are not necessarily any better (and biometrics is particularly tricky) but they do change liability, almost invariably meaning that the provider of the service is never liable.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Trick question: both will turn up in rainbow tables for unsalted hashes.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: What about sites that force you to make it easier?

Current BSI (German Office of IT Security) recommendation is 12 characters and no rotation: rotation being one of the reasons to choose simpler passwords.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman's ejection sparks theories as odd as some ChatGPT output

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Eric Schmidt's VC Bullshit

Apart from a great name for a band, it's revealing to read how Schmidt views Altman: purely in terms of the valuation (not how much money it makes (or loses)) of the company he runs. Obviously, in the Valley that's all that matters.

Now, this is not an attack on Altman, who's talented and hard-working if more than a little odd in his outlook, merely an observation on how investors will do anything to make us think only about about the money they're making. OpenAI has certainly done a lot to make machine learning accessible but a lot of this was down to the non-profit status. Since then, there's been the massive potential copyright breaches of ChatGPT, DALL-E and the like. And this is typical abuse of the commons by companies to make as much money as possible before the world catches up and notes that it's had something taken from it. If high valuations are good, then the companies are good, right?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The board that sacked him would have to go before he returned.

NASA's Psyche spacecraft beams back a 'Hello' from 10 million miles away

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Great work!

Just copying what the original article says doesn't make it right, including the moon-earth comparison, multiple of AU would have been better (about 9, I think).

And this isn't just dogmatic metric versus imperial; it's what's used in the field.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Great work!

Please, this standardisation on US units is insane when it comes to science which sticks with SI and derived units for a reason. 10^9 m should either be expressed as km or using astronomical units (light seconds, minutes etc.) when distances get really, well, astronomical.

But let this rant not detract from what really is a fantastic achievement!

Francis Maude mulls mulligan on muddled merger of UK govt tech services

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: David Cameron and those sunny coalition years

If you look at the actual economics, there never really was much austerity as the % of GDP spent on government services hardly changed. Not that many services didn't suffer from the lack of investment, because they did. But austerity was just never what it was supposed to be.

Philip Coggan wrote extensively and interestginly about this while he was at The Economist. Here's one example. Might be behind a paywall but well worth the read if you can get past it.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Francis Maude

Francis Maude! God another throw back to Maggie's boy middle-aged band of the 1980s. No redeeming qualities and I was surprised he was still alive when he was brought back into to cause trouble. By the look of him, I think he was too!

Wish you could sing like Charli XCX or possess any musical talent? YouTube AI might make that happen

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Who?

Legend has been around for over 20 years. Hasn't Dylan already sold his back catalogue: he wants to live in the here and now, yeah baby!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Who?

But not old enough! John Legend has been around for a long time. Maybe he's thinking of retiring and letting his avatar provide his pension? :-)

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Copyright war

I would say that Google is testing the water for a new business model. Thus far, it has been somewhat reluctant when it comes to pushing LLM based on scraping: the contrast with OpenAI and Co-Pilot is marked. This might have something to do with the fact that it's only run by greedy capitalists and not libertarian capitalists, but Google has over the last few years generally moved on to proposing services it can sell to businesses based on its technology and data troves.

Windows users can soon ditch Bing, Edge, other bundleware – but only in the EU

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Happy

Possibly, though he's been a bit quiet recently. Is he off with Nige to Australia? Or will he be helping Suella with her leadership bid? Or is simply enjoying the silky prose of Nadine's The Plot?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Happy

Rip van Winkle

Happy to wait a century or so!

Microsoft takes aim at on-desk, non-cloudy developers with Windows AI Studio

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Of course, it's more expensive but the beancounters think it means they can do without all those difficult techies who manage systems! This is debatable but largely driven by accounting practices.

However, I think the "cloud" contains too fundamental risks to businesses: data sovereignty and the risk of being locked in; but security, especially the increasing risks of whole cloud systems becoming compromised, really ought to be sufficient for companies to say know.

I can imagine that it's possible to outsource some data-processing using cryptograhically secure VMs that get up and downloaded but there's obviously currently not sufficient interest in customers to do this, in addition to providers wanting to offer a service that would have to properly priced.

Google DeepMind's GraphCast AI weather predictor looks fascinating on paper but ...

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Beware of tail risks

The degree of improved accuracy does not entail risks.

FWIW the BBC doesn't get it's forecasts any more from the Met Office, which runs its own simulations, I think it now gets them from a German company that uses the European models. And differences are to be expected. We don't have the granularity for proper surveys and chaos theory tells us we'll never be able to run all the possible different simulations. But that's why statistics are so important.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Beware of tail risks

This is certainly very interesting but the issue is not being more accurate 90% of the time but how inaccurate the model is in the other 10%. It's a bit like financial derivatives which can have enormous tail risks. Well, the same thing here could be catastrophic.

But it's certainly possible to see this kind of approach being adopted at least partially because, at some point, the physical models are also relying on statistical approximations. As the models get better they can essentially reduce computation time by using versions that were similar in the past.

Want a Cybertruck? You're stuck with it for a year, says Tesla

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I suspect, at least for some potential customers, this kind of artificial scarcity just adds to their perception of the great deal they're getting. Plus, it keeps Tesla in the headlines, which is essential for the direct to customer sales model.

The real risk is customers turning their backs on what will be largely out of date and inappropriate technology by the time they get they're vehicles.

Vote now on who should take the lead in Musk: The Movie

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Himself as Himself

And shades of Austin Powers in Goldmember!

I'd love to see Musk trying to act, even himself. Probably the closest thing to Tommy Wiseau from The Room if he isn't available to do it!

Fujitsu-backed FDK claims nickel zinc batteries ready for use in UPSes

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

It does say data centres. There obviously hasn't been sufficient need to improve car batteries for decades: cheap, reliable and long lasting.

European Space Agency grits teeth, preps contracts for SpaceX Galileo launch

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: who would very much prefer their payloads to be launched on European rockets.

You're technically and legally correct. But it's also complete fiction to suggest that Ariane is in anyway independent of ESA and the political dumbfuckery of the last decade.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: who would very much prefer their payloads to be launched on European rockets.

Unfortunately, the stonking success of Ariane 5 led many at ESA to take their eyes off the ball and then it got political, very political with decisions delayed and revised until things got so bad that they had to let the engineers get back to work. The horsetrading in Europe can be so depressing but then you read the stories of what happens in the US and you realise it happens everywhere. NASA did the right thing in giving SpaceX the money to build cheap and reliable launchers but we can already see what the megalomaniacs make of all those unregulated resources, or who think they can revoke contracts at a whim.

There is a lot to be said for the two supplier principle and this should soon be economically for satellite launchers.

Child psychiatrist jailed after making pornographic AI deep-fakes of kids

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Re: Hands up if anyone reading this is the least bit surprised.

Arrest that man!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The porn industry does seem to think women are either in this group or 20 years older. But generally all signs of maturity, especially pubic hair, are rigorously removed. I'm not sure whether this is because the nubile look is the most popular, I guess it is if producers insist on it. Though I personally find bald pubis a turn-off for precisely because it's so "youthful". But I'd consider this all part of the post-chanel cult of youth that has been dominant for the last hundred years or so rather than something the porn industry dreamed up.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I've yet to see any credible evidence of this. What pornography does appear to affect is people's expectations of sex and their own and other people's bodies.

If feeding fantasy really did lead to escalation we'd need to ban not just all erotica but violent crime fiction, also technically pornography, as well which is predominantly written and consumed by women.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: At what point do artificial images become "wrong"?

I think the AI issue is a side issue. The real crime is the illicit recording of the patients and what happens with that material.

Videos on YouTube of typical "japanese" soft porn images of sexy (if somewhat physically implausible), young women are already quite common.

BOFH: Monitor mount moans end in Beancounter beatdown

Charlie Clark Silver badge

You know a company has hit the skids when they start coming up with this kind of crap. Meanwhile the bottomless pit for Project Supernova is still open for jollies for the C-suite and their consultants and hangers on…

WeBroke WeWork, WePromise WeFix it: How subleasing giant hopes to survive bankruptcy

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Another parasite gone ?

The parasites almost never die. Either they move to a different exchange or get bought by another company.