* Posts by Charlie Clark

12172 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Apr 2007

Facebook Like, social sharing buttons on your website may land you in GDPR hot water if data goes a-wanderin'

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: This was the case...

Yep, pretty much an open and shut case. The "like" button is very clever marketing by Facebook but it really is just a tracking beacon and one of the reasons for the GDPR. More importantly, companies that use gimmicks like this are fooling themselves: while they can collect some data, they can only get what Facebook will give them, while Facebook gets to keep everything and aggregate it so that they can track users across the internet; they can (and do) even sell the data collected to companies' competitors. Would be nice to see more emphasis on the business aspects in these kind of stories.

Sticking with one mobile provider gets you... Oh. Price rises, big exit fees, and lovely, lovely lock-in

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Regulation failure

While some people are at fault for not paying attention to their contract and checking the market, a lot of this sounds like the kind of sharp practice that the regulator should put an end to before it starts. But who is the regulator here? Ofcom. Nuff said.

Apple iPhone X screen falls short of promises, lawsuit says

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: All true

There are no "real LED" displays

LG will happily sell you an OLED screen with all the contrast… OK the screens arent' quite as good as those on phones but given the distance you sit from them it hardly matters. But, LED backlighting has vastly improved the contrast levels of LCD screens because the backlights can be individually dimmed or switched off. Though, from what I see of how most people set their TVs up I don't think they'd notice or care.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Frivolity

I want my phone to be all display on the front

Why? To match your infinitiy pool and unframed works of art? The bezel is a perfectly functional element of a real world device. Making the phone all screen is either, just going to increase the number of broken screens, or increase the sales of covers to protect an increasingly fragile device.

While a lot of people do seem to ignore the notification bar, it's there for a (discreet) reason, which the notch unnecessarily disrupts.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Frivolity

In other words, a bezel.

I'm, and I think a lot of other people are as well, perfectly happy with bezels. The notch is a solution to a problem that doesn't exist and shows how much Apple has taken its eye off the ball.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Frivolity

So what happened to the principle of de minimis non curat lex?

In the US it was mugged by the terrible duo of Tort Law and Class Action.

The case looks well-constructed (for US courts) to me so I can see Apple being forced to concede a bit and adjust their marketing but I suspect any payout will be minimal: the claims are inaccurate but what are the damages associated with them?

Anyway, anything that brings about the end of the notch is fine with me!

Postmates plans rollout of autonomous delivery robots in US

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Robot Wars

The lack of a self-righting mechanism on this could be a problem in the arena, Dara.

The fastest, most secure browser? Microsoft Edge apparently

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Windows Phone also had various security reviews by whitehats that stated that it was more secure by design and implementation than Android and IOS.

Seeing as the design wasn't available in detail, it's difficult to see how this could be reasonably assessed. Some versions (and there were enormous technical differences between them) did, however, appear to fare well in tests.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Shock: certificate cartel doesn't like Let's Encrypt

It's arguable that certificate authorities themselves are responsible for the move to auto-generated certificates. These don't say anything about person that generated them but then they don't have to, they provide a validated public key for encryption.

But years of high prices and synthetic restrictions (one certificate per ip address) didn't stop the fraudsters or, worse, traffic hijacking.

A Christmas classic: Cloudera founder asks staff to stay another day

Charlie Clark Silver badge

a spate of people leaving of their own accord could rock the boat with shareholders or Wall Street and distract from handling the merger.

People leaving is highly unlikely to affect the vote unless shareholders are not really convinced that it makes sense. Usually they love mergers because it means less competition and fewer monkeys to pay.

Waymo presents ChauffeurNet, a neural net designed to copy human driving

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Simple questions

Your population from which you're taking your average includes a lot of young, inexperienced drivers. They pull the average down. With experience they'll get beyond average.

But they'll be replaced by equally inexperienced drivers so the average is more or less constant. As for getting better… I think that is dependent upon the routine: we get skilled as the journeys we most regularly make.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How many billions of dollars are being spent chasing this?

A baby only has to be shown a dog once or twice and it knows "dog".

At what age? It takes months for babies to be able to do anything non-instinctive. There do seem to be some hardwired behaviour such as identifying and watching facing but cognitive processing takes years. Oh, and there are lots of examples of how easy it is to fool human cognitive processing precisely because it depends upon some of the shortcuts we see in some machine learning.

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Re: I would dare Waymo

And what about on foreign planets? Don't see many meatware drivers on Mars…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Simple questions

What would a self-driving car do when the traffic light is red and a police officer makes you a quick sign to go ahead overriding the traffic light ?

I just saw this not happening and nearly leading to accident as a result. In many countries the emergency are allowed to run a red light but they do not have the right of way when doing so. More importantly, all the new vehicles do not used such rule-based approaches but can be trained fairly easily using examples. I think the point of the research is that training for everything becomes exponentially more difficult so different approaches are required.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: How many billions of dollars are being spent chasing this?

It's arguable that for at least the last 70 years most development around cars has been about improving safety and avoiding the problems caused by the meatware drivers. The costs, both financial and in lives, have been staggering.

While I don't think that autonomous vehicles will be suitable for everything, I do think that they will learn faster from their mistakes than each new generation of meatware.

In 2018, Facebook is the villain and Microsoft the shining light, according to techies

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "a beacon of all that was great and wonderful about social media"

Only a few one understood how dangerous it was since the beginning

Not sure about that. I think cultural studies has for some time been highlighting the dangers of mediated communication. What Facebook did really well was to make it pretty easy for people to give them their photos and thoughts in return for the promise of passing them on to their friends: it was easier to set up than a blog and came with notifications. It also fed the desire of the media and the politicians to engage with the public. The BBC's collection of brainfarts in its "Have Your Say" forums was one of the many canaries (usenet being one of the first) pointing out the fallacy but try getting a journalist to admit they're out of touch.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

The halcycon days

the Zuckerberg-front ad machine was once a beacon of all that was great and wonderful about social media

There was never anything wonderful about social media. It was always going to see the worst excesses of the echo chamber. But Facebook's invention was extremely clever marketing: by promoting the emotional side of "sharing", it encouraged people to share all kinds of data about their interests, preferences and contacts for Facebook to sell to advertisers and political campaigns.

Facebook might continue to attract scorn for the problems and ethics but the real risk it faces are people abandoning for messaging platforms, which only the Chinese have worked out to make money from. Though, if reports are to be believed, Facebook is preparing to rollout ads, and therefore tracking, in WhatsApp at some point in 2019. That would have been a more interesting topic for an article, too.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: none of the above

Don't forget Amazon, Spotify, Netflix, et al.!

Microsoft to rule the biz chat roost – survey

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Invalid numbers

I think you are underestimating the numbers hugely for Skype/ teams usage.

I doubt it but I suspect it depends a lot on how you define the use and hence the market. I've had to use Lync/Skype/Teams for one of my customers for years so I'm reasonably familiar with it and its use. You need a VoIP infrastructure to replace a traditional system after which it doesn't really matter what clients you use for it, but, sure Skype now does this quite well.

The market is really what companies are prepared additional money on. I'm not overly enamoured by Slack but I can see why it's popular in some environments and why Microsoft has been prepared to make Teams free go after it. I just don't think it will be enough to convince those with an investment in Slack to jump back. And, as I said, I think Microsoft is likely to miss stuff playing catch up.

When it starts force-feeding teams on GitHub it might be successful in establishing a new standard client but I'm not sure where the upside will be. Even if they achieve a dominant market share they're likely to find it hard to start charging. This has been the case for a lot of Microsoft products over the last ten years.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Invalid numbers

Looks like the numbers are based on installs. Seeing as Microsoft has shoehorned Lync/Skype/Teams/WhateverNext onto its enterprise customer machines it's hardly surprising to see the numbers flattering them. More indicative of the real market size are Slack and Hangouts as these usually mean overcoming inertia to get them installed and this usually happens when whatever is already there isn't enough. Microsoft might get there by making it the default. But that will almost inevitably mean "job done" and closing down the team and ignoring whatever the next new thing™ is, including not running Windows.

Neither Hangouts or Slack are perfect but that have both usually succeeded by doing one or two things that people care about very well. Slack works well with VCS systems that spew a lot of messages, Hangouts audio/video has always been rock solid and it scales fantastically. Microsoft has repeatedly failed to be as good in the same areas in its copycat products and, more importantly, failed to add anything worthwhile. Still, they don't give up easily. What next? Teams forced on Github I suspect as the dudes in Redmond discover Webhook APIs.

Dixons Carphone smarting from £440m loss as it writes down goodwill on mobile biz

Charlie Clark Silver badge

It isn't really any of the sellers' fault: the market has matured as it was bound to one day. Apple got an extension as it switched to bigger screens but the novelty of that seems to be wearing off too.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: hate it. use it

Hence planned obsolescence, welded-in batteries and short support cycles. No persuasion is now necessary.

Arguably we had more of that during the years of the two-year refresh cycle for the reasons listed in the original post. While there are some arguments for glueing and soldering everything, these should be countered by the right to repair. But even then most of us will choose to replace stuff because it's cheaper…

Microsoft, you shouldn't have: Festive Windows 10 Insiders build about as exciting as new socks

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Real progress

has finally added the option to save files in UTF-8 without a Byte Order Mark

Wow! But how long has it taken? Will it also disappear from whichever .NET code is responsible for spunking BOMs on JSON?

Register Lecture: Right to strike when your boss sells AI to the military?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: A conscience is a fine thing

If you find yourself working on a project with which you don't agree you should be able to ask to work on something else. If that isn't possible then a change of employer might be required.

Don't think it really matters whether this "dual use" military stuff or, say, genetic sequencing for the cosmetic industry, etc.

Latest Google+ flaw leads Chocolate Factory to shut down site early

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Google does it's usual...

Can you think of any company that provides unlimited free services forever?

Have a gander at this: Amazon agrees not to act as Silicon Valley's foie gras dealer

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Chacun à son goût

Maybe to the city-folks in the audience, but not to the critters in question. Back when I raised meat birds, the geese would line up for their free fill-up(0).

Sorry, I didnt want to ignore that. I'm not a coutry boy but that's my understanding, too. However, the foie gras bit does usually involve some additional feeding, that may include force-feeding, in the last few days.

The whole law i, based on squeamish hyprocrisy: the lifestyles of many of the proponents is dependent upon exploitation which they find acceptable just as long as they don't have to watch videos of it.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Chacun à son goût

Foie gras is enlarged duck or goose liver, which is made using the unpalatable process of gavage

Personally, I find foie gras too rich but the fuss about force-feeding is more namby-pambyism. Yes, the practice is unpleasant but on the whole the ducks and geese have a much better time of it than say the majority of pigs and chickens do in the massive factory farms around the world.

Dine crime: Chippy sells deep fried Xmas dinner

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Xmas dinner?

Possibly true if all you ever eat is roast beef. But with poultry? Gravy yes, but not horseradish.

The rule is: if you can have cabbage with it, you can have mustard with it (the same family after all), but you don't have to. Just make sure it's the good stuff: purveyors of any of the "mild" stuff should join the marketing department of the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation when the revolution comes!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Xmas dinner?

Bread sauce, on the other hand, is awesome.

You mean clove-flavoured cement? You're on your own with that stuff. Good gravy, good strong mustard and hot horseradish are all the condiments you ever need.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Obligatory video from Bottom. Though you really need to watch the Christmas episode to know where they come from.

That said, I thought the biggest problem with sprouts was a general tendency to brassica intolerance compounded by the infrequency: some people only eat them over Christmas. Don't know what they're missing!

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: battered?

9 minutes? I find that a bit on the short side? Are you using fresh or frozen – nothing wrong with frozen veg, but cooking times need adjusting.

Galileo's magnifico measurement: 1976 redshift test updated

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

The EU's masterplan…

Now we realise why Galileo is so important and what the UK is walking out on: the ESA is going to use the system to store up seconds and thus build up a time surplus. The cunning devils!

* Mine's the one with the Jasper Fforde collected works in the pocket.

Google: I don't know why you say Allo, I say goodbye

Charlie Clark Silver badge

unless you're running a business that relies on the existence of said product.

Well, you're a fool if your business depends on a freebie from a company that can be withdrawn at any moment. Google treats it commercial offerings differently. But then these have support contracts, etc.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Another Google project that they got bored with and gave up on?

It was yet another test bed for services they can sell to companies: demonstation of a chatbot. Was able to use Signal's encryption from the start, so no need to reinvent the wheel.

I already use Signal but find multidevice support and backups poor compared to Telegram.

Messages is good because it encourages a network independent protocol which means being able to send messages to anyone without being beholden to a particular network. Irony, of course, at the moment is that you do need Google Messages for this but it would be nice if it can be made to work.

Huawei CFO poutine cuffs by Canadian cops after allegedly busting sanctions on Iran

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Re:oil in dollars

This time, if the USA try to abuse SWIFT (which they mostly own) the global currency systems will change drastically and permanently, probably sending the USA back to the dark ages as a result.

Have you ever been to Mississippi? I don't think it ever left the dark ages.

Countries are much better prepared for US sanctions this time: Qatar leaving OPEC could be a coincidence or just a convenient new conduit for Iranian oil.

I'm not sure Trump really cares about Iran or whether he's doing all this for his islamic extremist friends (which is the House of Saud) in Saudia Arabia and his corrupt mates (Netanjahu) in Israel.

The theocratic rulers in Iran are, by and large, a despicable bunch but they are more reliable and open than the bastards on the other side of the Strait of Hormuz…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

There have already been energy deals between Russia and China which did not use dollars

Indeed, and the irony of the US reneging on the Iran deal is that the EU is now actively working with China (less so with Russia) to make non-dollar trading easier.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Can someone explain how this is even remotely legitimate?

The US routinely does this and views extra-territoriality as perfectly normal as long as it does it. Examples are sanctions applied to HSBC for money-laundering for Iran and the ongoing investigation of Glencore. I think the law is called the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and is the basis for Trump's reneging on the Iran deal: lots of companies are so scared of this that they're willingly dropping ties with Iran.

However, when the boot is on the other foot it goes apopletic: heaven forfend that any other country go after a US company! Oh, and dealing, including taking bribes, with murderous, autocratic regimes is okay if the president says so. So, we can sell whatever we want to Saudi Arabia…

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: China is not a democracy

Thanks for pointing that out, I wouldn't have noticed otherwise…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Canadians as puppets

I have no idea whether she's guilty of anything, but it's beyond stupid of the Canadians to play this game as American puppets.

No need to jump the gun.

Canada is legally obliged to act on the request of the US: this is standard practice. The important thing is how the courts decide and whether the US is able to enforce its new unilateral sanctions on other countries. There's quite a potential political upside in the courts not agreeing to extradite but let's give them the chance to do their job.

Do not adjust your set: Hats off to Apple, you struggle to shift iPhones 'cos you're oddly ethical

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Losing customer

The first is that the pre-eminent manufacturer of Android phones is Samsung - a company whose attitude to long-term support would make Don Juan blush.

I don't think you should confuse Samsung's fairly shitty approach to OS updates with the hardware which is pretty well-built and lasts well. Several people here have posted that their S* are still running fine, as is my Wave (hardly ever start it but it still works).

Android < 5 used to add features and memory requirements with new versions and phones hit RAM limitations fairly quickly. Since then feature development has been minimal and Google has put Android on a diet (ART replacing Dalvik, more aggressive scheduling). At the same time the baseline for hardware has improved: more RAM, more cores even on the cheaper phones. As a result Andrew's jokes about "landfill" phones don't resonate that much any more. Cheaper phones do the business and continue doing the business for longer. Samsung has adapted to this and I suspect Apple will, too: an SE of the 8 at some point, no doubt.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "Apple sees nothing from second-hand trade."

You can trade in old iPhones at UK stores, but you can get a better price by selling them privately.

Sure, but Apple is happy to see higher prices elsewhere. Anything that makes a new I-Phone seem "good value for money" is good for Apple and higher resale values certainly do that.

BTW. although I've never had an I-Phone, I'm not dissing their kit: the phones are well designed (apart from the notch) and well made. But I won't go into the walled garden.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: a £200 phone that does everything an iphone does.

When I got my 8 core £200 Android the bluetooth audio was perfect.

Problems with Bluetooth are usually entirely unrelated to hardware. Specifically when it comes to Bluetooth Apple has a shocking reputation but I suspect what you're experiencing is some kind of interference: Bluetooth is lower power and shares the unlicensed 2.4 GHz band with, amongst other things, wifi, but will also suffer near strong EM fields such as in a train station. Range is also a lot less than you might imagine, though this can depend on peripherals, some of which are really shit: I get a good 8m through walls from my sidebar but about 4m from my kitchen radio.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: "Apple represents a strong alternative to people creeped out"

Right now Facebook made very unpopular the data slurping, and Google and YouTube are just behind in behavioural targeting, so Apple has an easy hand.

Except, of course, letting people use the apps largely negates anything Apple does. Also, you forgot Amazon which I think probably collects the most and most useful personal data of people who use it a lot.

Using the moral highground for marketing purposes? Who'dve thought it?

Charlie Clark Silver badge

"Apple sees nothing from second-hand trade."

That's not quite true. Through the refurbishment programme Apple is probably the largest actor in the second-hand trade. This is a tried and tested method that car manufacturers offer and has several benefits for them: firstly, it keeps the trade; secondly, part exchange can allow rebates to appear more generous than they are, especially when users "trade up"; it helps sets a floor for second-hand prices which in turn allows it to keep the prices of new devices high.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I think Andrew is being a little sarcastic in this article.

BOFH: State of a job, eh? Roll the Endless Requests for Further Information protocol

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Depressingly accurate

I just had a three-week wait for a ticket where the computer was continually trying to uninstall or update some Outlook add-on which required not just closing Outlook but also rebooting, rinsing and repeating. Solved by manual intervention in two minutes but not my machine and I don't have the power to do that.

Charlie Clark Silver badge

I believe the BOFH and PFY have put in tenders for all the lovely work for customs, agriculture, satellites, etc. that needs to be ready by March 29th*

* Year deliberately left off RfQ and tenders…

MongoDB's Atlas shrugs, with all NoSQL biz's customer growth resting on its shoulders

Charlie Clark Silver badge
Coat

Re: Lol at Ayn Rand reference, but...

I have, it's the most terrible twaddle.

You have my sympathy! But when has badly written bullshit been a hindrance to becoming a bestseller? Take the Da Vinci Code, for example. Or the shelves of self-help and diet tomes that America seems to thrive on.

Rand's biography (escape from the Soviet Union to found a personality cult in the US) seems to fascinate some. But basically they also provide justification for libertarian and capitalistic excess so I guess this means you'll be off Peter Thiel's Christmas list!

Mine's the one with the signed copy of The Art of the Deal in the pocket…

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Revenue and operating

Operating losses $29.1m, up 20 per cent year-on-year

Okay, "grew" less than revenue but I still don't like the look of it.

Space policy boffin: Blighty can't just ctrl-C, ctrl-V plans for Galileo into its Brexit satellite

Charlie Clark Silver badge

Re: Actually, this may be a well-disguised win

And these are the people lecturing to us about open borders.

… within a single market. An important condition some people seem to like to ignore. Apart from the countries with colonial histories the proportion of non-whites in the population is tiny though that is starting to change quickly in many places: it's a lot cheaper for Indian engineering students to study in Germany than it is in the UK.

In any case group photos of NASA aren't much different.