* Posts by Charlie Clark

12180 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

What's silent but violent and costs $250m? Yes, it's Lockheed Martin's super-quiet, supersonic X-plane for NASA

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Hmmm lots of US government money seems to going into that, don't think Boeing will be bleating if they get the benefits.

Seeing as Lockheed has got the contract, how will Boeing benefit? Anyway, this is from NASA's tiny budget. The real money flows from DARPA's conveniently non-discretionary teat.

Here's the list of Chinese kit facing extra US import tariffs: Hard disk drives, optic fiber, PCB making equipment, etc

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I'm with Mr. T on this one

You're absolutely right, but Trump's trade war isn't going to help this.

He just wants Republicans who support him to do well in the mid-terms. If there is a real trade war, it would lead to significant job losses in the US. But Trump only needs a phoney one so the chumps in Trumpistan think that next week, next month, next year things will improve for them. So expect lots of announcements about hard tariffs while the details leak out. Trade will largely displace and America will become a less attractive place to do business, but it might mean keeping majorities in a far more pliant Congress.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I'm with Mr. T on this one

It's basically impossible to export even small quantities of many products into China due to ridiculous laws and red tape at customs.

Doesn't seem to have stopped the Germans selling into China. Making in China is more of a problem but the US market is pretty damn well protected as well.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Oh no !

There is a difference, though, in that Taiwan is extremely open about trade, more so even than Europe.

Wouldn't have anything to do America's promise to defend Taiwan from China and the massive arms deals as a result would it? Taiwan, like South Korea, is almost a US client state.

China does play fast and loose with trade rules, but largely because multinational corporations are desperate to get at the huge market and boost their own profit margins by making there. However, the end of the low wage employment boom is in sight with peak employment probably already past. At the moment it's not clear whether it will be automation or the declining labour force that drives the biggest change in China since Deng Xiaoping. Sort of like Japan since the 1990s but so much more so.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Back when Europe had import duty on DRAM ...

Displacement is the likely result of these tariffs as well and that's for those on stuff the US actually imports from China. But Trump doesn't care, he just wants to look good in front of the base.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Even American military arms suppliers can't compete in the US market

The depressing part is, this will actually create jobs.

I think this is unlikely. If the US retreats from international trade, it will attract less investment and it is investment that's needed to create the jobs. Instead US isolationism could weaken the dollar hegemony, potentially driving up US funding costs significantly, unsettling financial markets and driving investment and jobs elsewhere. As has happened with every protectionist regime of the last 50 years. Sure, American won't be another Zimbabwe or Venezuela but it will be diminished.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Trade deficit 375 BILLION dollars.

Trade surpluses are a problem, usually of the country with them. What does China do with all that cash? Buy American assets, particularly US treasury bills. If you want to know where this leads look at the Japanese boom and bust of the 1980s and 1990s. Germany isn't doing that well with its own trade surplus either: it means savings being invested abroad in dodgy assets.

International monetary policy has for years trade more or less successfully, usually the latter, tried to deal with the problem of surpluses. Trade wars, howeve, have never worked because all the incentives are against them.

However, news just in: American manufacturing jobs were lost to automation and rationalisation. Difficult to see how giving US robots preferential treatment will bring well paid jobs back to the rustbelt.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: @ Tom 38 You don't get it...

Trump is an interesting character.

And a poor diplomat: driving rapprochement in Korea is not in American interests. But as long as it plays well at home he'll do pretty much anything regardless of the consequences.

Law's changed, now cough up: Uncle Sam serves Microsoft fresh warrant for Irish emails

Charlie Clark Silver badge

it's a new action related to an old case.

Which makes it different to restrospective in what way exactly? It would set a very dangerous precedent if it succeeds. I would not be in the least surprised if the most conservative judges come down the hardest on this aspect. Will be fun to see Trump moan about judges he picks but can't sack.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Next step?

I suspect trying to apply it retroactively is enough to get it thrown out of most courts.

OTOH Trump has just made himself wide open to the next "Benghazi" because the new law will also allow non-US spooks access to data held on servers in the US. What could possibly go wrong? Okay, those provisions will probably be thrown out on constitutional grounds because of the protection that the US constitution offers to US citizens (the rest are just "aliens" and fair game for spooks, scammers, etc.).

Why a merged Apple OS is one mash-up too far

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: OS !== UX && OS !== CPU

Linux runs Android and can run desktops. So a common kernel is already a reality…

That's a bit sweeping and, as a result, misleading. The monolithic Linux kernel does support lots of different archs but tends to get customised for each one as a result. Then there is the boon and curse of the different layers, especially when it comes to GUIs which is why both Android and MacOS (some fanboi has just edited one of my questions on AskDifferent to use the "official" writing) mandate their own tightly coupled app frameworks and why lots of people moan about Android not being a full Linux.

With the Mach kernel Apple should have it easier porting the majority of the OS services to different archs and it has been doing for years on simplifying the GUI toolset. Though it probably wants to refactor some of the IOS settings that have grown all kinds of warts in the last few years.

But a toolkit that works for both a touch and mouse interface is notoriously difficult to get right. As always the devil is in the detail of the kind of widgets you want in which environment. I'm seeing this with the Gemini, which is a lovely device (sound on mine could be unusually poor), that is at the limits of a keyboard and touchscreen interface (you can reach the lower part of the screen with your fingers while typing) where a lot of widgets are being caught out on the half-height screen. But you can do a lot and for the rest you can let developers provide different settings information for different widgets for different resolutions. Developers will appreciate this if it is done correctly and one of the reasons for the popularity of QT's QML, I believe.

As for converged devices, I'll believe them when I see them. Apple might well let others test the water and make a splash when it thinks there is a market to be had (it stopped pioneering years ago).

2001: A Space Odyssey has haunted pop culture with anxiety about rogue AIs for half a century

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Headline?

indeed, but pandering to the audience goes way too far

It does, but when you're investing hundreds of millions it makes sense. Hollywood is happy to let independent or foreign films take the risks and then remake what sells well.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Headline?

Indeed, it was from The War with the Robots by Karel Capek that we got the word. Dystopias and Utopias are symbiotic which is why where we have Verne, we also have Wells; where one inspires the other cautions.

The greatness of 2001 lies in the fact that Hollywood producers didn't get the chance to sanitise and glamourise it. But they did learn from it which is why since then spaceships are noisy, because audiences apparently didn't appreciate the silence in space.

Intel outside: Apple 'prepping' non-Chipzilla Macs by 2020 (stop us if you're having deja vu)

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "cheaper than Intel"

For "cheaper" read bigger margins for Apple: margins on the phones are higher than those on the notebooks not least because the CPUs are cheaper to make.

But it's not the main reason: ARM allows more customisation and control and Apple has been increasing the parts that it designs itself, which allows it to differentiate its products more from the competition. Apple can then choose which manufacturer makes its design, though once Qualcomm gobbles NXP there won't be many.

Let's go to Mars, dude: Euro space parachute passes maiden test

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: not a fluid dynamics expert but...

If you go high enough up conditions are similar enough to test the systems. Well, as good as you can get without having a spare planet in the shed!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

From the linked article.

The Schiaparelli probe was an experiment to test the landing process on Mars.

So smirking about a test that exposed flaws in the landing process seems a little hubristic. Yes, it was an expensive test but it was still a test.

Happy as Larry: Why Oracle won the Google Java Android case

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Would be more like someone asserting copyright on the SQL specification and going after anyone who implemented it without obtaining the right to do so — I'm not even sure if you can obtain a licence for a copyright in the same way you can get one for a patent.

There is a bit more to this because of the stuff that Google did copy, but it could turn a few specifications into minefields.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: And here I was thinking...

Java != OpenJDK

But if the judgement stands then it will be enough to consider all Java as "tainted" which would be a nice irony!

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Don't open the champagne yet…

I thought the judgement referred the case back to Alsup's court for damages so the amount of any damages might be revised.

If the $ 8bn is upheld then this will have serious consequences for software development in the US as it effectively opens the courts to similar cases on almost all software. A real bonanza for patent trolls given how long copyright exists for. MPEG and other consortia are probably calling lawyers already.

I think Google may still have additional legal avenues to appeal. I still don't follow the copyright argument. I understand what you say but consider it egregious to try and assert copyright protection over an implementation of a published interface. I think this touches different legal areas, not just copyright. But I'm neither an American nor a lawyer so I'll leave that to their courts.

Brit cloud slinger iomart goes TITSUP, knackers Virgin Trains, Parentpay

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Telegram was also down in EMEA for about an hour about 09:45 GMT.

I wish these companies would run monitoring and status services on other systems.

Uber self-driving car death riddle: Was LIDAR blind spot to blame?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Really? Uber decided just to do whatever it damn-well felt like?

diverting some of the investment into bank accounts as a share of the company is acquired is within the ability of most of these people.

Investors, yes but not employees who receive shares in lieu: their shares are untouchable and untradeable. Yet another way the VCs manage to shaft people. Didn't Kieren cover this a while back?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Really? Uber decided just to do whatever it damn-well felt like?

that Kalanick and his bros have probably already cashed out

Difficult to do if the company hasn't been sold or done an IPO: all the valuation shit means nothing until then. Any trading is done between investors.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "...a [Lidar] blind spot low to the ground all around the car."

I have wondered what happens when a lidar system, spitting out a presumably rather bright light (as far as its sensors are concerned) meets another lidar system

I think this is done by using specific frequencies for each car.

Huawei consumer biz pres: Are we in talks with Trump? Nope

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "The USA has slightly more than 4% of the world's population"

Economy of scale doesn't work well always - or Apple won't be the company with the highest market cap. You can go bankrupt instead selling a lot of cheap stuff.

Amazon, which does have famously thin margins, recently surpassed Apple in market capitalisation, I think. So you're wrong both on assumption and conclusion.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: The only loser is the US consumer..

And, is it any different for cars?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The American gadget market is hard

I seem to remember that non-US badged phones have always struggled. I suspect that Apple has a handy lead with Samsung second but only due to an almighty marketing push – too lazy to look for real data. I don't think an absence of tarrifs would make much difference for Huawei and they're right the various Asian markets are much bigger.

Huawei really wants to be able to sell kit to the networks. But, again, the US has always been pretty protectionist in this area.

Java-aaaargh! Google faces $9bn copyright bill after Oracle scores 'fair use' court appeal win

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Still reeling

It seems reasonable to protect a good API

Which is why the majority of software specifications are open and royalty free? If you want interoperabiity then you don't build barriers.

I suspect one consequence of this ruling, no matter how much damages are awarded, will be to encourage Google to get rid of Dalvik. It's been working its way toward this for the last couple of years.

Apple turns hat around, sits backwards on chair, pitches iPad to schools

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: I wonder if students using Chromebook in school is bad for Apple?

Apple understands service lock-in more than most. The US school and college market have traditionally been seen as gateways for future business decisions hence the plethora of cheap licences from MS, Oracle, et al. It's also structured nicely for advantageous tax write-offs: where do you think the rebates come from.

That said it's not that big a market but Google's apparent success has obviously shaken Cupertino a bit and competition is good.

Take the dashboard too literally and your brains might end up all over it

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Thumb Up

Have an extra upvote for the Land Rover remark.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Why do Mazda fake the data?

You're right that car dashboards are the equivalent of complicated Swiss watches. But we all like to think we're going to be driving in the next Le Mans or Paris-Dakar…

Fatal driverless crash: Radar-maker says Uber disabled safety systems

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: NTSB opens field investigation into Tesla X fatality

Tesla saves a lot of money by not using LIDAR…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: The Shape of Things to Come...

What it needs is a couple of major motor insurers to stand up and say "on the present showing we will not be quoting to insure automomous vehicles"

I think you'll find that insurers are pretty keen on autonomous vehicles. They know how shit a lot of human drivers and also the value of the data collected. In legal terms the case in San Francisco against GM is likely to be much more relevant than Uber's fuckup. Insurance is likely to be one of the biggest carrots for autonomous vehicles.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
FAIL

Re: We must ban all self-driving cars on public streets now

In my opinion, the @USDOT should

You seem to be forgetting the little thing of states rights…

Slap visibility beacons on bikes so they can chat to auto autos, says trade body

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Yeah... enforcement

Sadly, people are not responsible, they need to know that breaking the rules ALWAYS invokes a certain, even minor, punishment.

I think it's probably a case of both carrot and stick. It's interesting to see how effective the helmet propaganda has been in some countries and yet you'll see cyclists in helmets riding like numpties. There was research into how ABS and airbags actually increased reckless driving and I think there is a bit of this with helmets.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Yeah... Right

no lights, dark clothing, brakes not working and no helmet

Sounds like the Netherlands… Until public policy consitently sees bicycles as vehicles and thinks about the kind of traffic management this needs there will continue to be half-hearted measures that are poorly enforced and misplaced faith in helmets.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Why not...

Forget to properly lube up your butt plug and it's chafing?

It's the chafing I like.

Typical keyboard warrior full of guts and glory when hidden…

Hence the real name, 'cos I'm scared. Your passive-aggressive, value-signalling reply is worse than your initial post.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

LIDAR probably does help trouble with a bike but you're basically right: wait for the technology to catch up so that hi-res, hi-speed cameras can be used as well.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: Why not...

Thumbs down for asking a simple question? Tough crowd today.

Have an extra downvote for being a whiny shit.

In answer to your question: firstly, metal tubes make pretty good Faraday cages; secondly, what about the all the existing bikes out there? Do these stay invisible and we simply declare open season on them?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Stop

Re: Not that much power

A radio beacon would require less power than a puny set of lights that will get a cyclist killed on an unlit road.

A cyclist needs no help whatsoever to kill themself on an unlit road at night. Not sure how a radio tag would help there either.

But why stop at bikes? Small children and animals should surely also be fitted, right?

Or you could spend money reducing the likelihood of bikes and cars meeting…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Yeah... Right

As ever it's enforcement: in the UK this would include making sure motorists don't treat cycle lanes as parking spaces.

But, actually, this kind of solutionism is an attempt to avod the difficult and expensive problem of traffic flow management. There are very few accidents between cars and bicycles in the Netherlands, and the recent experience in Copenhagen shows that this isn't just a one-off.

UK.gov: Here's £8.8m to plough into hydrogen-powered car tech

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: The New Hybrid

actually thought methanol as a fuel (either direct or in a fuel cell) was still more dangerous than petrol as it is actually more flammable

You could very well be right because it has a lower boiling point, but also far lower energy density than petrol. But I think the design made this a bit moot because the engine never runs that hot. I never looked at this in detail so I happy to be corrected.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: £8k subsidy per vehicle

Seriously, if someone is going to spend £60k on a car, they don't need an £8k handout from the government.

Since when has need ever had anything to do with it? Lots of subsidies go to those who don't need them. Think of all the lolly that landowners like Paul Dacre get for doing nothing.

Elsewhere Mr Orlowksi has ranted about how subsidies for renewable energies act like a tax on the poor. I don't agree with all the arguments (simplified for effect) but subsidies almost always tend to lead to distortions. This is generally true but isn't itself an argument against subsidies as they can still help to change behaviour. That said, the subsidies for electric cars in most countries have basically functioned as tax breaks for value signalling.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Re: Maybe on the plus side ...

Where's that too-cheap-to-meter energy we were promised in the 70s

Coming real soon now that we have £350 million a week extra to spend on research. And cake, of course!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: The New Hybrid

Assuming that the boffins can somehow deal with all the issues and objections to hydrogen fueled fuel cells

Well, seeing as hydrogen is the main problem that's going to be difficult. Hydrogen just as too many drawbacks: low energy density, incredibly difficult to store and the tendency to destroy containing vessels. I seem to recall work being done on using methanol as the storage and cracking it to get the hydrogen. This would be great if it worked because methanol can be transported easily and is relatively safe and easy to make.

Galileo, Galileo, Galileo, off you go: Snout of UK space forcibly removed from EU satellite trough

Charlie Clark Silver badge

think the last 'negotiator' that had a sufficiently large pair to gain anything from the EU was Maggie

Maybe initially when it came to the rebate but her strategy became obvious and the rest worked around it. This meant Britain thought it got crowd-pleasing exemptions but was actually being excluded from the good stuff. This worked so well that they stuck with it all the way to the referendum.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: The Swiss are in it

This is just more childish EU

This from the people that brought us "Brext it means Brexit". You really can't make the shit up that people come out with!

First there were notebooks. Then tablets. And now ‘book tablets’

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Point?

Chrome OS is a more modern OS than Android which was rushed out the door.

I think they were both initially rather rushed. The fact that ChromeOS is gaining the ability to run Android apps indicates that the initial idea for ChromeOS of doing everything in the browser wasn't that well thought through either.

Corking story: Idiotic smart wine bottle idea falls over, passes out

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: These clowns were still in business?

Kuvee fits the same pattern as the Soylent: nerds extrapolating from their own slightly odd needs. Not really much different to people who peddle crystals for healing, etc. for which there seems to be a market. But only in the Valley will you find a VC willing to throw money at something so "magical and revolutionary".

Fleeing Facebook app users realise what they agreed to in apps years ago – total slurpage

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Why too short paragraphs are bad

Given that Apple has a far less permissive attitude to user privacy, Tim Cook was commendably not-smug when he chimed into the debate.

Speaking at the annual Chinese Development Forum in Beijing on Saturday, Bloomberg quoted Cook as calling for stronger, “well-crafted” privacy regulation.

This should be a single paragraph otherwise the reference to Cook is unclear.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: This is what could really do Zuckwit and his company serious harm

News for you: most people don't care and won't do anything. This is why regulation is required. Roll on GDPR.