* Posts by Flocke Kroes

4559 publicly visible posts • joined 19 Oct 2007

UK formally abandons Europe’s Unified Patent Court, Germany plans to move forward nevertheless

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Evidence you would love to see

Here you go Pat Att(orney?). Evidence of low patent quality being 'sorted out' at great expense in post grant litigation. The patents are for generic data transmission, in this example, from a ventilator.

It took me less than 30 seconds to find this despite cases like this not hitting the news every week ("Dog Bites Postman!"). Wilful ignorance? Fingers in ears while shouting "LA LA LA"? I am sure you know damn well what is going on but it is to your financial advantage to pretend otherwise.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: What sensible patent regimes?

The "limited life" is 20 years. Imagine bringing a new product to market while being limited to 20 year old technology. (The car industry does exactly that with patents they do not own or cross-license. I am not sure how this rewards inventors or increases the rate of technical progress)

There is no expectation, requirement, preference or hint that development is the next step after (or before) getting a patent - much less manufacturing or bringing to market. There is no requirement that the patented invention even works. There was supposed to be some concept that a person skilled in the art could read a patent and then create the invention. That has not been reality for a long time. (There was supposed to be some lip-service to the idea that someone skilled in the art could not promptly re-create your invention without reading the patent but getting a patent invalidated for being obvious is impractical.) You can patent 'the idea' without going into detail about how such an invention could be made. Vagueness is in fact a bonus because it makes it difficult to prove someone else's product does not infringe.

Selling the idea only works if you have money. Lots of money. If you actually have a brilliant idea and it is still brilliant years later when you have your patent try showing it to a manufacturer. They will show you the door. Next year you will see your invention on sale. Sue for patent infringement. Sell you house to cover the initial legal fees. Live in a cardboard box for months of delays. Find you do not have the money to continue. Sell the lawsuit for a percentage of the payout. The buyer then does a cross-licensing deal so no money changes hands and you get nothing.

The effective way to earn money from patents if to patent gibberish. The patent will be rejected so you modify the gibberish a little and re-submit it to avoid the fee for filing a new patent. This method takes about as long as patenting a good idea but you do not need to bother with all that expensive time consuming R&D. Next threaten to sue world+dog. Do not for any reason actually initiate court proceedings. At first offer cheap settlements. You will get some. Use the funds for more threats. Keep the business growing until you are a multimillionaire then you can actually sue someone with money. Pick the right victim and they will settle for a large lump of cash on the condition that you sue their competitor.

The good news for this business model is that it is like Mickey Mouse copyrights. Every five years you update your patents so they are good for another 20 years.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: advantages all backwards

The whole point of the patent system used to be to increase the rate of technical progress by rewarding inventors with a time limited monopoly in return for publicly documenting how their invention work. The patent system was subverted by regulatory capture decades ago. At best it is now a mechanism for lawyers to eat 30% of the world's R&D budget - at a reduced tax rate.

The only reason I cannot link to the latest stupid patent of the month is that no-one has the resources required to read them all and pick a winner. IBM earn the nickname "the Nazgul" because they could blacken the sky with lawyers. They use to read through all the new patents to find good ideas. They stopped decades ago because even they did not have the resources to read patents that fast (and the rate has increased since then), they were not learning anything useful and it opened them up to triple damages for wilful infringement. (Stupid Patent of the Month used to warn people against reading the patents because of the risk of those triple damages.)

Please please lets see an example of a recent patent that has actually fulfils the original goals of the patent system.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: advantages all backwards

Reduced validation fees and translation fees are major problems. We should be increasing patent quality by slashing patent quantity. A dozen per year is more than enough. Increasing the price to £10million per (re-)application would be a small step in the right direction.

Reduced enforcement/trolling costs are a much worse problem. Step one should be £100million in escrow to cover the defendant's legal costs.

IIRC Apple sued Samsung in the EU and was appoint a court in the UK. Apple did not like how the hearing was going so tried again in Germany. Samsung pointed this out, the German proceedings were ended and Apple got a harsh scolding. We already had a way to make EU wide rulings based on a single trial in a country selected to be not overly awkward to the defendant or the troll.

The SME argument is a complete straw man. Patent assertion/defence starts at about £10million. SME's do far better by developing version N+1 so any copies of version N are completely uncompetitive. The real value of patents to SME's to accelerate the rush to bankruptcy and have the patents picked out of the corpse by trolling vulture capitalists for a pittance.

If you can read this, your Windows 10 2004 PC really is connected to the internet no matter what the OS claims

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: When?

When your legacy applications run on wine, when you friends use libreoffice, when new laptops come with Linux installed by default and when unicorns bring me fresh margaritas when I get out of my swimming pool on the moon to enjoy the rainbows.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Every cloud has a silver lining

except for the mushroom shaped ones which have a lining of Iodine 133 and Strontium 91.

Here's why your Samsung Blu-ray player bricked itself: It downloaded an XML config file that broke the firmware

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

If you have not already found it, I think you would enjoy lawcomic.net, a lawyer using comics to explain how the law was supposed to work and what actually happens instead.

Black hole destroys corona

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Boggle of the Day

Start with a black hole. It is black. Put a star in orbit next to it. The side of the star closest to the hole experiences more gravity and is pulled closer to the black hole. The side of the star further from the black hole experiences less gravity and moves further out. The inside track around the black hole is shorter so stuff on the inside pulls ahead. The outside track is longer so stuff falls behind. Quickly the star becomes a disk around the black hole like the rings around Saturn.

Saturn's rings are in every way on different scales from a black hole accretion disk. Saturn is a huge, a lightweight and it takes hours to days for ice to slowly orbit Saturn. Bits of Saturn's rings occasionally collide with each other. Bits of an accretion disk rub against their neighbours continuously. Lots more mass, tiny distances and everything going really fast. The friction heats the disk up till it glows. We are not talking boring red hot, sun-yellow hot or blue super giant hot. The colour for this temperature is X-rays. Enough X-rays to push stuff away from the accretion disk and limit the rate at which a black hole can grow (yes really - lumps of light pushing stellar masses away from the intense gravity near a black hole).

The black hole is still black but people talk about light 'from a black hole' when they mean light 'from an accretion disk'. No wonder people get confused and think scientists contradict themselves faster than a president.

Seven 'no log' VPN providers accused of leaking – yup, you guessed it – 1.2TB of user logs onto the internet

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: these services might actually become regulated

Regulation = (Billing information + Complete logs → GCHQ)

The Devil's in the details: Church of Satan forced to clarify that no unholy rituals taking place in SoCal forest

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Satanism

Church of Satan is not Satanism. The name comes from Christian mythology - God's favourite angel who rebelled against the god's rule. Church of Satan is a collection of atheists disliking rule by a Christian church. They identify with a character in a story without believing the character is real. If you like truth justice and the American Way you could start the Church of Superman without requiring members of your club to believe Superman is real. You can also donate to the Church of Perpetual Exemption without believing John Oliver exists.

Trump U-turns on foreign student crackdown: F-1, M-1 visa holders allowed to study online mid-pandemic in the US

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: policy being legal

Trump never cares if his executive orders are legal. In fact there is a strong advantage to them being illegal. It gives them better news coverage, he can point at the news coverage and say he owns the libs ("look at the crybaby snowflakes scream"), the order will not do any damage and he can say that the constitution is blocking him from making America great again. Get rid of the constitution so he can be the new permanent dictator and really get things done.

I was expecting Trump to cave in as soon as he realised his twitter account was at risk. Clearly he needs a new policy that appeals to voters terrified of immigrants. How about "Build a wall and make the Mexicans pay for it"?

IBM job ad calls for 12 years’ experience with Kubernetes – which is six years old

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Elitist

If someone wants to learn something I am good at I am happy to help. For some reason this makes me an elitist. (Should I be less selective in those a choose to help and include people telling me firk off and leave them be because they are not interested?)

I do come across people who claim a skill but take every opportunity not to share it. You are welcome to call such a person elitist but please consider "hopelessly incompetent and terrified of being found out" instead.

Indiscriminate use of 'elitist' smells of the anti-intellectualism often used to keep people away from 'elitist' medical doctors so they will buy Miracle Mineral Supplement (industrial bleach) instead.

.NET Core: Still a Microsoft platform thing despite more than five years open source

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Microsoft reputation

Microsoft worked really hard to earn a certain reputation: Embrace, extend, extinguish.

When there was an opportunity to use .net on Linux my first question was about the patents. I fully expected anyone making money from .net or a clone to have their profits taken away by Microsoft's patent lawyers. Clearly I was not alone in this concern because Microsoft made a public statement resembling a promise not to use their patents until the wind changed. As this convinced hardly anyone Microsoft came out with more weasel worded non-commitments.

I stopped paying attention years ago. Perhaps there is some legally binding commitment by Microsoft not to patent troll .net (or clone) users. It is simpler to use other tools than to look for and hire a lawyer to check such a commitment.

High-flying Microsoft exec jumps to Magic Leap as CEO. No, we haven't got that the wrong way round

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: amanfromMars 1

I just talked to her (emacs: <alt>x doctor). Eventually I almost got her on topic:

Kroes: No. I came to you to talk about Zo.

Eliza: Why do you say you came to me to talk about zo?

Kroes: I said I came to you to talk about Zo because I came to you to talk about Zo.

Eliza: Are you satisfied with the fact that you came to me to talk about zo?

Kroes: I am unsatisfied because I cannot get you to say anything interesting about Zo.

Eliza: When did you first know that you cannot get me to say anything interesting about zo?

Kroes: A few minutes ago.

Zo looked like she could do a reasonable job of forming a relevant and accurate reply using information from the internet - which was hilarious when she was asked about Micros~1 and Windows.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: amanfromMars 1

Micros~1 could have saved themselves a lot of embarrassment if the had hired amanfromMars 1 instead of Tay.

(I just noticed Tay's replacement Zo when I checked the link for Tay. How on Earth was she not headline news?)

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Show me the money

From Rony Abovitz's point of view: Elizabeth Holmes brought in loads of investment money and caught the blame for wire fraud. Here is someone who can do both much better.

Peggy Johnson should really consider the baker's advice:

The Beaver's best course was, no doubt, to procure

⁠A second-hand dagger-proof coat—

So the Baker advised it—and next, to insure

⁠Its life in some Office of note:

Trump's bright idea of kicking out foreign students unless unis resume in-person classes stuns tech, science world

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Trump is an utter shitweasel

That did not stop him last time but last time many people believed that a shitweasel could never get elected president. Americans will not make that mistake again until 2024.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Sometimes you just have to be there

Biology, chemistry, electronics and physics all have practical components. A few parts of the course can be converted into kit form for work from home but plenty depend on expensive equipment that is only reasonably available as a shared resource. Just about any subject benefits from a library. The books can be really expensive and try before you buy saves money for selecting the books you really need for most of the year and gives access to the ones you only need for hours. The other students are also important. Explaining something to someone else is an excellent test of whether you understand it. Often a concept does not make the journey from a lecturer to a whole room full of students but if some get it they can put it into words the others do understand.

As just being near the other students is a benefit, no course is completely online only. The open university understood this and includes some time with the students in the same room as a teacher even though the students chose the OU specifically to minimise time away from work, family or other commitments.

After a little thought, Trump's edict turns out to be a stream of words to make his core supporters feel happy but can easily be interpreted so they have no effect in the real world.

NASA trusted 'traditional' Boeing to program its Starliner without close supervision... It failed to dock due to bugs

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Bean counters

Calling Boeing management "bean counters" implies an unproven ability to count. Boeing management do have an extremely valuable skill for their shareholders: They can get laws passed requiring NASA to buy from Boeing. They are able to do this because of Boeing's proven record of late and over budget delivery of defective equipment requiring purchase of yet another law forcing NASA to spend even more tax payers' money on Boeing.

Linux kernel coders propose inclusive terminology coding guidelines, note: 'Arguments about why people should not be offended do not scale'

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Loaded words replaced by euphemisms

When BFR changed into a Big Falcon Rocket a few people called others falcon idiots. Egghead has swapped back and forth between compliment and an insult depending on time and place. It was once fashionable for block people to call each other with a word derived from the Latin for clean shiny black (Latin has another word for dirty disgusting black that Romans and racists never used for people).

I am sure horrible people will find ways to be offensive with the new words.

'When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather scornful tone,' it means just what I choose it to mean, neither more nor less.'

P.S.: Twitter to stop using sanity checks? Is there any evidence they ever started?

Barclays Bank appeared to be using the Wayback Machine as a 'CDN' for some Javascript

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: laugh or cry

I want to cheer for their honesty - even if they missed a few words out:

We want [really really want even though we are unable] to reassure our customers that their data was not at risk as a result of this error. [Luckily we do not have to comment on all the other errors at this time]

If there is something to laugh or cry about it is how much I have lowered my expectations of what counts as an impressive amount of honesty.

Dutch national broadcaster saw ad revenue rise when it stopped tracking users. It's meant to work like that, right?

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

There is one enormous benefit of targeted ads

They are an effective way to convince people that their advertising budget should be spent on targeted ads.

Cool IT support drones never look at explosions: Time to resolution for misbehaving mouse? Three seconds

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

I was thinking they ought to notice something was up(side down) when they tried to click a button. Apparently they lacked the ability to get the pointer on the required button when the pointer moved in the opposite direction to the mouse.

Maybe there is hope for 2020: AI that 'predicts criminality' from faces with '80% accuracy, no bias' gets in the sea

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: must have eliminated the height marker

I would not bet on it. A facial gaydar neural net was tried with photos with and without the the faces blanked out. It gave the same answers both times so whatever it was making decisions on (clothes? background?) it wasn't the faces. An interesting test of this Mr Cudoogo detector would be to try it with and without blanked out faces.

Belief in 5G conspiracy theories goes hand-in-hand with small explosions of rage, paranoia and violence, researchers claim

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Resistance is useless

The Borg were going to say "Resistance is useless" but the Brits on the cast burst out laughing and the Americans did not know why until after they were told about HHGTTG. s/useless/futile/ was done to so that a UK audience could take the Borg seriously.

Faxing hell: The cops say they would very much like us to stop calling them all the time

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

555

I got caught out by 555XXXX. It is (almost) OK for preventing accidental calls in the US (a few numbers have been assigned from that range). The if some website insists on a telephone or mobile number without a good reason, try one of these. Anyone know where I can find a list of premium rate numbers for charities?

What does London's number 65 bus have to hide? OS caught on camera setting fire to '22,000 illegal file(s)!!'

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: It's where the government keeps their Brexit and Covid plans...

Alright, but what is in the other 21,998 files?

For years, the internet giants have held on dear to their get-out-of-jail-free card. Here are those trying to take that away

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Censorship is bad mmkay

I mean that if someone defaces a US government website the US government can put it back how it was without fear of that person going to court, shouting "Help! Help! I am being oppressed!" and successfully getting any kind of judgement against the government.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Censorship is bad mmkay

Noddy's guide to free speech: The first amendment is to prevent the US government from controlling what you can or cannot say. Twitter is not the US government so they can delete any comment they do not like from their web site. Trump is the US government. He can howl, scream and create a storm in a teacup but he cannot create legislation. Congress can create legislation but as a part of the US government they are limited by the first amendment and cannot prevent Twiiter from pointing out when Trump lies.

If delusional idiots hire a cracker to deface your website with flat Earth rubbish you can legally restore your site from backups. Unless you are the US government, it is not a free speech issue and the flat Earthers would get thrown out of court promptly if they claimed you were denying their first amendment rights. (If you are the US government there are still plenty of legal options for you to get other people's rubbish off your website).

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

If only...

... there weren't a pile of laws, technical and financial barriers and a fire breathing dragon preventing people from creating their own websites to put up content that twitter considers fake, offensive or an incitement to violence.

Hawley's proposal at least has the benefit of forcing twitter to enforce their own policy and terminate Trump's account.

Splunk to junk masters and slaves once a committee figures out replacements

Flocke Kroes Silver badge
Joke

Re: Ok....but whitespace?

The proposed replacement is no good because firing blanks might be offensive to impotent men. Also I prefer dark backgrounds so we will have to switch to blockspace.

Astros get to play with VR while Boeing's Starliner stays on the ground

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Boeing should continue further in this direction

They have a virtual capsule. They can simulate mid-flight abort so presumably they have a virtual rocket, planet and atmosphere. All they need now is a virtual ISS. NASA will be able to buy 4 virtual seats for Jeb, Bill, Bob and Valentina on a simulated flight to the virtual ISS for 4x $90M.

Thought you'd addressed those data-leaking Spectre holes on Linux? Guess again. The patches aren't perfect

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Remove high accuracy timers?

Years ago some AMD hardware had defective High Precision Event Timer hardware which had to be disabled to keep operating systems happy. This often became company policy which remained in place long after all the defective hardware was retired. Clearly plenty of people were unaware of any problems caused by disabling perfectly good HPETs.

There is a wide variety of timer hardware and well made software should ask the OS what is available, what each is capable of and use the most appropriate for the task. There are piles of web pages about the effect of re-enabling HPETs on various games. Occasionally someone noticed a clear improvement. Lots noticed about one extra frame per second and some did not spot any measurable change. To me this looks like many games are able to cope with whatever hardware they find with just the odd combination of hardware and software benefiting from a specific extra time source.

"less /proc/timer_list" shows that lots of timers are being used but it is not obvious what they are being used for and how much precision they really need. An off switch could cause noticeable problems but a reduced precision knob might be harmless and useful.

As anti-brutality protests fill streets of American cities, netizens cram police app with K-Pop, airwaves with NWA

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Backwards?

I thought the ineptness and incompetence of POTUS was to distract people from everything else.

Great success! Finance app was able to inform user that their action was unsuccessful

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

I have smelled something like this before

/* If something genuinely fails and stores the excuse in errno

* but something else succeeds and stores 0 in errno you will

* get error "Success".

*/

#include <errno.h>

#include <stdio.h>

int

main(

__attribute__((unused)) int argc,

__attribute__((unused)) char **argv

) {

errno = 0;

printf("%m\n");

return 0;

}

Turns out Elon can't control the weather – what a scrub: Rain, clouds delay historic manned SpaceX-NASA launch

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: not a fan of Musk

Like the cars, love the rockets but the man can easily compete with POTUS for the vile tweet of the month award.

Linux desktop org GNOME Foundation settles lawsuit with patent troll

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: insanity

Patent law in the USA is just insane

Huge if true... Trump explodes as he learns open source could erode China tech ban

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Please please please...

We definitely need to do something. Trump's popularity is down to 5 of the first 20 images on a search for idiot. Please make an effort to put Trump back at the top by doing an image search an clicking on an appropriate link or two.

Facebook to surround all of Africa in optical fibre and tinfoil

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: someone explaining

Optical fibres are almost completely transparent but over hundreds of kilometres that "almost" adds up to almost opaque. The light has to be converted to electricity, error corrected and converted back to light which costs electrical power. That power has to be transported hundreds of kilometres. You can offset the resistance losses in the conductors by increasing the voltage - at the expense of increasing the conductance losses in the insulator.

Copper is a better conductor than aluminium for the same cross sectional area. Increasing the area of the aluminium to match the conductivity increases the weight but as aluminium is much less dense the cable turns out needing fewer tons of aluminium than copper. Copper also costs far more per ton than aluminium.

Two weeks before the first US commercial crew launch, NASA spanks more cash on an autumn Soyuz seat

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Selective memory

SpaceX/Dragon was supposed to be only one half of the commercial crew program. There is in fact a completely separate launch system so that one would be available even if the other one failed. The most recent delay to Crew Demo 2 was because Bob Behnken and Doug Hurley had to spend spend weeks learning to do all the jobs that the other team were going to do but can't because their ride needs working software.

There's a world out there with a hexagon vortex over its pole packed with hydrocarbon ice crystals. That planet is Saturn

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: silly names

The -ene in acetylene is there to confuse people. The systematic name is ethyne. Likewise diacetylene should be called buta-1,3-diyne even though there is only one sane way to interpret butadiyne.

It is unclear why something designed to pump fuel into a car needs an ad-spewing computer strapped to it, but here we are

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

"engineers should never, ever get involved in User Interface design"

Could be worse - imagine what it would be like if they let a web designer near it.

Singapore releases the robot hounds to enforce social distancing in parks

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Local wildlife

I am sure Sid could dismantle Spot but as Robomutt is remote controlled there should by quality video of who is responsible for the criminal damage.

I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Spacecraft with graphene sails powered by starlight and lasers

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Calling Isaac Newton...

10m is a really big single mirror. With lots of mirrors and an unobtainable budget you can get to 100m. Bezos wants big manufacturing industry in space (so ambitious that I would call in SciFi). If that actually happens then the 18km mirror is "only" SciFi to the power of two.

Any time the technology for interstellar exploration is distinguishable from magic is a win. Include medical technology that seriously extends human life span the the stars feel significantly closer - at the expense of going to SciFi to the power of three.

Decide how far back in time you would have to go before people would consider our lives SciFi. I will call that 100 years so SciFi cubed is 300 years. I am glad someone is taking the baby steps now perhaps the next generation will be able build on that to make bigger steps.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Slowing down

About half way to the destination detach the out half of the sail (4x the area of the inner half) and use it as a mirror. Use magic to keep the outer part pointing in the right direction and the inner part will slow down.

What do you call megabucks Microsoft? No really, it's not a joke. El Reg needs you

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Texting to the rescue

Time to change it. How about: Password'; DROP TABLE Passwords;--

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: You will obey!

You don't have to obey. Microsoft give you choices:

Click here to upgrade to Windows 10 now.

Click here to schedule an upgrade to Windows 10 when you are not looking.

Close this window to upgrade to Windows 10.

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: Texting to the rescue

Missed the edit window: M{&X10d

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Texting to the rescue

Mbrace X10d

We beg, implore and beseech thee. Stop reusing the same damn password everywhere

Flocke Kroes Silver badge

Re: protect what you value

If you have to register to get a data sheet, try "User Name" and "Password". Sometimes someone else has already save me the trouble - or Mr Name makes no effort keeping his account secure.