* Posts by Charlie Clark

12166 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

Finnish govt websites knocked down as Ukraine President addresses MPs

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Amazing

There wasn't a coup. That's your own cherry-picking.

Yes, history is complicated but post-WW II policy is based heavily on respecting the 1945 borders, wherever they happened to be. Putin's foreign policy has been largely about disregarding this in an attempt to resurrect the Soviet Union.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Amazing

There wasn't a "coup" in Ukraine in 2014, it was a popular uprising and Yanukovych left of his own accord.

Minsk was supposed to lead to peace…

It was at best a face-saving exercise that cemented a frozen conflict in Ukraine and led to thousands of dead. Russia's idea was to bleed concessions from Ukraine and hope for pro-Russian government. Instead the Ukrainian population decided to cut itself off from the Russia economy. Opinion in the country, especially in the East was divided and then the tanks moved in and now it's hard to find anyone who thinks the invasion was a good idea.

I have very little sympathy for Ukraine's regime

It's not a regime, it's a government. There's still lots of corruption and ineptitude but it's still an elected government.

Russian media watchdog bans Google from advertising its services

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Move along here, nothing to see

More damning is video material of executions and intercepted communications ordering it.

However, as the Russians have demonstrated well for years: they don't need to be good lies, just lots of them. No doubt the people murdered by a missile attack in Kramatorsk station this morning while they were waiting to be evacuated will be portrayed variously as recruits on their way to a military training station, saboteurs, that from afar look like flies. Anyway, it wasn't Kramatorsk, just somewhere in Yemen with a fake sign.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Muppetry

In Russia they have no choice but to believe it, not least because they've been force fed multiple conflicting narratives for years.

More worring is when you see some of the reports trotted out on networks like Fox (Breitbart is presumably full of it) with millions of people more than happy to believe it.

The only "bright" spot this week may have been the death of Zhirinowski who was invaluable to Putin because he was even more extreme. But after a lifetime of service to Mother Russia and, even after 7 alleged COVID vaccinations, he died of COIVD.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Move along here, nothing to see

"YouTube video hosting has become one of the key platforms spreading fakes about the course of a special military operation on the territory of Ukraine, discrediting the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation"

Yeah, only official Russian sources are allowed to spread fake news! I can't wait for the one describing the murder, torture and rape of the invasion as "typical youthful high spirits on a spring break".

South Yorkshire to test fiber broadband through water pipes

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Re: Where's Elon when you need him?

No, not Shirley, Janet…

Mine's the macintosh

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: @Captain Scarlet

Leaks from the mains are an interesting problem. Unless the network owner actually has to buy the water they have no interest in fixing leaks because it doesn't cost them anything. IIRC, and I'm happy to be corrected, this led to up to 30% loss in the network. This is one of the reasons why modern competition regulation aims to separate network owners (water, gas, electricity, etc.) from the resource providers. This also explains why so much is spent lobbying against such regulation!

First Light says it's hit nuclear fusion breakthrough with no fancy lasers, magnets

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Tokamak, or not tokamak, that is the question...

One of the advantages of geothermal is providing warm water for households as this is, usually, the biggest energy demand. The idea is that, if every house can get enough geothermal energy to heat the place, we won't need as any power stations. Coupled with solar thermal and decent sized water storage and you effectively have a large battery in every house as well as the basis for air conditioning in hot weather.

Of course, doing this for every house is likely to prove a bit of a challenge and yields may drop the more people do it (like drilling wells). Still, it's better than some of the ideas out there.

As for fusion making itself unnecessary, that's unlikely to be the case, but the less of it we need, the better.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Tokamak, or not tokamak, that is the question...

Well, yes, it turns out that this is harder than we thought. However, it's not as if the research hasn't led to ancillary benefits, especially regarding large magnetic fields: making them, controlling them, etc.

DARPA says US hypersonic missile is ready for real world

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The rules change as soon as you go from defensive to offensive strategies, which is why to retake Donbas (and the Crimea) Ukraine is going to need different weapons. To succeed defensively, you just need to survive longer than the other guy. The civilian population will provide support and shelter as long as possible.

Going on attack and your supply lines quickly become your biggest problem. If you move into enemy territory you also have to know how you're going to deal with the civilian population. Will it cooperate? Or will it need "subdueing"? And feeding?

There is no appetite in Ukraine for anything other than reclaiming post-Soviet territory and there won't be weapons for anything else. That said, there are no doubt plans and discussions in the Pentagon, Langley and elsewhere for actions in Belarussia, Georgia, Transnistria, et al. And I've no doubt that there are assessments of whether parts of Russian military will turn against the Kremlin if the war continues to go this badly.

But in the meantime the Russians will continue to shell cities indiscriminately and use what precision missiles they still have as well as possible but also the terrorise the civilian population in occupied terrritory through murder, rape, hunger and torture.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

News just in: arms manufacturers like to use wars to sell their wares. Unfortunately for the Russian military machine the Ukrainian show of Mother Russia's almighty weapon wondery* is going that well.

  • the tanks are being taken out by minute men
  • the guided missiles are rarely guided (some of them are going boom before they leave the depot). In fact the best ones seem to be in their navy and there don't seem to be many of those left.
  • the hypersonic ones used were from the display cabinet
  • the aircraft can be taken out by some pretty aged systems
  • they can't manufacture any spares
  • the missile launchers may come with the wrong tyres and are likely to get stuck in mud

Elsewhere, orders are flooding in for Stingers™, Javelins™, etc. Switchblades™ will presumably be on the list once the Ukrainians are able to deply them (Kherson looks likely) along with their own homegrown loiterers-with-intent. And Turkey can probably sell 10 times more of its drones than it can make; and it will have to get the US permission for components to make more.

In other words: after years of disappointment with wars against people armed with little more than machine guns, the US arms industry has been able to show what even limited numbers of its systems can do against a supposedly well-equipped adversary. This is probably one of the reasons why Russia has gone all "Chechyna" on the civilans using murder, rape and hunger where weapons have failed.

* Vlad himself came up with the title, allegedly.

Google makes outdated apps less accessible on Play Store

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: What's the point?

What about when the APIs are removed? And there are then things like cryptography libraries.

I'm not necessarily keen on Google's role as gatekeeper, but as long as sideloading is possible the damage is limited.

'Virtually no difference' between AI and humans in diagnosing prediabetes

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Health warnings on cigarette packages give you a fairly reasonable idea of, when faced with immediate gratification, how resistant we generally are to risks or consequences.

Besides, a change in lifestyle involving diet, exercise and daily routine is challenging even for the most motivated.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

This isn't really a diagnosis but screening and it's arguably a waste of expensive doctors' time to screen.

This is why ML is increasingly used for screening certain types of cancer: it's faster and more reliable. Rinse and repeat for anything that has clearly visible markers and, in a few years, a home screening kit may be as common as, say, a thermometer.

However, for lifestyle diseases like type 2 diabetes, there are probably easier ways of doing this than expensive pancreatic scans.

The metaverse of fantasy worlds is itself still a fantasy

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I think we agree that large meetings, whether in person or online, are generally inefficient for the reasons you list.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

On calls I don't use a camera and I disable incoming video feeds, which I find incredibly distracting. I suspect this says as much about me as it does about the technology but I find video calls significantly less productive than normal meetings and the temptation to use spare cycles for, er, other purposes is pretty big.

With normal meetings I guess you have to factor things like travel, etc. in but I still find them more effective if the personal aspect can be taken into consideration, only possible in small meetings. Video calls have been possible since the early 1970s have consistently managed to disappoint. They can be useful as ice breakers at the start of a call but after that audio plus screensharing is generally best.

There are plenty of opportunities for VR in medicine, engineering, education and games, but they're all going to be self-contained with little need for interoperability beyond the usual needs for standardisation.

The bet by Silicon Valley is that immersive experience of games will spill out into other fields: you'll take a break from Fornite or Minecraft to hold a video call or remotely fix a valve.

Apple patched critical flaws in macOS Monterey but not in Big Sur nor Catalina

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: There is an official update available from Apple

It's not quite that bad: hardware tends to receive OS updates for 5-6 years, which in terms of a business device, is reasonable and better than many Windows PCs, which by that time may still be receiving OS updates from Microsoft but the manufacturer has long since stopped caring.

That said, the policy is somewhat arbitrary and annoying. I have a perfectly good 2010 MacBook Pro with a refurbished battery that, for Apple's own reasons, can't go beyond Lion. So, it's just sitting around waiting to go on ebay, because there is at least still a market for it.

I'm still on Catalina with my 2020 Intel MBP and my reserve 2016 MBP (you have to have a reserve not least because of battery issues with Macs and this one too has a new battry) because I'm waiting for Apple to fix all the problems with their new architecture and merging with IOS. And I also need to have the same basis for hot-swapping, in case of hardware failure.

That the patch for the graphics driver has not been released for the older versions is disgraceful, though I assume Apple will get round to it when it suits. IANAL but I don't think the argument that there is a new version of the OS would really wash here because the new OS comes with new T&Cs.

Google talks up its 540-billion-parameter text-generating AI system

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Slightly obvious flaw

That's great if you want a bot to join in the conversation

It's not so good for the next Walter Kronkite, Brian Redhead, Bertrand Russell, Max Headroom, etc.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

I also think the term parameter is misleading here. It's obviously ludicrous in the normal sense of a variable that when changed, changes some behaviour (gear ratio on a car, for example): there's no way operators can deal with that number of parameters.

You forgot to add that apart from "toxic text", babies are able to produce other toxix items…

Mines the one with the weird stain on the front and baby wipes in the pocket…

US, UK, Western Europe fail to hit top 50 cheapest broadband list

Charlie Clark Silver badge

PPP anyone?

If the price comparison is solely based on exchange rates then it is inherently flawed. There is the concept of "purchasing power parity" which is supposed to mitigate exchange rate effects by comparing the price of similar products in local currency around the world. There are flaws in this, too, but it's often useful, especially when comparing what are average wages and what can be bought with them. The lower the average wage, the cheaper services will seem in comparison, but PPP can correct this to show that some things are in fact more expensive.

Of course, broadband costs are based on a mixture of high capital costs to build the network – the higher the penetration, the higher the cost – and lower wage and fixed costs to sell (got to have sales and marketing) and maintain it, plus some variable costs related to interconnection and peering charges. So you need to reflect those in any comparison.

War tends to play hell with infrastructure and telecoms is no exception. While they weren't murdering and raping, Putin's Chechens were also destroying and looting whatever they could take with them: copper cables being one of the favourites.

But elsewhere in the country, and relevant for the comparison, it seems that Ukraine benefits from having lots of internet service providers. Apparently, this might have something to do with competition. Just don't mention this to the FCC which is happy to see monopolies in the US…

Elon Musk buys 9.2% of Twitter, sends share price to the Moon

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Truth Optional

Elon Musk can't apply because he wasn't born in the US…

Making predictions for US elections is fraught with difficulty but I suspect Trump won't get another chance. By then the world will have moved on while he hasn't and there are plenty of "soundalikes" who fancy their own chances. If he's not in prison by then, he'll probably enjoy choosing his successor.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Re: "Given that Twitter serves as the de facto public town square…"

The Register is not quite Radio4

Personally, I've been pleasantly surprised at the resilience and development of commentary on El Reg. While there are plenty of oldtimers, it seems there is reasonable supply of new people with their own ideas. There are areas of broad agreement but, politics aside, I think there are few areas where the "my way or the highway" mentality of many echo chambers. And even when politics breaks through, it's generally (not always), possible to accept differing opinions may be valid. Of course, this does indicate some degree of socio-economic self-selection, but that's true for all media. And I suspect the moderators are kept busy.

And, The Register, manages to provide a degree of balance through the bootnotes, etc.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Why didn't old Trumper think of this?

For all his claims about his self-made wealth, he doesn't have as much money as Musk. There's money in his PACs but they would face trouble with a media investment.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

"Given that Twitter serves as the de facto public town square…"

Please, may this never be the case. It's just one of the many echo chambers that the internet has faciltated.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I hope he does take it over

That would be nice but it's not how capitalism works. While he is no doubt a talented and impressive entrepreneur, most of Musk's money comes from investors rather than profits from companies: faith in the future of Tesla causes people to buy shares now, driving up the price. This in turn drives down the cost of capital for the company, which provides an advantage over other companies that finance from cashflow. Lax monetary policy over the last decase has increased this advantage.

Microsoft arms Azure VMs with Ampere Altra chips

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: what

I think high-end x86 still outperform ARM in some single-threaded disciplines, but ARM has the edge in many other areas due to the degree of hardware acceleration, and, with Apple at least, faster memory.

And I agree with you, if anyone is to criticise the marketing, then hyperthreading is the place to start: any advantages disappear immediately for CPU intensive work.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Many data centres now have their own energy generation units (usually renewables because these are cheap and tax efficient) on site. But the simple economics of ARM systems with better per core performance in cheaper and smaller packages match customer expectations better. Virtualisation, essentially timesharing, makes sense on individual machines, but when you're billing for use, dedicated resources make more sense.

Court erred in Neo4j source license ruling, says Software Freedom Conservancy

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: This is why some people prefer the BSD licence

You're right but that not is relevant in this case.

The problem here is the same as with many dual licensed projects, which try and limit commercial exploitation of a project to a single company whilst keeping it open source.

Japanese startup makes baby carrier-style sling for 'Love Robots'

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I didn't look but, oh, where's the goatse gone?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Lots of April Fools involve setting up websites. For techies, it's part of the fun.

DeepMind 'grossly inadequate' at tackling sexual harassment, says former staffer

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: NDAs

Indeed, but also in the UK, you could easily just take the case to the police because it's a crime. Whether they'll take it seriously is another matter.

It's the Americans that tend to harassment as a civil case and the NDAs come into play only when out of court settlements have been made.

Docker goes double unicorn with $105m Series C funding and $2.1b valuation

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: TLDR

The great thing about private companies is that they don't need to provide full details about the money. However, for a company of Docker's size and age, $ 100 million probably won't last that long. And Bain also has a reputation for flipping companies after asset-stripping streamlining them. Sounds like an IPO is off the table so hoping to sell to a competitor.

Apple emits macOS, iOS, iPadOS patches for 'exploited' security bugs

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Nothing yet for Catalina

Only a Safari update. But nice to see Apple finally picking up the pace on updates.

Windows 11 growth at a standstill amid stringent hardware requirements

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Why move to Windows 11 ?

Years from now. The only thing that really matters in Windows 11 is the EOL for Windows 10. That's all CIOs will care about but by 2025 it's higly likely that many, if not most, corporate environments are virtualised and only need RDP.

Zlib crash-an-app bug finally squashed, 17 years later

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Irony

No one was proactive in fixing this, including companies that arguably make billions from using it.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Given the fact that Zlib is really just away to compress data, including http connections, I'm not sure that monoculture is an issue. But this is clearly an instance of the tragedy of the commons: everyone uses it but no one maintains it.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Ouch

Doesn't libpng require zlib as a dependency?

In any case lots of software, inlcuding MS Officce, will need updating because zip is the default file format for many, even if they use different file extensions.

Expect 'long tail of cyber retaliation' from Russia for sanctions, says ExtraHop CEO

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Russia has limited resources

Those that can leave will probably have already done or are in the process of doing so. I certainly don't buy the idea that Russia is leaving off cyberattacks against the West just because the tanks have rolled over the Ukrainian border.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Russia has limited resources

While it has in the past executed all kinds of cyberattacks, Russia has limited resources, specifically hackers to engage on this and the current brain drain because of the war and sanctions will also be having an effect. Even those sympathetic to Putin's war might well be considering their options. Reports are that the Russian military is already drafting reserves and training staff into the war. Who's going to want to wait for their call up?

Intel counters AMD’s big-cache PC chip with 5.5GHz 16-core rival

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Let's Qualify that 5.5GHz Figure

The densities sound impressive and the technology that achieves it is impressive. But once you start thinking in the world of atoms then you realise that potentially there's a long way to go, which is why work on optical computers – bugger the size because switching is so much faster than using electrons – or molecular ones – a data centre the size of a sugar cube is ongoing, because we're reaching the physical limits of electronics, especially the ones like transistors dependent upon or susceptible to quantum effects.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Let's Qualify that 5.5GHz Figure

And then there are the packaging other optimisations of Apple's chips. 5.5 Ghz might be needed to run the software for which there is no hardware acceleration.

Debugging source is even harder when you can't stop laughing at it

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Go

Ah, Father Jack's Guide to Coding. You forgot: drink! and girrrls!

Will Chinese giants defy US sanctions on Russia? We asked a ZTE whistleblower

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Re: … it will be because they can't help but chase the revenue…

Your argument extends a false premise into nonsense. Trade with America is essential for many economies for many reasons but these three are key: the size of the market, source of capital, rule of law.

That many sanctions are poorly thought out, ineffectual and partial is well-known, Iran springs to mind. But sanctions-busting is entirely market-driven and the Russian market is not that interesting for many, or do you think Putin the Paranoid is keen on letting the Chinese run its networking and telecoms?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I don't think many Chinese companies will defy the sanctions

Economically sanctions act to drive up the risk premium. If the counterparty then goes on to default, the risk premium is likely to become unaffordable.

That said, Russia did largely manage to avoid the full pain of sanctions post 2014. This was largely down to the profits made by rising prices on essential resources. However, strip the economy of energy resources and you'll see that it has been in decline for over a decade. This is why Russia continues to lose trained personnel, essential if you want to build up "substitute economy" and nowhere is this more apparent than in the armed forces which have thus far been shown to be far worse equipped than most imaginged. Though this is as much down to the kleptocracy as any inability to make parts.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

… it will be because they can't help but chase the revenue…

Apart from selling military kit, which is incompatible with the stuff Russia makes, there isn't much revenue for Chinese companies in Russia. It's a resource rich kleptocracy, where the profits that come from exporting resources get spent on trinkets for the rich.

Ukraine uses Clearview AI to identify slain Russian soldiers

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Fallen soldier identification

For mothers who have not heard from the sons for weeks if not months this might come as a blessing. Russia is still claiming that any conscripts in Ukraine are there by mistake…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

They're doing that mainly by listening in to the non-encrypted radio chatter, which is why they know that Russia is now deploying not just some troops, but entire battle groups from the Eastern Military District (Siberia). Ukrainian troops can all understand Russian and recognise many of the accents.

Mozilla creates paid-for subscriptions for web doc library

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Non-starter

You make no commercial arguments for the switch. Apple has largely frozen browser development because it has achieved what it needs: a runtime to replace Flash for music and video content.

Switching to Gecko would be a huge wrench for Apple's team. It is far easier for it to pick bits of Blink and make it work with Webkit.

BOFH: Putting the gross in gross insubordination

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Very nice indeed

But also a real win-win. You'd have thought the beancounters might suspect something but obviously the young and the weak are targeted by the pack!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

What's left after the security guard burps?

An advert for a junior sys admin?