* Posts by Yes Me

1745 publicly visible posts • joined 11 Jan 2008

IBM CEO Arvind Krishna needs new business cards already after appointment as board chair

Yes Me Silver badge
Flame

Nice try

the highly paid consultancy shifts for Rometty will likely not be well received by some in the rank and file
Are you competing for understatement of the year? If so, you're in with a good chance.

I'd hoped for better from Arvind.

Top Chinese policy think tank’s new 15-year ‘smart economy’ plan admits US sanctions have hurt Huawei

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: The difference between China and the west.

"They have a fifteen year plan." And at the end of it they will be ahead of the West in many aspects of hi tech, having learnt from the current trade war that Western countries are unreliable partners. Well done tRump, you helped to Make China Great Again!

China Telecom answers US internet routing hijack claims by joining internet routing security team: How do you like them apples?

Yes Me Silver badge
Headmaster

American sales in China

Not true. China has been a major market for Cisco, for example, for many years, although in the last two years they have been losing sales, mainly because of tRump's stupid tariff war.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cisco-systems-results-idUSKCN1V424I

Yes Me Silver badge
Childcatcher

Fixed it for you

"It should be noted that there is no evidence that has been made public, or even referred to, of AT&T spying. The argument put forward by the Chinese government is that by being based in the USA the company is subject to government pressure and therefore it should be assumed that it will end up spying for its Washington masters."

Sounds reasonable to me.

Facts: https://www.corp.att.com/worldwide/att-you-china/

Ad blocking made Google throw its toys out of the pram – and now even more control is being taken from us

Yes Me Silver badge
Joke

Re: In a past far far away - targetted ads

"the NZ IRD would achive better result by engaging some local talent, like the Piranha Brothers"

Even better, they could have launched a worldwide pandemic and closed the NZ border to everybody except returning expats, many of whom might regard paying back their student loan as better than dying in an overcrowded NHS hospital.

(Needed an icon for "Sick Joke Alert")

FCC mulls booting China Telecom from US networks over its ties with Beijing

Yes Me Silver badge
FAIL

Re: National security?

"Are you comfortable with the Chinese government having ready access to the personal calls of our politicians? Of OUR intelligence agents?"

Who is "our"? El Reg is not a US publication to my knowledge. Just play with the variables here, e.g. "are you comfortable with the Swedes having access...?" If you're British, "are you comfortable with the Americans having access...?".

All this has nothing to do with security; that's smoke and mirrors designed to conceal a good old-fashioned trade war.

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Trumps lapdogs

The whole anti-China thing was bound to appeal to tRump but unfortunately a lot of this stuff is bipartisan and Biden will not automatically reverse it. It's ultimately stupid, since the instigator of a trade war almost always loses; in this case China will be the big winner because they will emerge with a stronger hi-tech industry than ever, including a cradle-to-grave supply chain that doesn't depend on the West.

Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable, claims it misled standards bodies

Yes Me Silver badge

straight forward?

Your definition of straightforward and a patent examiner's definition of "obvious to one skilled in the art" might be different. Remember that patents in this case would have been approved *before* the standard was agreed and published. What seemed straightforward when you read the standard might not have been considered obvious several years previously when the patent application was evaluated.

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Wrong way round?

It's not the wrong way round. If patents are not disclosed during the open standardisation process, the result is highly unfair on companies that choose to implement the open standard in ignorance of the patents. Most standards development organisations (including the ITU) have strict disclosure requirements to avoid this unfairness. If Nokia is proved to have ignored those requirements, they will lose the case, painfully.

A 1970s magic trick: Take a card, any card, out of the deck and watch the IBM System/370 plunge into a death spiral

Yes Me Silver badge
Angel

Re: You can do that much more efficiently in C

Once upon a time in a country far far away, I had my hands on a network and an interpreted language that could send bits of code to be executed in another computer. For example, a bit of code that printed HELLO on the console and then picked another computer at random and send itself off there. Made quite an interesting concert on the various DECwriters around the room. Amusingly hard to stop.

Yes Me Silver badge
WTF?

Re: Broken NFS

An o/s written in SNOBOL? That would be a sight to see.

Uncle Sam throws Huawei CFO a bone in her extradition fight, but deal will require an admission of wrongdoing

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: @Irony Deficient - Mixed messages

Of course it's about money. The whole trade war started by tRump is about money. Using dirty tricks against Huawei is about money. The lies about security issues are about money.

.org owner Internet Society puts its money where its mouth is with additional IETF funding

Yes Me Silver badge
Headmaster

Unusually high score...

... for misleading wording by Kieren.

.org owner Internet Society
No, actually the IANA function of ICANN "owns" top level domain names, i.e. has the final say as to who has the right to run the corresponding registry. ISOC sort-of owns the PIR corporation which has been assigned that registry right by IANA.
But the subsequent financial reliance on ISOC, even though the IETF also raises money through sponsors and conference attendance fees, has not always resulted in a healthy dynamic.
What is unhealthy about the relationship? I've tracked it since the beginning in 1992, and it's always been fine and productive.
But those efforts continue apace, not least with China’s “New IP” proposal that would see more modern and efficient systems for networking management than the current TCP/IP approach. That proposed system would have clear advantages, but also have surveillance and control baked into it.
First, it isn't "China's" anything, it's Huawei. If NewIP is China's, then the Web is Switzerland's. More to the point, it isn't yet at all clear that NewIP is well-defined, technically plausible, and economically feasible. There are those who think it is none of those things. Thirdly, what is specified so far neither supports nor contradicts the assertion about surveillance and control. All we've seen are a few empty words about the importance of security and privacy.
Reform-ish

That effort exists, albeit in a half-hearted fashion. The board created a new body to look at its governance... However, a culture is hard to change and the board has insisted on maintaining complete control of any proposed changes to its governance.

The Board is still in the process of chartering a governance working group, to be precise. And it isn't a matter of the Board insisting on control of proposed changes; it's mandated by the Internet Society's by-laws, which require a four-fifths majority of the Board to approve by-law changes. The Internet Society is incorporated in the District of Columbia and can only act within the relevant D.C. law and the rules of the US tax system for non-profits, and of course that includes obeying its own by-laws.

I would appreciate more care and accuracy in reporting in future.

It's better to burn out than fade Huawei: UK rolls out schedule for rip-and-replace rules

Yes Me Silver badge
Stop

Motivations

"The sanctions are not politically motivated. They are financially motivated."

There's no distinction between the two in the tRumpian view of the universe, which has apparently infected the party formerly known as Conservative. This is an incredibly stupid move that will come back to bite the UK both politically and financially, when the revitalised Chinese high-tech industry takes over in 5 or so years from now. (We all know that technically and from a security viewpoint, the Huawei kit is just as good as anybody else's.)

Gartner: You think Huawei's sales figures are bad now? Wait till you see next year's

Yes Me Silver badge
FAIL

Bad news for who, exactly?

The worse the impact on Huawei, the worse it will be for Western industry a few years from now. Success of the US trade war against Huawei will only increase the Chinese efforts to build their own high-tech supply chain and make themselves even better at defeating Western competitors.

Playing trade as a zero-sum game has never been a good idea. Hopefully the Biden Administration will understand that in a way that tRump never could.

How the US attacked Huawei: Former CEO of DocuSign and Ariba turned diplomat Keith Krach tells his tale

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: It's not about clean or secure...

"US envy". Exactly. They made up the necessary lies (e.g. that Huawei has military ties and is controlled by the CCP) that Cisco etc. suggested to them. I hope the Biden administration will back off on the dirty war side of things, even if they still consider China as a dangerous trade rival.

Yes Me Silver badge

kinda irrelevant

It's kinda irrelevant whether they're a Good Thing. They're compulsory in most countries. That's why most governments hate e2e encryption, because all they get from the back doors is metadata and random bits.

Boeing 737 Max will return to flight after software updates, says EU's aviation regulator

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: more than software

It was a bit worse than not showing AOA DISAGREE if the AOAs disagreed. It was also an incredibly stupid software "feature" that consulted one or the other AOA on alternating flights, so an anomaly noticed on flight N would vanish on flight N+1 and reappear on flight N+2. As I read the reports, both flights that crashed were examples of N+2: an AOA anomaly had been reported two flights earlier, but signed off as transient before flight N+1.

AWS admits to 'severely impaired' services in US-EAST-1, can't even post updates to Service Health Dashboard

Yes Me Silver badge
Joke

Re: But

Ironically enough, the largest distributed processing system in the Eastern USA appears to be a single point of failure. One of the benefits of virtualisation!

It's always DNS, especially when a sysadmin makes a hash of their semicolons

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Re: Anyone who ever dabbles in vi

I think it's time somebody mentioned TECO.

Hundreds of Facebook moderators complain: AI content moderation isn't working and we're paying for it

Yes Me Silver badge
Facepalm

Failed Turing test?

Well, I tried that on jabberwacky.com, and I have to agree it didn't go too well:

Who are you?

John goes into a restaurant.

You should try escargot.

He orders lobster.

Lobsters aren't that cool.

He pays his bill and leaves.

But dave is a statue.

Now, what did John eat?

I can't tell you - spies are everywhere.

Yes Me Silver badge
Childcatcher

Money talks

It would interesting to see the internal development budget for AI usage. Something like:

Improving AI for moderating nasty content: $10,000,000

Improving AI for targeted advertisements: $10,000,000,000

(Their annual revenue being $70,000,000,000, these numbers are not ridiculous.)

When even a power-cycle fandango cannot save your Windows desktop

Yes Me Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Too Many Stories!

Speaking of conveyor belts (well, not really) I once heard from a purported eyewitness of a safety person investigating how a worker had managed to seriously staple her finger with a heavy-duty industrial stapler, despite its safety guard. "How did it happen?" asked the safety person. "Like this!" said the worker's supervisor, before they rushed him off to hospital. (This was decades ago, in a factory in a city in the East Midlands.)

Compsci guru wants 'right to be forgotten' for old email, urges Google and friends to expire, reveal crypto-keys

Yes Me Silver badge
WTF?

RTFM

"Nonetheless, Green contends DKIM's unintended side effect of permanent accountability should be rolled back. "

What on earth makes him think it is unintended? Perhaps he forgot to read the Abstract of the DKIM RFC:

DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) permits a person, role, or organization that owns the signing domain to claim some responsibility for a message by associating the domain with the message. This can be an author's organization, an operational relay, or one of their agents. DKIM separates the question of the identity of the Signer of the message from the purported author of the message. Assertion of responsibility is validated through a cryptographic signature and by querying the Signer's domain directly to retrieve the appropriate public key. Message transit from author to recipient is through relays that typically make no substantive change to the message content and thus preserve the DKIM signature.

Linux Foundation, IBM, Cisco and others back ‘Inclusive Naming Initiative’ to change nasty tech terms

Yes Me Silver badge

Very dark grey and very pale grey

"The Initiative lists related projects from the Internet Engineering Task Force ... "

No. The IETF doesn't have a "project" and the draft they cite is a personal contribution that has been widely criticised. That github repo is basically a scribbling pad with no status for the moment.

That's not to say the IETF plans to increase the use of offensive or exclusionary language. But the way an ongoing discussion is misleadingly cited as a "related project" is tendentious to say the least. To say that in a more dark grey and pale grey way, it's a lie.

HTTPS-only mode arrives in Firefox 83 as Mozilla finds new home for Rust-y Servo engine

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Thank goodness...

...that I stopped updating Firefox at v 71.0. I don't want to be treated like a little kid by my browser.

Biden projected to be the next US President, Microsoft joins rest of world in telling Trump: It looks like... you're fired

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Re: FCC

Some of those tweets (including the first one, of course) are truly hilarious. It isn't even worth trying to work out which are trolls. Just a bucket of laughs.

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Pugh, Pugh, Barney McGrew, Cuthbert, Dibble, & Grubb

I doubt that even a right-wing Supreme Court would rule that you can pardon yourself for something before you've been indicted, let alone convicted.

Yes Me Silver badge
Pint

Re: Yay! Party time!

"who actually takes office"

Pres. Biden, for sure. Remember that the armed forces swear to protect the Constitution first of all.

Who do I feel sorry for? The poor fools in the Secret Service who get assigned to protect ex-President Trump. That will really be a punishment assignment.

Definitely a <see icon> day.

Remember so-not-a-pirate Kim Dotcom? New Zealand’s highest court has just said the USA can extradite him for copyright naughtiness

Yes Me Silver badge
Mushroom

Those crazy Canucks

"wonder WTF the canucks were thinking when they decided to go for a re-run of this with Miss Huawei"

Actually they were just following orders from south of the border: Canada border agent says he received unusual FBI phone call in Huawei CFO U.S. extradition case | Reuters

Yes Me Silver badge
Headmaster

Terms of service

Dropbox, for example, say this in their terms of service:

Your use of our Services must comply with our Acceptable Use Policy. Content in the Services may be protected by others’ intellectual property rights. Please don’t copy, upload, download, or share content unless you have the right to do so.
Somehow I doubt if MegaUpload said that.

Huawei bid to move chip production in-house so it can survive US sanctions will start with a 45nm process – report

Yes Me Silver badge
FAIL

Trump's great gift to China

Yes. There's no doubt that Trump has given China (not just Huawei) the strongest possible motivation for developing a complete chip supply chain. It will take them a few years, but it will definitely Make China Great Again. About the worst possible thing Trump could have done for American hi-tech.

Did I or did I not ask you to double-check that the socket was on? Now I've driven 15 miles, what have we found?

Yes Me Silver badge
Angel

Socket switches seem like a weird idea...

My grandmother (who was brought up when gas was available in Burnley, but not electricity) didn't agree. She thought that just like you need a gas tap on every outlet, you also need an electricity tap. When the plug-in electric clock (a present to my grandfather from grateful parishioners) finally broke and was thrown away, she saw that there was no switch on its specially installed round 2-pin socket over the mantelpiece. (This was years before 13 amp sockets were installed.) So she sealed off the escaping electricity by Selotaping an aluminium milk bottle top over the socket. (This was years before home milk deliveries stopped.)

Fortunately the short circuit that readers are no doubt hoping for did not occur, and she survived for many more years. The next time we visited, my father ripped off the aluminium, but I'm pretty sure Grandma insisted on a stout cardboard replacement. You don't want electricity leaking into the room.

QUIC! IETF sets November deadline for last comments on TCP-killer spawned by Google and Cloudflare

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Another solution to a problem that shouldn't exist.

Again, read the actual specs, not some quickly written 2nd hand news "story". The QUIC designers are rather a long way from naive or stupid. (I am not one of them.)

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Error free wireless networks?

I suggest reading the QUIC documents before shooting from the hip. None of what you say applies to QUIC.

Linus Torvalds hails 'historic' Linux 5.10 for ditching defunct addressing artefact

Yes Me Silver badge
Devil

Yes, but...

Wanna bet that no box somewhere is gonna install this and brick itself as a result? There's always one out there.

UK tech supply chain in dark over Brexit preparations months ahead of final heave-ho

Yes Me Silver badge
Trollface

Frightened of the dark

"The IT supply chain remains in the dark over how to plan for Brexit..."

No.

The UK government remains in the dark over how to plan for Brexit...

Fixed it for you.

Excel is for amateurs. To properly screw things up, those same amateurs need a copy of Access

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Using a computer where pen and paper would have sufficed!

"So I can see why some people would turn to Access and even Excel to meet their requirements."

Right. Let's say you urgently have to report infections and deaths for a serious new illness to a central authority, knowing full well that the results will be in the national media as well as sent off to the World Health Organisation. I wonder what you'd choose...

Five Eyes nations plus Japan, India call for Big Tech to bake backdoors into everything

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Re: Can never work

Yes. This could just be the boost that true peer-to-peer encrypted messaging has been wasiting for.

Global Privacy Control emerges as latest attempt to let netizens choose whether they want to be tracked online

Yes Me Silver badge
Facepalm

Your lawnmower is obsolete

You just wait until you start to see ads telling you that your lawnmower is 5 years old and must need replacing soon. (I need to patent that idea, it's a clear money-spinner.)

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Browsers

Cookies just make tracking easier. If there were no cookies, tracking would still be done, but it would use a third party service of some kind, and would by now be a very big machine learning application. Abolition of tracking via cookies would just be a nice business opportunity for somebody. I'm guessing that the major CDNs would be able to offer a tracking service as a lucrative add-on, for example.

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Re: confused

If you don't track, you've got nothing to sell, so in the real world there is no difference whatever between ignoring DNT and ignoring GPC.

Yes Me Silver badge
Thumb Down

Re: They just don't get it........but maybe that's the point!!!

"one would hope"

Downvote because "hope" is remarkably ineffective against profit-driven capitalism. So is regulation, since it's trivial to off-shore the surveillance system into a less regulated jurisdiction.

The only way to make things better is to use unbreakable cryptography end-to-end, which is exactly what the spooks and the cops hate most. And even that doesn't work if the remote site you are accessing collaborates with the surveillance system (which is often called by a name such as Google). So that needs unbreakable anonymity too. Which among other things requires you to hide your IP address. Which means using TOR all the time for everything. Which the spooks and the cops also hate, apart from it being a PITA.

So GPC will be exactly as successful as DNT.

(I recently got a new "smart" TV. It's so smart that its manufacturer is now slinging ads and spam at me on every system where my Google ID shows up. So far they haven't found me on the Register site, which is slightly reassuring.)

Britain should have binned Huawei 5G kit years ago to cuddle up with Trump, says Parliamentary committee

Yes Me Silver badge
Headmaster

Re: "But cozying up to the US definitely is."

"since Suez"

Much longer. Since mid-1940 when the UK ran out of gold and was saved by the US lend-lease program(me). Suez was just a reminder.

Nominet refuses to consider complaint about its own behaviour, claims CEO didn’t mean what he said on camera

Yes Me Silver badge
Flame

Re: At what point do you pull the plug?

"Its just the same as PIR trying to sell off .org but at least that was blocked."

No, it isn't. It may be hard for Kieren's fans to believe, but .org was always going to be operated under constraints placed by Kieren's arch-fiend known as ICANN. The .org registrants wouldn't have noticed much difference.

The .uk situation is completely different because the ultimate authority is the UK government. We'd be much better off with the registry run by civil servants than the corporate animal that is Nominet. It's being going downhill for years and now it seems to have reached rock bottom: not fit for purpose.

Square Kilometre Array signs off on construction plans – UK last holdout before building phase begins

Yes Me Silver badge

Re: Units?

1) Why Paris, please?

2) 130 PB/yr is less that 10 times what the Worldwide LHC Computational Grid can already achieve, so it isn't much of a stretch given the rate of change in the technology.

US finds new Huawei to hurt China with new sanctions at top chip maker SMIC

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Good news for China, in the end

I have no doubt that China is already developing its own alternatives to Western suppliers for all this machinery (the highest of high tech, as far as I can tell). And of course, because of the Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company, this move will increase the likelihood of Taiwan finding itself part of China again sometime in the next ten years. So this will all work out very well for China in the end, and badly for the USA. Another embellishment for Trump's CV.

Help! My printer won't print no matter how much I shout at it!

Yes Me Silver badge
Happy

Re: I don't want to stereotype doctors as arrogant...

Your problem there is that you need to make them wait far longer than 10 minutes for their call to be answered. And make the music really horrible.

Fixed it for you.

Yes Me Silver badge
Joke

Re: Slaughterhouse in Alberta.

Ah, that's sad, I thought there was going be sanguinary ingress in your story.

NHS COVID-19 launch: Risk-scoring algorithm criticised, the downloads, plus public told to 'upgrade their phones'

Yes Me Silver badge
WTF?

New Zild

"Around 6.4 per cent of all Android downloads are attributed to devices from New Zealand. Why?"

Right now, the NHS app isn't available on Google Play in NZ. And its name doesn' t remotely resemble "NZ COVID tracer". So this is very odd. (Anyone who operates with an NZ SIM in the UK is either nuts or rich and foolish.)