* Posts by John Robson

5205 publicly visible posts • joined 19 May 2008

Australian PM and Deputy threaten Facebook and Twitter with defamation liability for users' posts

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Postal

I think an advertising company - pasting a message onto a billboard - is a better one.

Microsoft turns Windows Subsystem for Linux into an app for Windows

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Found a shortcut

Wine and/or a VM that way round is sane.

Along with a support ticket each year to say "When are you compiling for linux"

VMware imagines 'memory servers' – a new source of shared software-defined RAM

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Need to see the Numbers

Yes it will...

But if you think about it as high speed swap... then it probably starts to make alot of sense.

Opt-out is the right approach for sharing your medical records with researchers

John Robson Silver badge

That's not consent regarding sharing of data - that's something which was pretty well discussed, and has pretty wide ranging benefits and limited downside.

No-one really needs their organs once they are deceased.

There are various groups who would like their bodies to remain intact post mortem - and that's fine, that's why there is an opt out.

This is consent to sharing the most personal of data with completely unknown and unspecified companies for unknown and unspecified purposes.

Given the attempt to shift the NHS to the US model of "care" that data becomes *really* dangerous.

Intel's €80bn European chip plant investment plan not bound for UK because Brexit

John Robson Silver badge

Re: What a surprise

2016 - a referendum whose campaigning was shown to be illegal, and which I think we all know was entirely lies.

2017 - 42% vote share isn't a majority

2019 - I can imagine that most people saw no point in voting for an MEP at this point

2019 - 43% vote share is bigger than 42%, but is still a long way from a majority.

Even the 52% support in 2016 was pitiful, it represented something like 25% of the population, and on any change *so* significant a 50%+1 threshold is as dumb as a box of rocks.

"People voted out because they didn’t want rules set in Brussels"

Really - all of them.

They do know that we were the ones setting the rules in Brussels?

John Robson Silver badge

Re: What a surprise

Maybe there was an answer to that issue - ask the public again.

You've got the current deal we have, you have this deal we're not entirely happy with, or we can try again.

John Robson Silver badge

What a surprise

You have two choices:

Build in market A, and have tariffs/shipping to market B

Or build in market B and have tariffs/shipping market A

Where market A >>> market B it's hardly a difficult choice. I am sure that sufficient skilled and educated people live in both markets...

The planet survived six hours without Facebook. Let's make it longer next time

John Robson Silver badge

Re: It will take a while

Final meandering question: Would it be possible to create an antisocial media that wasn't antisocial?

Yes - but you need to figure a way to pay for it, or to have it truly distributed (and that would need it to be a very reliable "just plug it in" appliance - and then you need to support that as well...

Apple beat Epic Games 9-1 in court. Now it's appealed the one point it lost

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Is it going to matter ?

The visa/mastercard cartel is hardly a market...

Is 30% justified? I don't know, let's look at the competition - Alphabet charges... 30%

For subscription based services an ongoing 30% is patently absurd, for one off purchases it's not so clear.

Not sure what the Apple T&Cs say about sending people off to make an account on a website - not offering any way to pay for an account at all.

Fatal Attraction: Lovely collection, really, but it does not belong anywhere near magnetic storage media

John Robson Silver badge

"No, I said BANG IT. I want to hear the disk hitting the table."

Don't you love engineers who know exactly what they're doing.

Russian spies reportedly used SolarWinds hack to steal US counterintelligence details

John Robson Silver badge

Re: US vs THEM

---8<---

I know its cutting slightly the wrong way, but really...

Netflix sued by South Korean ISP after Squid Game fans swell traffic to '1.2Tbps'

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Looks like the ISP wants 2 bites of the cherry

Except that I am paying for a freepost box...

That's why it costs me more if I want a box that can receive more letters....

Just because one person uses my freeport box a lot doesn't mean that the post office can charge them *as well*

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Looks like the ISP wants 2 bites of the cherry

"Yep. But it's a very asymmetric cost, ie Netflix doesn't pay for the 'last mile' delivery."

No, because the consumer has already paid for that.

The post office don't get to bill me for letters delivered, all the cost is borne by the sender.

But I could set up a freepost address, and then the sender wouldn't pay, I would,

Why should SK charge both parties for the same bandwidth?

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Looks like the ISP wants 2 bites of the cherry

Well, when I was running a CDN we'd put the hardware in - they'd pay for power/cooling.

It makes a huge amount of sense from both parties, since you only deliver once to the cache, and don't pay central bandwidth fees for all the deliveries downstream, and the ISP obviously gets a huge benefit as well.

So both save on bandwidth costs - the ISP by more than enough to pay for the power.

The CDN also gets to provide a better service to it's customers in that region.

PCIe 6.0 spec just months away from completion, doubles max data transfer rate

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Fine, provided ...

It explicitly says that in the article...

EU readies 'antitrust charges' against Apple Pay for locking rivals out of iPhone NFC chip

John Robson Silver badge

It's substantially harder to get malware to access elements of the secure enclave when there isn't a requirement for the door to be left open.

John Robson Silver badge

And you can get some malware to read and adjust those transactions...

You seriously think that Google aren't still looking over your shoulder just because the transaction is done with a banking app?

John Robson Silver badge

You can already choose your banking app..

The only thing you can't do is have some malware use the NFC payment facility.

It's a choice, but it's not exactly a limiting one for the consumer...

You have an iPhone, so you already trust Apple to some extent, and you want to use the NFC for card payments... scan the card, and ... well that's it really.

Maybe we should "open up the roads" and give people the choice of driving on the left or right...

Not all choice is good.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: While this is a real concern, it is only half the problem

Nope - I've made plenty of large transactions without PIN...

Competition watchdog? We've heard of it. But emergency comms firm still on track to Airwave hello to £1.2bn

John Robson Silver badge

Re: The right tool for the job

Not been out with an active fire crew, but there is certainly value in a dedicated, decentralised, localised comms setup with good penetration. I can imagine various situations where fire wouldn't help most radio penetration.

I suspect that AW was a leap forward in terms of dispatch control and information to crews en route, and very much in terms of cooperation with the other services at or near a scene. Once you are at an incident then you are probably right that for the vast majority of the time a single open channel is what's needed.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: The right tool for the job

My assumption was that the high rate data and voice/low rate data could be separated completely.

So the fire officer in charge of the scene can get the building schematics on the high speed data link in the vehicle and plan/discuss/guide based on that, whilst the tetra radio on the vehicle provides a local repeater so that the handsets being used in the burning building basement can still talk to the network at large.

Not something that LTE can do (the relaying part in particular).

John Robson Silver badge

It's not as if motorola weren't already profiting from airwave's continued existence...

John Robson Silver badge

Re: The right tool for the job

No good reason for the data and voice to be completely lockstepped.

The voice features have no replacement in LTE, the data is presumably more useful in vehicles than on every handset.

This phrase "legacy halfway-between-a-mobile-phone-and-a-walkie-talkie radio system Airwave" really doesn't do Tetra justice.

Facebook rendered spineless by buggy audit code that missed catastrophic network config error

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Who me?

Isn't that the one device you want *in band* management for?

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Who me?

About as many people as have run Reload on a cisco router.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Some people

They still use you :(

John Robson Silver badge
Trollface

Re: Who me?

I was too lazy, so i wrote a report saying zero accessibility and then updated reality to reflect my report.

Google won't fight South Korea's new app store payment laws requiring third-party payments

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Boris + Digital Economy

Huh?

Service providers pay for their connectivity

Consumers pay for their connectivity

Where does BT charge based on content again?

US road safety watchdog decides against probe into Tesla battery fires

John Robson Silver badge

Define unsafe...

Few enough incidents that they *all* make the news, as opposed to just some youtube "funny" reel in a few years time?

We should really insist that at least one (pre-nominated) day a year every road death gets full national coverage.

John Robson Silver badge

ISWYDT...

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Not So Sure

Where a tesla battery is being charged using a tesla bms from a tesla supercharger...

I suspect that any issue would be tesla's...

Of course the statement rather suggests that there is no issue to answer.

VMware to kill SD cards and USB drives as vSphere boot options

John Robson Silver badge

a USB stick as a boot device is fine - it's maintaining a database on it that's the issue.

Read only boot devices don't have a wear levelling issue.

John Robson Silver badge

So do they sell magical SSDs that don't wear out?

Pretend starship captain to take trip in real space capsule

John Robson Silver badge

It’s hardly one up man ship any more

When SpaceX call out “on their way to space” at 128km…. BO and VG aren’t one upping anything…

Firewalls? Pfft – it's no match for my mighty spares-bin PC

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Eh?

"rebooting is hardly difficult."

Yeah - that's the bit he probably wasn't able to do.

Sir Tim Berners-Lee and the BBC stage a very British coup to rescue our data from Facebook and friends

John Robson Silver badge

Re: BBC

Their biggest issue is that their definition of balance is to give equal air time to a respected scientist and a nut job off the street who thinks that vaccines are faked and the moon landings give you autism.

Cheeky chappy rides horse around London filling station, singing: 'I don't need petrol 'cos he runs on carrots'

John Robson Silver badge

Re: I cannot fathom the downvotes

Pretty sure we could have printed those anyway...

Revealed: How to steal money from victims' contactless Apple Pay wallets

John Robson Silver badge

Re: No Problem

I always assumed that zero liability was for visa, not customers.

Texas cops sue Tesla claiming 'systematic fraud' in Autopilot after Model X ploughed into two parked police cars

John Robson Silver badge

My local authority claims to have dimmed a set of lights at night, but they’re still blinding - I crawl by them at only a few miles an hour - it’s a popular crossing point and I can’t see anything other than a bright green haze

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Drunk driving is illegal and dangerous

"After all, if it were any other car and not a Tesla, the outcome would likely have been the same."

Probably not - there would have been a different crash earlier in the proceedings.

tz database community up in arms over proposals to merge certain time zones

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Is the database really that big

A slider that has one end labelled DST isn’t a complex interface, and it would only be needed on the few devices with a clock. My old thermostat (just about digital, but certainly not connected).

(Apologies I did say toggle button, wasn’t what I was thinking)

It’s only relevant on a device that does some time based switching, and displays a basic time based interface - old thermostats are the only example I could come up with (never had a cooker or microwave that knew what day it was).

Anything using a web interface has a better way to configure stuff (use the web UI - import a snippet of the TZ dB when the user configures you (only need the forward data for this TZ after all).

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Is the database really that big

Why would anything embedded want anything other than UTC?

Being slightly serious though - what micro embedded devices need to report local time to a user without some other device doing the display and interaction?

I suppose there might be a few things like thermostats which have local interaction with a clock involved, but... Have a "DST" toggle button?

John Robson Silver badge

Is the database really that big

that the merge is necessary in any way?

I don't really see that there is much additional overhead to keeping the separate, not like they update five times a day each.

One-size-fits-all chargers? What a great idea! Of course Apple would hate it

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Apple don't like it?

Then I'll exclude from scope any phones without a digital audio output...

a similarly random distinction to make.

The legislation option has been rumbling on for so long that the industry has basically solved the original issue by mere threat of legislation and then competitive pressure.

John Robson Silver badge
Joke

Re: Apple don't like it?

"The flying pigs were having trouble competing with the meteor showers this evening."

Typical - it was cloudy.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: but the industry is now down to 2, maybe three connectors...

"But they're so special!!"

In only one sense.... they developed a connector that does everything a phone needs a decade ago, the rest of the industry caught up quite a few years later.

The idea of limiting waste is great, but the legislation is 15 or so years late. Apple are moving towards USBc, but there is no compelling reason to abandon all the chargers and accessories which exist and work perfectly well.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Apple don't like it?

Well I had palm specific connectors as well, and the treo was a smarter phone than I had for a long while.

The iPad is not a phone, and doesn't have the same usage patterns, or established accessory market.

You're suggesting creating a mountain of e-waste as a solution to the problem of e-waste.

The move will eventually happen, but we aren't in the days when if your charger broke you would struggle to find a compatible one (unless you went nokia, in which case they were almost all the same).

What is it about USBc that provides a compelling reason to move from lightning?

Is it that you want to charge your phone at 100W? lightning handles at least 12W, which is plenty fast enough for anyone who ever needs to sleep.

Is it that you want to export a PCIe lane? Does the A15 chip family even have any PCIe lanes?

As you said, it's not as if there are loads of competing standards for chargers any more - there are basically two - so there isn't a requirement for legislation.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Apple don't like it?

Huh - I said it as a *good* thing.

Apple phones (and other devices) have used two connectors since 2003.

They have recently moved to USBc for some of the psuedo computer tablets (the iPadPro range)

That's a good thing, despite meaning that "innovation" is relatively slow.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Apple don't like it?

Yes - but the industry is now down to 2, maybe three connectors...

I don't think we need to legislate to stop the ridiculous situation we had 15-20 years ago

John Robson Silver badge

Re: If they are worried about charger waste

Not noticed USBc collecting dust, but my laptop is sat on a stand most of the time, not in a dusty pocket.

The main reason for lightning was that it was better than any other connector available at the time.

The reasons for keeping it could centre on not driving e-waste, why change a connector which does all you actually need for a phone (let's face it you don't back up over a cable any more).

The cynical will suggest that it's all about licensing, but there is a significant body of existing accessories which would be obsoleted with a phone upgrade for no particularly good reason.

Until there is actually a functional reason to change.... why change?

The iPad pro has changed, although I'm not really sure why - but I wonder if the A and M series chips will converge and we'll therefore be able to export PCIe lanes from our phones (docking adaptor with an eGPU anyone)