back to article Cinema boss gives up making kids turn off phones: 'That's not how they live their life'

The CEO of AMC Theaters says his company will consider allowing people to text during movies. In an interview with showbiz mag Variety, Adam Aron said that it wasn't tablets and streaming video services that were keeping millennials out of movie theaters (or for our younger readers, "the place where your parents go to watch …

Page:

  1. ckdizz

    Yeah, that's exactly the kind of thing that will get people back into the cinema. 150 tiny glowing lights across the cinema with socially inept cretins jabbing at them with a fat finger. I can't see how that would be an annoying distraction from the movie you just paid $15 to see.

    1. Stevie

      The Shining (4 Chkdizz)

      That is the major factor currently keeping me out of the cinema. At close to twenty bux a pop now, having the little oblong searchlights shining back at me is intolerable.

      Actually, it would be intolerable at any price.

      So I rarely go to a movie and never in the opening week. I wait until the fucktards are bored with whatever it is, and then go if I can be arsed.

      1. DiViDeD

        Re: The Shining (4 Chkdizz)

        $20 a pop for a movie is bad enough. Try remaining tolerant when you've paid north of $300 for an opera or ballet performance and the hall is peppered with little white spotlights as people take selfies of 'Hey mum, I'm in the Opera House!' variety, text their mates to say 'Hey, guess where I am?' and make pointless attempts to record the performance on video.

        Hell, I've even seen someone playing Angry Birds during Madam Butterfly!

        And theatre goers don't even have the option of torrenting!

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      So have a cell phone section

      It won't bother me, and it will be better than the current situation where there is almost always a few screens lighting up here and there in front of me during a movie and distracting my eye. If it is all taking place out of my field of view I'm fine with it.

      Bonus points for theaters with a balcony - make that the cell phone section and it would be impossible to see from the regular seats even if you try.

      At least it won't be like the smoking section on planes I remember from when I was a little kid, where everyone is breathing the poisoned air no matter how far away they were or where they looked.

      1. DiViDeD

        @ DougS Re: So have a cell phone section

        "At least it won't be like the smoking section on planes I remember from when I was a little kid, where everyone is breathing the poisoned air "

        Do you really believe air quality has got BETTER since they removed the smoking sections? DVT was almost unheard of back then, and this was in main due to the fact that the cabin air was refreshed at least 10 times as often as it is now. Reduced oxygen, greatly increased CO2 and the increased chance of pathogens both remaining in the cabin air and being given an undisturbed collection of aircon vents in which to breed.

        But at least it doesn't smell of smoke anymore.

        1. Sinick

          Re: @ DougS So have a cell phone section

          You're drawing a mighty long bow there, William Tell, er, DiViDeD

          Of course "DVT was almost unheard of back then." That doesn't mean the incidence is necessarily any higher now. They'd only just started to officially recognise some of the many medical risks of smoking by the time the ban came in. In the decades since smoking was banned on flights, awareness of the medical consequences of long periods of inactivity has also increased.

          And even IF the base number of cases of DVT has gone up since then, that doesn't mean the proportion of cases has risen. The sheer number of flights, and the average length of flights (and therefore the overall number of person-hours in the air) have all gone up tremendously in the decades since smoking was banned.

          And even IF the proportion of DVT has gone up since then, how the hell is air quality THE key causal factor in thrombosis, as you claim? A far more likely causal factor would be the way that average legroom/seat width/aisle room/overall cabin space per person has also decreased, making it harder to stretch/move.

    3. Pascal Monett Silver badge
      Coat

      Not to mention the fun it will be with all those Siri/Cortana-enabled phones waking up at various times because some sound in the film triggered a response.

      Because obviously nobody is going to think to put them on mute any better than they do today.

      I used to be a cinema-goer. I had a subscription at my local multiplex, and wife and I would go almost every week. Before the mobile phone swamped the world, when the film started you could expect the most excited blabbermouths to calm down and actually watch the film after a few minutes. Nowadays ? Hopeless.

      So I've abandoned going to the cinema. I prefer waiting for the DVD, even if it means I'm four months behind. Don't care about that - that is how much I hate the "cinema experience" today. This move has zero impact on that decision.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Same for me, Pascal

        Used to go so often people would laugh at me / us.

        Most definitely started noticing attention spans dropping around the dawn of the smartphone era - the talking got noticably worse as the 'culture of me' came in with social media and then it became totally egregious disruption of films, then socially acceptable and now look - officially acceptable.

        And if you even dare to challenge people for talking / using phones / putting their stinking hooves up around your ears on the seat - then you get lynched. Accused of challenging the 'human rights' (yes this was put to me) of someone who simply has no situational or environmental awareness. Oh, yeah, and MANNERS - remember those?

        Remember when people went to the cinema to see films? Now it's just another place to check Facebook. Which is why I can cancelled my cinema loyalty card, bought a cracking LED telly and surround sound system, and invested the money I was spending in the cinema on Blu-rays, Netflix, Amazon et al.

        OK, I'm behind and have to wait (I work in the peripheries of the industry and don't pirate so don't even start there).

        But you know what? My living room has its own official policy. It's 'no morons admitted' and it works very nicely indeed. I would say my enjoyment and anticipation of movies coming has increased because I know I am guaranteed a stress-free screening.

        This news is ridiculous - phone friendly screenings are the antithesis of cinema. They are / will kill the theatre experience. The very polar opposite is what is required to get me back to the cinema - phone hostile screenings, like they do in the Alamo Drafthouse in the US.

        This seems like being complicit with a rising tide of cluelessness and reduced attention span. In giving up in expecting manners from people, cinema chains risk killing their ostensible raison d'etre. Will it kill takings? No. They're losing cinephiles in favour of swill-munching halfwits that just want some bright colours and sounds for two hours - but who cares, right?

        Every time the tills ring on another round of stinky food another piece of what going to movies used to be dies.

        1. Triggerfish

          Re: Same for me, Pascal

          I went and watched Star Wars and did not notice any of that, mind you I was in a different country maybe it's also a bit cultural.

      2. Jagged

        "Not to mention the fun it will be with all those Siri/Cortana-enabled phones waking up at various times because some sound in the film triggered a response."

        - That's an idea. Could the trailers announce "Siri Mute" just before the movie starts?

      3. NP-HARD
        Stop

        I'm happy to wait for VCR release for most movies...

        A night out at the cinema costing upwards of £20 p/p, where's the incentive not to stream it and pop your own corn?

    4. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      +1 libation to you

      This.

      THIS.

    5. phuzz Silver badge
      Facepalm

      I can't be bothered to go to the cinema when I can quite happily watch at home sooner or later, but when I do go I never notice other people using their phones. Perhaps it's because I'm under forty or perhaps I'm just too busy watching the film I spent money to see.

    6. Bluto Nash

      ...and let us not forget

      the original and relevant ringtones that they bring with them.

  2. Adam 52 Silver badge

    So his cunning plan is to annoy all the affluent 30, 40 and 50 year olds, as well as all the genuine film buffs, in order to attract some 20 year olds. I wonder how that will work out.

    1. Jeffrey Nonken

      How about us 60 year olds?

      1. Warm Braw

        How about us 60 year olds?

        Sorted,

        (Sounds perfect to me...)

        1. Dan 55 Silver badge
          Windows

          Nice that cinema owners have realised that dementia sufferers don't like their ears bleeding by the end of the film. What about the rest of us?

          Bah, humbug.

  3. Paul J Turner

    Something's not right

    If there's a bunch of people who pay to go in to not watch the movie, either the movies have too much time with nothing much happening to hold their attention continuously, or they are just a**holes there to annoy people. So make movies that cater to the ADD crowd and/or get some big blokes to throw the nuisances out.

    1. Tromos
      Joke

      Re: Something's not right

      "...make movies that cater to the ADD crowd..."

      They already do. Normal people call them 'trailers'.

      1. Destroy All Monsters Silver badge
        Trollface

        Re: Something's not right

        I guess artsy europeanfurreign movies being shown in the small crumbling building that the city planning council forgot can be viewed without the "always on" distraction. These are for "old people" anyway.

  4. Montreal Sean

    Phone bans may not be the problem.

    Maybe a lack of movies worth paying $12-$25 for is the problem.

    1. Mark 85

      Re: Phone bans may not be the problem.

      Then don't go... simples really.

  5. gecho

    Piracy Ok Too?

    Paying for movies and music isn't how many live their lives either.

    1. Voland's right hand Silver badge

      Re: Piracy Ok Too?

      Paying for movies and music isn't how many live their lives either.

      Paying for movies and music isn't how 22 year olds live their lives either. That generation simply is not willing to pay. They have accepted as a norm not to own anything and to have their dirty underwear exposed to all and sundry. They however expect everything for "free" in return.

      1. Pascal Monett Silver badge

        Until they start working, that is, and the heavy cluebat of reality hits them in face with rent, taxes and debt. That's when they start down the path of understanding that nothing is actually free in this life and all work deserves remuneration.

      2. DaddyHoggy

        Re: Piracy Ok Too?

        Perhaps there's hope for the generation coming in behind the current 22yos then?

        My 14yo daughter - Spotify, Netflix, ebooks have been her 'norm' for the last 3yrs (since she got her first smartphone for her move to Secondary school) - this year she started buying actual physical books, bought a retro record player and has started to buy vinyl (old from charity shops and new from artists she likes who are releasing their music on vinyl). She likes going to the cinema and doesn't take her phone with her (and gets annoyed by people who use theirs in the dark), but she's picked this up from us - it's phones off and away when the lights go down.

        Perhaps she's unique - perhaps we've brought her up with an appreciation for joy of books and art and that there can be an emotional attachment to physical objects that does not come with transient streaming of content...

        There's already too much phone use spoiling the cinematic experience at the moment and they're not allowed, if this becomes the acceptable then I won't be going to the cinema any more...

  6. Throatwarbler Mangrove Silver badge
    Thumb Up

    "When you tell a 22-year-old to turn off the phone, don't ruin the movie, they hear please cut off your left arm above the elbow," Aron said.

    Works for me. Issue all the other (non-texting) patrons hacksaws: problem solved.

    1. Rich 11

      problem solved

      Except for all the screaming. Although if it's a horror film, maybe that would add to the atmosphere.

      1. Dan 55 Silver badge
        Alert

        Saw VII, at a cinema near you.

  7. Mark 85

    How they live their lives.... that's important I guess since obviously the parents never taught the youngsters common courtesy and respect for other's rights. I'm also believing that they're texting such important stuff as "Hey.. I'm here at the movies." or "the popcorn is stale".

    It's been a long time since I've been to a movie theater because actually watching a movie in a building full of out of control kids was impossible. With this mentality on the part of the theater chains, it'll be an even longer time before I return. Now, Mr. Aron, get a clue on why your receipts are down.

    1. Andy Non Silver badge
      Childcatcher

      "building full of out of control kids".

      This. We've long since given up going to the cinema due to noisy kids spoiling the movies for us.

      Now get off my lawn.

  8. MrDamage Silver badge

    What's the harm?

    Please don't play with your phone while I'm trying to enjoy the movie, as a punch in the face often offends.

  9. Herby

    Maybe...

    They can charge more to allow the use of texting devices. Then add a soundtrack of ringers and silly ringtones throughout the movie "just to make it interesting".

    1. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: Maybe...

      Or a technical solution in the form of an app, iBeacon transmitter, and whatever Google's version of an iBeacon transmitter is called. When the app realises it's in the cinema it mutes the phone.

      To inspire millennials to download the app just say that they are entered into a draw for a free ticket once every 100 years and make it clear that it shares all their personal information with the cinema and trusted third parties.

  10. Jimbo in Thailand
    Facepalm

    Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes...

    1. LOWER THE FREAKIN' EXORBITANT TICKET PRICES!

    2. LOWER THE FREAKIN' EXORBITANT POPCORN, DRINKS, & CONCESSIONS PRICES!

    3. BUILD THEATRES WITH LARGE SCREENS AGAIN!

    4. TURN DOWN THE FREAKIN' VOLUME LEVEL!

    5. MAKE IT AN ENJOYABLE EXPERIENCE FOR THE MOVIEGOER!

    Just went to see Batman vs Superman in 3D the day it opened here in Thailand at a new cineplex at a mall that opened about a year ago. I only bring this up so you know it's not an old theatre. Disregarding the fact that B vs S was complete sh1te, the whole experience was disappointing because:

    1. For the very 1st time we had to buy the damn 3D glasses!

    2. The popcorn was typically ripoff priced... but this time it was half the size to make up for it.

    3. The screen size was so small it was like watching the movie on TV at home.

    4. The 3D effect was minimal even sitting only about 8 rows back from the screen.

    5. The audio was SOOOOO LOUD I had to stuff tissue in my ears. This is nothing new, but each year they seem to increase the volume level. It's now cranked up to 11!

    i had a similar experience watching Star Wars: The Force Awakens a few months ago and also Gods of Egypt in Bangkok not long ago.

    And these jackasses wonder why people, more and more, choose to stay home and watch pirated versions.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes...

      But to some degree that is just Thailand.... in my experience everything in Thailand is too loud.

      Not far away in Vietnam i have watched lots of movies at the theatres because for $10 (US) i can buy 2 tickets and popcorn and drinks (for 2 people). The cinemas are the same standard and size as i have been to in the UK and Singapore. The air-con, (dolby) sound, seats and screen are all excellent.

      They even have couple seats with no arm rest, which is quaint.

      People use their phones in films but i go to English movies that have Viet subtitles, so losing interest is more understandable if the film is not in your first language.

      The main reason i don't go to the cinema is the lack of films. I don't even torrent most of the trash that is released these days.

      1. Jimbo in Thailand

        Re: Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes...

        "But to some degree that is just Thailand.... in my experience everything in Thailand is too loud."

        LOL, that's certainly true but the last time I was in the US I went to see a couple of movies with my brother and the volume levels were also up a bit. Of course my other moviegoer complaints also apply, except that in US theaters, ticket and concessions prices are even more unbelievably outrageous.

      2. Triggerfish

        Re: Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes... @AC

        Funninly enough that was where I watched Starw Wars, the cinema audience seemed pretty well behaved to me.

        The cinames were excellent value for money, enough legroom to slump in the seat.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes...

      No, food and drinks should cost 10x or be banned altogether. How could you watch a movie when everybody around you munch popcorn or other bad food loudly? Also, that's maybe why volume has to be increased...

      And what about the disaster they leave around their seats? If the main reason someone geso to the theatre is to satisfy his or her stomach, well, maybe there's a reason also why many others stay away from theatres, nowadays... even when there is one of the rare movie worth to watch (and listen to).

    3. Tony Paulazzo

      Re: Of course the movie studios/theatre chains ignore the obvious fixes...

      BUILD THEATRES WITH LARGE SCREENS AGAIN

      Amen to this. Luckily I live quite close to an imax (Bradford, which seems to be studio non gratis - not showing Jungle Book, doesn't always get the latest releases), but watching Interstellar there in imax format took me back to my childhood cinema days, utterly mindblowing.

      The Odeon is closer but only has one (fairly) large screen (with nice sound) and that's showing the 2D version, the 3D one is in one of the smaller screens which I won't pay for, they're barely better than a decent home cinema.

      Millennials are quite a large percentage of the audience, and whilst they will play with their phones up to film start, it's rare anyone will continue after the film starts, and the few that do get so much abuse from people behind them they soon turn it off...

      1. werdsmith Silver badge

        BUILD THEATRES WITH LARGE SCREENS AGAIN

        But iMax theatres are popping up everywhere and the 4DX is also starting to spread out.

        Some theatres (Cambridge Vue in the Grafton screen 8 for example) have lay-flat seats similar to first class airline seats.

        I can't say I notice glowing phone screens unless I look for them, same with people eating generally not intrusive. People chatting loudly during the actual film and kids kicking your seats is annoying though (although with 4DX people pay to get kicked in the back).

        My local Cineworld is always busy and there are queues for the expensive popcorn, nachos, dirty dogs and sugary drinks, so they are not going to lower any prices. They do allow people to bring in their own food and drink though, so picnics hampers it is!

        First world problems etc.

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    How about segmented sessions?

    - Mums and Bubs matinee (got that now, best avoided)

    - Scrotes and Phones (go for it)

    - Talkers and Walkers (how many times can they need a pee?)

    - Film buffs who actually want to see ALL of the film.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: How about segmented sessions?

      I'd actually pay for a 'film buff' only card scheme - happy that my fees were used to police screenings and chuck out thickies that talk, use phones, etc.

  12. Mark Simon

    That should work …

    I don’t go to the cinema any more because the movies are boring, the food is over-priced, the seats are uncomfortable, the advertising is painful, I’m surrounded by jerks who can’t enjoy am movie in peace and I’m being charged a fortune for the experience.

    Now what could entice me to change my mind … ? That’s it! Allow twerps with the attention span of an epileptic rabbit on heat and the intellectual capacity of a sandwich to light up the place with phones on TwitFace or some other loser network. That should round of the experience nicely.

  13. Andrew Jones 2

    Oh no! The 22 year olds don't like the rules, maybe we should change them so they are better suited.

    Oh no! The 22 year olds don't like ANY rules, maybe we should exempt them from all rules to better suit them.

    Oh no! The 22 year olds don't like being in prison for breaking the law, maybe we should just them release and wipe their criminal records clean.

    DO NOT start down this path, it's bad enough that a worrying amount of the younger generation (god I can't believe I have reached the age where I am using words like that now) have this "the world owes me " attitude!

    Otherwise, feel free to go ahead but don't start complaining when your cinemas are barely filled with ONLY teens and young adults sat texting, while anyone who actually wanted to watch the film, have started frequenting other cinemas where if someone turns on their phone screen in the middle of a film, they get thrown out. I've actually seem some news sites' comments sections filled with people who claim it is not distracting when someone turns on their phone screen - in an otherwise relatively dark room.

    1. DrM
      Happy

      Whats the matter with kids?

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wCXr_6wgns

  14. DrM
    FAIL

    Why stop here?

    Let's make it socially acceptable to talk too, it's just a bit more annoying? Or sitting down -- what if you and your friends can't talk as a group sitting down? Walk around and talk to other people.

    Then all we need are remote controls for the majority of the older, male patrons that will let them endlessly flip through all the different movies playing.

    A positive suggestion -- adding a "L2" warning to movies that require an attention span of longer than two minutes.

  15. Winkypop Silver badge
    Alert

    Reserve the last 5 rows for phone-a-holics

    That's where all the (ahem) action has always been anyway.

  16. Whistlerspa

    I don't go to the cinema anymore because:

    * the tickets are too expensive.

    * the confectinary and drinks sold are too noisy.

    * too many patrons have no consideration for others and talk or indulge in other distractive behaviours.

    * cellphone activity is common and really annoying.

    * people are allowed to enter the theatre after the film has started.

    Oh and in the last five years or so the standard of the films themselves has left a lot to be desired because I'm really over superheroes, remakes and sequels / prequels!!!

Page:

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like