back to article Atari accuses El Reg of professional trolling and making stuff up. Welp, here's the interview tape for you to decide...

Legendary games company Atari has accused a Register reporter of making stuff up and acting unprofessionally following an interview earlier this year in San Francisco at the launch of its new games console, the Atari VCS. In that article, we were critical of the fact that the machine did not work, and that its chief operating …

Page:

      1. Sgt_Oddball
        Windows

        Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

        C64? Lucky bugger....all I had was a VIC-20..

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

          Could have been worse - you might have had a Plus 4.

          1. Zoopy

            Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

            Luxury! We had a Timex Sinclair 1000 and we were glad for it!

            We'd wake up the night before we went to bed, start the tape drive playing into the computer's input port, while da' beat us with BASIC manuals.

            1. GIRZiM

              Re: Luxury!

              A Timex Sinclair 1000!

              The best we could afford was a 1K ZX81 and no cassette recorder; we had to type in all the code from the magazine every time we wanted to run a program, squash all the bugs and add all the missing code the magazine managed not to print.

              But if you tell that to the young people today, they won't believe you!

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Trollface

        Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

        It was pointless us Beeb owners trolling the Spectrum people. They would type a witty response on their prophylactic keys, but forget it every time the RAM pack plugged into the back fell out.

      3. TonyJ

        Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

        "...Bit late to the party you lot were. Us Speccy/Amstrad/Comodore 64 kids were well versed in trolling - I can assure you! (Those rich BBC kids never got involved)..."

        My very first computer was a Christmas present from my mum and dad - it was an Atari (800XL? had a tape recorder as well as a cartridge slot). Alas, there were issues with the tape recorder so he took it back and swapped it for an Acorn Electron. My dad chose it because it was "BBC Compatible" and therefore educational.

        Oh I envied those kids with a Speccy, Commodore or BBC.

        I did manage to save up my pocket money though and buy a BBC B+ a few years later.

        Wasn't ever very good at programming the thing but I knew what every component on the motherboard did.

        You're right though...in the who-has-which-home-computer wars, I was never dragged in once the other kids knew what I had. :)

    1. jake Silver badge

      Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

      Trolling was a thing in the very late 1970s in the BBS world ... Several years before the C64, much less the Amiga.

    2. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

      The Falcon finally got there and could be considered better than the Amiga 1200 (although the Amiga's OS was still 1000 times better than GEM/TOS/Whatever that thing was), but only because Commodore then had the worst CEO in history of everything who sat on follow-up to the Amiga 1200 for years like it was the Iron Throne or something, until he ran the business into the ground.

      However software was scarce for the Falcon, it lasted a year, and Atari imploded too.

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      There had been 3 ATARI companies!

      1) ATARI (the original company) died in the early 1990s.

      2) Then another completely different company Infograms (France) named itself ATARI in early 2000s and died in the early 2010s.

      3) Then another different (chinese) company named itself ATARI in the late 2010s. And releases cheap re-hashes of old ATARI games from the 1980s.

    4. ForthIsNotDead

      Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

      That's very true. Jack Tramiel, as controversial as he was, definitely rescued the company and brought some of the innovation and potential back. However, even under the Tramiels, a lot of the mojo and pure fun-factor that made Atari what it fundamentally was gone.

      After the Tramiels, Atari was nothing but a name. A husk. Nothing of the "true" Atari, originally under Bushnell, and latterly the Tramiels, remains. It's a corpse.

      The name Atari has changed hands a bunch of times since then, it's nothing more than a brand now, a recognisable name to be used as a marketing vehicle, with no one even remotely associated with the Atari of old being involved, none of that Mojo. Just bullshit, hype, vapour, and lies. Consequently, I feel no guilt whatsoever in declaring: "Fuck "Atari" and the fake hype-machine that they rolled in on.".

      The whole company can do one as far as I'm concerned. Even if they do release a working machine, I'm not interested.

    5. adam payne

      Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

      Oh the Atari ST Vs Amiga flame wars how I remember them fondly.

      We all know which one was better, it's the one you have the fondest memories of.

      Anyway back on topic, looks like Atari got schooled.

      1. Hairy Spod

        Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

        So its definately the Amiga that's better then.

        I'm glad that's settled

    6. Alan Bourke

      Re: Oh how the might have fallen...

      "Atari STE was a giant among machines - probably the best all-round home computer platform across all arenas on the market at the time"

      Aha. Ahem. Yeah.

  1. wolfetone Silver badge
    Pint

    Distribute this pint to those involved, bravo!

    1. Prst. V.Jeltz Silver badge
      Pint

      dont be stingy :p

      have another!

  2. Hans 1
    Facepalm

    Poor Mike

    Mike does not appear to be a seasoned vaporware or snake oil purveyor, just a marketing guy turned exec ? He has absolutely no clue about what he is selling, no clue about what he is talking about and of course, bringing a piece of plastic to a press conf is, well, not helping him.

    What did he expect ?

    How hard can it be to put a pi with retropie in the plastic, have an intern design a new ui (so journos don't notice it is in fact retropie) - job done.

    1. deadlockvictim

      Re: Poor Mike

      Hans 1» Mike does not appear to be a seasoned vaporware or snake oil purveyor, just a marketing guy turned exec

      Is there a difference? I thought that's what marketing does: purvey snake-oil.

      1. Hans 1
        Coat

        Re: Poor Mike

        Is there a difference?

        Yes, marketing guyz dream up press releases and do PR, they basically come up with nice stories for sales guyz to tell. They are safe in the office, hardly ever see questions that need immediate responses, they need time to think of a way to squeeze as many buzzwords into a sentence as possible.

        Sales guyz are usually the snake oil purveyors, with whom you can expect a minimum of product knowledge, they know what to say and know how to make something up when they are caught off guard.

        Noting that with that piece of plastic, I could get it up and running a customized retropie in less than 40 minutes ... most time spent fitting extension cables for network, usb, hdmi, and power as well as fitting the pie firmly in the casing so it looks "professional".

        Do also note that VCSAtari are on twatter but have not worked out how to tweet, yet ;-).

        Icon: For poor Mike, with love and compassion!

        1. Pascal Monett Silver badge
          Thumb Down

          Re: with love and compassion

          Nope.

          I have no compassion for a marketing guy who invites a technical journal to an interview without bringing any functional items, instead bringing mock-ups, not being able to answer technical questions and then pretending to be hurt when the ensuing article is not written like a Vogue-magazine fanpiece.

          Flaming idiot. And now he's Streisanded himself.

          No sympathy.

          1. Aladdin Sane

            Re: with love and compassion

            Does make you think they're unfamiliar with El Reg's output.

          2. Hans 1
            Coffee/keyboard

            Re: with love and compassion

            I have no compassion

            Check that icon, I think your sarcasm parser segfaulted ...

        2. Rob D.
          Facepalm

          Re: Poor Mike

          Yes, the sympathy gene was resonating a teensy bit with Mike there - not too much though. Listening to the audio you can hear the resignation in his voice and I could just picture the pre-meeting with Mike's management:

          Mike: I've nothing to show. It's just bits of plastic and cables.

          Management: Go on, Mike, we have every faith that you can spin this and make it look like gold.

          Mike: But really I'm just the project lead. You've given me a fancy title and responsibility for the budget but I have no power and nothing to offer. We really should call it off.

          Management: Look, Mike, it's like this. Either you go and sell this turd as if it's solid gold so we can get some more funding to polish the turd properly, or we fire you, you lose your health benefits and that nice house you live in.

          Mike. Fine. Can I swing by the marketing office and take some Atari baseball caps with me - at least they work?

          1. defiler

            Re: Poor Mike

            ...we have every faith that you can...

            Got it in one. It's surprising how many people have every faith in my ability to achieve the ludicrous. I do feel for Mike.

    2. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: Poor Mike

      If you want to fake Tempest 4000, you need squeeze a NUC into that pretty box.

      1. Steve the Cynic

        Re: Poor Mike

        Pfft. You can't do Tempest right on a raster display anyway.

        Both I and the late Mrs Cynic liked the original vector-CRT arcade Tempest machines a lot, although I think she might have been better at it than me.

  3. redpawn

    You Just Need to Have Faith

    It is only our faith in money that makes money work and so it is with Atari. Have you ever considered that the machine you are using now only works because you have faith in it? ... me neither.

    1. Pen-y-gors

      Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

      Oh no, no. Faith is so essential and powerful. The sun only rises every morning because I believe it will. My laptop only boots because I have faith that it will. Those BSODs are a sign of a lack of faith - I am a worthless sinner. The daily sacrifice of a virgin also helps (getting harder to find these days)

      And for a wonderful example of the power of Faith, <insert Brexit reference here>

      1. jonathan keith

        Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

        Nonsense: everybody knows that it's the magic smoke that makes electronics work.

        1. jelabarre59

          Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

          Nonsense: everybody knows that it's the magic smoke that makes electronics work.

          It certainly is for Lucas Electrics. Hence the need for this.

          1. jake Silver badge
            Pint

            Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

            Invoking the name of the Prince of Darkness sends chills up the spine, even here in California ... Still, on the bright side, if it weren't for Lucas refrigerators you lot would never have discovered the proper temperature to keep beer! :-)

            1. Aladdin Sane
              Coat

              Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

              Are you implying that the weak piss water they sell on the wrong side of the pond is beer?

              Mine's the one with the bottle of Doom Bar in the pocket.

              1. jake Silver badge

                Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

                You mean Carling or Fosters or Harp? No, absolutely not!

              2. Alistair
                Windows

                Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

                careful there Aladdin, some of us have hands on the good stuff. Mind you, we're north of the 49th.

          2. RuffianXion

            Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

            Jesus Christ, that webpage made my eyes bleed.

      2. IsJustabloke
        Trollface

        Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

        "The daily sacrifice of a virgin also helps (getting harder to find these days)"

        Is wales running out of sheep then?

        1. DiViDeD

          Re: You Just Need to Have Faith

          "Is wales running out of sheep then?"

          No, it's just running out of the sort of pure, unsullied sheep you can take home to meet your mother.

          Or sacrifice to the technology gods.

    2. FrankAlphaXII

      Re: You Just Need to Have Faith No More

      See title.

      FTFY.

      And honestly, the lyrics to "Falling to Pieces" seem to suit the situation here pretty well.

  4. Lee D Silver badge

    Rule #1:

    Always keep a record.

    Your boss wants you to do something stupid? Keep a record. Get their name on it. Make a fuss if they won't do it. Keep records even if they won't sign off. Who said what, when, how, and where? Get to the point where they just scribble a sign-off or fire off the email which says "Yes, dammit, I said do it!".

    You're getting complaints? Keep a record. Record what the complaint was. What the stats and systems said about the claims in that complaint. Keep the email logs. Keep recordings. Keep all available context.

    You're making a complaint? Keep a record. Record everything. Their response. Check if they have fixed it regularly.

    Certainly if you are reporting publicly and therefore likely to run into situations like this.

    1. paulf
      Thumb Up

      Isn't CYA* a good life lesson at all times anyway? Quietly apply it to your every day life; you never know when you may need it, but when you do you'll be glad you have it. Many a time it has got me out of a sticky situation and adversaries really hate it when you hit back with facts and evidence!

      *Cover Your Arse for the uninitiated

    2. Primus Secundus Tertius

      Record keeping gone mad! There is an ancient ditty:

      ---

      No-one on this Earth was meant

      To remember or invent

      What they did wth every cent.

      ---

      1. Lee D Silver badge

        In the modern age, it's really easy.

        Make sure all your stuff is electronic.

        Then just keep all your emails.

        I signed my last lease agreement, my mortgage, my divorce, etc. all electronically. Employment contracts - If they aren't already electronic, I scan them in and email to myself.

        My email account goes back to about 2000. I have the email accounts before that in a file somewhere (it's only about 1Gb). In work, I have policies that basically all result in "if you want this, file a ticket, fill out a form, put it in an email" and then helpdesk tracking of everything and EVERY EMAIL ever sent or received from my account since I started there.

        It's really not that hard, in the modern era.

      2. ArrZarr Silver badge

        Ancient? That ditty sounds American so I can only presume that this was coined in the Left-Pondian prehistory. 1920s maybe?

        1. DropBear

          There seem to be more caveats to this than trees in the forest, honestly. Yes, record keeping can be invaluable protection in certain situations, but... not if you ever wavered or caved to the pressure from above to do something you shouldn't have agreed to do. Not if you were ever in the situation of not being able to afford to test how far you can stretch your rope before it snaps. Not if you ever made a mistake in the "how to get other people do what I want" game which is definitely manglement's home turf, and very likely not yours. Not if "they" were savvy enough to invent a plausible excuse to keep communication out of the sphere that would allow you any meaningful record keeping beyond "I assert that this is what he told me but I have zero proof".

          And while you're at it, you better have the unerring judgement of a God each and every single time even under the fuzzy conditions of real life, because if you vigorously object to something that turns out to not be a problem they'll burn you to ashes, and if you fail to object to something that does end up being a problem you'll burn again. Record keeping: good advice? Sure, but also incredibly overrated...

          1. hplasm
            Devil

            However...

            " Record keeping: good advice? Sure, but also incredibly overrated..."

            BOSSOID: "...why didn't YOU DO THIS????!!!!"

            YOU: "Er, when did you ask me to? Do you have the email...?"

            CYA: Unlocked.

    3. Tim99 Silver badge
      Devil

      Manglement

      Rule #1: I went on a public service senior managers course about 30 years ago. One of the lecturers told us a valuable saw: The main purpose of most documents generated in an organization is to act as a weapon - The weapon can be defensive or offensive, and often can be both...

      1. Prst. V.Jeltz Silver badge
        Alien

        Re: records

        Its this sort of obsessive record keeping that prompted my grandparents to leave vogspere and emigrate en masse to the Brantisvogon star cluster, where they formed most of the Galactic bureaucracy.

  5. Wellyboot Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Management style

    Excellent – a quality rebuttal.

    Their statement say a lot about the mindset of upper management running Atari if they think modern journalists don't keep everything that might one day be required to defend a defamation case and that casual libel is ok.

    As this blog has been made available in the UK you can probably take Atari to the cleaners in court here (settle for a grovelling live apology at the next big CES).

    Finally the trump like 'sad' at the end, please no!

  6. Bavaria Blu
    Happy

    Atari - what is that?

    I think most people think Atari is the character in Isle of Dogs. I wouldn't let it get to you. Relax!

    1. ArrZarr Silver badge
      Coat

      Re: Atari - what is that?

      No, silly - Atari is the situation when your group has only one liberty remaining.

    2. Flocke Kroes Silver badge

      Re: Atari - what is that?

      Getting hit on the head by a falling star? Oops, no that is Ataru.

      お住所とお電話番号を教えて下さい.

Page:

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon