back to article Intel CEO Krzanich quits Trump's Manufacturing Council over response to Charlottesville rallies

Three big-name CEOs have put some space between themselves and the US President: today they resigned from the American Manufacturing Council, President Donald Trump's panel of advisors formed to create more manufacturing jobs in the United States by bringing together titans of industry to share their experience. On Monday …

Page:

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    all it needs now

    is for Tim Cook and Elon Musk to follow suit and perhaps a few more people on Capital Hill might just possibly (or maybe) start to realise that Trump has to go. He is (IMHO) fast becoming a huge liabilty to the USA. He does not seem to know when the best move is to shut the hell up.

    He's supposed to be such a great deal maker. Well the best deal makers are those who like poker players keep their cool, cards close to their chest and play the bluff.

    This man is a bully and is therefore dangerous to each and everyone of us.

    1. Sorry that handle is already taken. Silver badge

      Re: all it needs now

      Musk already left after Trump withdrew the US from the Paris Agreement. I don't know about Cook though.

      And the only person who claims or believes that Donald Trump is a good deal maker is Donald Trump...

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: all it needs now

        Cook hasn't ever been a part of any of Trump's "councils" so he doesn't have anything to resign from.

        Though he could troll Trump by joining, which would probably earn a positive tweet from Trump to counter the negative press these three resignations (with more to follow tomorrow, you can be sure) only to resign the next day.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: all it needs now

        "And the only person who claims or believes that Donald Trump is a good deal maker is realDonaldTrump..."

        ftf... wait, they are the same person?

        1. Sir Runcible Spoon

          Re: all it needs now

          Is it just me, or does quitting for political reasons not tally up with the statement 'I don't want to get involved in politics'.

          Also, from what I heard, Trump condemned both sides from the outset. Yet here we see statements to the effect 'America is built on diversity of opinion' etc. in the same sentence as 'you must condemn these people more than anyone else' - even though both sides were guilty of violence.

          Sounds like more political statements to me.

          For those lacking in nuanced reading skills, please note that I have neither condemned nor condoned anyone in the story (whether that is Trump or the people who quit their roles) - I have merely made observations and raised a question or two.

          1. Lord Elpuss Silver badge

            Re: all it needs now

            "even though both sides were guilty of violence."

            'Nuanced reading skills' my arse. It was a 'Unite the Right' white supremacist protest. If an armed mugger threatens me in the street and I 'protest' his action by kicking him in the balls, that doesn't mean 'both sides were guilty of violence', it makes it one violent act met by a measured resistance.

            1. Sir Runcible Spoon
              Unhappy

              Re: all it needs now

              " it makes it one violent act met by a measured resistance."

              ..and this leads us all to a better understanding of one another how? People generally get together and protest because their voices are not being heard (whether or not their message is palatable or not).

              Do we learn nothing as a species? No-one has to agree with extremist views, in fact I think ignoring someone who thinks they have a superiority complex is probably the best answer. Oppressing people for non-conformist views merely validates their position (see recent Google memo for another example).

              What a bunch of reactionary shit-kickers who deserve what's coming to them we have all become :(

              This doesn't make me angry, it makes me sad. Very sad.

              1. Palpy

                Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                But violent racism must be met with committed strength, not flowers. We understand quite a lot about fascist and race-supremacy movements, and one of the things we should by now understand is that resistance -- in the strongest possible terms -- is utterly necessary early on.

                The West watched Germany in the 1930s. After the brownshirts march, then comes Kristalnacht. Then the "race cleansing" and war. (And yes, when speaking about the Nazis in the US, Godwin's Law is formally and officially suspended -- by Godwin himself.)

                Right now in America the brownshirts are badly outnumbered. But they are emboldened by Trump and his white supremacist whacko, Bannon. With phantom support from the President of the United States, it is absolutely urgent that the rest of America shout the racists down. Knock them down. Kick them while they are down. And make sure they and their racist delusions never crawl up out of the gutter.

                There is no solving the problem of hatred permanently, I think. The multiple bell curves of human variability guarantee that there will be some hate-obsessed people among us. Some will find each other; some will be loners forever. Yes, we should understand that they are emotionally disabled. More to be pitied than censured -- as individuals. As a social movement, as a growing force working against social harmony and justice, they must be opposed. With absolute determination.

                1. ecofeco Silver badge

                  Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                  With absolute determination.

                  With absolute force.

                  While a not huge problem in Europe, the police in America are heavily infiltrated by white supremacists and closet Nazis who are openly killing unarmed people in the street.

                  The time for nicey nicey is over. Past due in fact.

                  1. Anonymous Coward
                    Anonymous Coward

                    Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                    ...the police in America are heavily infiltrated by white supremacists and closet Nazis who are openly killing unarmed people in the street.

                    Did they tell you that at one of your little secret meetings in your mate's tree-house?

                    1. ecofeco Silver badge

                      Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                      Google it.

                      Many reputable sources.

                      I live in the treehouse in your mind. Thanks for playing.

                    2. Richocet

                      Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                      It's there plainly in Rage Against the Machine's lyrics.

                      1. Anonymous Coward
                        Anonymous Coward

                        Better understanding of and from NAZIS?

                        The nazis and other white supremacist scum did not travel to Charlotte to help anyone "understand" anything other than their hate, and had no intention of listening politely while those who disagreed expressed their views. They are beyond help, and Trump and his apologists claiming equivalence with the anti-facist protestors who met them because some of them were smart enough to show up prepared for the fight they knew the nazis would bring no matter what is disgusting.

                        I am happy to report that several of my friends who were Trump supporters from the beginning back when everyone thought Jeb Bush would be the nominee were so horrified by his statements yesterday that they disavowed him on Facebook last night. Unless what my friends did was an isolated incident, this is going to show up when polling for his approval rating takes this into account next week. I wouldn't be surprised to see him under 30%, and if he continues to stick his foot in his mouth like yesterday (which I hope he does, so no one can claim ignorance of who he really is) he'll drive that under 20% before long.

                        Not many republicans subscribe to his racist views, so the more he makes it clear what a sick man he is, the more he'll drive everyone away except the white supremacists. Any republicans who support him because he's "their president"....well, if he's removed from office via impeachment or the 25th amendment, Pence will then be "their president" and he won't say things that bring shame to the republican brand.

                  2. GotThumbs
                    Boffin

                    Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                    "the police in America are heavily infiltrated by white supremacists and closet Nazis who are openly killing unarmed people in the street."

                    You are FREE to come rome the streets to see for yourself.

                    Keep in Mind, Chicago has more people shooting and killing each other....not police shooting them.

                    Look at the % of people shot by police and take an honest look at the circumstances.

                    The only case I feel is messed up was the officer who shot the australian woman from the passenger seat of the patrol car...that is messed up and there was zero threat from her. His partner would think twice (I bet) about riding with the guy again....only then he'd be called a racist.

                    The fact is...the public does NOT know everything that goes on in and around their area....only what the news chooses to tell them.

                    1. ecofeco Silver badge

                      Re: Better understanding, sir RS, is all very well.

                      Nice sheltered life you got the GotThumbs. Get out much?

            2. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: all it needs now

              ...it makes it one violent act met by a measured resistance

              Except that is nothing like what happened is it? I know facts and nuance fall by the wayside once lefties get going, but the facts do remain:

              1. The Unite The Right people were protesting the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee, which has been in place for over 100 years.

              2. They had obtained all the permits required for their protest.

              3. The violence was initiated by Antifa and BLM counter-protesters - who had no permits to protest and came tooled-up for the violence.

              Interestingly, the police made very little effort to keep protest groups separate - almost as though the leftie govenor of the state wanted it that way, so he could decry all the 'right-wing violence'. Unfortunately, that politcally motivated ploy allowed the violence to get so out of hand that people died.

              Trump decried the violence on both sides at the outset as there was plenty of blame to go round. However, that wasn't what our mainstream media, who have their own left wing agenda, were interested in. Hence the pressure to only blame one side. Have you even seen mention of Antifa or BLM? The coverage I have seen would lead you to think the only people there were Nazis.

              I have no sympathy for the Nazis there, but I am wary of the complete airbrushing of both Antifa and BLM - both of whom are quite happy to use violence and property distruction to get their way. Left wing extremists should be held equally accountable for their violence.

              If you are interested at all in truth, I suggest you watch raw footage on YouTube. There is plenty of it. You may well come to different conclusions than those the media want you to draw.

              1. ecofeco Silver badge

                Re: all it needs now

                You equate Nazis and left wing actions as equal?

                GTFO.

                1. Anonymous Coward
                  Anonymous Coward

                  Re: all it needs now

                  You equate Nazis and left wing actions as equal?

                  GTFO.

                  Tell that to the hundreds of millions murdered by the communists.

              2. Anonymous Coward
                Anonymous Coward

                Re: all it needs now

                Wasn't it something like 2:1 first responders and police to protestors yet it took seven minutes to get anyone close to the car attack?

                The police were stood down so that it could kick off, it kicked off, now MSM are running the narrative.

                I know this site is biased but I had hoped from greater scrutiny and even interest from those who comment, it's too easy know what we should think from peers rather than taking the time to gather all the information available.

                I often wonder how things went the way they did at the start of world war two. I do now know, it is hard work questioning what we are told, the answer may not be black or white and we may need to leave the warm comfort of the crowd.

                1. Sir Runcible Spoon

                  Re: all it needs now

                  The reason the National Socialists were listened to in Germany was because the German people felt repressed by the subsequent policies imposed after WWI and Hitler made all sorts of promises to stir their national pride etc. Many people were fooled and we know what happened next.

                  That environment doesn't really exist right now in America, so these idiots are only ever going to convince people who already think like they do - it will never gain momentum.

                  However, by reducing the arguments and responding with violence the ultra-left wing (who do appear to be just as abhorrent as the ultra-right wing in their actions) are raising their profile and will end up forcing more people to identify with them - not because they are racist, but because they are *white*. Once you start going down that road they will end up with more social acceptance and then the threat becomes very real.

                  Since there are people in positions of power who fully understand how this all works, you then really need to question why the far-left is behaving the way they are and if they are being used (under the guise of doing the right thing).

                  No amount of down-votes on here is going to stop me questioning *everything*, even if people choose to take it as some kind of approval of a group they don't like (or disapproval of a group they do like).

                  Human nature is human nature, I totally expect it these days. Can't say I'm impressed though.

                  1. uncle sjohie

                    Re: all it needs now

                    One of the reasons of the strong feeling of oppression, was the fact that the French took over the coalmines, including the Germans working in them, made them mine the coal, took all of it, and sold it to pay of the war-debt the treaty of Versailles imposed on the losing Germans. This meant that families were freezing to death, while the coal they dug up, was sold for no other reason then to make money for the French. Hindsight has taught us in the EU, that it wasn't such a great idea. since it created an atmosfere wherein the National Socialism of the Nazi's could rapidly prosper.

                    I won't go sofar as to say part deux of the great European civil war wouldn't have happened, but cutting the Germans some slack, would have gone a long way of keeping the Nazi's the fringe group they were in the beginning.

              3. scarletherring

                Re: all it needs now

                > Antifa

                Where did this term come from all of a sudden? Could it be the right-wing media decided that "anti-fascist" sounds too much like they might be the good guys? Obviously they want us to consider them the baddies, but I see how that'd require some sleight of hand, since the other side are, you know, actual fucking nazis.

                > BLM

                Another meme I've found interesting, equating BLM with the white supremacists. You'll notice that they are not proposing to make the US a black-only nation or even to take away civil rights for all but the black. It's not a black-supremacy organization and so the equivalence, as they say, is false.

                Knock it off, will you? The sheets are showing.

                1. Anonymous Coward
                  Anonymous Coward

                  Re: all it needs now

                  Nice try kommissar.

                  You know full well that 'Antifa' is what they call themselves. You also know full well that intimidating and beating up people who don't show sufficient hard-left-wing idealogical purity (or are simply on their way to/from work) is THE standard for their 'peaceful' protest tactics. Peaceful protestors don't turn up all dressed in black with facemasks and weapons.

                  As for BLM, you know their leaders are more into the idea that white people are genetic defects that should be wiped out (to quote Yusra Khogali). That'll probably be why they ban white people from their meetings. They are certainly responsible for the murders of police in New York, as they incite that at every rally.

                  These are both hate groups. But I guess they are in step with your kind of hate.

              4. hammarbtyp

                Re: all it needs now

                1. The Unite The Right people were protesting the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee, which has been in place for over 100 years.

                Right, anytime in the past 100 years any person of any colour could just roll up and protest about the statue and what it represented. Unite the right were not protesting they were acting as agent provocateurs so that they could could represent themselves as the victim

                2. They had obtained all the permits required for their protest.

                Did the permit request say they were going to bring Nazi flags and armed militia?

                3. The violence was initiated by Antifa and BLM counter-protesters - who had no permits to protest and came tooled-up for the violence.

                There is no way you can say that. This follows the usual far right play book. Turn up to an area in the maximum provocative manner, encourage counter protest and then act like the aggrieved party. It is direct from the kristallnacht where any resistance to these assholes is used as an excuse for more extreme violence.

                Note only one side had a armed militia and only one side had deaths and serious injuries. What makes it worse is the leader of the 'free' world playing along with the playbook.

                Interestingly, the police made very little effort to keep protest groups separate - almost as though the leftie govenor of the state wanted it that way, so he could decry all the 'right-wing violence'. Unfortunately, that politcally motivated ploy allowed the violence to get so out of hand that people died.

                Another direct excerpt from the far right play book. Police stand back, its a left conspiracy . Police go in, it is a conspiracy to deny us our freedom of speech. The police were in a no win situation as soon as they turned up. Fox news will make sure of that

                Trump decried the violence on both sides at the outset as there was plenty of blame to go round. However, that wasn't what our mainstream media, who have their own left wing agenda, were interested in. Hence the pressure to only blame one side. Have you even seen mention of Antifa or BLM? The coverage I have seen would lead you to think the only people there were Nazis.

                People turned up with swastikas, for christ sake and paraded around shouting seig heil and you seem surprised the other people were upset?

                The violence was purely orchestrated by provocation from one side. They had every right to protest the removal of a statue, but the manner chosen was specifically to ensure maximum provocation. The fact was they wanted violence because it played into their world view as a down trodden minority. Trump showed what side he was on. Just imagine what his reaction would of been if it had been a Muslim driving a car into alt-right protester rally. Would he be saying, oh well there was violence on both side? Of course bloody not

                I have no sympathy for the Nazis there,

                then stop making excuses for them

                but I am wary of the complete airbrushing of both Antifa and BLM - both of whom are quite happy to use violence and property distruction to get their way. Left wing extremists should be held equally accountable for their violence.

                Let me repeat. One side drove a car through a bunch of other people killing a paralegal who was peacefully protesting a group of right wing thugs dressed in Swastikas and you feel responsibility is equally held? I guess you would be one of those in 1930's saying "I don't agree with Hitler, but those Jews had it coming"

                If you are interested at all in truth, I suggest you watch raw footage on YouTube. There is plenty of it. You may well come to different conclusions than those the media want you to draw.

                and how do you know what is raw and which is doctored? How do you put the footage in context without knowing who took it? Funny thing about truth, is that everyone thinks its absolute, but is in fact relative

            3. GotThumbs
              Boffin

              Re: all it needs now

              Who was armed at the protests....both sides.

              You simply need to look at some of the video to see for example...a black man using a spray can as a flame thrower.

              In America, we all have the freedom of speech and freedom of assembly. Regardless of whether we agree with the message or not....Americans have to RESPECT others right to free speech...we don't have to agree or listen to it.

              If no one showed up but the organizers...it's would have been a non-event.

              Think about this....if only one person shows up to play tennis....there is no opponent to volley back and thus there game is quickly deflated and uneventful.

              Nothing wrong with counter protesters protesting elsewhere...where there is zero chance of an altercation....but they antifa groups chose face to face confrontation...and got what they wanted. An excuse to feed the mob mentality and trash property.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      He is (IMHO) fast becoming a huge liabilty to the USA

      Becoming? Becoming? Becoming?!

      The words truly fail me.

    3. Lord Elpuss Silver badge

      Re: all it needs now

      Elon Musk left the council back in June. Tim Cook has never been in it.

    4. nijam Silver badge

      Re: all it needs now

      > ... fast becoming a huge liability to the USA

      Becoming? Always has been, I think you'll find.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Is it cool to bring Popcorn to a.....

    .....slow motion train wreck.

    Asking for a friend.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Cracks open beer...

      Nope.

    2. ecofeco Silver badge

      Re: Is it cool to bring Popcorn to a.....

      What's with you two?

      (cracks open beer AND popcorn)

  3. Florida1920

    Response time

    "Disloyal" member of his Manufacturing Council? Instant tweet

    Neo-Nazis march within shouting distance of the White House? Ho-hum

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Response time

      It seems there is nothing worse than disloyalty or failing to praise Trump. Nothing. Putin knows this and is hardly criticised at all. Kim thumbs his nose at Trump's piss & wind bluster and is threatened with nuclear annihilation. It's like being in a playground.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Response time

        Too bad Trump didn't have psychologists investigating his relationship with his father when he was younger. There could be a whole library of books based on how screwed up he is with his never satiated need for love and approval, and emotional development that stopped at the age of six. Fred Trump must have been a real piece of work.

        1. Drew 11

          Re: Response time

          Wel, if you equate being a KKK member to being a "real piece of work", then yes, Fred Trump was a real piece of work.

          He probably disowned Donald for being Orange.

        2. ecofeco Silver badge

          Re: Response time

          Fred Trump was an outright gangster. That is no exaggeration. He was a career criminal.

        3. Hollerithevo

          Re: Response time

          Fred Trump was a racists and fined by the Govt for excluding Black people from housing he had taken Govt money for building.

          Donald Trump has as advisors two anti-Semitic white-supremacists.

          Do we really have to pretend any more?

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Response time

            ....two anti-Semitic white-supremacists

            Funny how lefties keep calling them this, yet I have yet to see them produce any proof. How about some transcripts or some articles of their anti-semitic white-supremiscist ramblings? No?

            So they are anti-semetic and white-supremiscist simply because Al Grauniad says so?

            1. Florida1920

              Re: Response time

              Funny how lefties keep calling them this, yet I have yet to see them produce any proof.

              Silence is complicity. If Trump can't denounce Nazis -- FFS, NAZIs! -- without prodding, WTF more proof do you need?

              Also:

              State Department's Anti-Semitism Office Will Soon Have No Staff

              White House stays silent on anti-Semitic connection of Trump's anti-CNN video

              Why Trump Can't Answer Questions About Anti-Semitism

              Trump Should Fire Steve Bannon, But He’s Too Weak And Afraid (Red State)

              Trump’s Early Morning Retweet Shows He Just Doesn’t Get It (Red State)

              If you can tear yourself away from the fawning FNC for a minute, you can find many more examples.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: like being in a playground.

        When I was last in a playground, the bullies and their close mates didn't have control over the most expensive armed forces in the world, and weren't publically asking what was the point of having nukular weapons if they couldn't use them.

      3. Warm Braw

        Re: Response time

        failing to praise Trump

        It seems his staff are only inflating the bubble.

        1. allthecoolshortnamesweretaken

          Re: It seems his staff are only inflating the bubble.

          Just like what you'd expect from your garden variety banana republic dictator.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    You elected the clown...

    ... now the consequences are on you!

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: You elected the clown...

      ... now the consequences are on you!

      Unfortunately, the consequences are on all of us, whether we are American or not.

      And it will get worse before it starts to recover.

      1. allthecoolshortnamesweretaken

        Re: And it will get worse before it starts to recover.

        Isn't that what LBJ said about the war in Vietnam?

  5. Bloodbeastterror

    Three Presnitedstates (sic)

    I commented a couple of years ago that in 2001 the citizens of the US had elected a talking monkey. A few weeks ago I saw him in an anterview and he was fluent, thoughtful and reasonable, appearing to be the statesman that he might have been during his presidency.

    Obama? Elegant, intelligent, considered. Everything that a decent president could be, hamstrung by hostile and racist Republicans.

    And now this. When you elected a shallow flimflam huckster, what exactly did you expect? Not nuclear war wth Northe Korea, I'm sure, although no doubt that would go down well with the redneck religious nutcases looking forward to Revelation.

    As commented earier, words (almost) fail me at the hastening decline of the USA as a civilisation.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Three Presnitedstates (sic)

      Have an upvote for this

      When you elected a shallow flimflam huckster,

      What an apt description.

      Oh well, hello no fly list.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Three Presnitedstates (sic)

      Obama?

      You mean the most corrupt president to ever sit in the Oval office? Let's consider:

      1. Fast and Furious, 2. Benghazi, 3. IRS targeting of non-leftwing groups, 4. Iran nuclear deal (+ cash for hostages), 5. DOJ spying on AP reporters, 6. Five Taliban commanders for one deserter (Bergdahl), 7. Suing Arizona for enforcing federal immigration law, 8. Illegal war against Libya, 9. NSA spying on Americans, 10. Solyndra 11. Miriam Carey death, 12. Complete knowledge of Hillary's illegal email servers, 13. Cap & Trade bypass of congress, 14. Fake VA waiting lists, 15. GSA spending spree, 16. DOJ and New Black Panther Party, 17.EPA poisoning of Colorado river, 18. ObamaCare state Co-op failures, 19. Pigford, 20. Sebelius violation of Hatch Act

      I can go on, including the illegal unmasking of Trump officials from foreign surveillance transcripts, but I think you get the drift.

      What you are actually seeing then, is a return from the depths of civilizational decline to which Obama had taken the US.

      1. Bloodbeastterror

        Re: Three Presnitedstates (sic)

        "the most corrupt president"

        Ah ha ha ha... So America has woken up. At last...

        Far too late, my friend, far too late. With the election of The Orange Buffoon the U.S. has tripled the speed of its downward spiral from international leadership, and has become a global joke, a laughing stock. Idiocracy (the film) has proven its foresighted accuracy.

        1. GotThumbs
          Boffin

          Re: Three Presnitedstates (sic)

          How about some facts to support the words your quoting?

          What acts of corruption has President Trump committed?

          Or are you simply helping to spread false information?

Page:

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like