* Posts by Mage

9273 publicly visible posts • joined 23 Nov 2007

Mobile app devs have, oh, about 9 hours left to decide whether to stay on Google's ad platform

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Elephant in the room

Google, Adobe, MS, Twitter, Apple, Facebook etc morally ought to stop collecting ANY data from user, other than IP address and page hits.

EmDrive? More like BS drive: Physics-defying space engine flunks out

Mage Silver badge
Alien

Re: possibility of cheap space travel.

Given the power source or solar panels needed, any EM or Mach craft will be heavy.

The biggest cost is actually getting stuff off the ground into space.

Neither of these ideas make Interstellar travel any more feasible.

Mage Silver badge

Re: The Germans don't watch youtube enough

Except Edison didn't invent it. He was looking for a better way to make carbon filaments. Tungsten was too difficult to work with. Nor did he invent Cinema despite his patents. He was an entrepreneur, not a scientist.

I agree the EM drive and Mach drive are worth investigating (Photon propulsion does work), though the expectations of the proponents for space travel are overblown. Though you don't need reaction mass, unlike Ion drive, solar power is only good well within the orbit of Jupiter. Nuclear power needs fuel and if you had a fusion drive you can use the helium etc produced in a linear accelerator / Ion drive. Electrons can be accelerated separately and mixed with the Helium ions.

Finally: Historic Eudora email code goes open source

Mage Silver badge
Unhappy

2400bps!

I started with 1200/75, (1982) then I was using 300 baud on a PCW8256 to a PAD, then X.25 to the mail server (1986).

Later 19.2K then 28K in 1990s using POP3 / SMTP. Eudora for a long time. Thunderbird from 2005. Total 12647 when I click on main inbox. Sadly it's been going backwards in GUI terms and usability. Mozilla seem clueless. I've switched to 52ESR for Firefox, it's gone mad.

14.4K on the Nokia Communicator up till 2004. Or twice as much billing per second for 28.8K. It wasn't the iPhone that made Mobile data possible for the masses, not directly. It was 3G (245K, which iPhone originally didn't have, it used GSM's EDGE) and cheap data packages instead of per second or per Megbyte expensive billing.

The home landline was local call rate billing till 2006 and still only 33K then.

Swiss sausage sizzler 4.0 hits 200 bangers per hour

Mage Silver badge

Re: Competition?

The Germans have a hot sausage vending machine.

The Wurst time to be alive!

Big bimmer bummer: Bavaria's BMW buggies battered by bad bugs

Mage Silver badge

Re: decisions like "we use QNX"

QNX isn't the problem.

It's a quite good OS and a pity RIM/Blackberry bought it. Used to be used for storage controllers and real time industrial controllers.

I'd like to see it either OS, or owned by someone more generic than Blackberry. Would be nice alternative to Linux for I/O based controllers that only optionally have a GUI.

Linux is OK, but there is too much of a mono-culture.

Mage Silver badge

Re: Are You Surprised

Also RAV4 has/had flaw on lock securrity.

What cars could be interfered with via a DAB broadcast even if Radio tuned into "official" multiplex? (It's not cost that stops there being Pirate DAB stations).

Various exploits via OBD or what ever you call it.

Tesla.

Seems we are going backwards on car security.

Hitler 'is dead' declares French prof who gazed at dictator's nashers

Mage Silver badge

swallowed cyanide and then shot himself

Before or after setting fire to the room / bunker?

Mage Silver badge
Alien

Re: You'll be showing us your snapchat shot of the other side of the Moon

Actually the Russians photographed the far side of the moon in 1959, Luna 3. Apollo 8 astronauts viewed from orbit in 1968.

Far side good for a radio telescope shielded from human interference. The poles might be good for any sort of communication relay station (radio or laser) not suitable for a satellite, though I'm not sure on that.

Mage Silver badge

Re: on the dark side of the moon

I had a friend that was a Pink Floyd fan. I thought it was a daft phrase in 1973 too. I did buy Relics, possibly because it was cheap old stock. Then again, I bought ELP Brain Salad Surgery. I was young and impressionable then.

Mage Silver badge
Black Helicopters

who was supposed to be protecting him anyway?

Hmm... time for a Hitler offspring themed version of Archangel?

Mage Silver badge
Alien

on the dark side of the moon

The Independent has this strange phrase too. There is the side that faces away and the side facing us. No dark side.

Within Arm's reach: Chip brains that'll make your 'smart' TV a bit smarter

Mage Silver badge
Big Brother

Re: (see China)

Also, Russia, USA, UK, all Muslim states (not all are Arab).

Maybe this is the magic unicorn tech that a certain Government is hoping for?

Mage Silver badge

Re: As long is there's no third party

Wot, even the Plod? It would want to have about 99.9% accuracy instead of the <2% the Plod has.

ALSO MAJOR MAJOR privacy and civil liberties issues. Yes the Ad industry slurping is nasty, but Governments, state agencies, criminals and perverts are worse.

IPv6 growth is slowing and no one knows why. Let's see if El Reg can address what's going on

Mage Silver badge

Re: I can take a stab at it..

Also older US corporations, some governments and US Universities have actually enough IP4 addresses they don't need (often 16 million each) that might last the Internet 20 to 100 years.

So every time the IP4 are exhausted, mysteriously they are not.

Mage Silver badge

Re: NAT: NO IT DOESN'T.

However good luck setting up IP6 NAT on a domestic router. The whole point of IP6 was to avoid the need for NAT.

They had to change how MAC worked on IP6 too because of privacy issues.

Security, Privacy, backwards compatibility and interworking all look like afterthoughts. Yes, my router and ISP support IP6, but I lose both firewall and NAT if I enable it and there are no sensible IP6 settings other than on/off.

Mage Silver badge

IP6 slowing

Because it's a stupid design and not compatible with IP4, so everyone has to run IP in parallel.

Good news: It's still legal for Apple to keep its MacBook, iPhone batteries from melting

Mage Silver badge

Good.

Now can we have most of the fake patents, trademarks, design patents (=UK registered Design), DMCA, fake copyright held by major corporations chucked out too?

Also reform USPTO and other agencies. Charge MORE for rejection than acceptance.

Stop the copyright landgrab of 144 years and cut back existing copyright which has been extended too much.

Curb power of USA ITC instead of it being used via dubious USPTO approvals and US Corporations to block trade from outside USA.

The future of radio may well be digital, but it won't survive on DAB

Mage Silver badge

Lucky to get 192 on DAB

It's 128K for stereo here in Ireland, which is an insult.

Mage Silver badge

Re: DAB+

DAB+ isn't used to give better coverage or quality in many cases, but to double the number of stations at same quality.

DAB+ simply saves some money.

Ergonomically ANY sort of Digital radio is poorer than FM & AM. It's not driven by consumer needs or quality or technology, DAB & DAB+ are political decisions that benefit national broadcasters and multiple channel State broadcasters the most.

Digital radio isn't green either if there is genuinely the same quality and coverage and also the receiver power is considered.

Mage Silver badge

Re: The economics??

Also a sub £10 USB stick can pick up DTT, which has better coverage than DAB.

DTT could use better quality, here in Ireland, the RTE DTT radio audio (98%+ coverage) is same poor bit rate as the 45% coverage DAB.

Mage Silver badge

49.9 per cent in the last quarter of 2017 to 50.9

But that is NOT 50.9% listening to Dab.

They conflate streaming/Internet which needs fragile instrastructure, has privacy issues and isn't broadcast.

They count DAB sets (home and car radio) even if entirely or mostly used on FM.

Where are the phones with DAB? Or DAB sets with AM for outside of local reception (esp at night?). Or the DAB sets with +200 hrs battery life (even 1939 battery radios had 24 to 240 hours run time depending on size). How many DAB portables even manage two days?

Also bit rate is too low, to save money.

RTE Irish DAB an even bigger waste than UK.

DAB & Digital Broadcast benefits National stations.

There wasn't ever to be a true Analogue Switch Over, just closure of larger FM stations and keeping smaller ones, because there is no-one for Ofcom to sell the spectrum to and DAB is too much coverage (even though it's worse for big stations) and too costly for small stations.

Norway has made a bad mistake.

Slurp up patient data for algos that will detect cancer early, says UK PM

Mage Silver badge

Re: The NHS has no tech, no data-centric or tech-centric organisation

Don't they already outsource to Capita, who must in turn outsource because who are the the experts in Capita?

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Proof

Is there any properly peer reviewed and statistically significant proof that:

1) AI exists?

2) AI would deliver the desired results?

3) It isn't just a scheme to make money?

4) It can be properly anonymised?

The Big IBM AI program in the USA never delivered.

Previously NHS illegally shared with Google, a company with zero track record in health, but a proven to exploit personal data to make their claims of advertising plausible. IBM at least has some background, but Google is really an advert seller.

The harbingers of Doomwatch: Quist is quite the quasi-Quatermass

Mage Silver badge

It's a shame

BBC kills of good series, resurrects junk ones and generally now more into pushing their own agenda than any real education or drama.

Mage Silver badge
Devil

re: just put it all up

They reused the tapes to save a pittance. I was working in the Beeb then (mid 1970s) and we all protested at the short sighted vandalism.

What we didn't know was that they were scrapping film to save some storage space.

Do have accountants tell you the budget, profit, loss, costs. Do NOT have administrators or accountants decide policy or decide what the money is spent on.

The BBC digitization and archives and iplayer is a shambles. They had a good project & killed it.

Apart from the issues of destroyed stuff. They periodically call for help with missing or lost episodes/programs. Euphemism for wilfully destroyed by order of management!

US Congress mulls expanding copyright yet again – to 144 years

Mage Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: It would also require a positive registration initially

Everything is is fine. No registration. The USPTO is already broken and the US already has a broken registration system.

Who would run it internationally?

Currently if you write, compose, sculpt, choreograph, paint, draw, photograph, outside of USA you have the copyright AUTOMATICALLY.

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Corporate Theft

This doesn't benefit any creator or artist. Only already rich Corporations.

Even the UK extension to Life + 70 is wrong. It should be Life + 25 (so as to leave something to the creators children).

It should not be more than 25 years from initial publishing if no individual or band is getting royalty. Corporations receiving ALL the royalties should be limited to a Generation.

Also anything copyright should actually be published, available at a reasonable price. It should enter public domain if work is unavailable to purchase at a reasonable price for 5 years.

USA Radio already doesn't pay full royalties. There are creator rights AND performance rights. What Spotify pays is too little, but YouTube is even worse. Google and Pinterest are copyright parasites.

Copyright is important so that creators and performers get paid. Also so companies make a return on their investment. But this is just pure corporate greed.

Look how modern we are! UK network Three to kill off 3G-only phones

Mage Silver badge

2G (GSM, not USA CDMA)

The GSM voice calls don't suffer cell breathing. The 3G was a retrograde design, really giving more speed because of 5MHz vs GSM 2G 0.2MHz "channels", CDMA (based on USA 2G) was a bad idea as the capacity falls to about 50% as it's loaded. The 4G speed increase needs 20MHz channels, though doesn't suffer the CDMA ills on downlink. However 4G efficiency for voice is terrible as it's only VOIP, no native RF voice codec like GSM 2G and 3G has.

The High Street and eBay still sell GSM only watch gadgets and phones. There ought to be 2 years retail notice of turning off 2G/GSM or 3G (SOGA) after ceasing sales. Irish operations only have to notify Comreg and give 6 months notice. Three Ireland acquired O2 Ireland (and thus masts for Tesco Ireland) which has GSM.

This is really comparing MOBILE with real broadband via Fixed Wireless (a rare thing). It's about 12 years old and done before 4G was rolled out. The 3G & 4G issues are true though.

I found last year some phones in Carphone Warehouse were GSM only. Their excuse was that they were only "feature phones" not smart phones.

By all means stop selling 3G (and GSM) phones. A good idea as long as the 4G models work all over Europe on 3G & GSM.

Open justice FTW! El Reg fought the law – and El Reg won

Mage Silver badge
Pint

Wonderful

Is El Reg one of the last bastions of Journalism fighting for Truth & Justice?

There are a few others left.

Some outlets/papers don't do ANY journalism now, simply quoting Wikipedia, PR, adverts and wire services.

LocationDumb: Phone tracker foul-up exposes world+dog to tracking

Mage Silver badge

Re: carriers sell the data to services

So another example of how the USA prioritises profits of corporations over the rights of individuals?

FCC needs reformed, and for all the MANY failings of ITU (19th C taken over by UN), DNS, Domain stuff, IP addresses obviously should be under ITU, not ICANN/US Corporations.

Crazy.

Mage Silver badge
Alert

I'm baffled

How does Location Smart get the info in the first place? You need to be the Police AND have a warrant in most Democratic countries. Or be State Security in the non-democratic ones.

Microsoft returns to Valley of Death? Cheap Surface threatens the hardware show

Mage Silver badge
Coffee/keyboard

Re: As phones hit $1000, are Surfaces really expensive?

$1000 phones are a niche.

There are really good phones at $200 to $400. Sometimes even less. Not talking about Contract.

Mage Silver badge
Coffee/keyboard

Low Cost? at $499!

Low-cost tablets is how Surface started – at $499 for the cheapest RT Surface.

A low-cost tablet is €70 to €200, not $499 (likely was near £499 inc VAT).

Obviously low cost compared to iPad, but all Apple major products are massively over priced for what you get.

£500 to £700 gets a not bad laptop, though if you want gamer performance rather than email, web, wordprocess & a bit of spreadsheet, maybe £2000. Most SOHO and SME only add Accounts, Payroll and CRM to that.

Surely an MS Surface is a niche, especially given that the GUI is like Windows 2.0 on a Hercules card? What is the USP? It's not any longer backward compatibility.

Blighty's super-duper F-35B fighter jets are due to arrive in a few weeks

Mage Silver badge

Re: indiscriminate due to the technologies of the day?

No. Nothing to do with inadequate technology!

Churchill DELIBERATELY targeted civilian areas of German cities as part of the strategy to distract Luftwaffe from bombing UK airbases in Battle of Britain. Perhaps he remembered the Zeppelin raid on London in WWI. Hitler then ordered development of the V weapons, which ironically killed x10 as many workers (mostly slaves) as targeted civilians. Putting the resources into subs and aircraft would have been more effective.

The firebombing of Dresden and Tokyo were war crimes. The Tokyo conventional bombing killed more civilians than the atomic bomb. Neither atomic bomb was needed. There was no need to repeat Okinawa, just simply blockade and watch the Russians advance. The Russians had declared war only a few weeks previously and were rapidly advancing. They were moving vast amounts by rail from the European front after VE day.

Biometrics: Better than your mother's maiden name. Good luck changing your body if your info is stolen

Mage Silver badge
Facepalm

Biometrics

They can only be used as the NAME part of a log in. NEVER EVER the password part of a log in. Because you can't change them.

IDIOTS.

Mage Silver badge

US Verification

The way they use Social Security numbers and birthdates is madness. Esp, the Police in USA and JUST using birthdate/area/name and not the unique driver's licence number or something else unique. Not just identity theft (The stupid way Social Security numbers are used) but OFFICIAL identity confusion on fines.

Whois privacy shambles becomes last-minute mad data scramble

Mage Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Typical ICANN

Contract terms that are coercive, violate law or would cause people to violate law are not enforceable. See also contracts inside shrink wrap boxes or on SW after/during install.

Mage Silver badge
Black Helicopters

Accredited access component

" the accredited access component. Registries and registrar will need to figure out a way to grant specific people access to non-private data but there is no guidance over the best way to do this or even who is eligible to gain that level of access"

Same as getting user of a home IP address or a wire tap in most Democratic countries. A warrant issued to police as a result of application to court with reasonable excuse. Not fishing expeditions, or unproven allegations of infringement. Prove some real intent at copyright infringement or illegal content in open court FIRST, then get warrant for the actual court case.

People like convenience more than privacy – so no, blockchain will not 'decentralise the web'

Mage Silver badge

eventually, to Google indexing

Re-writing history? Yes when there was only email, FTP, Gopher etc it was hard. Web sites made it easy. Altavista worked quite well (established 1995, realistically in use from 1996). Google was about two years later and not used so much till later still.

!

Now lots of people only use maybe two internet replacements of mailorder catalogues (eBay & Amazon). Most use one encyclopedia, one movie database and book database (both bought by Amazon). Maybe four main social media companies (Tencent, Facebook, Google, Twitter?)

!

Maybe five big Cloud providers (who are decentralised without blockchain!)

!

Blockchain and associated cryptocurrencies is a boon to money laundering and criminals, secondarily speculators. Banks don't need it. Secure private communication don't need it. Decentralisation doesn't need it (various peer to peer systems and distributed systems have existed without it). A serious problem is that it's not scaleable to large volumes of users and transactions.

Yet Google seems to think we want bookmarks, Pinterest, Wikipedia, YouTube, Google Books and paid results instead of search now.

US senators ask FTC to investigate Google's Location imbroglio

Mage Silver badge

Battery & Polling

This is a nonsense reason. The country or the mast location has in reality no bearing on how often the system should poll a server. Also those sort of parameters (like regular email client pop3 checking) should be under user control.

Which messages anyway? We should know.

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Google said

Can we believe?

Streetview WiFi slurping was no accident and now isn't needed.

"collecting phones' nearest cell tower locations because that would let it deliver messages faster; it denied retaining that location, and later disabled the 'service'."

That is absolute gibberish. The Mobile operator needs to know which "locations" a cell phone is near, it's part of the protocol of ALL mobile systems otherwise Mobile wouldn't work. It makes no difference whatsoever to anyone sending or receiving messages using a mobile network. So can we believe any of the rest of the statement?

Almost everything Google is doing on the Internet relating to client connections might be breaking existing EU laws, not just GDPR.

Android TV T&C you have to agree before even tuning a TV are coercive. The information gathered is illegal in EU.

The stock Android phone is a disgrace and can we believe turning off any slurp actually disables anything? A lot can't be turned off. MS seems to be trying to copy Google with Windows 10. Evil services that can't be disabled. Massive by default on slurping that never existed before.

Google Play Service on Android collects lots of information that Google has no legitimate use for and isn't needed for Playstore to work.

UPnP joins the 'just turn it off on consumer devices, already' club

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Now, home boxes, that's a different matter.

Why?

It should have been nuked from orbit before release.

The Router "feature" to have uPNP should never have existed. Let's not forget that even without the internet uPNP on a host (PC etc) is mostly a stunningly bad idea. Automatic install or connection to of something unseen somewhere else on a LAN?

Even apart from the Internet fail, it's a far worse a design disaster than USB HID because anyone could plug something into the LAN. At least with USB the user is actually plugging in the whatever it is*

It should NEVER have been added as a feature on ANY router.

It should be disabled on every PC too. Along with SSDP.

(* If using unknown USB chargers, use a cable that has no data connections. Don't plug in unknown USB things and note what messages appear on screen).

Android devs prepare to hit pause on ads amid Google GDPR chaos

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Re: "personalised ad" stuff is absolute nonsense.

The solution for Google & Facebook etc is simple. Stop peddling the fake snake oil of Targeted and Personalised. Stop gathering personal and other information.

Just do adverts like TV, radio, magazines, newspapers, buses and billboards do. Stop the click fraud and lies about impressions, have 3rd audits.

Stop with the too invasive analytics, just count unique IP addresses per running hour and don't keep them.

Web Advertising has become an evil, dishonest, exploitive, immoral, law breaking, parasitical monster.

IP freely? What a wind-up! If only Trevor Baylis had patent protections inventors enjoy today

Mage Silver badge

Re: Edwin Armstrong

Actually the Superhet was a French invention, and based on mathematics anyway. There is argument that Superhetrodyne and FM should not have been patentable as they are ultimately mathematical ideas. RCA should never have had either patent.

Patents, especially in the USA since the Victorian era, favour big corporations as they can afford a team creating them and lawyers to defend them. They are pretty useless to individuals unless they can quickly sell to a corporation. The USA USPTO is totally broken as they are uninterested in properly searching prior art, novelty, unobvious to those skilled in the art etc as they get more money from approvals than rejection. Their system is built round the idea of the Patent later being tested in Court. Obviously the Richer and US native company will win.

Copyright isn't as tricky but can be bypassed as you can't protect the idea. Again the main problem is big corporations. Google will assume works are orphaned or Public Domain unless a massive Corporation threatens them. They and Wikipedia only care about their OWN content. Hollywood, photo libraries, etc wants to extend forever and claim small guys infringe when they don't. DRM is contrary to the concept of Copyright. It should be illegal.

A good design patent / Registered design is a special sort of copyright. Again it favours the big company, but even there they need a unique shape (coca-cola bottle), or a mis-spelled word (Lyft) or made up word (Kleenex), or a custom design of logo / font face.

The solution isn't abolishing IP, but reforming the system.

App devs bewildered by last-minute Google GDPR klaxon

Mage Silver badge

generic ads, Google apply a unique advertising ID

That absolutely needs to stop. Unless they want to kill advert funded apps.

Mage Silver badge
Devil

Re: list the price of the ad-free version on the consent dialog

Before you waste time and bandwidth downloading it!

Most apps with adverts have no adfree version at any price, or at a sensible price. Also how do you get the money back if the paid version is rubbish?

I'm not going to consent to adverts to test an app.

Score one for the bats and badgers! Apple bins €850m Irish bit barn bid

Mage Silver badge

Re: Ireland is no California when it comes to sunshine.

Entire weeks with no wind over most of western Europe, inc Ireland. Wind needs 100% backup of other sources and isn't scaleable to much more than 10% when it is there.

Also weeks with grey sky or rain. West of Ireland has about x6 the rainfall of Dublin. There is already about as much hydroelectric as is feasible. Ireland is pretty flat in the middle with most mountains around the edges. Hence bogs.

Iceland is a better choice for datacentres. Or Northern France. Ireland is only an artificial choice.

Mage Silver badge

Planning Objections

Yes, the Wicklow guy was self interest.

However this was Apple ego. There are plenty of sites already serviced, close enough to existing likely employees and far more suitable.

Yes, there wasn't much forest, but Ireland has an even lower amount of percentage forest than the UK, which has one of the lowest in Europe. Losing any land to a datacentre is crazy when plenty of existing space is available. Shannon Industrial estate. Three Industrial estates in Limerick. Nenagh. Very many other places. But not "posh" enough for Apple.

~

I see Apple and Eircom have moved their Europe / Ireland HQs to Jersey to take advantage of UK's lax offshore Tax havens now that Ireland is actually going to charge the Corporate Tax they claim to. Apple was paying about 1/100th of Ireland's official Corporate Rate. EU is finally clamping down. Is it the real reason some top Tories want hard Brexit? UK is sovereign over more offshore havens than any other nation.

T-Mobile owner sends in legal heavies to lean on small Brit biz over use of 'trademarked' magenta

Mage Silver badge

Stupid

The problem is worse in USA. USPTO makes more money from approvals than rejections and US model is the assumption that if it's an invalid award, it will be invalidated by a court case.

"Winter is Coming" book #4 in "Cocky Seasons" series. Obviously the background of the romance's book cover is in a nice shade of pinkish magenta. Obviously I'm now an author for the day job rather than in IT/Programming/Electronics.

The system for Trademarks & Patents needs reformed. Abolishing Copyright, Trademarks, Registered Design (Design patent in USA) and Patents is the wrong solution. We need reform.

The only worthwhile aspects to abolish are DRM, DMCA, perpetual renewals of copyrights by Corporations. Maybe ICANN. Why can't a domain name follow copyright rules. It's crazy that a malware/squatter/ads can grab it if you forget to renew or skip for a year?