* Posts by Charlie Clark

12166 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

Microsoft polishes up Chromium as EdgeHTML peers into the abyss

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The rewrite that never was

Edge was never a rewrite from scratch of IE. Not only did it share some of the same bugs, writing a new browser from scratch is a huge undertaking. Edge was IE without bits of shit like ActiveX. It had a new JS runtime and some other with bangs but basically built on the rewrites that started with IE 9. But without the lockin of ActiveX and no mobile base, it was obviously never going to be much more than the help viewer on Windows.

The IE team from IE 9 should be given credit for picking up the pieces of an abandoned project and working hard to implement web standards and continuing to do this with Edge. I think this means that Edge is a little bit more standards-compliant than Safari. Not bad considering where they were 10 years ago.

Space policy boffin: Blighty can't just ctrl-C, ctrl-V plans for Galileo into its Brexit satellite

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Strangely in the last week or so....

What impresses me most is that it's two and a half years since the referendum, just three months to leaving, and no one can actually determine if she's tilting towards leaving or remaining nor predict which or what we will actually get.

I guess this is largely because she doesn't seem to know either. She saw an opportunity to become leader of the party and Prime Minister and then didn't seem to know what to do afterwards. If she'd laid out a platform for conference in 2016 and called an election on the basis of it, she'd probably have won a credible majority to push it through. But, like Gordon Brown before her, she dithered and called the election too late and, more importantly, after officially asking to leave. Everything since then has been a rearguard action because, in the words of Harold Wilson, politics is the art of the possible and what is on offer is exactly that: an attempt to avoid a disorderly exit.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
WTF?

Re: Strangely in the last week or so....

Almost all of Remain voters do not understand what Remain means either.

A double strawman which implies only you know what the EU is and that the rest of us are clueless morons. Sounds like you have complete faith in referendums.

The EU has completely transformed its constitution, remit and makeup three times in twenty years, without any people’s vote.

What? You mean ignoring the ones required by law in Denmark and Ireland along with the advisory ones in France and the Netherlands?

Over 50% of current EU members have been fascist states within the past 50 years. Franco, Salazar, Greek colonels, and Hoxha seem all to have been forgotten

Numerically and geographically inaccurate. Time for your dried frog pills, methinks. FWIW Hoxha was the dictator of Albania, which isn't in the EU.

And are you suggesting that companies that have transitioned from autocracy to democracy can never be accepted as democracies? But let's not let the facts get in the way of your ranting…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Strangely in the last week or so....

Does seem stupid that leaders of the 3 main(tory, labour SNP) parties voted to remain but still we plough on for a minority vote to leave.

Not really. It's the role of Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition to oppose the government. The Tory party is as divided over the issue as it has been for the last 30 years, which is basically why, instead of taking responsibility for policy, Cameron abrogated it in a referendum, which unsurprisingly failed to resolve the problem.

Labour might fancy a general election but Corbyn doesn't really want to take responsibility for anything. I suspect that, should Labour win a general election, we'll see exactly the same kind of splits that we're seeing in the Tories. The SNP probably doesn't want an election (fewer seats for Scotland but also likely to lose more to both the Tories and Labour) but has also consistently argued to keep the status quo.

In other words: SNAFU.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Strangely in the last week or so....

she reluctantly calls a second referendum to break the impasse, at which point the slim majority of the country that can perform basic maths

I'm not sure there'e time for a referendum. And, even if there was, what would the question be? and what makes you think the public would behave differently than in 2016? I suspect turnout might be lower but a lot of people would vote for it to happen, whatever it is. I see images of buses covered with ads for large turkey dinners with £350 per turkey per day if only they vote for Christmas.

No, this is a mess that parliament created and that parliament should sort out. That is what responsibility means and the basis for parliament's sovereignty.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Strangely in the last week or so....

...my respect for Mrs. May has actually risen.

Mine is still below when, as chairman of the Tories, she told conference the party was known as the nasty party. That said, she now seems to be a bit surer of herself since the damp squib of the leadership challenge.

The deal is more or less was the EU proposed from the outset with some fudging that is supposed to help it pass parliament. It's miles from May's chequers plan and basically documents the possible: enough to claim some degree of independence while maintaining access to the single market. A few ministers have decided it's easier to join the backbenches than take collective responsibility for something they're all more or less agreed to at one point or another.

The whips now have the job of convincing their MPs that they've had a good run and that it's now time to put country before party. But you still hear people talking about brinksmanship being the way to get a better deal. That would be more of the brinksmanship that got Britain this far…

The EU will say the door is always open while continuing not to move an inch. Practically there is nothing that can be done that wouldn't need ratification by member states (the current deal fudges this as well) which certainly can't be done before the end of March 2019.

And in any case, migration from other member states continues to fall, while migration from outside the EU has actually risen over the last couple of years.

In summary, a lot of MPs think that they personally stand to gain by dragging this out.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Who needs GPS?

To go to the pit or factory? Return of annual wakes in Blackpool to revive the tourist trade on steam locomotives powered by Welsh nuts (RIP Tenniel Evans) and lashing of ginger beer all round!

As sales slide, virtual reality fans look to a bright, untethered future

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Wow, such a resounding endorsement. Sounds like I'll have to get one… It'll go well with the chocolate fireguard.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The real market is industry

Medicine, machine maintenance, fiddling with nuclear reactors is where there is a real market, although some of it may just be to train robots.

Blockchain study finds 0.00% success rate and vendors don't call back when asked for evidence

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Chain, yes, distributed, no

If you can distribute the compute on existing hardware and charge twice for doing half the work but plastering a buzzword on... then why not?

I'm not sure you can due to the work of trying to wrap all the different transactions into a single chain. But maybe it's a cunning plan by the energy industry for more power plants?

In any case, the idea that a distributed network of computers can guarantee the status of any one object – effectively truth – is a good example of the magical appeal of solutionism. As we're all, to a greater or lesser degree and in varying domains, open to such appeals, you can see that the market for bullshit is effectlvely endless and potentially very lucrative for those with sufficient self-control in front of the mark!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: There's a non filler talk on that topic

Thanks for the link. Not sure what a non-filler is but the slides are nicely done.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Chain, yes, distributed, no

I quite like the idea of using a blockchain to sign steps in a transaction but the distributed stuff is just a solution looking for a problem. You just need a trusted third party that holds the ledger / provides the service, like a clearing centre but one that is banned from conducting transactions on its own behalf. Where this is being done correctly we're seeing more competition for things like handling of payments. But this is about as newsworthy as introducing a new hashing algorithm.

Gartner to wearables biz: Through failure comes success!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Downside risk

While there is some obvious utility in some of the devices, particularly related to health this always comes with potentially huge downside risks if the very personal data collected is not looked after properly and American class actions get going. It also looks like that to grow prices and margins will have to shrink. A lot.

It was a lit CeBIT see, got teeny weeny, world's biggest tech show yearly party... closed its German fest's doors yesterday

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I'm sure the local economy will miss the opportunity to book out rooms at significant prices at show times.

I'm sure it will, though it still has the Hannover Messe…. Had to stay out somewhere even further while that was on once. The city of Hannover is a nice enough place but it doesn't really have the capacity for the larger trade shows and it doesn't have enough of those to justify building it out.

Not a price cut! Apple perks up soggy iPhone demand with rebate boost

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: iPhone SE

But the bluetooth is either broken or deliberately disabled.

The latter, part of Apple's strategy is to take existing, open protocols add something proprietary to it and licence it. So, instead of DNLA (media streaming over the network) you get "AirPlay" and Bluetooth is only useful for connecting to Apple headphones. People don't mind paying a premium as long as stuff "just works" and that is something that Apple generally does get right.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Who needs analysts?

Once people get sick of paying well over the odds for average technology then paying even more for Apple care then they will be finished. That day isn't too far away.

People overpay for the "average" technology all the time: just look at the car industry. The I-Phone has always charged a premium in comparison with other similar specced phones; memory has traditionally had the highest margin. And customers have been happy with the overall value proposition. Apple's biggest worry isn't really the prices they charge, it's customers thinking the phone they already have is good enough and that they'd rather spend their money on something else. The most recent highend I-Phones are stuffed with stuff no one apart from Apple bloggers really cares about. And then there's the fucking notch.

Not that this implies impending doom for Apple, they'll adjust the portfolio, like they did with the "c" models that didn't sell well, and present a new model, presumably without a notch and perhaps ever so slightly less expensive and it will sell like hot cakes. And it will continue its push into services.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Apple's problem

Is that the OLED display adds a ton of cost

I suspect the BOM won't really back that up and phones with similar screens from Shenzen are cheaper.

Apple probably doesn't mind the stock drop though - they still have $150 billion in stock buybacks planned over the next few years so having the stock fall by 25% means the buybacks are a better deal.

For whom? Share buybacks are generally considered to be the least efficient uses of cash. Sure, if the stock price falls then a company can buy more of its shares back. But, if the idea is to reward shareholders, their "reward" is worth less so the benefits are moot.

People pay too much attention to share prices both as auguries and assets which is why it's also important that companies pay dividends.

Amazon's homegrown 2.3GHz 64-bit Graviton processor was very nearly an AMD Arm CPU

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Let's recall the other definition of MIPS

Twice as fast as a raspberry Pi? Clocked at 2GHz?

Underwhelming.

Not really. As others have mentioned, it depends what you're doing with it and what else the silicon does. I'm sure if Broadcom were still developing silicon they might have had a chance at the contract because the RPi CPUs are such a known quantity. But they're not and options for volumes of server chips are limited.

But the workload for these chips is likely to be anything running on the lambda service. These are low latency, low workload, low power services where ARM makes more sense than x86_64.

Huawei MateBook Pro X: PC makers look out, the phone guys are here

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Cons

The website says 8 GB / 16 GB LPDDR3 2133 MHz*. So 16 GB is possible but I guess it's not user-configurable.

As you grow older you will need to adjust the resolution and, for desktop use, use an external monitor.

Apple heading for Supreme Court showdown over iOS App Store 'monopoly' gripe

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Monopoly probe...

Nah, restrictive practices are restrictive practices. Cf. Nestle losing its ability to be the only supplier of very expensive coffee for Nespresso machines. This should be a fairly simple smackdown against Apple, except that Silicon Valley often gets an easy ride in front of American courts. This is only partly down to the difficulty of applying some definitions of monopolies to the digital domain.

FWIW the 30% is something developers should be litigating against. Consumers should be pointing out the general lack of choice: Apple says you can't have different browser engines or mail clients or music players. This is not only restricting competition, it is also limiting innovation and also potentially reducing security: it's not as if Safari doesn't have its own share of zero days.

Blighty: We spent £1bn on Galileo and all we got was this lousy T-shirt

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Well, who'd have thought it?

I'd have thought May should be first up. Negotiating a deal that hands over billions with a loose "might do" text as regards a future "maybe" trade deal doesn't sound like a deal you could sell to anyone.

The great betrayal fallacy. May was the elected leader of the party that wanted to push ahead with leaving. She appointed pro-leavers to the job of top negoatiators. And this is the best they could come up with. Rinse and repeat and you won't change much because the UK wants access to the single market and doesn't want border controls with Ireland reintroduced.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Well, who'd have thought it?

Greece joined the EU in 1982. Spain in 86. Croatia a mere 5 years ago. People were going to these places long before they were in the union.

Visa-free travel was largely driven by the EU. The Open Skies programme has been a key driver of opening up the flights market in Europe. Yes, people were going somewhere foreign for their holidays before the Treaty of Luxemburg but the rolling back of borders certainly accelerated the trend.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Well, who'd have thought it?

For 40 years we've seen our coastal towns destroyed by the EU with the help of HMG.

More like cheap travel led to people preferring to spend their holidays in Mallorca, Greece or Croatia as going to any UK airport around Christmas demonstrates. No idea why this is the case. Wonder if the weather has anything to do with it?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
FAIL

Re: FFS

We'll just have to take the bull by the horns, re-build our Industry again and become the technological force again that we once were.

Still got your war pamphlets, I see.

Dig for Britain

<Britan can take it</i>

They profited the most from the EU's generous farmer-sponsoring.

Per person it's probably the welsh farmers who benefit most. Scotland makes most from the Barnet formuala for redistribution within the UK.

Of course, those who make the most are the large agribusinesses and I don't see much changing there. Well, perhaps they'll push to replace Bulgarian and Baltic farm labourers with others they can pay even less.

It used to work in the eighties (or other times before the EU)Did it bollocks, it was until the Single European Act that all trade barriers in the EU fell.

Seeing as Bitcoin is going so, so well, Ohio becomes first US state to take biz taxes in BTC

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Made for money laundering?

One would hope they have taken into account the money laundering angles.

Does indeed look to be made for this but in that case BitPay is probably likely to be on the hook. BitPay's play is obviously to encourage more people to use a volatile currency as a means of payment within a dollar economy. Hm, something seems odd in that statement, can't quite think what.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Paying taxes on credit *can* be a good idea

In most countries it isn't an option. Talking to the taxman is almost always the best option, most will happily offer plans or delays as cheaper and more efficient than chasing up outstanding amounts.

Reverse Ferret! Forget what we told you – the iPad isn't really for work

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

In the US, the iPhone has around half of the market, which insulates Apple to how niche it is becoming in other markets.

Make America Broke Again!

* Mine's the one with a copy of The Art of the Deal and sun-goggles in the pocket.

Black Friday? Yes, tech vendors might be feeling a bit glum looking at numbers for the UK

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Relief

I'm still hoping to get to a sofa / bed shop on a day when they're not having a sale of some kind.

So you've come for a long wait have you? Please take a seat…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Relief

I thought Germany had strict laws on sales - as to what prices you could charge and how often you could have them.

It used to: sales were limited to winter and summer but the rules were relaxed about 20 years ago so it's pretty much like the UK with sales all the time, with the best deals obtained outside the sale period…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Why? That just means selling less at other times and selling the stuff for less: cashflow now at the expense of profits. Sales should be about clearing inventory such as last year's models to make room for new magical tat.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Boffin

Relief

Here in Germany my inbox is blessed free from the e-mails touting tat that I don't want at any price. But it might just be that I managed to unsubscribe from all the notifications and GDPR mopped up the rest.

Who am I kidding? Bound to the calm before the storm…

Thanksgiving brings together Apple's Siri and Google Assistant

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Traditions

Xeophobic Nazi?

What's one of them?

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Happy

Traditions

In a very American celebration of setting aside differences to sit at the same table

You mean like the British Christmas which usually ends in shouting and fisticuffs (if done right)?

Sounds about right, especially considering it's celebration of the inadequacy of the Pilgrim Fathers — and what a bunch of inadequates they were! — to prepare for the winter and were dependent upon the generosity of the locals. And look how well that turned out for the First Nations! ;-)

Surely the moral should be: see a bunch of Americans starving, for God's sake don't help them or they'll take you for everything you've got!

Talk about a cache flow problem: This JavaScript can snoop on other browser tabs to work out what you're visiting

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Claims of spying are overblown

And what makes you think they don't already have a browser malware that includes a Red Pill? Hypervisor attacks ARE a thing, you know?

Anything that can do that can own the browser anyway.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Claims of spying are overblown

We show that we can spy from one browser tab on another and even from one browser on other browsers running on the computer.

Not really. The technique can detect which sites may have been visited with reasonable accuracy. That's enough for some degree of profiling but it's a long way from spying. And it relies on the really paranoid using multiple tabs and keeping the browsers open.

If I was really paranoid I suspect I'd disable tabs and possilby even run each browser instance in a VM.

Behold, the world's most popular programming language – and it is...wait, er, YAML?!?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Whitespace

I think it's a good language for teaching non-programmers to program. That doesn't mean I have to like it for more advanced work.

This seems to be common a misconception here. It's actually very suited for advanced work with the relevant performance sections offloaded to C, C++, etc. People are starting to move from Matlab to Python not just because of the licence costs but because they're getting the same performance with the features they want. YMMV, of course.

There's a reason why many embedded devices have crap software - the programmers have never learned the necessary skills.

That, and the fact that managers have often pushed for features and releases and not given a shit about quality or security.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Whitespace

There's a reason why many embedded devices have crap software - the programmers have never learned the necessary skills.

That, and the fact that managers have often pushed for features and releases and not given a shit about quality or security.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Whitespace

Are there many such people outside of an obfuscated code contest? That's an entirely different thing from preferring flexibility in the use of whitespace, rather than have its use forced by the language.

Not really, Python's use of whitespace makes it unambiguous This is big plus when reading code even if it is an unwelcome challenge from those coming from different conventions.

The compiler doesn't care whether brackets or whitespace are used for structure so the arguments are really those of personal preference or possibly psychometrics of people reading code. Haven't seen any of these recently but I seem to remember that they favoured whitespace for structure.

Whatever, if you don't like Python because of the whitespace then it's your loss as it's becoming the first computer language for a whole generation of non-programmers. Is this merely a coincidence?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Any language where the amount and flavour of whitespace is significant should be strangled at birth.

Because…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Makes me pine for the days of XML...

Which problems did XML actually solve? And which ones did it create?

Holy moley! The amp, kelvin and kilogram will never be the same again

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "...using methods that can be replicated anywhere on the planet."

There are measurements that suggest those constants are in fact not. Constant, that is (cannot remember which ones, though)

There are some observations that suggest that Planck's constant ("h") might not be, er, constant in space and time. Time is sort of understandable, at least in the very early phases of the universe during expansion but I think the observations are of much more recent times. Came across this a few years ago so it could have been debunked or theorised away but it would not suprise me in the least if the universe didn't have quite a few more surprises for us.

Alphabet gives bipedal robots the Schaft 'cos no one wants to buy its creepy machine maker

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: After the Google acquisition, it completely clammed up

Google hates outside code, outside programing languages, and outside libraries.

No it doesn't. It engages constructively in lots of different projects and actively supports others. It does have some odd development practices that seem to stem from people moving rapidly between projects and also from the shear scale of some deployments. I personally am flabbergasted that they didn't crash their data centres and network with all the transcoding they do for YouTube due to the world and dog insisting on 4K cat videos!

It does develop, acquire and abandon quite a lot of projects but this is within its role as investor. It seems to keep the useful stuff and role it into other projects. Lots of companies do this but generally seem to acquire and then shutdown potential competitors (Oracle, SAP, et al).

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: After the Google acquisition, it completely clammed up

Boston Dynamics was sold off. Google/Alphabet really doesn't seem to be interested in the war machine stuff. Presumably it's taken the IP it wants for Waymo and other bets.

Brits shun country life over phone not-spot fears

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Why is it ludicrous? All my life things like employment prospects, healthcare, education and transport have figured large in people's decisions on where to live and house prices and rents reflect this: somewhere close to a station/motorway costs more than somewhere a bit further away. For a while it was popular to live close to but outside a larger town but things likeand the move of jobs from "enterprise zones" back to cities and the the continuous increase in traffic have made this less attractive. Throw into this the problems of getting good teachers and medical staff to rural areas and the continuing decline of the farming population.

But, as the article says this seems largely PR for uSwitch.

iPhone XS: Just another £300 for a better cam- Wait, come back!

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Not me

What difference does it make if this is built into the phone or added by the user to suit their own individual use-case?

Or, as the car salesman said: "Oh you wanted wheels with it, did you? They cost extra…"

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Power efficiency difference

I think OLEDs are inherently more power hungry, presumably due to the discrete lighting. But, 10-bit colour in a consumer device? Who needs it? It's like some of the hifi stuff out there: technically superb but practically unnoticeable.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Not me

Put your phone in a case and apply a toughened glass screen protector.

Ie. the device, as sold, is not fit for purpose as the OP says: stupid design choice makes the device inherently susceptible to breakages.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Confused

I'm told Apples suppliers are reducing the number of conveyor belts coughing out the XR parts

Interesting. I guess this could be similar to the S6 / S6 Edge thing where people preferred the more expensive model. Of course, at these prices Apple can't really lose.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Confused

For a long time it seemed obvious which I-Phone was which but the new range has me confused. Not that I'm planning to buy one but I wonder: is it just me?

Six critical systems, four months to Brexit – and no completed testing

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Time running out

Why are you not having another referendum?

Because the first one was such a stupid idea! Having another one (what would the question be?) wouldn't be popular (and not just with Brenda from Bristol) and probably wouldn't change anything. Downside: everybody gets riled up again. Upside: can't really think of one.