back to article THE TRUTH about beaver arse milk in your cakes: There's nothing vanilla about vanilla

Sweden's food watchdog has confirmed to horrified netizens that, yes, ooze from beavers' back-passages is used to add a vanilla flavour to cakes, ice creams and drinks - and has been for years. A yellowish secretion called castoreum is extracted from the animals' scent-laying anal glands, and is sometimes mixed into perfumes …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

  1. Sampler

    Contemplating getting the carton for the vanilla protein shake I had this morning out the bin and checking the ingredients now..

    1. LarsG

      Come on

      Where the hell do you find a beaver to get its arse juice?

      Damn that is so perverted, this will surely be banned as was the use of hamsters and toilet rolls by EU directive 234/45.ARS3/Y0R-UP/342-2

      Has anyone asked the beavers for their opinion?

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Come on

        > Has anyone asked the beavers for their opinion?

        Rumour has it they rather enjoy the process.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Come on

        "Has anyone asked the beavers for their opinion?"

        Since they're dead, skinned, and dried out I suspect they're rather quiet on the hole, er... whole.

      3. Marvin the Martian

        Re: Where the hell do you find a beaver...?

        There's one living in the West Country; a batch of three escaped and only two were caught, a few years ago. The remaining one was recently spotted near Nuneaton.

        I don't remember if it was a male or not, so you have a 50-50 chance.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Where the hell do you find a beaver...?

          two were caught, a few years ago. The remaining one was recently spotted near Nuneaton.

          So the other two were eaten?

      4. monkeyfish

        Re: Come on

        234/45.ARS3/Y0R-UP/342-2

        An arse directive on hamster toilet roll? fhur-fhur.

      5. Peter Simpson 1
        Holmes

        Re: Come on

        I call BS.

        There's no way catching beavers is easier or cheaper than growing vanilla plants. The number of beavers required to meet the world demand for natural vanilla flavor would be astronomical.

        Sorry, but this has "urban legend" written all over it.

        // Bull $#!#, not "beaver scent"

        1. tomban
          Paris Hilton

          Re: Come on

          According to Wikipedia:

          "While it is mainly used in both foods and beverages as part of a substitute vanilla flavour, it is less commonly used as a part of a raspberry or strawberry flavoring. The annual industry consumption is very low, around 300 pounds, whereas vanillin is over 2.6 million pounds annually"

          Still, 300 pounds is an awful lot of beavers.

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Come on

          > There's no way catching beavers is easier or cheaper than growing vanilla plants.

          There is no way those who process dead beaver would not try to extract every last scent they could from the dead animal. If this includes selling its dead arse juices as vanilla flavouring then that is exactly what they will do.

          1. JeffyPoooh
            Pint

            Re: Come on

            "...extract every last scent..."

            I see what you did there. Good one - intentional or not.

        3. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Come on

          I was wondering. Could it April 1st? No: this is just too unlikely, nobody would even begin to believe it.

          Then I realised... it's no more unlikely than musk.

        4. shrdlu

          Re: Come on

          Vanilla beans will be cheaper than castoreum but still too expensive for most purposes. Commercially vanillin is made from wood pulp. It's a by-product of the paper-making industry. So you should only expect castoreum in very high-end organic foods and the most expensive perfumes. The most expensive perfumes also use musk collected from the scent-glands of musk-oxen and civet cats. You definitely won't find musk in a vanilla protein shake.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Come on

            "You definitely won't find musk in a vanilla protein shake."

            I'd better not - he's supposed to be working on space rockets and supersonic trains!

          2. KrisMac

            Re: Come on

            No, No, No! The most expensive perfumes use whale snot: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ambergris

        5. SolidSquid

          Re: Come on

          Depends on how strong it is. If one pound of beaver ass can be used to produce the equivalent of 100 pounds of vanilla based flavourings then it might be cheaper in the long run

        6. AVee

          Re: Come on

          "I call BS."

          Nope. A dutch TV program which tracks origins of consumer products to show how they are created dug into this earlier this year. And yeah, the stuff exists, is being collected from killed beavers and being sold as a natural flavor. Getting a food producer to admit they use it turned out to be a different story, but the stuff exists and is being sold.

          The two episodes covering this are online here:

          http://keuringsdienstvanwaarde.kro.nl/seizoenen/2013/afleveringen/14-03-2013

          http://keuringsdienstvanwaarde.kro.nl/seizoenen/2013/afleveringen/21-03-2013

          The program is in Dutch, but contains some stuff (the start of the second episode) which takes place in Canada which are in English (with dutch subs). It shows a Canadian trader with a shed full of dried anal glands...

      6. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: Come on

        This place is crawling with them - national symbol and biggest pest.

      7. Nym
        Flame

        Re: Come on

        Do you know what beaver means in American slang?

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Contemplating getting the carton for the vanilla protein shake I had this morning out the bin and checking the ingredients now..

      You'll regret it...

    3. csmac3144

      There is nothing that comes out of a beaver's arse that I don't already love.

    4. veti Silver badge

      On the ingredients list, it usually appears as "natural flavouring", or "natural flavoring" if you're Left-pondside. There are strict rules about what you can call "vanilla", but almost none about what you can call "flavo(u)ring".

    5. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Sampler: "Contemplating getting the carton for the vanilla protein shake I had this morning out the bin and checking the ingredients now.."

      The vanilla's okay, but you don't want to know where they got the protein from.

      Peter Simpson 1: "Bull $#!#, not "beaver scent""

      No, no- they use bulls**t as *strawberry* flavouring.

      Anyway, I don't see that this should be news to our Scandinavian friends- I once owned^w saw a Swedish video that was an hour of some guy doing nothing but eat beaver.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Mmmmm....

    That made me hungry.

    Think I'll have a nice "vanilla" icecream this evening to follow my usual garum and andouille supper.

  3. Denarius
    Childcatcher

    and I thought that luwak coffee was a bad idea

    now icecream is off the menu. Where will it end, no lets rephrase that, what delight next becomes disgusting ? Wont some-one think of the children ?

    1. Frankee Llonnygog

      Re: and I thought that luwak coffee was a bad idea

      vanilla latte, anyone?

    2. Robert Carnegie Silver badge

      Luwak coffee - a question

      Just curious - are vegans allowed to have that or not? It comes from the animal obviously, but it isn't something that the animal wanted to keep. I would still guess no, though.

      The flavouring from dead beaver bum can't be vegetarian, though.

      1. Lamont Cranston

        Re: Luwak coffee - a question

        Kopi Luwak is delicious, assuming you like coffee but dislike it's bitterness (you could, of course, obtain the same effect for less money by buying your coffee at Starbucks).

        My wife's a vegetarian, but didn't see anything wrong with Kopi Luwak (apart from the whole "you're drinking brewed poo").

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Luwak coffee - a question

        > Just curious - are vegans allowed to have that or not?

        You know, when I was reading the article, that was the first thing that came to my mind.

        "Ordinary" vegetarians even might even quail at a product derived from a killed animal. Does the packaging of otherwise vegetable products make it clear that there is arse milk form a dead beaver in the product?

      3. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Luwak coffee - a question

        Answers:

        Vegan - absolutely not. Out of the question, it is still sourced from an animal.

        Vegetarian - it depends upon their personal level of adherence to strict vegetarian policies.

        1. Dave 126 Silver badge

          Re: Luwak coffee - a question

          Hehe, 'Poo' would be a suitable (if not commercially viable) name for a Twitter-like 'social media' service. My reasoning is that many animals use pee or poo to get messages out to their peers they are not currently in the presence of. If of you want to take this idea and turn it into a multi-billion dollar company, I only ask a 1% cut... I'll even throw in some tag-lines to get you started:

          "Why say it when you can spray it?"

          "Putting the Pee into people"

          "Poople"

          Of course, humans would want to expand the vocabulary of the medium beyond the three messages favoured by many mammals, ie "This is MINE!", "I'm feeling HORNY!" and "I have an interesting bowel condition". Or there again, that's enough to cover much of the human condition.

        2. R Callan
          Joke

          Re: Luwak coffee - a question

          I must be a "good" vegetarian then. Everything I eat is of vegetable (plus fungal) origin, just that some of it is filtered through animals before i get it. I love cow filtered grass, but prefer to call it steak.

        3. sam bo

          Re: Luwak coffee - a question

          "Vegan - absolutely not. Out of the question, it is still sourced from an animal."

          I would dispute that. It may have passed through an animals alimentary canal, but as the civet ate the bean-pulp and passed the bean, it could even be argued that it had not been "inside" the civet. Technically , your food is not "in" you until it has passed the lining of your gut and been absorbed into your bloodstream.

          Think of your body as an elongated donut, with the outer layer the skin and the hole of the donut your digestive tract.

          Wild Luwak coffee should be fine for vegans - caged civet luwak coffee should be ethically repugnant to all.

        4. No, I will not fix your computer
          Stop

          Re: Luwak coffee - a question

          >>Vegan - absolutely not. Out of the question, it is still sourced from an animal.

          The bean was never part of the animal, although you could claim that the labours of the animal are being exploited (commercially they are fed on the whole bean), but if that counts as animal product then so does any vegetable which has been farmed as you're using the labours of humans.

          What if a bee fertilises your crop? are you exploiting the bee? does it cease to be vegan?

          Any fertiliser that are used on fields actually go on to become part of the product (often blood/fish/bone sourced) or animal waste - thus making virtually no product vegan (under your definition).

          What about water? that's probably been through many an animal in it's time.

          So, when you say "absolutely not" - are you sure?

          1. Trixr

            Re: Luwak coffee - a question

            Regarding the logic of what you say, it's obvious you're not a vegan - "absolutely not" is correct. Honey from bees is not permitted either by strict vegans.

            Add to that the fact that the beasts are now mostly farmed to produce the "processed" beans - including feeding the coffee berries all the time, when it isn't their natural eating pattern - and it's double-fail.

            I'm not a vegan, but at least I've spent some time understanding their principles rather than coming out with some half-baked "logic" out of my own arse. So to speak.

  4. Eddy Ito

    As an omnivore, may I say yum? I hated soaking those oily gamey buggars in a brine for a week. Granted, not so much lately as there are bigger game in "dem dar hills" that is far more lean and versatile in the woods.

  5. Sir Runcible Spoon
    Joke

    Sir

    People will be going off Caviar next.

    1. DJ 2
      Joke

      Re: Sir

      Or even chicken eggs.

  6. JimC

    s for that musk stuff

    Or the civet cat glands...

  7. Khaptain Silver badge

    Anal Ooze

    Does this mean that at some point, someone caught a beaver, pulling various bits and pieces off , including the analy situated scent glands, squeezed them, waited for some ooze and actually though that it might be a good idea to eat.

    And then decided it might be a good replacement for Vanilla.

    1. Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
      Flame

      Re: Anal Ooze

      More likely some camp fire cookout [see icon], when the post-prandial discussion turned to the new cook's talents "that was a great stew, had a hint of vanilla". "Ah, you'll never guess what bit of the beaver smelled like that".

      1. Khaptain Silver badge

        Re: Anal Ooze

        That must have be the kind of camping outing where the scouts are still too young to understand that "Eating some beaver" doesn't actualy involve a small furry rodent.

        1. Destroy All Monsters Silver badge

          Re: Anal Ooze

          I will refrain from talking about beaver juice! At all.

  8. John Smith 19 Gold badge
    Joke

    Hunt down the villanous abusers of this small rodent. I call for ..

    a Beaver Patrol. *

    *With apologies to the fans of Pop Will Eat Itself.

    1. AOD

      Re: Hunt down the villanous abusers of this small rodent. I call for ..

      Have a +1 from me for the Poppies reference.

      I will now have "Radio P.W.E.I" bouncing around in my head for the rest of the day.

      1. John Smith 19 Gold badge
        Happy

        Many years ago I found my self in the Midlands town of Leicester outside a police station

        on "Beauvoir" Street (as in Simone) when some Constables were beginning their shift...

        The locals (not being French) cannot pronounce its name properly..

        Put a grin on my face for the rest of the day....

        1. CraPo

          Re: Many years ago I found my self in the Midlands town of Leicester outside a police station

          Whereas, the Vale of Belvoir (in Nottinghamshire/Leicestershire) is actually pronounced beaver!

          1. Fraserrr

            Re: Many years ago I found my self in the Midlands town of Leicester outside a police station

            Actually it's 'belvoir' and is indeed pronounced beaver! The area near where my parents live is know as the vale of belvoir, and is centred around belvoir castle - all pronounced beaver! Always makes me smile!! :)

    2. Professor Clifton Shallot

      Sweet Sweet Pie

      Get The Smell! Kill The Beavers!

  9. Bad Beaver

    Meanwhile…

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.