* Posts by P. Lee

5267 publicly visible posts • joined 4 Dec 2007

Poll: Climate change now more divisive than abortion, gun control

P. Lee

Science is a tool for analysing/understanding the world

Like a hammer, it can be used to help construct a house or cave someone's skull in.

AGW's has a few problems:

- it serves its political users very well. That in itself brings it into disrepute.

- its a statistical study. We all know what you can do with statistics (check out the recent BBC articles on correlation) and it appears that leading AGW proponents destroyed data to prevent it being made public. This looks like a really bad religion.

- Most of the world live at the mercy of forces they don't control. One more issue that may make things more difficult long after they are dead isn't at the top of their list of priorities

- the pitchforks and torches come out for anyone who disagrees with AGW. That is not the normal response of people with obvious common-sense on their side. Again, this looks like a really bad religion.

Quite frankly, heart disease is the number one abnormal killer in the West. It is fat and sugar which will likely kill you. Dietitians know this. Politicians know this, but do nothing to stop it. The evidence is a lot stronger than for AGW. It turns out that sugar is worse because to inhibits your body's ability to determine when you've eaten enough. I saw a BBC report noting that the WHO was going to publish a report into the problems of sugar consumption and the US sugar association wrote to them to point out that if they went ahead, they would lose $400m+ of funding from the US government. The report was never published. The point is, no-one thinks the government or any other large organisation is actually operating in their interest, so why would you trust them? All "independent research" comes back with results which benefit the funding organisation.

It gets worse. There's lots of funding but no solutions. That screams "pork-barrel." It doesn't even seem to be a fight between "big oil" and "greenies." Energy consumption won't drop and the energy companies would be at the forefront of any new energy provision. They are never going to lose out. It appears that governments cover "transition costs" so that's more profit for them if they provide the (more expensive and less efficient) windmills. The other group which seems to benefit are the financiers who deal in the new "carbon markets" which are springing up and which are set to be the *largest* of all markets. Hmm, the largest part of your economy deals in government permits - what could possibly go wrong?

The chap who pointed out the problems of sugar in the 1960's-70's when industry wanted only fat (rather than both) to be the problem was essentially drummed out. It wasn't that the science was wrong, but that it wasn't the result industry and government wanted to hear.

What a surprise, politicians (as a group) with a proven track-record of dishonesty are not trusted. I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!

Intel marries Chinese chippery firm to SoC it to low-end tablet market

P. Lee

As with MS, so with Intel

Well done Nokia Rockchip!

Actually this makes sense for Intel - essentially they are buying a Chinese brand. ARM delivers profits to the vertically integrated so Intel are doing the same. They can subsidise all the kit to get a decent volume of testers for android (or windows) on atom so they can improve that half of the stack without looking bad in the profitable West.

Like MS, Intel's advantage of a huge software base is nullified by the fact that the software assumes AC power supplies and is not power efficient. Doing a straight Linux install would result in a rubbish phone product. That's what Apple learnt by making iOS not the same as OSX.

I can't see success for Intel here though. Their profit margins are just too high to compete in the phone or tablet space. What they need is a phone/tablet-specific CPU which won't eat into their desktop profit but which they can price to match ARM. Again, this is the same as MS' dilemma with RT. Success in one area destroys profit in another.

You've got Mail! But someone else is reading it in Outlook for Android

P. Lee
FAIL

Re: <title goes here but will it be encrypted?>

No, Outlook is singled out because the whole idea of paying for stuff is that you are paying for someone to pay attention to the tedious bits that might be overlooked in a free product.

Also, this is a phone system well known for having a less than stellar privacy and security controls, so security should be uppermost in the mind of anyone designing a system for corporate use.

If MS had a track record to be proud of, it would look like a security gaffe, with their actual track record it looks like corporate slime. What can I say? Reputation is important.

Tech that we want (but they never seem to give us)

P. Lee
Facepalm

Re: laptop battery life

First gen Mackintosh?

P. Lee

Re: A KVM switch that follows the Eyes

Holographic webcams which allow you to look at the screen (who you are talking to) but transmit a picture of you looking directly at the camera, so you don't always look as though you are watching something else.

P. Lee
Facepalm

Re: Non-reflective laptop screens.

I have a dell E6510 quadcore i7 with a non-reflective screen with 16G RAM and an SSD.

I love it right up to the point when I have to lift it - then I want an MBA.

P. Lee
Happy

Re: Non-reflective laptop screens.

Haha!

I have a Compaq/HP NC8000 with 4:3 screen! I suspect the other reason for 16:9 is the width it provides for the keyboard. It's quite good for web browsing as I can see more of the web page.

I went into an apple shop the other day and asked for a laptop matt screen. The cult member just looked at me blankly. It was hilarious. I can no longer find that option on their website, which is less funny and more sad.

Google tells indie labels to take its YouTube deal or face OBLIVION

P. Lee
Holmes

Re: Pitchfork time.

All companies do this. Only if you are large enough do you get the chance to negotiate T's&C's.

Individual negotiation is too costly.

Surely more important is what's in the T's&C's? Is that unreasonable?

Intel cutting prices, taking on all comers in fondleslab market grab

P. Lee

Re: target market is China – .. what .. Tim Cook calls the "junk part of the market"

>The same bit of kit on Western shores would have cost £500+!

Because the cost is not in the production but in the selling. This will be the West's downfall. We have already seen the high-street retail struggling because retail and marketing is too expensive.

The problem is over-production. We can saturate the market so now we have to reduce quality to trigger re-purchases and we have to spend millions stealing sales from other products. This is not sustainable. We need smaller suppliers who can grow with good ideas, not massive suppliers desperately seeking some way to foist "new and improved" on us to cover their marketing budgets.

P. Lee

> The problem Microsoft has, they compete with their partners.

One of MS' problems is that they have partners.

Apple have complete vertical integration and reap profit from all parts.

Samsung have everything except the software stack (Well some of that too - but the OS is free).

MS's problem is that they are trying to sell an OS in market where they don't vertically integrate and they don't have hardware which will need replacing. The vendor OS already does most of what we want. So Intel wants a slice of profit, the Asus wants a slice of profit and MS wants a slice of profit. Instant 1/3rd profit for MS. Plus Asus looks at Intel and wonders if component prices will be hiked; looks at MS and wonders if OS prices will be hiked and thinks it would rather have an ARM license and Android, with or without Google. Samsung does the same thing and thinks a Tizen alternative is also a good plan. There are too many powerful players and too much investment at stake to rely on other, fickle companies.

This is why MS is likely to lose in the market: On the demand-side, no-one wants a phone locked down like a laptop SOE (i.e. BYOD fail - companies will have to buy all their own phones again); on the supply side, companies like Samsung want certainty and control, which ARM brings but Intel and MS do not.

Valve's Steam streaming service lets you play games on the toilet

P. Lee
Pint

Thanks Valve!

I' had been desperately trying to work out a justification for a 10G network!

P. Lee
Joke

Cool

Not to mention actually workable rather, than pie-in-the-sky cloud-rendered gaming.

Latency-sensitive games will still be out, but there's a whole lot of other things which will be fine.

I wonder if Valve might think of applying the tech to more business-oriented applications once the kinks have been ironed out. If it can do games, it should handle LibreOffice rather easily. If we get full-duplex sound you're edging towards an RDP replacement. Add SteamOS and you might have a small-biz server in a box. Virtualise a windows workstation to add a mainstream accounts package...

The year of the linux desktop! :p

Apple wheels out sueball cannon, again

P. Lee

re: Why the S2?

Because SII is like SIII which is a bit like SIIII?

I'm beginning to wonder if Samsung like this stuff. If you are at the premium end of the market, you don't mention your competition. This looks like vanity for Apple, I suspect they would have been better off dropping it and saying, "well, we still think they infringed and were in the wrong so we sued on principle, but they aren't good enough to worry us."

Hanging on to this makes Apple look like a loser, even if they win.

US skywatchers get Earth's first peek at new meteor shower

P. Lee
Coat

Re: Vanitas vanitatum omnia vanitas

> Wait! There's Cake!?

Nope. The cake is a lie.

Tech sector still loves its slaves: study

P. Lee

Re: Meanwhile...

The difference is that Apple makes enormous profits and can easily afford to do the right thing. As noted, the manufacturing costs are a tiny percentage of sell-price. It's those pretty shops and creepy staff that raise the prices, but even then, massive profits are still made.

Broom and toothbrush manufacturers, not so much.

For this reason, I'd be happy to buy such things online and convert the retail outlets to sell things I really care about seeing. Fresh food, for example.

'I run my business from my phone' says Benioff as Salesforce shovels $93m into the furnace

P. Lee

Re: "...from my phone..." Really?

The question is, "what's the role?"

Visionary leader? Maybe. Don't let anyone like that near execution functions.

Apart from that, I'd be scared of anyone who thinks they can do that.

Son of ACTA pours fuel on IP trade fire

P. Lee

Remind me again...

Why do you need a treaty or any other legislation, to say that US exports "are in the national interest"?

Just say "No."

PC makers! You, between Microsoft and the tablet market! Get DOWN!

P. Lee

I had a look at an old surface system. I was surprised at how good it was for replacing a laptop.

That isn't what it first looks like. The truth is that most laptops I see spend their days docked, to accommodate a 2nd large screen, an external mouse and possibly a keyboard. If you do all that through one USB/TB connection, a tablet which is only occasionally used without those devices could well be an option. The one I saw was atom-based but a better CPU might make it more usable.

Many companies have hotdesks with the peripherals supplied so just taking a tablet to and from work and occasionally on the road is an option. It might even get MS back into the home (ok, I'm kidding there).

What MS have missed though is that the tablet is cool precisely because it isn't under corporate control - it is an expression of self. Take that away and its no longer desirable.

What will be interesting is to see if ARM can approach this scenario from the other end by giving people an over-powered phone which docks to a KVM. Phone graphics are already up there. Let's see if big.LITTLE / 64bit ARM can give us a single bit of silicon which can double up as a phone and PC. It should start at home with USB screen / bluetooth keyboard/mouse or a screen with a charging/docking station built in. I suspect this is what MS are desperately trying to avoid.

P. Lee

Since when is a 12" screen a killer feature for business?

Great for selecting your next track on spotify perhaps, but colour me and my visio diagramme "unimpressed."

MacBook Air 13-inch: If you squint hard enough, you'll see a lesser-spotted Apple Price Cut

P. Lee

The MBA has a particular use-case.

Personally, I'd have liked to see a 16G RAM option so I can run a 8G VM. I don't think that would have impacted battery life too much. Resolution is nice but probably impacts battery life and most of the time, an external screen is available. Does it have stereo speakers yet? HP's touchpad has good sound which just shows what you can do in a confined space.

I know apple is focused on its market, but a proper delete key is still high on my agenda. Apart from that, its a nice little thing. a few tweaks and it could be at the top of quite a few windows-based users who are just tired of lugging heavy Dell E6xxx's around.

P. Lee
Coat

Re: Wi-Fi down at a local watering hole matched the 12-hour battery life

Kudus to you if you can get that job!

iPhone-stroker-turned-fandroid sues Apple over iMessage text-slurpery

P. Lee

Re: Oh FFS

The perils of OTT services.

As I understand it, sender's iphones hold an addressbook entry tagging you as an imessage user and keep redirecting "messaging" (what everyone expects to be SMS) to apple rather than the telephone number. However, apple will have no way of differentiating between a flat battery and a migrated user.

I think this is seamless on setup. Therefore, this should be seamless on teardown - i.e. an "offline" imessage should revert to SMS. I suspect Apple will deny that their messaging app is primarily sms and user's shouldn't expect sms.

While I can understand how this happens technically. It is far too convenient for apple to leave such a bug in the system to make migrated users unhappy. They should be penalised for it. If setup is seamless getting you into imessage, the exit should also be seamless. If the destination imessage user is offline, it should tell the message originator app to immediately revert to proper SMS.

I'm not sure about the fine though. It seems to high for damages but too low as a punitive measure. It just looks a bit opportunistic.

Multiplayer Elite to debut on May 30th

P. Lee

Re: @Joerg

Maybe he used to be a game beta- tester?

P. Lee
Mushroom

Re: you approach a station..

Haha!

Hex editor... Military Lasers!

Bitcoin blockchain allegedly infected by ancient 'Stoned' virus

P. Lee

Re: Many Monkey theorem

I'd bet that this is the chaos of MS' software interacting with random data to produce... random non-functional rubbish output. Even if it did replicate the entire sequence of bytes in order, without the applied intelligence and the context of a floppy disk boot mechanism, those bits have no meaning.

GIGO: unlike the moneys, this has some evidence.

Also, mow many many mips are expended looking for "stoned" on a daily basis?

World loses mind: Uber valued at TEN BEEELLION DOLLARS, Pinterest pegged at $5bn

P. Lee

Re: 1999 called...

Its worse. What's driving the stock market is pretty much zero interest rate which means there's hardly anywhere else for money to go - better a slim hope than no hope of return. At least this way, if you get out early enough you make some cash.

This time around, the economy is already completely shot with governments keeping interest rates down and printing money like its 1929.

Cloud computing aka 'The future is trying to KILL YOU'

P. Lee

Re: Of course the cloud will eat your lunch, time for a new diet

The Cloud isn't changing the game - that's just PR.

The Cloud is a reaction to a changed game. The problem is that we've pretty much finished IT development. We have networked pretty much everything that needs to be networked. We have storage to store the enterprise data we need. Our accounting systems, desktop productivity hosts, PLCs, email servers have already been bought and implemented.

IT has little left to improve. There are improvements to be made, but nothing like the gains of the last 20 years. Therefore, the prices of new kit and consultancy can no longer be justified, because the ROI isn't there. Companies stopped buying desktop PC's. Vendors have reacted by removing upgrade options. New laptops now have un-upgradable RAM, lower RAM limits and more stuff glued together to make them unrepairable.

The Cloud is just moving workloads around, its unreliable and inefficient since the infrastructure isn't tuned for the jobs required. That provides a lovely new market for more hardware and more consultancy. It requires massive amounts of engineering to solve problems which smaller units simply don't have. How many times have I seen adverts about using the cloud to scale your email. Really? I've never met a company that didn't know how to scale its email. Before it was shut down, myrealbox hosted email was serving 250,000 people with a two node cluster for mail pickup and another two nodes for SMTP on *Netware*.

Once everyone had bought all the software they needed, they didn't need to go back for more. So now we have OS's which time-out and to which applications are tied. Software is moving to rental and will be upgraded whether you need it or not, simply because you don't need it. Supply has outstripped production which normally means vendors should go out of business, but with software legalese, you now can't have an asset because the vendors need it to be a liability for you.

You used to buy licenses to run software on a single computer. Now the software is hobbled to core counts, because a single CPU can serve a major enterprise and that is too cheap for the vendors. When that isn't enough revenue, they provide "appliances" running dual-core desktop CPUs to make sure you aren't using cheap hardware to get more use out of their software than they think you are paying for. The whole reason for faster hardware is being nullified with licensing and the hardware market has not many places left to go except consolidation. Once people have finished consolidation of major sprawl, server hardware vendors will be back in the same place that desktop makers are now.

It will be interesting to see how things develop with FLOSS. Just as Intel is supporting MongoDB, I'll be interested to see if other hw vendors begin pushing open source, just as a way to allow better utilisation of their hardware. Current licensing schemes are driving poor design, because you can't just spin up more instances / new hardware easily. Why not replicate lots of databases (with high read-to-write ratios) across lots of nodes and load-balance so that new applications have only a small overall impact to any one node. If I were HP, I'd be pushing postgres rather than oracle in order to sell more HPUX nodes. By "pushing" I mean putting in resources, not just encouragement.

This is the opening for new companies: software licenses are far too expensive. The downside is the big players wrapping up the industry in patents to discourage competition. As Google v Apple shows, you need deep pockets regardless of merit.

Real, hovering SPEEDER BIKE can be YOURS for cheaper than a house

P. Lee
Mushroom

Also not recommended in forests.

Titsup Russian rocket EXPLODES, destroys $275m telly satellite

P. Lee

Space-as-a-Service

Clouds looking decidedly lumpy and hot.

Comcast exec says wired broadband customers should pay-as-they-go

P. Lee

Re: Extreme Price Gouging, Extreme Nonsense

> until now, the content was never personalized.

^ This. Though "personalisation" is mostly "destination IP and time of consumption."

The problem is that everyone is desparately trying to centralise personal services instead of broadcasting and personalising at the consumer end. We can mostly blame the desire for DRM for that.

There's little technical reason not to have an STB which torrents content off-peak and then streams it locally. But no, they have to stream it directly from their servers, which brings up latency and peak-time bandwidth problems.

I go the broadcast route - Silicondust tuners with ethernet-out going to MythTV for local streaming. If Oz TV got with the programme and broadcast something other than mpeg2, the content could go straight to tablets as well as laptops. As it is, all the customisation for my TV viewing goes on locally, offloading from the ISP network and the provider. That seems like the proper way to do it.

Autodesk to release 'open' 3D printer

P. Lee
Coat

Question!

Will my local printer work if my internet link is down?

FSF slams Mozilla for 'shocking' Firefox DRM ankle-grab

P. Lee

The proper way to handle DRM

1) Implement it.

2) Be surprised when you discover that it's broken.

The better standards are supported, the less call there is for different browsers. If I trusted Google more and Chrome had noscript/flashblock and a separate search/location box, there'd be little reason to pick one or the other.

With noscript on, precise rendering is way down the list of priorities.

Game of Thrones written on brutal medieval word processor and OS

P. Lee

Re: You wouldn't give him a hard time if he was using a typewriter

Its a serious arrogance and a logical error to assume modern is better than old.

He isn't typesetting, he just needs to record words. He isn't embedding spreadsheets into documents or designing network diagrammes. It's difficult to see what Word 2013 offers that Wordstar can't do.

I suspect vim would also work as well.

If what you have does what you need, there's little point wasting time learning something new.

He might have one of those nice old IBM clickity-clack keyboards too. :)

Do you use NAS drives? For work? One just LEAKED secret cash-machine blueprints

P. Lee

Security fail

Only the key should be required to be secret.

Internet of Stuff: Cleaner washing, more milk ... fewer COW FARTS?

P. Lee

Re: But, but, but...

Sounds like the Australian power company who offer a service of going out and shooting some wild camels on your behalf, to help you offset your carbon footprint.

Gigabyte Brix Pro: You don't need no steenkin' Xbox... when you have 4K-ing amazing graphics

P. Lee

Re: £900 ???

> I'd need to buy around 40 games just to break even

This is where we meet the difference between PC and console. PC games last between generations, so its quite easy to acquire 100+ games, especially in the steam sales. I think I picked up all the CoD series up to MW for $25. I moved from a core2 duo with a GT 9800 to a hex-core cpu and GT680 (5-6 times the performance) and everything still works. Even better, I can also load up on my laptop and take the games with me. I've got Monkey Island, which I played in the 1990's. (I could go back to the 1980's with kings-quest though I prefer to leave that as a happy memory!) I can let my kids work on their problem solving skills in MI on whatever hardware I have - I don't need to keep old tech around or risk losing the game because some power supply with a proprietary connector has blown. I don't lose my games because the original game ran on something with analogue video hardware and now I can't get a screen that isn't digital.

Also, did I mention Steam Sales? Humble Bundle?

P. Lee

Re: Hmmm...?

Windows or osx (ahem) in a vm?

A game, a game server and the base OS?

How about libreoffice always on or (with 802.11ac / wires) an xterm server, asterisk...

Multiple simultaneous logins?

P. Lee

Re: £900 ???

Once you factor in game costs, this is cheap compared to consoles. It's normal PCs this will struggle against. I don't see the point of a quad i7 paired with intel graphics. Surely an i5 is enough to feed that gpu. I want a pciex16 graphics slot, even if it sits in an expansion bay.

When will someone give me an i7 laptop with pciex16 external links an a little NAS which does the downloading? I want a download-only login for steam and download scheduling with something more elegant than cron.

I want them to succeed but this needs refinement. Maybe water-cooling too.

Survey: Patent litigation skyrocketing, trolls top 10 sueball chuckers

P. Lee

Still missing the point

Even those that do make stuff are suing over things they shouldn't.

That's the same as trolling.

Also, obtaining patents for things which shouldn't get one. That's also trolling. They may not be suing at that point but they are threatening their competition and potential competition, which is essentially the same.

Apple, Beats and fools with money who trust celeb endorsements

P. Lee

Re: Limited bit rate?

The real problem is with CD's.

Not their audio format, but the complete lack of metadata attached to each track. FLAC would be fine except for the lack of support in portable players. I want one solution which works, not having to transcode all the time.

The other thing the article neglected is that mp3's are mostly used in mobile devices with poor headphones, so again, audio quality is almost irrelevant.

I must be getting old. Mostly I listen to podcasts with only the occasional musical item from Mitch Ben, or to the old stuff of my youth as a nice trip down memory lane while I'm hoovering. Obviously I'm not cool because otherwise its, "pop a CD in the player" for a bit of classical instrumental or medieval-style vocals.

GM reveals how much you'll pay to turn your car into a rolling 4G LTE Wi-Fi hotspot

P. Lee

Re: I'd love to see them try this in Australia

Depends how you've trained them. We often took ours places and made them sit still on our laps without making a noise. It isn't easy, but it is a discipline worth developing. I don't think we've ever had a problem with our UK-Oz flights which we've done every couple of years.

If you routinely use digital to distract, that will be needed and a book won't suffice. That seems self defeating to me. Train them with the ideal state, not the one with the fastest results.

Oracle vs Google redux: Appeals court says APIs CAN TOO be copyrighted

P. Lee

Re: Probably the death knell of the "industry"

>How about: "Not for sale or use in the United States of America"

Swifttech (water cooling) already do that and that's fine by me. Let the US stew in its own overpriced monopoly markets.

But I think this is different. APIs are a list of things which a language/library can do. Since software is infinitely malleable It seems reasonable that more than one language/library would be able to do those things and should be allowed to advertise as such. As has been subtly mentioned, printf is an API call. No, it shouldn't be copyrightable as a nod to common sense. Additionally, if fair-use is defined as a % of total code copied, the APIs will almost certainly fall in that scope.

The desktop/mobile argument is also flawed. Sorry Oracle, but the original idea doesn't make sense, especially if you allow laptops to qualify as desktops.

Personally, if I were the judge hearing Oracle's arguments, I'd throw them out as being deliberately nonsensical to the point of operating in bad faith. Let that be a lesson to those who say one thing for marketing/sales and then try to use small-print to implement the opposite.

Even if this went against Google, all you'd get is a phone from Samsung which boots up the first time with a ROM clever enough to download an install image from elsewhere. Android would be spun off to another company. But that won't happen. Too popular to stop is probably a reality and we all know how adept multinationals are at not making taxable profit.

Is Trevor Pott-y? Nope – he's bang on about VSAN performance

P. Lee

Ah, Overhead

What you really want is for the OS to do its job and develop past the late 1990's.

VMs are a band-aid to solve a problem that the OS should be doing. The OS is supposed to manage access to resources. The OS is supposed to stop apps interfering with each other. Could we not have the OS manage multiple versions of libraries? Could we not have a little manifest file for each application which says, "I need these resources: x,y,z" Could we not have network-based resource publishing and discovery (even if loopback) rather than using a flaky registry database?

Why do we need to emulate entire machines in order to get these functions? How is it that VMware and hyper-V can do it, but straight Windows can't.

Oh right, we'd rather sell you another product than develop the first one.

LA air traffic meltdown: System simply 'RAN OUT OF MEMORY'

P. Lee

Re: altitude overflow?

There was a design flaw but that didn't cause this problem. As described, it was a coding-time bounds-checking failure. The coding should reject parameters it doesn't handle. If you don't have a full spec and decide to use a 16 bit integers, you reject the input of anything outside that during input validation. That would have left the X2 unmanaged, but the rest of the system would have been stable. Hopefully, the feedback would have been sent back to the UI that the value was too high and the operator could have tried lower values until he found one that worked, which is still likely to be way above all the other traffic.

One hopes the radar tracking routine is a little more robust.

Nintendo says sorry, but there will be NO gay marriage in Tomodachi Life ... EVER

P. Lee

Re: They have learned actually

Not to mention that most of these games are aimed at children.

Not something which comes naturally to the LGT's and there are plenty of people for whom unusual relationships would place the game out of contention.

Did I mention games are aimed at children? Sexual relationships before puberty are irrelevant - why would you want to sexualise something aimed at kids? The natural environment for children is to have a male and female parent. It doesn't matter what laws you pass, children aren't really found under gooseberry bushes and that doesn't change.

WTF is Net Neutrality, anyway? And how can we make everything better?

P. Lee

Re: oncoming shortage = new higher price for exisitings services !

This.

Plus, once everyone pays to play, we are back where we started. At no point is there an incentive incentive for the ISP to increase bandwidth, as long as they are a monopoly. The "pay to play" control is the peering hardware connections, not links. This should be regulated. As far as content destined for an ISP network is concerned, there should be a regulated price/markup allowing anyone to connect for that price.

I'm happy for rich content providers to buy fatter links into an ISP but they must not be able to dictate QOS across someone-else's network based on source rather than content-type. The reason for this is that when the ISP end-users pay, rather than corporates, it help keep things above-board and transparent.

The technical problem is defining "content type." Usually we us IP ports, but we'll need broader catagories - realtime (voip/video calling), buffered (streamed video), interactive (http), non-interactive (SMTP), low priority (torrent) etc.

Let's also not forget that nearly all this low-latency requirement only exists to support a (somewhat failed) attempt at DRM by using streaming rather than store and play. As has been noted, torrent traffic is quite happy delivering massive amounts of video over congested links. Use the torrent protocols, add a layer of DRM (don't play before X; delete 36 hours after showtime) and save yourself a bundle of deployment cost. Infringement happens - why make it cost you more that it already does?

I know there are use-cases for provider-streaming, but for home use, an STB + local streaming is far better.

Boffins say hot air makes Antarctica colder

P. Lee

Re: there's a lot....

I don't believe it! Common sense and global warming meet!

However, I fear that you are missing the point of AGW. It's supposed require A WAR ON AGW with freedoms being given up, vast amounts of cash being spent on politicians conferences and the creation of a new market in carbon allowing particular kinds of people to get rich.

You can't go around spoiling it by telling people to use a dredge. Fortunately, that kind of common sense will be utterly ignored while we wait on the next study.

Humphrey, I don't think we should rush in until we have all the facts!

Yes minister.

Copyright minister: Those missing TWO copyright exceptions? We're still on track

P. Lee

You have to throw the rights-holders something

Why?

As has been noted, if you distribute according to sales, you are by definition, giving money mostly to those who don't need it. Also remember that piracy (if that's your concern) and blank media are not really related unless you're talking about the industrial scale stuff from China - in which case taxing in the EU is a bit pointless. In fact, as soon as you look at tax, you have a problem with distribution because unlike most tax, the government isn't really spending the money on things it needs. All its doing is supporting an inadequate business model. If you can't determine a "right" distribution, there's little point collecting the tax. You've also got to ask yourself if what you are supporting is of social benefit. Do we want another Justin Beiber?

Why would you even bother thinking about media conversion and parody? I'm not sure that you should have to pay to make fun of people. If there is general mocking of the original, or the meaning of the original, it's probably fair game. If the police are taking an interest in whether I've burnt an itunes track to CD so I can play it in the car, they have way too much time on their hands. Just look away. If I have a stack of 1000 CD copies of the same track, I might not be converting for my own use. In that case, an investigation may be in order.

UN to debate killer drone ethics

P. Lee

Autonomous?

What could possibly go wrong?

Probably less than the US' record of attacking allies by mistake...

$3.2bn Apple deal would make hip-hop mogul Dr Dre a BEEELLLIONAIRE

P. Lee

Re: Isn't Beats Audio just a funky way of saying...

Up at either end, flat in the middle, and everything in between interpolated - if my 80's memory serves.

Also achieved by the "bass boost" option button for a cleaner interface (late 80's/90's).

"No option" is the latest version of a simple interface. It appears they have achieved Apple's requisite level of user interface design.

Actually, HP's original touchpad has excellent sound - knocks the spots of most laptops. I don't know if that was Dre-influenced. Personally, I've always thought that marketing HP and rap-influence together was an uneasy situation. Surely if HTC, HP and Apple all have it, it can't still be cool and fighting against the Man.

Oi Apple, an iscsi initiator would be far more useful. Anyone who is serious about sound is going to run things through an external amp and can mess with it there. By "serious" I mean, "at least vaguely interested in turning the volume up a bit."