* Posts by John Robson

5237 publicly visible posts • joined 19 May 2008

UK chemicals multinational to build hydrogen 'gigafactory'

John Robson Silver badge

Agree - there isn't a single solution for everything... I don't see the risks and complications of an H2EV being worth the limited benefits for cars/vans - the arithmetic changes for HGVs, they can afford the complexities of storage, and could store *so* much that they'd be able to deal with a relatively weak supply chain.

For basically any car the issue isn't max single stop range, it's either speed of charge *or* continuous charging for those rare long journeys (maybe a handful each year).

I'd like to see some battery standardisation, so that you can rent an additional battery occasionally, whether that's Li based, AlAir based, or something else, plug it in and boost range for that trip.

Maybe have it "spare wheel" sized, since so many cars are doing away with the spare wheel... yes I know that's a variety of sizes, but it's not that many really.

The one thing that is absolutely clear to me is that direct combustion is a piss poor way to provide motive power - even moving to hydrogen you still generate various nox-ious gases, and the efficiency is substantially worse than fuel cells.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: AFAIK, ONLY Tesla drivers can use those charge points.

"Norway should be used as a great example of how to do this stuff. Almost every village that has a supermarket and a filling station also have at least 2 DC chargers."

Perhaps more importantly they are mandating that all car parks should at least have the routing for cables to provide AC charging to every spot (they don't yet have to install all the cable, but the routing has to be available). That immediately reduces the dependency on fuel station style charging.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Quick charging

Quite a few of the tesla charge stations are now open to all users.

John Robson Silver badge
WTF?

Re: Quick charging

Whilst regulations don't *require* you to take a break in a smaller vehicle... it's still sensible to do so.

Taking regular short breaks is a mechanism to reduce fatigue and increase safety, failure to do so should be considered careless driving.

BEVs are far more effective than you (who I assume is talking from a place of not having one) realise.

I have an MGZS, it (just about) fits my wheelchair and family, and is pre facelift - so "only" has a range of 174mi range (WLTP), which I normally consider to be about 140, though I have done a trip to my in-laws and back without recharging - that's a touch over 160 (I normally take a five minute "volt and bolt" to leave a little extra wiggle room, but didn't on this occasion).

But the number of times in a year we use a public charger is so small it can be counted without even resorting to toes - and a couple of those have been destination chargers, so taking exactly zero time out of our day. It makes the six hour journey to my parents about one hour longer, but *much* easier and more relaxing.

There will be a few travelling salespeople who do silly miles each and every day, but they really are very rare - and that's where something less difficult to handle (like an Al/Air pack) could really come into its own. It's not particularly efficient, but neither is H2. Compared with H2 it's trivial to handle and transport.

Or of course battery swap stations for those users - who are probably either leasing or fleet users anyway.

John Robson Silver badge

I can see a role for lorries, but for vans and smaller you're right - DC charging for the relatively small number of long journeys is a better approach than hydrogen - there might even be an intermediate technology, something like Al/Air as a safe and easy "extender" with similar energy efficiency to hydrogen but without the storage/transport issues of hydrogen

Google, Oracle cloud servers wilt in UK heatwave, take down websites

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Last night a friend was grumbling that they couldn't get into either ocado or waitrose

Stop using a sieve to carry it then.

Taps work quite well, not aware of anywhere using standpipes at the moment.

Demand for smartphones is drying up

John Robson Silver badge

Re: It is a different reason for PCs

Yep - I'm holding off replacing the wife's iDevice 8 until the iDevice 7 or 6 starts to fail in the hands of the offspring. The flexibility it allows is one of the major reasons I decoupled telephony contracts from telephony hardware a long while ago.

We used to upgrade (and pass down) one phone every 18 ish months, but it's been a little over two years since the last upgrade (which was feature driven), and no real sign of needing to upgrade any time soon - even then I might also just opt to replace the battery in the 6 (assuming that's what starts to give out).

Just because you failed doesn't mean you weren't right

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Basic QC

My last foray into EMC testing was fun. EMC testing facility was basically a small wooden building in the middle of a field - with a rather long electrical supply cable.

Server had three ~1200W (I think) PSUs, and because it was "just testing" we had them all plugged into a single four way extension.

About to do all the zappy stuff to the box, which had been put in the back of my car the previous day, and so we plugged in the four bank. The inrush from those PSUs turned all the lights out for about half a second.

Fortunately the chassis and PSUs were already certified, so we just decided to ignore that...

John Robson Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Basic QC

If you own the machine - then it's the machine's fault,

If, however, you own the test equipment, then it's the test equipment's fault.

Cruise self-driving cars stopped and clogged up San Francisco for hours

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Does it really need to be AI?

No, it means that my offspring have corrupted my brain with minecraft coordinates.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Does it really need to be AI?

Oh I don't hate it - it's not worth the effort.

Of course I call it soccer whenever I have to refer to it, and generally treat it with the disdain it* deserves... but hate is going too far.

* Commercial soccer that is. I have nothing against school/community based sports**.

** No using a golf bat on a golf court doesn't count as sport.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Does it really need to be AI?

"Needs to do more than just react to ball air pressure spikes otherwise the vast majority flagged as potential offside will not be offside."

Yes - but that's why it flags it to the team watching the monitors on the sidelines, not direct to the ref.

John Robson Silver badge
Coat

Does it really need to be AI?

Why not just put tags in the back of everyone's shirt and track that and the ball - no AI required...

If player's Z axis location is further forward than all but one of the opposition when the ball air pressure spikes (because it's being kicked) then flag potential offside - with an indicator on screen as to the player in question and the ball at moment of pressure spike.

Uber to pay millions to settle claims it ripped off disabled people with unfair fees

John Robson Silver badge

So now...

instead of being charged for being "too slow" to get into an uber, they are charged time to fill out a form which others don't need to fill in...

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Why is this legal anyway?

If they fix the system and reimburse those affected... I'm all for doing it in a speedy way, rather than having it drag out over months.

But despite not being an admission of guilt, it should also not be a permanent immunity... Anything else they do and this should be lumped back on top.

Intel’s first discrete GPUs won't be a home run

John Robson Silver badge
WTF?

3060

Low end?

Not quite sure I'd call a £350-450 card low end, though I'll admit it's a while since I've cared about GPU performance.

Improve Linux performance with this one weird trick

John Robson Silver badge

Depends what you are doing with the car... if you're trying to set a robotically driven quarter mile then it's a good plan.

The issue is that most systems aren't standalone.

SCOTUS judges 'doxxed' after overturning Roe v Wade

John Robson Silver badge

" There is really no other reason for this data being published."

How about - to highlight to the judiciary that there exists a terrifying amount of information about everyone which should be protected by law.

Supercomputer pinpoints exact origin of 'Black Beauty' meteorite from Mars

John Robson Silver badge

Re: OK, stupid question time

https://www.virtualmicroscope.org/content/nwa-7034-black-beauty

Its martian origin was confirmed by pyroxene analyses (Fe/Mn ratios)and noble gas measurements that match measurements of the martian atmosphere. This meteorite is a breccia with a basaltic bulk composition and initially classified as a porphyritic basaltic monomict breccia clasts containing a wide variety of textures and include gabbros, quenched melts, and oxide rich reaction spherules. Other portions of the breccia contain plutonic lithic clasts such as monzonites and norites, basalts, and impact melt clasts. This is a very heterogeneous breccia!

Initial studies of NWA 7034 determined that the meteorite's bulk composition coincides with the composition of the average martian crust determined from mission data. This bulk composition also matches some of the rocks and soils measured in Gusev Crater by the Mars Exploration Rovers (MER) and in fact, this meteorite represents the strongest link between a martian meteorite and the geochemistry of the martian surface determined by remote sensing.

Watch a RAID rebuild or go to a Christmas party? Tough choice

John Robson Silver badge

Re: More pertinantly

You choose your polling interval according to the length of time you are willing to live with the array in a degraded state - I'd suggest that 12 hours is too long for critical production systems, but might be tolerated on a low usage home setup.

You only ever *know* that the RAID was working at the previous poll (active alerting excepted, though again technically you only *know* at the timestamp of the last event, which we hope was informational).

The assumption that it's degraded isn't knowing that it is and reacting, it's the baseline which tells you how long are you OK to be running in a degraded state before you jump on it.

If the answer is very small then you should be running with a warm spare drive (or several) available anyway.

If the answer is long enough for people to move around and do things then you don't need to check more often than that, the assumption that it is degraded is what defines your polling cycle.

Each polling cycle (or trap/event) either resets that counter or puts you into a "this drive has failed" state, which does require action on some timescale.

John Robson Silver badge

More pertinantly

RAID isn't RAID if it isn't actively monitored.

And between polls it must be assumed to be in a degraded state.

Wash your mouth out with shape-shifting metal

John Robson Silver badge

Re: While the prospect of toothpaste that DOESN'T taste like mint is appealing

How does that work - homeopathic toothpaste is surely water...

UK tribunal: App Store class action seeking up to $1.8b can continue

John Robson Silver badge

Re: How did they come up with that value

App store profits...

Crikey. I don't think I've ever spent that much money on apps...

John Robson Silver badge

How did they come up with that value

I can't do maths....

Damages between £25 and £75 pounds... (£500-1500m distributed amongst 20m iOS users)

That feels relatively mild

Google said to be taking steps to keep political campaign emails out of Gmail spam bin

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Hint to Google

Again, the tory support media would want you to believe that they're all the same.

They're not - but the apathy they can generate by saying that they are all the same is key to keeping the worst of them in power.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Hint to Google

"Whoever it is and whichever party it is, they are all much the same."

The trouble is that it's only the worst of them that want you to think that. It's not actually true.

CAPSTONE mission is Moon-bound, after less rocketry than expected

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Touching Cloth?

Scott Manley's explanation

Basically near rectilinear means it's *really* elliptical, about as far away from a circle as you can get without the lunar surface getting in the way - it's nearly a straight line in, then out...

Halo orbit, it's actually orbiting part of the Earth Moon gravitational system, not just the moon.

It's a clever orbital position, theoretically really nice for a variety of reasons... This mission will confirm a bunch of those

Google location tracking to forget you were ever at that medical clinic

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Google's minimum viable response

"The SCOTUS will simply require Google provide that information, and thus they cannot delete it."

Maybe this is a cunning ploy for privacy - make it completely illegal to delete or refuse to hand over any and all data in an attempt to get the tech giants fighting over privacy by not collecting it all to start with.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Google's minimum viable response

Just tell law enforcement that they now delete ALL location data. See how they like that

UK signs deal to share police biometric database with US border guards

John Robson Silver badge

"look at the second amendment - I don't know how you get around that one though as it's an implicit right."

It's also an amendment - i.e. it's a change to a document. You just need another one, and there is precedent for an amendment to overrule an earlier amendment.

The way to "get around" it isn't to get around it at all, but to update the constitution in line with the modern world.

NASA delays SLS rollback due to concerns over rocky path to launchpad

John Robson Silver badge

Crawler...

They could just land the rocket back on the launch... oh, sorry

EV battery can reach full charge in 'less than 10 minutes'

John Robson Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Full charge in 10 minutes?

So there isn't a significant issue with colleagues - you just can't imagine a world in which your life has to change for the better "because change"

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Full charge in 10 minutes?

"If you live in a flat with no off-street parking, you may want to buy a really cheap ICE car to get around and save money to be able to move"

Why would it have to be ICE?

There are vanishingly few places where an EV can't be at least as convenient as an ICE vehicle. And if you live in a flat with no parking then pretty much by definition you live in a highly densely populated urban area. Blocks of flats I have lived in or visited have had off street parking, it might not currently be dedicated per resident, but there has (almost?) always been off street parking.

Why would you switch to a vehicle that you had to go to the chemist to get fuel for when there are oat deliveries every day from a choice of three vendors?

EVs are the future of personal transport. I'd love e-bikes to make up a large part of that, but that's actually a completely different issue.

Public transport also needs to be properly funded, and equipped to deal with the needs of the public, rather than shareholders.

There are plenty of solutions, but burning proverbial dinosaurs doesn't need to be one of them.

SpaceX: 5G expansion could kill US Starlink broadband

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Didn't the FCC recently drop the ball on 5G masts near US airports?

"The POTS copper network should be retained as a strategic national asset. Getting rid of it to save BT a few quid is like Beeching's rail cuts."

Not sure... it's not like the majority of the network is copper anyway - even in the last mile there are plenty of aluminium cables as well.

What's the strategic national interest in copper over fibre?

Beechings cuts were disastrous because the prevented people accessing the mainline, so alternative forms of transport became necessary, and at that point easier to use that alternative for the whole journey.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Move Fast

It applies to breaking your *own* things, not other people's

Chinese boffins suggest launching nuclear Neptune orbiter in 2030

John Robson Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: Launch in 2030...

So it's my reading that's off ;)

I blame a head cold.

John Robson Silver badge
Boffin

Launch in 2030...

... with a reactor due to be tested in 2030.

Something's off there.

Soviet-era tech could change the geothermal industry

John Robson Silver badge

Re: what if ...

I didn't say it was practical... it was just that at this kind of power, reflectivity needs to be perfect, and it never is, and certainly doesn't remain that way if you start heating things significantly.

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Even 200°C has applications

No reason you can't use the outflow from the turbines for district/municipal heating.

John Robson Silver badge
Pirate

Re: what if ...

With the amount of power we are talking about even a 99.9% reflective surface would vaporise pdq

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Could this be the energy source that 'solves' energy for humanity??

Well there is no reason you can't do both.

The outflow from the turbine hall is still plenty hot enough for district heating.

John Robson Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Is 500°C (932°F) hot enough?

Additional benefits include:

- Non intermittent source

- Rapidly variable station output

Aside from the really obvious "most of the plant has already been built and connected to the grid"

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Is 500°C (932°F) hot enough?

But if you get higher temperatures you can probably start to use the existing turbines in coal plants... and since the tech allows it from most of the planet there's a good chance they can do this at existing sites...

That's not a benefit to be overlooked... just imagine if all our dirty plants could be powered by steam from an FDH (freaking deep hole).

Returning to the Moon on the European Service Module

John Robson Silver badge

Pleasing???

""We've taken those directly from old Space Shuttles", Cleaver told us, which makes for a pleasing symmetry considering the mission."

That's not a pleasing symmetry. Taking such bits of kit and throwing them away isn't particularly pleasing in today's world

Startup rattles tin for e-paper monitor with display fast enough to play video

John Robson Silver badge

Yield must be awful - I'd love to get a few A3/A2 displays - heck, if they were reasonably borderless I could patch them together with a raspi behind each one.

But they are multiple thousands of pounds each...

Digital signage is such an obvious use case, and doesn't require high refresh rates - doesn't necessarily need colour (though that could be a nice to have).

John Robson Silver badge

The monitors might have been available for a while... but they are obscenely priced.

It's a shame, it would be nice if e-ink could be a scalable display option, be great for digital signs/notices in a variety of places.

Running DOS on 64-bit Windows and Linux: Just because you can

John Robson Silver badge

Stars!

Still one of the best, most balanced 4X games...

NASA circles August in its diary to put Artemis I capsule in Moon orbit

John Robson Silver badge

Re: A hydrogen fuel leak, but everything's fine

That wasn't a hydrogen leak... the tank was annihilated by the impinging of an unintended rocket exhaust directed at the tank rather than the ground.

TypeScript joins 5 most used languages in 2022 lineup

John Robson Silver badge

Erm... Maths?

"Linux passed macOS to take second place with 40 percent of responses compared to Apple's 33 percent"

So if Linux had 40%, MacOS had 33% then Windows must have had 151% of the remaining 27% in order to have come out ahead of Linux...

Spain, Austria not convinced location data is personal information

John Robson Silver badge

Re: Hm, I'd say..

No objection to them having the data - but they should be required to:

- Keep that data secure

- Not share that data with any third parties who don't have a warrant for the information

- Share that data with the subscriber